Fruits Basket Another Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良いんだけどコレじゃない感

It's good, but I feel like it's not this

This review contains spoilers. 色んなカプの子供たちが出てきて嬉しい、嬉しいんだけど違うんだよ。透と夾の同棲生活とか子育て風景とかの後日譚が読みたかったんよ...。色々すっ飛ばして子供大きくなってるし、別の毒親持ち主人公と慊人の子供メインの話になってるし、志岐から見た慊人は優しい母親で志岐が幸せになるのはいいんだけど、小学生時代に初めて2次元に恋したキャラが夾のファンとしては残念でならない。結局、主人公の毒親問題は解決しないからモヤモヤするし、草摩の力かはとりの記憶消去の力(もうないのか？)であの母親の記憶消して病院送りにして欲しかったわ～。最後まで主要キャラの顔は描かれないしコレじゃないんだよなぁ。仕方ない読みたい世界線の話は昔めちゃくちゃ漁ってた久々に夢小説を久々に漁るか....

This review contains spoilers. I'm happy and happy that so many Kap kids have come out, but that's different. I wanted to read later stories such as Toru and Kana's Cohabitation Life and Child-Raising Scenes... A lot of things have been skipped over and the kid is getting bigger, and the story is mainly about the main character with another toxic parent and the child of a villain, and it's nice that Shiki is a kind mother and Shiki is happy, but it's a shame for a fan of the character that first fell in love in two dimensions when she was in elementary school. In the end, the main character's toxic parents problem isn't solved, so it's confusing, and Kusama's power or Tori's power to erase memories (isn't there anymore?) And I wanted her to erase her mother's memory and send her to the hospital. The faces of the main characters aren't drawn until the end, so this isn't it. I can't help but want to read the story of World Line is a long time ago I was fishing a lot a long time ago, I wonder if it's been a long time since I caught a dream novel...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きなフルバの世界

I love the world of Fulva

This review contains spoilers. 本編と対になるような主人公なんだなと思いました。亡くなったお母さんが大好きなフルバ生きてるお母さんに全否定されるアナザーどちらも草磨家と、母子家庭で孤独な女の子のハートフルストーリーなのだけれどアナザーは本当はもう少し言いたいことがあったのではないかなと言うような終わり方。なぜあのお母さんが主人公にそんな仕打ちをするのか。虐●親に理由などないのかもしれませんが…あの親と縁が切れるとか、もう少し主人公が救われる場面があればよかったなと思いました。作者さんの体調不良もあって、熱量が枯渇してしまったのかなと思わざるを得ない仕上がり。フルバメンバーのその後がもう少し見たかったなとも思いました。登場人物が多すぎるし、お子さん達に十二支的なアイコンがないので、どの子が誰の子かわかるまで（思い出すまで）ちょっと時間かかった。綾女ちゃんのとこはすぐわかったけど笑

This review contains spoilers. I thought the main character would be the opposite of the main story. Another, which is completely denied by Fulva, who loves her deceased mother, is a heartfelt story about the Kusama family and a lonely girl in a mother and child family, but Another actually ends in a way that says there was something more she wanted to say. Why would that mother treat the main character like that? Maybe there's no reason for abusive parents... I thought it would have been nice if there was a scene where the main character was saved a little more, such as when the relationship with that parent was broken. Due in part to the author's poor health, I can't help but wonder if the heat has been exhausted. I also thought I'd like to see a little more after the Fulva members. There are too many characters, and the kids don't have any zodiac icons, so it took me a while until I understood (remembered) which child was whose child. I found out about Ayame's place right away lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

フルーツバスケット気になってた

I was interested in the fruit basket

This review contains spoilers. やっぱりフルーツバスケットの先気になってたから良かった評価低い人もいるけど全然たかくてもいいおもった

This review contains spoilers. After all, it was the forerunner of fruit baskets, so I'm glad there are people with low ratings, but I thought it was okay to be tough at all

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだ見たい

I still want to see more

アニメの新シリーズから入って、ようやく原作に至り、anotherにたどり着きました。長い時間をかけた作品で完結なのだと思いますが、本編の描かれていない場面を見てみたいと思ってしまいました。

I started with a new series of anime, and finally got to the original, and arrived at Another. I think it was completed with a work that took a long time, but I wanted to take a look at scenes that weren't depicted in the main story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

懐かしい

nostalgic

学生時代フルバを読んでいた世代としてはなんだか親目線で読み進めてしまいます。前作のキャラクター達がガッツリ出てくるわけではなく、今のところは面影やほのめかし程度な感じですが十分面白いです。

For the generation that read Fulva when I was a student, I somehow read on from a parent's point of view. The characters from the previous game aren't showing up at all, and so far it's only vestiges and insinuations, but it's interesting enough.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょくちょく見え隠れする彼ら

They often see and hide

This review contains spoilers. 話の途中途中に、フルバのみんなのことが出てくるのがとても嬉しい！3巻の最後の作者さんコメントに完結って書いてあるけど…え、まだだよね？主人公の家庭の事情とかなんにも解決してないし？草摩本家の闇とかも描ききれてないし？うおちゃん出てきてないし？まだだよね？これで終わったら不完全燃焼すぎていやだ〜！

