<Chapter release>The Counterfeit's Fateful Encounter Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

作画は微妙

The drawing is subtle

髪とか目とか作画で特に目立つ部分のデザインがかなり微妙。表情の作り方も個性的というかちょっと怖い。とりあえず話の続きが知りたくて新刊が出る度に購入してるけど4巻はタイトルの回収(溺愛)もまだなのにサブキャラの恋愛を見せられて期待外れでした。原作の都合もあるのだろうけどヒロインの自信のなさや謙虚さを延々と引っ張られると作品自体の好感度が下がるので､そろそろスパッと切り替えて溺愛にシフトしてもいいのでは？と思います。5巻ではいくらかメインの2人の話が進むことを願って評価は⭐︎5で。

The design of the parts that stand out particularly in the drawing, such as the hair and eyes, is quite subtle. The way facial expressions are made is unique, or rather, a bit scary. Anyway, I wanted to know the continuation of the story, so I bought it every time a new issue came out, but volume 4 was disappointing to be shown the romance of the subcharacters even though the title hasn't been collected (love) yet. There are probably advantages to the original story, but if the heroine's lack of confidence and modesty is dragged endlessly, the likability of the work itself drops, so isn't it okay to switch quickly and shift to doting? I think so. I hope the story of the two main characters progresses somewhat in volume 5, and the evaluation is ⭐ ︎ 5.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！！

interesting!!

This review contains spoilers. 主人公自信ってくれ！可愛いぞ！って感じです笑見ていてはやく続きを言ってくれ！！って感じが最高に好きでした

This review contains spoilers. Give me confidence in the main character! it's cute! It's like lol and tell me the continuation as soon as possible!! I really liked the feeling

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読み返す

Reread it over and over

This review contains spoilers. 奥深いストーリー、登場人物同士の関係性、心情の変化が素敵です。ひとつひとつの物事が丁寧に進んでいくのが、読んでいてもとても静かに心落ち着く気がします。そして…ほぼ毎巻現れるクラリスの心の中の亡霊マルチダ、怖いです? ホラー作品の幽霊の表現よりもずっと恐ろしいな、と思いました。あとクラリスにとって、どれだけ酷くこびりついた心傷トラウマだったかが分かります。クラリスにもっともっと溢れんばかりの幸福が起きる事を願っています。幸せあれ！これからも楽しみにして応援します。

This review contains spoilers. The deep story, relationships between the characters, and changes in mood are wonderful. I feel that the fact that each thing progresses carefully is very quiet and calms my mind even when I read it. And... is Martida, the ghost in Clarice's mind that appears almost every volume, scary? I thought it was far more frightening than the expression of ghosts in horror films. Also, I can see how deeply traumatic it was for Clarice. I hope that Clarice will have even more and more overflowing happiness. Be happy! I will continue to look forward to supporting you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よくあるストーリーだけど

It's a common story

This review contains spoilers. 最初はまぁ良くあるストーリーだなって思ってましたが、素直でピュアでめちゃくちゃいい子なクラリスが実は博学で領地の人達の為に一生懸命なとことか、実はジーン様が初めからクラリスを求めていたとことか、スピンオフ化しそうなメイドちゃんとシドのまだ微妙な関係性とかすごく面白いです。早く次を読みたくて短話にすれば良かったと後悔中です。

This review contains spoilers. At first, I thought it was a pretty common story, but it's really interesting that Clarice, who is an honest, pure, and insanely nice girl, is actually erudite and works hard for the people in her territory, that in fact, Gene was looking for Clarice from the beginning, and the still delicate relationship between Maid and Sid, who seems to be spinning off. I regret that I should have made it into a short story because I wanted to read the next one as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

なんだか温かくてずっと見ていられる

It's kind of warm and I can watch it all the time

This review contains spoilers. 色々な誤解もトラウマになってしまった事も、温かく優しく包み込むように解いていく素敵な二人です。最初は冷たくて段々と愛情が芽生え…みたいな話はいっぱいありますが、このお話は最初から不器用で伝わり難いけど優しさが溢れています。だからですね、辺境伯側の人たちももれなく最初から温かいです。静かな優しさと聡明さを併せ持つクラリスがどんどん美しくなっていくのがとても嬉しい！ずっと見守っていたい二人です。メアリーとジルの今後も楽しみです。文句なく五つ星の作品です！

This review contains spoilers. They are two wonderful people who resolve various misunderstandings and traumatizing things in a warm and gentle way. There are many stories that seem cold at first and love gradually develops... but even though this story is clumsy and hard to convey from the beginning, it is full of kindness. So, the people on the frontier side were all warm right from the start. I'm so happy that Clarice, who has both quiet kindness and intelligence, is becoming more and more beautiful! They are two people I want to keep an eye on. I'm looking forward to the future of Mary and Jill. It's a five-star work without complaint!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

好きなタイプです

It's my favorite type

基本は学園もののオーソドックスな恋愛ものが好きですが、この作品はジャンルは少し違うけど惹かれました！全巻購入してます♪

Basically, I like orthodox school romance stuff, but I was attracted to this work even though the genre is slightly different! I bought the whole volume ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

コミカライズいい。

Comicalize is good.

