First Love Monster Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

も～

too

This review contains spoilers. 何この小学生イケメンすぎ中身は、子供だけど絵がかっこいいし好きです。

This review contains spoilers. What is this good-looking elementary school kid inside is a kid, but the pictures are cool and I like them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

思わず突っ込んでしまう（笑）

I can't help but rush in (laughs)

This review contains spoilers. 小学生には絶対に見えないイケメンがたくさんでてきます（笑）なかなか笑える設定だと思いますよ（笑）

This review contains spoilers. There are a lot of good-looking guys that elementary school students would never see (lol) I think it's a pretty funny setting (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 22, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ギャグとして見れば

If you look at it as a gag

小学生ではあり得ない見た目の男の子達が登場しますが、アニメ化された際の声優さんもイケボ揃いでとことん現実離れしていました。ただ『あり得ない』と思っているといろいろ気になって読んでいられないと思いますが、すべてギャグとして受け入れてしまえば笑えるマンガの１つとして楽しめると思います。

Boys who looked impossible for elementary school students appeared, but the voice actors when it was made into the anime were all so cool that they were completely out of reality. However, if you think it's “impossible,” I don't think you'll be able to read it because of various things, but if you accept everything as a gag, I think you can enjoy it as one funny manga.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ

anime

アニメ見てから、漫画読みました。こんな小学生いないだろー！と思いながらも、かっこいい男の子達満載の作品です。

After watching anime, I read comics. There are no elementary school students like this! Even though I thought, it's a work full of cool boys.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ランドセルになわとび

Wandering around in a backpack

こんなイケメンの小学生いないよ！ってとこがこの漫画の醍醐味だと思うなあ。なんかレビューで結構きついこと書いてあるよね、好き嫌いは自由だけどどれもその先生が一生懸命書いた作品だと思うから書き方は大事だなとあらためて思いました。

There is no such good-looking elementary school student! I think that's the real thrill of this comic. There are some pretty tough things written in the review, and I think all of them are works that the teacher worked so hard to write, so I thought again that how to write is important.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃ笑いました！！

I laughed so much!!

面白かったです！レビューが悪いですね。リアルを求める方には合わないかもしれません。

That was interesting! The reviews are bad, aren't they? It may not be suitable for those looking for realism.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

少女漫画だから微妙なんだろうね。

Since it's a girls' manga, it's probably subtle.

This review contains spoilers. 昔からＢＬ作家が少女漫画書くと、元々少女漫画読んでる人達にディスられる傾向があるけど、正しくな感じ。内容的にはぶっ飛びなので、リアルにありそうでない少女漫画読者には受け入れ難いかも。コマ読みづらい、とか、描き分けなってない、とかありましたけど、普通に読めます。描き方批判してる意味が解らないです。その辺りもＢＬ読者と少女漫画読者の慣れの違いでしょうね。リアル追求気味の少女漫画読者には向かず、ＢＬ作家が少女漫画を書く事に違和感を感じる読者にも向きません。ベタな展開には飽き飽きです。度肝を抜くような設定や展開を希望！そんな方にはオススメかもしれません。最後に、当方は日吉先生のファンではありません。日吉先生の作品は始めて読みました。苦もなくさらりと読めましたし、キャラ解んなくなった、とか一切ありません。発想が面白いし、登場人物も魅力的。ですけど、やっぱり少女漫画だからしっくりこない感じがヒシヒシとします。なんで少女漫画なんだろう、って理由で星４つ。

This review contains spoilers. Since ancient times, when BL writers write girls' comics, they tend to be dismissed by people who originally read girls' comics, but that feels right. It's out of the blue in terms of content, so it may be difficult for readers of girls' comics that aren't real to accept. There were times when the frames were hard to read, or the drawing wasn't right, but I can read it normally. I don't understand the point of criticizing how to draw. That area is probably the difference in habituation between BL readers and girls' manga readers. It is not suitable for girls' manga readers who are pursuing realism, and it is also not suitable for readers who feel uncomfortable with BL writers writing girls' comics. I'm tired of the solid developments. I hope for settings and developments that will blow your mind! I might recommend it to those people. Finally, I'm not a fan of Hiyoshi sensei. I read Hiyoshi sensei's work for the first time. I was able to read it without any trouble, and I didn't understand the characters at all. The idea is interesting, and the characters are fascinating. However, after all, it's a girls' comic, so the feeling that it doesn't fit right makes me cringe. I wonder why it's a girls' manga, so 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

