Lady Lydia's Beautiful Determination Betrayed, and Set on Breaking Off an Engagement Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

サクサク進み読みやすい！

It progresses quickly and is easy to read!

This review contains spoilers. アーネスト様カッコいい！帰国してくれて良かった！ロジェなんかと結婚しないで良かった！本気のヒーローは間違いなくこっち！と思える展開です。ストーリーがダラダラしてなくて良い！あとはリディアが幸せになってくれる事を願ってます。

This review contains spoilers. Ernest is so cool! I'm glad you came back home! I'm glad I didn't get married to Roger! The real hero is definitely here! It's a development that makes you think. The story doesn't have to be lackluster! After that, I hope Lydia will be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

クズ過ぎる

Too much scum

This review contains spoilers. 3話までがロジェがクズ過ぎてイライラし過ぎて4話でスッキリするには少し足りなくて早く続きを見たくてたまらない。リディアにあんな仕打ちをしておいて婚約破棄する気はないとか、どんな風に考えてるかとかも知りたい。

This review contains spoilers. Up to episode 3, Roger was too scum and too frustrated, and episode 4 wasn't enough to feel refreshed, so I'm dying to watch the continuation soon. I also want to know how Lydia is thinking about having treated her like that and that she doesn't feel like annulling her engagement.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公がかっこいい

The main character is cool

This review contains spoilers. とにかくスカッとするからおすすめ！次から次へと新しい展開が起こるので飽きないです。令嬢もので1番好きかも。

This review contains spoilers. Anyway, I recommend it because it's refreshing! New developments are happening one after another, so I never get tired of it. Maybe it's my daughter's favorite thing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

This review contains spoilers. 連載が始まってまだ間もないですがとても面白いです。ヒロインは王太子妃になってハッピーエンドかな？先は気になるので小説を読んでみようと思います。続きも楽しみにしています！

This review contains spoilers. It hasn't been long since the series started, but it's very interesting. Does the heroine have a happy ending after becoming the Crown Princess? I'm worried about the future, so I think I'll read the novel. I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

リディ

Liddy

頑張ったねリディ…っ！！これからの展開がとってもきになります！！清々しいほどにあいつはクソ女だったなぁ

Good work Liddy... huh!! The future developments are going to be amazing!! so refreshingly, that guy was a damn woman

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ひどい

worse

This review contains spoilers. 婚約者も浮気相手のオンナも、品がなくて酷すぎます。弾劾できたのはスカッとしたけど、それでも傷付くのはヒロイン…｡王太子様、リディをシアワセにして！

This review contains spoilers. Both my fiancé and the woman I'm cheating on have no good stuff, so it's too bad. It was a surprise that they were able to be impeached, but it was the heroine that still hurt... Crown Prince, make Liddy stand up!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ザマァにはスッキリしましたが

I was so refreshed

This review contains spoilers. 最新話まで読みましたが、ロジェが分からなかった。リディアと婚約破棄する気も、エイミーと婚約するつもりもなかったのに、何故エイミーと恋仲という噂を払拭する努力をしなかったのか。何故リディアよりもエイミーの肩を持つような言動に徹していたのか。「言われて気づいた」ような場面かありましたが何故言われるまで気づかなかったのか。何を考えているのか、結局どうしたかったのかが分かりませんでした。4話目の感じだとエイミーはまた出てきますよね。まぁまたざまぁになるはずなので楽しみにしてます。ロジェはどうだろう……まぁもう出てきたところでリディアには近づけないと思いますがね（＾ｖ＾）

This review contains spoilers. I read the latest episode, but I didn't understand Roger. I didn't feel like breaking up my engagement with Lydia, and I had no intention of getting engaged to Amy, so why didn't they make an effort to dispel the rumor that they were in love with Amy? Why was she devoting more time to words and actions like holding Amy's shoulder over Lydia? There was a scene where “I was told and noticed,” but why didn't I notice it until I was told? I didn't understand what I was thinking or what I wanted to do after all. If it's like episode 4, Amy will come out again, right? Well, it should be all over again, so I'm looking forward to it. What about Roger... well, I don't think I can get close to Lydia since it just came out (^v^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

