I Left my A-Rank Party to Help My Former Students Reach the Dungeon Depths! Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

シンプルに面白い

Simple and interesting

面白いです。つえーものであり、ざまぁものであり、ハーレムものでもあるんですが、まず単純にファンタジーとして面白いなと感じる作品です。冒険者、仲間、失敗、成長、危機、活躍、名声、この辺りのシンプルな面白さを丁寧に描いており、安心して読める印象です。主人公に対しての目線も様々なものがあり、人間模様にも飽きがきません。良い作品だと思います。

It's interesting. It's amazing, it's different, and it's also a harem thing, but first of all, it's a work that I feel is simply interesting as a fantasy. It carefully depicts adventurers, friends, failure, growth, crisis, activity, fame, and the simple fun of this area, and I have the impression that it can be read with peace of mind. There are various perspectives on the main character, and I never get tired of the human pattern. I think it's a good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ざまぁ系おもしろ

Zama series is interesting

ざまぁ系の中では1番好きです。絵、話の展開が良いです。モンスターや技の種類が魅力的で読んでいて楽しい

I like it the most in the Zama series. The picture and story development are good. The types of monsters and techniques are fascinating and fun to read

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです

I like it

This review contains spoilers. キャラクターも可愛いとおもう主人公はサポート職で実はすごい系。のほほんとしていて見ていて可愛らしいです(*^^*)Aランクパーティーのキャラが性格悪そうなのでどうなるのか続きが気になります

This review contains spoilers. I think the characters are cute too, and the main character is in a support position, which is actually amazing. It's so cute to look at (*^^*) The characters in the A rank party seem to have bad personalities, so I'm curious about what will happen next

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる…！

I'm worried about the continuation...!

This review contains spoilers. ユークめっちゃ最強じゃんと思いつつ、元パーティーメンバーがクソすぎてｲﾗｯとしましたが、元教え子のみんなと仲間になれてこれから伝説が始まると思うとワクワクしました?個人的には常備鍋がめっちゃ欲しいなって思いました(笑)

This review contains spoilers. While thinking that Yook was really the strongest, I was annoyed that the former party members were so damn bad, but I was excited to become friends with all of my former students and think that the legend would begin now? Personally, I really wanted a regular hot pot (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ユークの役割を軽視する元の仲間が嫌

I don't like my former friends who disdain Yuke's role

地味なサポートを軽視するパーティは、今後長続きしません。反対にユークを迎えた新メンバーのパーティーは、これからどんどん活躍していくでしょう。

Parties that disdain modest support won't last long in the future. On the other hand, the party with the new members who welcomed Yuke will be more and more active from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公に好印象

Good impression on the protagonist

よくあるパターンのざまぁ系ですが悪くない。全部を読み切れていないので、先の進行が気になりました。ちょっとしたハーレム状態なのも、良い感じです。

It's a common pattern, but it's not bad. I haven't read all of them, so I was worried about the progress ahead. It's also a nice feeling that it's in a bit of a harem.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメと遜色無いくらいです!!

It's almost as good as anime!!

アニメから原作読みしてます戦闘場面などアニメと遜色無いくらいの躍動感で感動しています！主人公ユークとのパーティーの雰囲気が男女のベタベタ感少なく読みやすいですハーレム状態だけど、みんなが堅実的で真面目だな〜と微笑ましく感じました

I'm reading the original story from the anime, and I'm moved by the sense of dynamism that is comparable to the anime, such as battle scenes! The atmosphere of the party with the main character, Yook, is less sticky for men and women, and it's easy to read. It's in a harem state, but I smiled that everyone was steady and serious

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公が自分から出ていくのがいいですね

It's nice when the main character comes out on his own

地味な凄い能力の主人公が追放ものの流れですが、主人公が既に過ごす能力の持ち主であり、それを自覚してチームから出ていくというところが新鮮ですね。冷静で面倒見もいい責任感の強い主人公も好感が持てますが、教え子の女の子達の性格も、絵も可愛いし、かと言ってやたらに幼くなく、好感がもてます。ただ、もちろん面白いですが、しばらくすると既視感ありありというところが気になりますし、主人公の叔父さんが凄い人でその関係で・・・というところが少し・・・というところがあります。今後、独自の面白さを展開できることを期待しています。

The main character, who is plain and has amazing abilities, is banished, but it's refreshing that the main character already has the ability to spend time, and he is aware of it and leaves the team. I also like the protagonist, who is calm and has a strong sense of responsibility, but the girls' students have cute personalities and pictures, and they aren't really young, so I like them. However, of course, it's interesting, but after a while, I'm worried about the fact that there is a sense of déjà vu, and there are places where the main character's uncle is an amazing person and because of that... there is a bit... We hope to be able to develop unique fun in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いハーレム物語

Funny harem stories

This review contains spoilers. 作画は良い、ライブダンジョンのアイデアを借りてるのも、キャラ立ても。中世風だけれど、娯楽社会で、ダンジョンを資源とした資本主義社会。テンプレ上等の方にお薦めです。

This review contains spoilers. The drawing is good, they borrow ideas from live dungeons, and they also make up characters. It's medieval-style, but it's an entertainment society, and a capitalist society that uses dungeons as resources. Recommended for those who are good at templating.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アクションシーンがよかった

The action scenes were good

補助職の主人公がパーティー追放され、新しいパーティーに加入したことで真価を発揮するようになる話。女の子たちがかわいい。一巻の絵は拙い印象を受けるところもあったが、どんどん上手になっていく。アクションシーンのうまさもこの作家さんの強みかも、と思いました。