個人的には好き(*^^*)

I personally like it (*^^*)

好みはかなり、別れる作品です。かなりぶっ飛んだ設定や斜め上のキャラの行動をネタだと笑い飛ばせる方なら楽しめると思います。その他、問題点としてはキャラか似たり寄ったりで時々認識間違えてたり「このキャラ誰？」と思うことがしばしばあります。色々書きましたが、総合的には、好きです♪ギャップ、ネタ、絵柄好きなので^^アニメも楽しみ(*´ω｀*)

It's a work where people have quite a few different tastes. I think anyone who can laugh it off with a pretty ridiculous setting or the behavior of characters who are slanted is going to be able to enjoy it. Other problems include characters that are similar or close, and sometimes misunderstood, and “who is this character?” I often think that. I've written a lot, but overall, I like it ♪ I like gaps, material, and designs, so ^^ I'm also looking forward to anime (*'ω`*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

小学生と恋愛

Love with elementary school students

少女マンガならではのアリエナイ設定もの。小学生と女子高生の組合せの恋愛はいくら漫画でもないでしょ、と思いつつ読み進めました。

An Arienai setting unique to girls' manga. I read on while thinking that the romance between an elementary school student and a high school girl isn't even a comic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

これはすごい！

this is amazing!

This review contains spoilers. まさか表紙のイケメンが小学生とは思いませんでした。内容も結構ぶっ飛んでいますが非常に面白い作品でした！

This review contains spoilers. I never thought the handsome guy on the cover was an elementary school student. The content was pretty ridiculous, but it was a very interesting work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

最高！笑

the best! lol

内容がシュールすぎて…もうラブコメじゃなくコメディーでふ

the content was so surreal... it's not a romantic comedy anymore, it's a comedy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 05, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

純粋無垢だからこそ台詞に説得力あり

Dialogues are persuasive because they are pure and innocent

This review contains spoilers. ひとこまひとこまが挿し絵レベルなので、絵の美しさや可愛さは申し分ないです。1巻では登場人物の説明に終わっている感じが否めませんが、2巻からがこの漫画の面白さのように思います。とりあえず顔面崩壊率が跳ね上がります、全力でヒロインとは思えない顔描いてるなぁと思ったら笑えてきます。そしてヒロインがまともな突っ込み役にポジションを据えます。ただ何も考えなくていいラブコメだったら物足りないと思われるかもしれません。しかし奏が語る『お母さんが言ってた』話はとても穏やかで、一見つまらなそうですが、当たり前のことを当たり前に伝えるって実は大変なことです。それが、小学生だからこそ、母親を亡くしている彼だからこそ、嫌味のない自然な言葉として入ってくる感じがします。人にされて嫌なことはしてはいけない、誰もが耳にしたことがあると思いますが、『自分は平気でも相手は違うかもしれない、そこをどれだけ想像してやれるかが思いやりだ(うろ覚えです！)』というのは現代人に欠乏しがちな感覚だと思いました。そういう意味でアニメ化される価値はあるかな？と思いました。ピアニカ吹くのに夢中でランドセルなくしたヤベェ！でもピアニカありゃよくね？ああ、十分だな。そうだな。の件が個人的にツボです、あと昼ドラネタ…でもまだまだ笑いを取りに行けるところはあるはず。伸びしろとして、☆は1つお預かりします(^^)

