The Rising of the Shield Hero: The Manga Companion Manga Reviews (P.8)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから入りました

Entered from anime

先にアニメを観てから読みました。最初のほうは理不尽ですが、主人公が、徐々に信頼できる仲間達を得て、能力も獲得していくのが面白いです。この先どうなるのか、楽しみです。

I watched the anime first and then read it. The first one is unreasonable, but it's interesting that the protagonist gradually gains reliable friends and acquires abilities. I'm looking forward to seeing what the future holds.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

成り上がり

The rise

This review contains spoilers. 異世界に召喚しておいて、盾の勇者だからってこの扱いは酷すぎる。他の勇者が皆無能なのが、ちょっと気になりました。主人公の努力や有能さを際立たせるためとはいえ、なんでこんな使えない人間ばかりが勇者として選ばれて召喚されたのか、召喚基準が謎すぎます。

This review contains spoilers. Summoned to another world, this treatment is too harsh just because he is a shield hero. I was a little worried that all the other brave men were incompetent. Even though it was to highlight the protagonist's efforts and abilities, the summoning criteria are too mysterious why only such unusable humans were selected and summoned as heroes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

オタクの大学生が盾の勇者として召喚されて

An otaku college student is summoned as the Shield Hero

「小説家になろう」発人気小説のコミカライズ作品。盾の勇者として異世界に召喚されるが、冒険三日目にして仲間に裏切られ、信頼と金銭を一度に失う。他者が信じられなくった主人公は、奴隷商から亜人の少女ラフタリアを買い、二人で旅に出る。鳥型の魔物フィーロも仲間に加え各地で民草を助けながら、来るべき波に備えながら旅を続けていくことに……。とにかく面白い。波乱万丈の筋立てが飽きさせない。

A comicalized work of the popular novel “Let's Be a Novelist.” He is summoned to another world as the Shield Hero, but on the third day of the adventure, he is betrayed by his friends, and he loses his trust and money all at once. The protagonist, who is unable to believe others, buys Raphtalia, an Ajin girl from a slave dealer, and the two of them embark on a journey. In addition to his friends, the bird-shaped monster Philo also decided to continue his journey while preparing for the coming waves while helping folk herbs in various places... Anyway, it's interesting. The eventful plot won't let you get tired of it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです。

It's interesting.

大好きな作家さんで、ぜひともオススメしたいと思います。ストーリーも、キャラクターも、とても良いと思います。

I love this writer, and I would definitely recommend it. I think the story and characters are very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

異世界召喚

Summon Isekai

This review contains spoilers. 異世界に召喚された4人のうち、盾の勇者の尚文だけが冷遇され様々な汚名を着せられてどん底に落ちるところからのスタート。盾の性能をどんどん上げて強くなっていく過程がおもしろい。汚名が晴れるまではかなり長く何度もイライラさせられますけどね。

This review contains spoilers. Of the 4 people summoned to another world, only Naofumi, the shield hero, was treated coldly and put on various stigmatization, and it started from where it fell to the bottom. The process of increasing the shield's performance and getting stronger is interesting. It's quite a long time until the stigma clears up, but it makes me frustrated over and over again, though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

勇者

hero

This review contains spoilers. 主人公が、いろいろとかわいそうな展開になっていくのですが、物語としては、たのしくよむことができました。冒頭から、いろいろなことがおきるので、飽きずによめる作品だとおもいます。

This review contains spoilers. The main character unfolds in a lot of pitiful ways, but as a story, I was able to read it in a fun way. A lot of things happen from the beginning, so I think it's a work I never get tired of.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

胸くそを乗り越えてからが面白い

It's interesting after getting over a heartbreak

早々に胸くそ展開すぎるけど、そこからのし上がっていく様はやはり面白いです。防御オンリーの盾の使い方も多様だし、つかいようによってはチート級だったり、バトルにも魅力があって止まらなくなります。他の異世界ものとはまた違う世界観で、先が読めない面白さもあるし。ただひとつ気になることがあるとすれば、主人公ショタキラーすぎるwてとこでしょうか

It unfolds too fast, but it's still interesting how they move up from there. There are many ways to use defense-only shields, and depending on how you use them, they are cheat levels, and battles are so attractive that you won't be able to stop. It's a different worldview from other otherworldly things, and it's also interesting that you can't read ahead. If there's just one thing I'm worried about, it's probably where the main character Shota Killer is too lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

盾の勇者への対応が酷い

Dealing with the Shield Hero is terrible

This review contains spoilers. 2巻まで読んだ。4人が剣、弓、槍、盾の勇者として召喚されたけど盾の勇者の尚文に対して他の勇者も王様他城の騎士達からの扱いが酷い。そして最初から胸くそ悪い出来事があって尚文同様怒りしかなかった。ラフタリアと武器屋の親父さんと出会えたのが今のところ救いです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 2 volumes. Four people were summoned as heroes of swords, bows, spears, and shields, but the other brave men were also treated horribly by the knights of the king and other castles against Shobun, the shield hero. Then, there was a heartbreaking incident right from the beginning, and like Naofumi, I had nothing but anger. The fact that I was able to meet Laftalia and her father who is a weapon shop has saved me so far.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

こんなことが…ブック○フに行ってみるか？

Something like this... why don't you go to Bookfu?

