Replicant -What It Means to Love Dolly, the Sheep- Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

高評価につられて購入

I bought it because it was highly rated

第3次世界大戦により人口減少のための対策として、新たな人類としてクローンを認めた近未来を描いたもの。クリスの回想部分が本編なんですが、切なさの中に狂気・執着が見え隠れしていて、そのバランスが良かった。難点といえばページ数のからみ(トータル110頁)からか結ばれてからの描写が少ないということ。もうちょっと話に浸かりたかったかな。

It depicts a near future where clones were recognized as new humans as countermeasures for population decline due to World War III. Chris's recollection is the main story, and insanity and obsession were visible and hidden in the sadness, and that balance was good. The downside is that there are few depictions after being connected, probably because of the entanglement in the number of pages (110 pages in total). Maybe I wanted to immerse myself in the story a little more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

考えてしまう

It makes me think

正直、思った通りの展開でした。ですが、絵と表情が物語に深みを出しています。クローンとか同性愛とかについて、色々考えさせられる作品でした。

To be honest, it developed just as I expected. However, the pictures and expressions add depth to the story. It was a work that made me think a lot about cloning and homosexuality.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

人を愛することが出来るって素晴らしい

Being able to love people is wonderful

人を愛するのって尊いとはじめて思わせてくれた作品ですガチ泣きしました人を愛せるって本当に素晴らしい尊い(涙)なかなか出来ることではないから内側から芽生えてはじめて出来る自然な現象だから人を愛する感情の芽生えは貴重なものだとこの作品が私に人生ではじめて感じさせて教えてくれました。ありがとうございます！(泣)

It's a work that first made me think that loving someone is precious. I cried a lot, being able to love someone is really wonderful and precious (tears). It's a natural phenomenon that can only sprout from within, so this work made me feel for the first time in my life that the emergence of feelings of loving people is precious because it's not easy to do. Thank you so much! (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

近未来映画

Futuristic films

This review contains spoilers. 短いページ数に、恋愛だけでなくギュッと道徳や倫理観も収まっていて、映画を一本見終わったような何度も見返したくなるお話でした。クローンとなり変わることを一瞬で判断したところは、彼の愛情の深さを感じます。

This review contains spoilers. Not only love but also moral and ethical values were tightly packed into a short number of pages, and it was a story that made me want to look back over and over again as if I had finished watching one movie. I can feel the depth of his love when he decided in an instant that he would turn into a clone.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

何と言うか、、、せつないなあ

What do you say... that's too annoying

This review contains spoilers. ハピエンと言えばそうなんだけど、、お互いの幸せを思うあまり愛してると伝えられなかった主人公と彼。クローンに人権が与えられるまでの扱いと、愛する人の為結局臓器移植を推進してしまった、移植反対派だった主人公の心情を思うと本当、ハピエンなのに切ない！

This review contains spoilers. Speaking of Happien, that's right, but the main character and him couldn't be conveyed that they love each other so much because they think about each other's happiness. When I think about the treatment until human rights are given to clones and the feelings of the protagonist who was an opponent of transplantation, who eventually promoted organ transplantation for his loved ones, it's really sad even though it's happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで切なくキレイなお話

A sad and beautiful story until the end

絵に惹かれて購入しましたが近未来のSFでBLと言うよりは切ない恋愛物語でした。単話を簡潔にまとめられているので無駄がなくテンポ良くストーリーが進みますが登場人物の葛藤も伝わってきます。出来ればもっと読みたいと思うほど主人公達が魅力的です。仮想の外国が舞台なので導入部からまるで映画を観ているようでした。描き下ろしのお陰で足りなかったセス側の心情が知れてピースがハマった感じです。良かったです。

I was attracted to the picture and bought it, but it was a sad romance story rather than BL in futuristic sci-fi. Since the single story is summarized in a concise manner, there is no waste and the story progresses at a good tempo, but the conflicts of the characters are also conveyed. The more I want to read if possible, the more fascinating the main characters are. Since it's set in a virtual foreign country, it was like watching a movie from the introduction. Thanks to the drawing, the feelings on Seth's side, which were lacking, became known, and I felt like Peace was addicted to it. That was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

近未来でありそうな世界

A world likely to be in the near future

This review contains spoilers. タイトルからレプリカントのお話だとわかりますが、切ないクリスの気持ちがよくわかる、素敵なお話で、こうくるかという意外な顛末でした。ネタバレはなしで読んだほうがいいです。いつまでかはわかりませんが、今は読みホでも読めます。

This review contains spoilers. You can tell from the title that it's a replicant story, but it's a wonderful story where you can really understand the sad feelings of Chris, and it was a surprising story that it would turn out this way. You'd better read it without spoilers. I don't know how long it will last, but now I can read it even if I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

先生の作品大好きです！

I love the teacher's work!

「君は僕を管理する」が衝撃的で大好きな作品なんですが、先生の作品にしてはページ数が少ないので、あんまりなのかなとかSFモノ苦手なんだよなと思っていた私がバカでした。こんな感動作品に出会えて私は幸せ者だわ。

“You Manage Me” is shocking and I love it, but since the number of pages is small for my teacher's work, I was stupid because I thought it wasn't that many or that I wasn't good at sci-fi stuff. I'm a happy person to come across this moving product.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

星新一？

Shinichi Hoshi?

This review contains spoilers. 何も見ないで一回読んでほしいです。と言いつつ初めてレビュー書いてしまいました。一度読んだら、えええ～って思ってもう一度読みたくなります。切なさの分よかったなぁ～と思うかもしれません。泣いたの初めてです。

This review contains spoilers. I want you to read it once without looking at anything. While saying that, I ended up writing a review for the first time. Once I read it, I thought yeah... and I want to read it again. You might think it was good to understand the sadness. This is the first time I've cried.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

クローン。

clones.