待望のコミカライズ

The long-awaited comicalization

This review contains spoilers. もともとの作品を読んでいて待望のコミカライズだったけど、ちょっとロジェリオの見た目がイメージと違ったかも···もう少しおとなしそうな寡黙そうなイメージだったんだけど、ロジェの見た目チャラ男すぎるような···。原作あんまり口数多いタイプじゃなかったと思うんだよね。エイミーはイメージピッタリ。ちょっとロジェだけ原作から改変されてしまった感があります。弾劾される時ロジェは騎士らしく罪状を聞いて自分のやらかしを理解できていたのかあまり反論してなかった気がする。概ね弾劾の中で自分の罪を理解して大人しく反省していた気がするんだよね。逆にエイミーが本性露にして喚いて暴れて、それでやっとエイミーの本性を知ったロジェが何で主人公や家族がエイミーと距離を置けと言ったのか、どうして警告されたのか理解した感じだったよね？ロジェはエイミーの事婚約者であるリディ以外で関わった初めての女友達で、ただ物珍し感じだったから恋愛感情ではなく、家族じゃないけど手が焼ける妹分みたいな感じで見てたんじゃないかなって思えたのでエイミーの本性を目の当たりにしてやっと正気に戻った感じだった気がする。弾劾中も原作ロジェの方がもう少し好感持てたかな。※途中まで読んでの感想です※だいぶ原作改悪されてしまってロジェとか全然キャラ違うし原作冒涜してるといってもいいようなキャラ改悪、原作改悪酷くない？みんな原作を一度読んでほしい。なんでこんなに改悪しちゃったの？ストーリーでは加害者側だが、原作改悪の一番の被害者がロジェ···。こんなにキャラ改悪する必要あった？原作では弾劾後リディを貶めるような事言わないし、弾劾後の救貧院もリディアが騎士であったロジェから騎士の道を奪ってしまうのは···って与えた最後の慈悲で、ロジェは自分がこれだけリディを傷つけたのに、慈悲を与えたリディに心から反省し、感謝して必死に救貧院の任務についていたよね？人の作品をコミカライズするのだから、原作をもっとリスペクトしてほしい。コミカライズを原作さんがどんな気持ちで読んだだろうって思うと複雑な気持ち。改悪は原作に泥塗るのと同じ事でしょ？出版社の意向なのか、誰が改悪したのかわからないけど、酷いレベルの改悪だと思う。これだと物語が変わってしまうよ？原作者さん怒っていいレベルだと思うよ。ロジェ別人じゃん。

This review contains spoilers. I was reading the original work and it was a long-awaited comicalization, but maybe Rogério's appearance was slightly different from the image... it was a slightly more quiet and quiet image, but Roger's look was too crazy... I don't think the original story was the type with that much talk. Amy's image is perfect. There is a feeling that only Roger has been slightly modified from the original. I have a feeling that when he was impeached, Roger heard the charges like a knight and didn't really refute whether he understood what he did. I generally feel that during the impeachment, I understood my own crimes and quietly reflected on them. On the other hand, Amy revealed her true nature and went wild, and it felt like Roger, who finally knew Amy's true nature, understood why the main character and family told them to keep their distance from Amy, and why they were warned, right? Roger was the first female friend that got involved with Amy other than Liddy, who is her fiancé, and since it was just unusual, it wasn't a romantic feeling, and I thought she was watching it like a younger sister whose hands were burning even though she wasn't a family, so I feel like she finally came back to her sanity after witnessing Amy's true nature. I wonder if the original Roger was a little more likable during the impeachment. ※This is my impression of reading it halfway through ※Isn't the character reform so bad that the original story has been modified quite a bit, and the characters are completely different from Roger and it's safe to say that they have blasphemed the original story? I want everyone to read the original story at least once. Why did it get so bad? In the story, it's the perpetrator's side, but the biggest victim of the original modification is Roger... Did the characters need to be improved this much? The original story doesn't say anything that would discredit Liddy after the impeachment, and the almshouse after the impeachment also took Lydia's way as a knight was the last mercy he gave... and even though he hurt Liddy this much, Roger sincerely reflected and thanked Liddy who gave her mercy, and desperately went about the mission of the almshouse, right? They comicalize people's works, so I want them to respect the original work even more. It's a mixed feeling when I think about how the original author felt when reading Comicalize. Isn't reform the same thing as putting mud on the original story? I don't know if it was the publisher's intention or who made the revisions, but I think it's a terrible level of reform. this would change the story, right? I think it's a good level for the original author to get angry. Roger is a different person.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良くある話しなのですが、