This review contains spoilers. Each and every detail is at the level of an illustration, so the beauty and cuteness of the picture is perfect. I can't deny the feeling that volume 1 ended with an explanation of the characters, but I think volume 2 is the fun of this comic. Anyway, the facial decay rate jumps up, and it makes me laugh when I think that she's drawing a face that doesn't seem like a heroine with all her might. Then, the heroine takes a position as a decent entrant. However, if it's a romantic comedy where you don't have to think about anything, you might think it's not enough. However, the story “The Mother Said” Kanade talks about is very calm, and although it seems boring at first glance, it is actually difficult to take things that are taken for granted. That is because he is an elementary school student, and because he has lost his mother, I feel that it comes in as a natural word without disgust. I'm sure everyone has heard that you shouldn't do anything you don't like being treated to, but “even if you don't mind, your partner may be different, and it's compassionate (I remember!)” I thought that was a feeling that modern people tend to lack. Is it worth animating in that sense? I thought so. I lost my backpack because I was obsessed with playing pianica! But wouldn't it be nice to have a pianica? Oh, that's enough. that's right. That is a personal pressure point, there are still more places where you can go get some laughter during the day... but there must still be places where you can go get some laughter. As a room for growth, I will keep 1 of ☆ (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい発想！！

Great idea!!

絵が可愛くて好きです♪( ´▽｀)イケメンばかり出てくるし…個性ありすぎるし…。続きが気になります（≧∇≦）

The pictures are cute and I like them ♪ ('▽`) There are only good-looking guys... they have too many personalities... I'm worried about the continuation (≧ 126 ≤)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

主人公が恋をした相手が、小学生でびっくりしました。まだ試し読みでしか読んだことないけどとっても面白かったです。

I was surprised that the person the main character fell in love with was an elementary school student. I've only read it as a trial reading yet, but it was really interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

まさかの設定…！

Unexpected setting...!

絵が綺麗＆イケメンがいるのが好きです(*´∀｀*)ストーリーも結構面白かったですw設定が良いと思いました！

I like that the pictures are beautiful and there are good-looking guys (*'∀｀*) The story was pretty interesting too, I thought the setting was good!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

絵は綺麗

The picture is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 絵は凄くし好きなえでした！でも、こんな小学生いないしょ！って感じの小学生が3人も出てきて、、、

This review contains spoilers. The picture was amazing and I loved it! But there are no elementary school students like this! Three elementary school students who felt like that also came out...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

成長期ですから！

It's a growing season!

小学生なのにありえない位恵まれた体で女子高生を翻弄中ですよ（笑）恵まれた体は普通の大人並なのに、やっている事は小学生というギャップ！大人なら躊躇ってしまうところをこどもの無知と無茶で突っ走るラブコメです。まだまだ先が気になる作品です。

Even though I'm an elementary school student, I'm at the mercy of high school girls with an unbelievably blessed body (laughs) Even though my blessed body is on par with a normal adult, what I'm doing is a gap between being an elementary school student! It's a romantic comedy that runs through places where adults would hesitate due to children's ignorance and recklessness. I'm still worried about the future of this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

そんなバカな!!

that's stupid!!

とツッコミたくなる程のイケメン小学生&仲間たちのお話しです(笑)絵がとってもキレイで萌えます。話の進みはゆっくりめなので次巻に期待です(o´∀`)b

It's a story about a handsome elementary school student and his friends that makes me want to twitch (laughs) The pictures are so beautiful and fascinating. The story progresses slowly, so I'm looking forward to the next volume (o'∀`) b

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった✨

That was interesting ✨

表紙の、吹き出しのセリフに惹かれて(笑)一気読みしてしまいました?小学５年生と女子高生の恋という、かなり斬新な設定でしたが、５年生とは思えない大人びたキャラクター像やストレートで飾り気のないイケメンぶりも良かったですし、少しずつ進展していく二人の姿がほほえましくて、サクサク読めました?絵がアニメーションっぽくて、主人公を始め美男美女がいっぱいなので、個人的に嬉しかったです?今後の展開が楽しみです?

I was attracted to the speech speech on the cover (laughs) and read it all at once? It was a pretty novel setting, the love between a 5th grader and a high school girl, but the adult character figures and straight, unadorned good-looking guys that didn't seem like 5th graders were also nice, and the appearance of the two progressing little by little made me smile, so I was able to read it quickly? The picture looks like an animation, and there are lots of beautiful men and women, starting with the main character, so I was personally happy? Looking forward to future developments?

Helpful

Reviews for First Love Monster Manga