This review contains spoilers. I'm so happy that everyone in Fulva comes up in the middle of the story! It says it's complete in the author's comment at the end of volume 3, but... well, not yet, right? the main character's family circumstances or anything haven't been resolved, are they? You haven't even drawn the darkness of the Soma Honke? Uo-chan hasn't come out, hasn't she? Not yet, right? Once this is over, the combustion will be too incomplete, and I don't want it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

フルバが好きで

I like Fulva

簡単にまとめれば、子供世代の話。フルバを読んだ後ならこの子は誰と誰の子供かな？と予測しながらも楽しいかも。ただ、3巻で完結してはいません。なので星一つ減らしてます。

In a nutshell, it's a story about the children's generation. After reading Fulva, who and whose child is this kid? It might be fun even though it's predictive. However, it wasn't completed in volume 3. So I've reduced it by 1 star.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

なつかしい

nostalgic

フルバの続編との事で、各キャラのその後が分かり面白かったのですが、若干消化不良な感じだったので、もう少し続いて欲しかったです。

It was a sequel to Fulva, and it was interesting to understand what came after each character, but I felt a little indigestion, so I wanted it to continue a little longer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

うーむ、これで完結か…

Hmm, is this the end...

前を向いて歩き出しました　→ 完結これからってところで、終わったという感じです。前作の番外編と思って読めばいいのかな？新作と思うと中途半端ですけど。ひとことで言えば、物足りない。です。

I looked forward and started walking → complete is just around the corner, and I feel like it's over. I wonder if I should read it thinking of it as an extra edition of the previous work? I'm half-hearted when I think of it as a new product. In a nutshell, it's not enough. That's it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

アナザーはアナザーでおもしろいんだけどフルバが頂点すぎたから評価が下がっちゃう感じかなあ…おもしろいんだけどな…フルバ読んだ直後なのに誰の子どもで叔父が誰で〜って理解するのに時間かかります(頭が悪いだけです)終わったのかな終わってないよね…？これで終わりは悲しいなあ

Another is interesting because Fulva is too high, but I wonder if it's like the ratings go down because Fulva is too high... it's interesting... it takes time to understand whose child and who their uncle is... it's just after reading Fulva (it's just stupid) I wonder if it's over... it's not over...? this is a sad end

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

フルバ前作とのつながり

Connection with Fulva's previous work

こちらを先に読み、前作があるとの事で一気読み。それから、また、こちらを読んで誰と誰の子か想像しておりました。前作を手に取った事がない方には、一度前作を読んでいただきたい❗２３刊。

I read this first, and since there is a previous work, I read it all at once. Then, I read this again and imagined who and whose child it was. For those who have never picked up the previous work, I would like you to read the previous work ❗ 23.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

懐かしのフルバ

Nostalgic Fulva

This review contains spoilers. 子供たちが次々出て来て誰の子か考えるの楽しいです。はなちゃんは思った相手と違ったけどw毒母は社会的に抹殺したい。

This review contains spoilers. The kids come out one after another and it's fun to think about who they are. Hana is different from who I thought, but I want to get rid of Poisonous Mother in society.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

(^_^)

(^_^)

前作の子供たちのストーリー。面白いけど、もう少し前作のキャラが出てくれたらなと思ってしまう。

This is a children's story from the previous film. It's interesting, but it makes me wish the characters from the previous game came out a little longer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

頑張れ‼

Go for it ‼

This review contains spoilers. 主人公の成長物語と一言で言ってしまうには…色々考えさせられる作品です。が、次世代の話なので過去作品のその後みたいな感じで懐かしくもあり楽しかったです。

This review contains spoilers. To put it in a nutshell as the protagonist's coming-of-age story... it's a work that makes me think a lot. But since it's a story about the next generation, it felt like after past works, and it was nostalgic and fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

親世代との対比

Contrast with parent generation

まず懐かし〜フルバのみんなのこどもたちのお話。随所に親の遺伝を感じる子どもたちの個性と何より親世代との対比！！呪いで囚われていた草摩のみんなはやはりどこかお互いに難しい関係性でしたが、子世代は普通にみんな仲良しです?もちろん、草摩の遺恨は強くそれを感じてきた子世代もかなり大人びてはいます。そして本編フルバは主人公透が草摩家に関わりみんなの心を解いていきますが、今作は草摩家の子たちが主人公の心の闇を一緒に背負い解いてくれます。仄かに恋愛を匂わしつつ、心情や自分の在り方などなどが3巻まで描かれています。元々愛蔵版の記念で描かれた作品なのでお話自体はあまり進展ない感じですが草摩のみんなが幸せそうで何より?出来れば続きが見たいです。

First, nostalgia ~ a story about all the children in Fulva. The contrast between the individuality of children who feel their parents' genetics everywhere and the parent generation above all else! Everyone in Kusama, who was imprisoned by a curse, still had a difficult relationship with each other, but is everyone in the child generation usually on good terms? Of course, Kusama's grudge is strong, and the child generation, which has felt it, has grown quite a bit. Also, in the main story, Fulva, the main character Toru is involved in the Kusama family and unravels everyone's hearts, but in this film, the children of the Kusama family carry the darkness of the protagonist's heart together to unravel. While faintly smelling of romance, it depicts up to 3 volumes of feelings, the way one is, etc. It's a work originally drawn to commemorate the Favorite Edition, so I don't feel like the story itself has progressed much, but above all, everyone in Kusama seems happy? I'd like to see the continuation if possible.

Helpful

Reviews for Fruits Basket Another Manga