This review contains spoilers. 本屋の本が異世界転生させたのか？異世界側から呼ばれたのか？(笑)なんて思ったり思わなかったり。最弱と思ったら最強になれました系王道異世界モノです。大好物なので自分はいつも楽しく読んでいます。自分が読んでいるところまではエロ展開も特にないのでそれ系を求めている方は違う作品を読まれた方がいいと思います。細かく見ていきたい自分にはスキルツリーの一部しか見えないのがもどかしい(笑)

This review contains spoilers. Did the books in the bookstore make you reincarnate in another world? were you called from another world? (Laughter) I thought and didn't think so. When I thought I was the weakest, I was able to become the strongest, and it's a royal road from another world. It's my favorite food, so I always enjoy reading it. There isn't any particular erotic development up to the point I'm reading, so if you're looking for that type, I think it's better to read a different work. I want to take a closer look, and it's frustrating that I can only see part of the skill tree (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

なろう作品の中の秀作

Excellent work among Naro's works

少し前の作品だからか、昨今の玉石混交というのも憚られるようなゴミ溜めとなったなろうコミカライズとは一線を画す存在。世界観としての設定も割と作りこまれているし、主人公の行動理念に首を傾げさせられることもあまりない。上記は当然のことのように思えるが、特に異世界転生のような設定でこれらを満たすのはなかなか難しいらしく、結果、相対的に本作の地位が向上しているようだ。

Perhaps because it was a work from a while ago, the recent mix of boulders is a completely different presence from Naro Comicalize, which has become a fearful garbage bin. The setting as a worldview is also relatively well-crafted, and there aren't many things that make me tilt my head around the protagonist's ideals of action. The above seems obvious, but in particular, it seems quite difficult to satisfy these with settings such as Isekai Reincarnation, and as a result, it seems that the status of this work has improved relatively.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

矛と盾、どちらが強いのか的なお話かと思いきや、主人公がどん底から立ち直ると言うのがメインのお話でした。これ系の主人公は偉いなあといつも思います。

I thought it was a story about which one is stronger, Contradiction or Contradiction, but the main story was about the main character recovering from the bottom. I always think that the main characters in this series are great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

コミカライズでは良い方

The one that is good at comicalize

原作小説未読ある意味追放物の走りみたいな設定。追放というより不遇だが。作画レベルは悪くないのでコミカライズとしては良い方だと思います。

The original novel unread is, in a sense, the setting is like Run for Exile. It's more of a misfortune than an expulsion, though. The drawing level isn't bad, so I think it's a good comicalization.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とてもおすすめ

Highly recommended

This review contains spoilers. この漫画は主人公が盾の勇者として異世界に召喚されます。ですが、仲間に裏切られて全てを失います。そのどん底から立ち上がる物語です

This review contains spoilers. In this comic, the main character is summoned to another world as the Shield Hero. However, he was betrayed by his friends and he lost everything. It's a story that rises from the bottom

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作未読

Unread the original

原作は未読です。コミカライズ、とても丁寧だと思います。分かりやすくて読みやすいです。ヒロインがとても可愛らしく、好きです！！

The original story is unread. I think comicalization is very polite. It's easy to understand and read. The heroine is so cute and I love it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

3.7

3.7

まっ2期迄アニメ化されてるから知ってる人多いだろうけど、途中霊亀やあっちの世界とか自分の中では中だるみ感あってどうしようと思いつつ最新刊23巻買って見たが、思ったより、ん〜な展開で正直次どうしようとなっている。

Well, there are probably many people who know it since it has been animated until season 2, but on the way, I felt sluggish, and I bought 23 volumes of the latest edition while thinking about what to do, but more than I thought, it's an unbelievable development and honestly what to do next.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よくできている

Well made

こういうファンタジー系の漫画としてよくできてるなと思いました。人気があるのも納得です。ただ、あまり好みではないかなー

I thought it was well-made as a fantasy comic like this. It's understandable that it's popular. However, I don't think I really like it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

主人公もヒロインもとてもよかったです。ヒロインの健気なところとか応援したくなります。ストーリーもおもしろかった。

Both the main character and heroine were very good. I want to cheer for the heroine's health. The story was interesting too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

面白いんですけど、もう・・・途中まであまりにもひどい展開に胃がキリキリする。主人公の人間性が少し変わるのも理解出来る。でも、懐に入れたあとは何だかんだ言って・・。アニメも面白かった。でもやはり1期は見ていて胃がキリキリした。

It's interesting, but it's already... my stomach is tingling with the development that was so bad until halfway through. I can also understand that the main character's personality changes slightly. But after putting it in my pocket, I said something... The anime was interesting too. But after all, watching Season 1 made my stomach tingle.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

長編ですね

It's a long story

まず、絵が安定して綺麗です。主人公が好青年というか嫌な人じゃないのがいいです。後はファンタジーバトルについていけるかですね。

First, the picture is stable and beautiful. It's nice that the main character isn't a good young man, or rather a bad person. After that, I wonder if I can keep up with fantasy battles.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何か好きなのよね

You like something, don't you

迫害しかも一度ならずと繰り返される理不尽さが不快なはずなのに、それを上回っての成りあがっていく段階の一エピソードずつがとてもいいんですよね。村人に感謝されたり能力評価されたり神鳥の聖人様とあがめられたり。奴隷商のキャラクターを好きになるとは自分でも予想外だったし（笑）言うまでもなくラフタリアとフィーロは大好きです。で、アニメ一期分くらいまでだと星５つけてもいいんですが、なろうによくあるっぽく話が長くなるといろいろ詰め込んでどこに行きつくかわからなくなったりするので星一つ二つマイナスしときます。

The persecution and unreasonableness that is repeated more than once must be uncomfortable, yet each episode at a stage where it goes beyond that is really good, isn't it? They are appreciated by villagers, evaluated for their abilities, and praised as the saint of sacred birds. It was unexpected for me to fall in love with the character The Slave Trader (laughs), and needless to say, I love Raphtalia and Philo. So, if it's up to about the first season of the anime, it's fine to give it 5 stars, but as often happens with Narou, the story gets packed in so many things and you don't know where it ends up, so I minus 1 star and 2 stars.

Helpful

Reviews for The Rising of the Shield Hero: The Manga Companion Manga