This review contains spoilers. 原作を読んで知っていたため、コミカライズ読みましたが、あたりですね。ですが、この原作、Rシーンがあるんですが(まだまだずっと先ですが)Rシーンは描かれるのだろうか。読んだ感じ全年齢対象っぽいので、Rシーンなしだろうな。クラリスの実家のざまぁはスッキリしましたね。ジーンの溺愛が加速して甘々な関係がコミカライズで見られるのは嬉しいです。ネタバレ→クラリスたちはもちろんの事、メイドちゃんとシドも幸せになりますし、マリウスもいい人見つけて幸せになります。絵は綺麗ですが、男性はカッコよく描いているのに女性が(とくにクラリスとメアリー)可愛くない…もっと可愛く描いて欲しかった。髪を下ろしたジーンがめちゃくちゃカッコよかった。

This review contains spoilers. I read the original story and knew it, so I read Comicalize, but that's right. However, there is an R scene in this original work (although it's still a long way off), but I wonder if an R scene will be drawn. Reading it feels like it's for all ages, so there probably won't be an R scene. Clarisse's parents' house felt refreshed, wasn't it? I'm happy to be able to see Gene's infatuated love accelerate and their sweet relationship is comicalized. Spoiler → Not to mention Clarice and the others, Maid and Sid will also be happy, and Marius will also be happy to find a good person. The picture is beautiful, but men draw in a cool way, but women (especially Clarice and Mary) aren't cute... I wanted them to be even cuter. Jean with her hair down was so cool.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

身代わり

substitution

This review contains spoilers. 主人公が身代わりになるお話は、身代わりであることを相手に隠して苦労するパターンが多いと思いますが、この主人公は潔く辺境伯に明かしよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. In stories where the main character takes the place, I think there are many patterns where people struggle by hiding that they are substitutes from their opponents, but it was nice that this protagonist was gracefully revealed to the frontier Haku.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

心が洗われる

My heart is washed

This review contains spoilers. 家族に虐げられ地味に生きて来た令嬢が姉の身代わりで結婚させられるのですが、主人公の令嬢の心が綺麗で優しくて素敵な女性です。辺境伯も心根が真っ直ぐで優しく主人公を包み込む感じが心洗われます。大好きな作品です。

This review contains spoilers. A daughter who was oppressed by her family and has lived a sober life is made to get married in place of her older sister, and the main character, the daughter, is a wonderful woman with a beautiful heart. The feeling that the frontier Haku also has a straight heart and gently envelops the protagonist is heart-washing. It's a work I love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリーがしっかりしている

The story is solid

色んな漫画を読んできたけど、この手の漫画ってストーリーがベタだったり回りくどかったりするけど、嫌味のないピュアなストーリーで新鮮な気持ちでしっかり読めるから早く続きが読みたいです。旦那様もカッコよくて凄く素敵。この漫画は読まないと損するかもね。最後まで楽しみです。

I've read a lot of comics, and the story of this kind of comic is solid and complicated, but it's a pure story with no disgust and I can read it clearly with a fresh feeling, so I want to read more soon. My husband is also cool and really nice. You might lose money if you don't read this comic. I'm looking forward to the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

どんどんハマっていく

I'm getting more and more addicted

とても良い作品です。ストーリーがいい！読んでいくうちにどんどんハマっていきます(*´꒳`*)似たようなお話もたくさんある中で、この作品は最高です♪何度も読み返してます?

It's a very good work. Nice story! As I read it, I became more and more addicted to it (*'`*) Among the many similar stories, this work is the best ♪ Have you reread it over and over again?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

幸あれ…

good luck...

This review contains spoilers. 蔑まれて育った主人公だけど、ジーン様に見初められて幸せが近くなってよかったです。お姉様が本当に意地が悪くてスゴい…両親のまさかの事実にもびっくり…この先、２人が何事もなく幸せになりますように！

This review contains spoilers. It's the main character who grew up being looked down upon, but I'm glad I was first seen by Gene and happiness became close. My older sister is really mean and amazing... I was surprised by the unexpected fact of my parents... I hope the two of them will be happy without incident in the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

落ち着いている二人！

The two are calm!

