The Good Deeds of Old Adventurer Kane Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

初めから優しい世界。良い人間が当たり前の様に善行して皆が感謝して・・・チラッと変な人はちらついたけどそこは善人達が浄化(笑)

A gentle world from the beginning. Good people did good deeds as a matter of course and everyone was thankful... strange people flickered at a glance, but good people purified there (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

善行がある意味武器

Good deeds mean weapons

薬草取りのDランク冒険者ケインは、善行を積みのし上がっていく。ケインさんの人柄も良いですね。今後が楽しみ。

D-rank adventurer Kane, a herbalist, builds up good deeds. Kane has a good personality, too. I'm looking forward to the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

優しさ

tenderness

This review contains spoilers. 主人公ケインがとにかく優しいのが良いですね、ありきたりなオッサン系ハーレム作品かと思いきや、全くそんな感じは無く、エロ要素もほぼ皆無、武力や暴力ではなく優しさを感じる作品です。

This review contains spoilers. It's nice that the main character Kane is just kind; I thought it was an ordinary old man harem work, but there's no such feeling at all, there are almost no erotic elements, and it's a work where you feel kindness rather than force or violence.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

善人

A good person

This review contains spoilers. ほっこりするストーリーで面白いです。絵のメインキャストの女性が分かりづらいところがあります。。ストーリーのテンポも早いです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a relaxing story and it's interesting. There are places where it is difficult to understand the woman who is the main cast of the picture.. The tempo of the story is also fast.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルが好きじゃないので、嫌煙、

I don't like the title, so no smoking,

This review contains spoilers. していた作品。パワープッシュ作品レビューです。購入はしていません。主人公が、何処までもピュア。好感が持てます。1巻の構成で、損してますね。読み進めた方が、魅力が出て来る作品です。個人的には姫さんが、段々キャラ（※性格）が格落ちして行って、とても残念。話が進むと、彼女が段々馬鹿に（※恋、故に）なります。そこ、惜しいかな。逆に聖女さまと、魔法使いのマヤさんの株が上がっていきます。マヤは登場した1巻だと、イヤな奴（※キャラ）です。余り好きじゃ無い。段々と色々なエピソードが明かされていき、面白くなって来ます。絵柄も上達している気がします。獣人の子を契約獣？にする辺りまで読みましたが、個人的には邪神だったかな？倒すエピソード関連が、好きです。其処まで読むと、物語（主人公）の魅力（良さ）が、理解出来るかな？と、思います。絵はデッサン狂いも無いし、読んで不快感、苦痛は無いのですが、少年、青年誌に良くある、程良い（？）ライトなエロ描写的なものは、入れる決まりなのでしょうか？それさえ無ければ、買っても良かった………入れないと売れないのかな？大人の事情ってやつか。仕方無い。タイトルが嫌いなのは、読むと理解るのですが、主人公のケインがおっさん要素が無いんですよね。本当何処までも良い人です。本当、呆れるくらいに。彼には変わらないで欲しいです。そんなお話です。今後の展開が、気になる作品ではあります。購入は、悩みますね（笑）

This review contains spoilers. The work I was doing. This is a review of Power Push's work. I haven't made a purchase. The main character is pure everywhere. I like it. It's a loss due to the one-volume structure, isn't it? The more you read, the more appealing this work comes out. Personally, it's very disappointing that the princess's characters (*personality) gradually fell out of rank. As the story progresses, she gradually becomes dumb (*because of love). I wonder if that would be a pity. Conversely, shares of Seijo and Maya the Wizard will go up. Maya is a disgusting guy (*character) in the first volume that appeared. I don't really like it. Gradually, various episodes are revealed, and it becomes interesting. I feel that the design has improved as well. Is Beastman's Child a contract beast? I read it to the point where I did it, but personally I wonder if it was an evil god? I like the one related to the defeat episode. If you read that far, can you understand the appeal (goodness) of the story (protagonist)? I think so. The pictures are not wrong with the drawing, and there is no discomfort or pain when reading them, but they are common in shonen and youth magazines, so good (?) Is it a rule to include things that are light and erotic? If I didn't have that, I could have bought it... wouldn't it sell if I didn't put it in? I wonder if it's an adult situation. It can't be helped. I don't like the title, and I understand it when I read it, but the main character, Kane, doesn't have an old man element. He's really always a good person. Really, it's astonishing. I don't want him to change. That's the story. I'm worried about future developments in this work. Purchases are troublesome (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