It's a common story,

This review contains spoilers. アーネスト王太子と妹パトリシアが素敵なのと、リディアが凛としつつも傷付きやすい少女みたいな心の持ち主で、引き込まれました。エイミーは典型的な自己愛性人格障害なのですが、なぜリディアをターゲットにして陥れようとしたのか？は、もうエイミーを見たくないので、描かなくて結構ですw(見るとしたら、エイミーは、牢屋でボロボロになってるにも関わらず、監修に色目を使おうとして失敗するとか馬鹿みたいな末路だけは見てみたいですw)

This review contains spoilers. I was drawn in by the fact that Prince Ernest and his sister Patricia are wonderful, and that Lydia has a heart like a girl who is both dignified and easily hurt. Amy has a typical narcissistic personality disorder, so why did they target Lydia and try to fall into it? I don't want to see Amy anymore, so I don't need to draw it lol (if I were to watch, I'd just like to see Amy, despite being in tatters in prison, she failed in an attempt to use color vision in supervision and was an idiot lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続き読みたい！

I want to keep reading!

This review contains spoilers. 絵が好みでつい買い進めてしまいました。眼差しが綺麗で好きです。無事断罪も終わりラスト…あとはラストまで！読みたい！そういえば破棄宣言が主人公からって割と珍しいタイプな気もしました。

This review contains spoilers. I liked the picture, so I just went ahead and bought it. I like her pretty eyes. The conviction is over and the end... the rest is until the end! I want to read it! Speaking of which, I also felt that the annulment declaration was a relatively rare type from the main character.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになって欲しい

I want you to be happy

当たり前の事が、わからないで自分のことばかり言う人が本当にいる相手の気持ちなんて、解ろうともしないで、自分の気持ちだけ、同じ気持ちを相手も思っていることをどうやってわかってもらえるのか、本当に悩んでしまう事がある、強く言っても逆効果だし、そんな人の為に悩むリディアには、幸せになって欲しい自分のまわりに振り回されて、悩んででもそれは自分中心だから、でも、それで強くなれると思いたいいろんな事を乗り越えて強くなるリディア、頑張れ

Things that are taken for granted, there are people who only talk about themselves without understanding how they really worry about how they can understand only their own feelings, and it's counterproductive even if you say it strongly, and Lydia, who worries for such people, wants them to be happy, and even if she's worried, it's self-centered, but I want them to be happy, and I want to think that even if they are worried, it's because they can become stronger with it Lydia gets stronger by overcoming a lot of things, do your best

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

期待をこめて

With anticipation

他の方のレビューにもあるとおりよくある設定です。ですがその定式のなかでいかに面白く感じられるか、それもまた醍醐味となりますよね?本作はスピード感と情報のバランスがよく、絵が綺麗で読んでいてコミカライズの良さを満喫しました。原作はまた違った描写もあるみたいで、こちらも気になっています。続きが楽しみです?

This is a common setting, as described in other people's reviews. But how interesting you can feel in that formula is also a real thrill, isn't it? This work had a good balance of speed and information, and I enjoyed the good comicalization because the pictures were beautiful and I read it. There also seems to be a different depiction of the original story, so I'm curious about this too. are you looking forward to the continuation?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです。

It's interesting.