よくある家族に虐げられた令嬢が恐ろしいと噂の貴族へ身代わりで嫁いだら、実は見目麗しいだけでなくいい人で・・・と言ったら身も蓋もないんだけど、ストーリーも絵もキレイで、辺境の地は寒いんだろうと思わせるような温度感があったり、クラリスが健気で聡明で、ジーンが重厚感ありつつ落ち着いていて、それでいて暖かな二人でお互いを大切に思って、本当に少しずつ心を交わしていく過程が丁寧に描かれているのがいい。恋愛は控え目でも、ジーンに守られてる安心感があるのがとても素敵！

When a daughter who was oppressed by a common family got married in place of an aristocrat rumored to be fearsome, she was actually not only good-looking, but she had no body or soul... but the story and pictures were beautiful, there was a sense of temperature that made you think the frontier land was cold, Clarice was healthy and intelligent, and Jean was calm yet profound, and the process of really exchanging hearts little by little was carefully depicted It's good to be there. Even though romance is humble, it's so nice to have a sense of security being protected by Gene!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

最高のコミカライズです！！

It's comicalization at its best!!

キャラ、ストーリー、演出、全てが完璧です。1番はキャラの魅せ方が本当に素晴らしいということ。キャラの細かい演技やセリフがしっかりしているので、自然と感情移入して引き込まれます。設定が面白いのでこれからのヒロインの活躍が楽しみです！

The characters, story, and direction are all perfect. Number one is that the way the characters are attractive is really amazing. The detailed performances and lines of the characters are solid, so you can naturally empathize and be drawn in. The setting is interesting, so I'm looking forward to the heroine's future activities!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻まで読んでください

Please read until volume 2

１巻まではよくある異世界ものかな？と思いながら読み進め…。２巻から加速度的に面白くなります！ファーレンハイトの秘密が明かされてからはもう課金が止まらない。キャラもいいです。

I wonder if volume 1 is a common thing from another world? Keep reading while thinking... It gets interesting at an accelerated rate starting from volume 2! Once Fahrenheit's secrets have been revealed, they haven't stopped charging. The characters are nice too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ステキ

wonderful

心がキレイだからこそ、回りにはしっかりと伝わって、みんなから愛されてるんだな。姉は地獄に堕ちてくれ。

Because they have a beautiful heart, they are clearly conveyed to people around them, and they are loved by everyone. My sister should go to hell.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

試し読みでハマりました！絵がきれいなだけでなく、内容もよく、早く続きが読みたい。次々明かされる秘密がたまりません♡

I'm addicted to the trial reading! Not only are the pictures beautiful, but the content is good, and I want to read more quickly. The secrets revealed one after another are irresistible ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がキレイ

The picture is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. すごく、絵がきれいで物語も引き込まれる感じで先が気になる！！姉の憎たらしさがさらに妹の賢さと奥ゆかしさを際立たせていて面白いです！！

This review contains spoilers. It's amazing, the pictures are beautiful and the story draws me in, so I'm worried about the future!! My older sister's hatred further accentuates my younger sister's cleverness and profundity, which is interesting!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あぁ、最高

Oh, that's great

好きです。こういうお話をずっと探していたかと思うほど、すごく読むのが楽しいです。ちゃんとお話としても展開が面白いし、これぞ王道と思える部分もキュンキュンします。なにより不器用さがあまりにも焦ったくて、一周回ってキュンとくるんですよ。最高です。

I like it. It's so much fun to read that I think I've been looking for stories like this for a long time. The development is interesting even as a proper story, and the part where I think this is a royal road is also exciting. Above all, their clumsiness is so impatient that they go around a circle and it makes me cringe. It's awesome.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

久しぶりにはまってます。

I haven't been addicted to it in a long time.

話しの内容はよくある感じなのかもしれないけど、辺境伯爵に大切にされて、少しずつ恋を意識して、惹かれていく場面は、キュンキュンしてしまいます。久々に購入して良かったと思える作品。早く続きが読みたい。まだかな～？もうそろそろじゃないかと思っていますが。

The content of the story may be a common feeling, but the scene where they are cherished by the frontier count, gradually become aware of love, and are attracted to it makes me cringe. This is a work I'm glad I bought after a long time. I want to read more soon. not yet? I think it's about time, though.

Helpful

Reviews for <Chapter release>The Counterfeit's Fateful Encounter Manga