This is a story where the main character, who is an assistant, is banished from a party and begins to demonstrate his true value by joining a new party. The girls are cute. There were places where I got the impression that the first volume of pictures was poor, but they got better and better. I thought that the good action scenes might also be this artist's strength.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

いい

That's good

キャラクターデザインも好きだしキャラクターも魅力的でとても良かったです。どのキャラクターも可愛くて良い。

I liked the character design, and the characters were attractive and very nice. Every character is cute and nice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい

cute

パーティを組む女の子達がみんなかわいい。もともとのパーティを抜けて、かわいい女の子達とパーティを組むわけですが、冒険で無双しつつ女の子達の目が変わっていく感じ。

The girls who form the party are all so cute. They leave the original party and form a party with cute girls, but it feels like the girls' eyes are changing while being invincible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

勘違い甚だしい元パーティー(笑)

I misunderstood the original party so bad (lol)

主人公が万能過ぎて、いなくなってもその大きさに気づけない憐れな元パーティー特に、勇者は話を聞かない性格で、挙げ句自分にとって都合の良い展開しか知らないというお花畑の脳味噌。ホント、ありがちな話ながら、何でコイツ勇者なの？っていう気持ちがこれまで読んできた中で最も強い

A pitiful former party where the main character is so versatile that you don't notice its size even when he's gone, in particular, it's the brain of a flower field where the hero doesn't listen to stories, and after all, he only knows developments that are convenient for him. It's really a common story, but why is this guy a hero? That feeling is the strongest I've read so far

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

逆転無双

Samurai Warriors

赤魔導師のルークは、パーティから離脱するが、元教え子達のパーティに加わり迷宮を目指すが、、、逆転無双ものは見ていて気持ちいい

Luke, the Red Mage, leaves the party, but he joins the party of his former students and aims for the labyrinth, but... it feels good to watch Reversal Warriors

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻読了。今のところエロさはない

I've read volume 2. There is no eroticism so far

This review contains spoilers. 2巻読了。表紙のデザインを見て、少年・青年漫画でよくあるハーレム展開なんだろうな〜と思っていましたが、ハーレムはハーレムでも今のところエロさはないしガッツリとした恋模様は展開されていないので、このままの状態が続けばよいな〜と思います。四人みんなでワチャワチャしている感じが好きなので。?そして、主人公が真面目で凄腕なのに謙虚でピュアなところが推せますね〜。このまま真面目を貫き、教え子とラブ展開にならないまま夢を目指して邁進・達成して欲しいものです。?

This review contains spoilers. I've read volume 2. Looking at the cover design, I was wondering if it was a common harem development in shonen and youth comics, but even though Harem is a harem, there isn't any eroticism or intense love patterns so far, so I think it would be nice if it continued like this. Because I like the feeling that all four of them are messing around.? Also, I can recommend that the main character is humble and pure even though he is serious and has amazing skills. I want them to continue to be serious and push forward and achieve their dreams without developing a love relationship with their students.?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

追放系

Exile

迷宮アタックを配信する異世界ものは珍しくて新鮮。縁の下の力持ちであるユークを使えないとバカにするパーティから抜けて可愛い女の子だらけの教え子パーティに拾ってもらって無双していく。絵柄もストーリーにあっていて可愛い。

The one from another world that distributes Labyrinth Attack is rare and fresh. If you can't use Yuke, an unsung hero, they leave the party that makes a fool out of them, get picked up by a student party full of cute girls, and become unrivaled. The design also matches the story and is cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

迷宮へ

To the labyrinth

This review contains spoilers. パーティーを首になったのは何でかなと思うくらい強い。いろんなことをアドバイスできていてすごいと思った。いろんな困難がありそうだけど頑張って欲しい。

This review contains spoilers. I'm so strong that I wonder why the party got fired. I thought it was amazing to be able to give advice on so many things. There seems to be a lot of trouble, but I want you to do your best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

オモシロイ

Funny

元パーティーの奴らがクズ過ぎる。勝手な言い分ばっかりでユークにどれだけ助けられてるか気付いてないとか、バカばっかり。パーティーに迎えてくれたのは、元教え子たち。お互いを尊重しあい、困難な敵に立ち向かっていく。

The old party guys are too scum. They're just idiots who don't notice how much Yuke is helping them with all their selfish remarks. The people who welcomed me to the party were former students. We respect each other and confront difficult enemies.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

サポート

support

This review contains spoilers. 赤魔導士とはなんぞやと思いましたが、補助魔法に長けている主人公が、女の子たちと協力しながら強い魔物を倒していくお話です。戦闘のライブ配信っておもしろいね。所謂ハーレム状態なので少々辟易するところもありますが、エロ方面には行ってないのでおもしろく読めます。

This review contains spoilers. I was wondering what the Red Mage is, but it's a story where the main character, who excels at auxiliary magic, cooperates with girls to defeat strong monsters. Live streaming of battles is interesting, isn't it? It's a so-called harem state, so there are places where it's a bit disheartening, but since I haven't gone in the erotic direction, it's interesting to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

どこまで行けるか

How far can you go

This review contains spoilers. 赤魔導士という補助魔法使いの主人公が、Aランクパーティを追放された後、元教え子たちとパーティを組んで冒険するというお話。特に目新しい感じはありませんが、冒険の動画を配信するってこところが面白いと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. The story is about the main character, an auxiliary wizard called Red Mage, who, after being banished from an A rank party, forms a party with his former students and goes on an adventure. It's not particularly new, but I thought it would be interesting to distribute adventure videos.

Helpful

Reviews for I Left my A-Rank Party to Help My Former Students Reach the Dungeon Depths! Manga