This review contains spoilers. 婚約者がクズだ。婚約者の彼女の事を考えないで、他の女に優しくするなんて。早くリディアが幸せな姿が見たいです。

This review contains spoilers. The engagement sucks. Don't think about your engaged girlfriend and be nice to other women. I want to see Lydia happy soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

先が気になる

I'm worried about the future

This review contains spoilers. いくら気心しれた婚約者だとはいえ、婚約者を大事にしないロジェには怒りしかないですね！ロジェは立派な貴族なのに、常識的な行いも出来ない人にリディにはもったいない。3巻まで読みましたが、リディはロジェに愛はないようで…(このことに関してはホント良かった)王太子とリディのこれから二人の行くへが楽しみです。ロジェとエイミーの糾弾が、より重くなることを強く望みます。

This review contains spoilers. No matter how caring she is about her fiancé, there's nothing but anger at Roger for not taking care of her fiancé! Even though Roger is a fine aristocrat, Liddy would be a waste to someone who can't even act with common sense. I've read up to 3 volumes, but Liddy doesn't seem to love Roger... (I'm really glad about this) I'm looking forward to seeing the Crown Prince and Liddy go in the future. I strongly hope that Roger and Amy's accusations will become heavier.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

勧善懲悪！

encourage good, punish, evil!

This review contains spoilers. 悪女の悪事が発覚するわするわ！公衆の面前で弾劾されて、化けの皮が剥がれるの楽しみ！早く次巻が読みたいです⤴

This review contains spoilers. The evil woman's misdeeds will be discovered! I'm looking forward to being impeached in front of the public and having my monster skin peeled off! I want to read the next volume soon ⤴

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

これからスッキリするんだろうなぁと期待

I'm expecting it to feel refreshed from now on

This review contains spoilers. 婚約者がまるっと心変わりして、捨てられるのかと思ったら、融通不断な男に根性のクソ悪い女が、自分の優越感を得るためだけに近づいて、男は気づいてないようで、周りが証拠を集めて、断罪する話。みたいですね。早く続き読みたいです。どうなるのかなぁと期待してます。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where her fiancé completely changes her mind, and when she wonders if she'll be abandoned, a woman with bad guts approaches an adaptable man only to gain her own sense of superiority, and the man doesn't seem to notice, and people around her gather evidence and condemn them. It's like that. I want to continue reading soon. I'm looking forward to what will happen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きが読みたい?

Want to read more soon?

リディアがここからどう婚約者と侍女をぎゃふん?と言わせてストーリーが進んで行くのかとっても楽しみです。

how does lydia get her fiance and handmaiden from here on out? I'm really excited to see if the story progresses after making me say that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

完結まであれば流れで買うんだけど。。

If it's done, I'll just buy it as it is...

内容は魔法もなく聖女でもなく、貴族の話。モヤモヤするからすっきりしたくて最新刊まで購入したけど。時間が経つとなんとなくわかる結末を購入するかな？もう少しまとまってから掲載の方が良いかと。。、

The story is about aristocrats, without magic, and not about saints. It's confusing, so I bought even the latest edition because I wanted to keep myself refreshed. I wonder if they'll buy an ending that you'll somehow understand as time goes by? I wonder if it would be better to wait a little longer before posting... ,

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

スッキリ〜！

Refreshing~!

もう、これでもか!と!スッキリしたい方に是非オススメですね～めちゃくちゃスッキリしそうです。3話まで購入。楽しみです。

this is it already! and! I definitely recommend it to those who want to feel refreshed~ it seems insanely refreshing. Buy up to 3 episodes. I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

婚約者

fiancee

This review contains spoilers. 長い間婚約関係だとたまに全くの接点がないような女性が現れたら心惹かれるのかな？女性はあざとくわざと媚びているけど婚約者が最優先じゃないだけで、すでに婚約者として最低では？

This review contains spoilers. If a woman who has been engaged for a long time shows up once in a while and you don't have any contact at all, would you be attracted to it? Women are playfully flattering, but it's just that their fiancé isn't their top priority, so aren't they already the worst as fiancés?

Helpful

Reviews for Lady Lydia's Beautiful Determination Betrayed, and Set on Breaking Off an Engagement Manga