This review contains spoilers. すっきりとまとまった綺麗な物語でした。セスの愛が深すぎですね。どんだけクリスのこと愛してんだっていう。愛する人と幸せに生涯を全うできた2人のお話、素敵でした。

This review contains spoilers. It was a beautiful story that was neatly put together. Seth's love is too deep, isn't it? They say how much I love Chris. It was a wonderful story about two people who were able to complete their lives happily with their loved ones.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

この値段で良いのか…？(ネタバレなし)

is this price good...? (no spoilers)

全人類に読んで欲しい……！このページ数で「あれ、私今映画見たんか？」ってなるの凄すぎて……凄いです。あの、何言ってもネタバレなりそうだから何も言えないけど何も見ずに、なんならレビューもバレありそうだから見ずにとにかく読んでみてください！愛です、愛……！

I want all of humanity to read it...! The number of pages says “Huh, did I watch the movie just now?” Naru is so amazing... it's amazing. Um, no matter what you say, it's likely to be a spoiler, so I can't say anything, but don't watch anything, and if anything, the reviews are likely to get caught, so please read it anyway without looking at it! It's love, love...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 100Pほどのお話にクリスとセスの思いがぐっと詰まってました。両片思いの切なさ。お互い知ってて知らないふり。できれば全てを二人で話し合ってほしかった。でもそのささいなすれ違いがあっても、最後まで添い遂げた二人に、幸せと切なさの両方を感じます。

This review contains spoilers. Chris and Seth's thoughts were so packed into the 100P story. the sadness of unrequited love. Pretend we know each other and don't know. I wanted the two of us to discuss everything if possible. But even with that little misunderstanding, I feel both happy and sad for the two who stayed together until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵もストーリーも良い。

The picture and story are good.

近未来のファンタジー作品ですが、現実にあってもおかしくないお話だと思いました。クローンという題材でピュアな愛が描かれていて着想が凄いなと感じました。欲を言えばもう少し長くても良かったのかなと思います。

It's a fantasy work from the near future, but I thought it was a story that wouldn't be strange even if it were in reality. Pure love was depicted under the subject of cloning, and I felt that the idea was amazing. Speaking of greed, I think it would have been nice if it was a little longer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最高に純愛でした

It was pure love at its best

とにかく純粋な綺麗な恋愛模様で読み終わったあと切なく胸が締め付けられる様な、けど幸福感もともに得られるそんな作品でした。おすすめです！！

Anyway, it was such a work that made my heart feel sad when I finished reading it, but I was also able to get a sense of happiness. I recommend it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

映画にしてほしいような

I want it to be made into a movie

内容だったな、胸がギュッとなるよ。そして最後にオイイイイイイ泣ってなるやつこういう胸が苦しくなるような漫画弱いんだよ

That was the content, it made my heart ache. And the one that makes me cry at the end is a weak comic that makes my heart ache

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ただの綺麗な話、ではない。

It's not just a pretty story.

This review contains spoilers. 短いのであっという間に終わっちゃう。なのでクリスが最後に幸せだったのかそうじゃなかったのか、はっきりと私には分からなかった。いや人を騙してるんだから幸せじゃなかったよね。綺麗な話のようだけど、とりようによっては凄く狡い話にも見える話が、飴細工のような繊細な絵で丁寧に丁寧に描かれてます。

This review contains spoilers. It's short, so it'll be over in no time. So I didn't know for sure if Chris was happy at the end or not. No, I wasn't happy because I was deceiving people. It seems like a beautiful story, but depending on how you take it, it looks like a very cunning story, and the story is carefully and carefully drawn with delicate pictures like candy zaiku.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃ

It's a mess

良かったこのお話。絵柄とか雰囲気からもう好きなんだけどとっても切なくて優しいお話だった。単行本になってないのもったいない

I'm glad this story. I already like it because of the design and atmosphere, but it was a very sad and gentle story. It would be a waste that it wasn't turned into a standalone book

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

クローン研究の話。

I'm talking about cloning research.

サブタイトルの意味が全くわからず(読んだ今でもわかってませんがw)苦手なジャンルかなと敬遠。でも何故か気になりだしたので読んでみると絵が世界観と合っててすぐに引き込まれましたね。クローン研究をしているクリスとセスの２人のそれぞれの苦悩が表現されててとっても素敵な話でした。

I don't understand the meaning of the subtitle at all (I still don't understand after reading it lol) and I'm afraid it's a genre I'm not good at. But for some reason I started to get interested, so when I read it, the picture matched my view of the world and I was immediately drawn in. It was a very wonderful story that expressed the anguish of Chris and Seth, who are doing cloning research.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです！

That was interesting!

ストーリー重視で、エロほぼ無しでBL苦手でも最後まで読めると思います。婚約者も含め、最終的に皆幸せで良かった！書き下ろしで、何気ない日常が垣間見れて嬉しかったです。とても良いお話だったので、欲を言えばもう少し長く読めたらよかった。

It focuses on the story, and there is almost no eroticism, so I think I can read it until the end even if I'm not good at BL. I'm glad everyone was happy in the end, including my fiancee! I was happy to be able to catch a glimpse of casual everyday life after writing it down. It was a very good story, so if I had to say greed, I wish I could read it a little longer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

じーん

Gene

This review contains spoilers. 切なくてジーンとしました。最後の最後にあの手紙。2人の気持ちが深く考えさせられる話でした。また読みたくなる話です。

This review contains spoilers. I was so sad that I decided to go with Gene. That letter at the very end. It was a story that made me think deeply about their feelings. It's a story I want to read again.

Helpful

Reviews for Replicant -What It Means to Love Dolly, the Sheep- Manga