物語は素晴らしい

The story is wonderful

内容はパーフェクト。筋書きもストーリーの進め方も問題無い。ただ、キャラの描き分けが甘い。キャラによって男女の区別がつかない。エロが無いのも評価高いが、ヘンテコな性癖要らない。8巻まで進んでこの絵だとかなり辛い。そこが星一つマイナス。

The content is perfect. There is no problem with the plot or the way the story progresses. However, the drawing of the characters is poor. There is no distinction between men and women depending on the characters. The fact that there is no eroticism is also highly regarded, but there is no need for weird sexual tendencies. I've advanced to volume 8, and it's pretty painful with this picture. That's one star minus.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

なんとなく

somehow

テンポもよく読みやすいですね。ただ何故オジサンかモテる？というか‥

The tempo is also good and easy to read. However, why are old men popular? Or rather...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

結局ハーレム

Harlem after all

気付いたらパーティーが主人公以外全員女性に…。アルアルですが、ちょっとあからさまかなぁ。主人公自信の性格もあって、パーティー内でのラブコメ展開は無さそうですが(今のところは)。主人公は「人の良さ」が魅力で他人に慕われる描写は多いけど、例えば仲間と背中を預けあう友情的な絆はまだない。そういった面もあれば、もっと魅力的なキャラになりそう。

Before I knew it, the party was all women except the main character... It's Al Alu, but I wonder if it's a bit obvious. The main character also has a confident personality, and there doesn't seem to be any romantic comedy developments within the party (so far). There are many depictions of the main character being loved by others because of his “goodness in people” being attractive, but for example, there are still no friendly bonds where people leave their backs on each other. If it had that aspect, it would be an even more attractive character.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

3～4巻から面白い

Interesting from volumes 3-4

1巻は完全に布石です。たぶん、ケインさんにイライラする人や、嫌悪を抱く人もいるかと。2巻後半あたりから、ちょっと変わります。3～4巻からは、善い人だけど、お人好しではなくなるというか、おっさんなりに？おっさんだから？段々と善人らしく成長していって、なんとなく好きになりました。

Volume 1 is a complete stepping stone. I think there are probably people who are frustrated or disgusted by Kane. It changes slightly from around the latter half of volume 2. From volumes 3 to 4, he's a good person, but he's no longer friendly, or rather like an old man? because he's an old man? I gradually grew to be a good person, and somehow I fell in love with him.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

女の子たちかわいい

The girls are cute

主人公は強くないです。ただお人好しで良いことをして周りに助けられていく。どうなるか続きが気になります

The main character isn't strong. They are just friendly and do good things to be helped by people around them. I'm curious about the continuation of what will happen

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

４巻まで読みました

I've read up to 4 volumes

善い行いをする人には力が集まるという感じですね！とても続きが気になるところで終わってしまったので早く読みたいです。

It feels like people who do good deeds gather strength! It ended when I was really worried about the continuation, so I want to read it soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

気になります

I'm curious

たまたま見掛けただけで、一部しか見れていませんが…優しい冒険者ケインさんの、ほのぼのとしていた筈の日常が１つの出会いから変化して、それからどうなっていくのかが気になります

I just happened to see it, and I've only been able to see a part of it... I'm curious about how the gentle adventurer Kane's supposed heartwarming everyday life changes from one encounter, and then what happens

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いけど主人公が空気

It's interesting, but the main character is air

薬草収集で生計を立てている主人公が善行で成り上がっていく内容で、おっさんになるまでがパッとしていなかった分、おっさんになってからのいい結果が次々と起こっていくので面白く読めました?ただ、主人公のおっさんの個性が弱く、周りのキャラが動き回った結果をホイホイ貰っているような感じなので、主人公はあまり好きにはなれなかったです?

It's interesting to read that the main character, who makes a living by collecting medicinal herbs, develops through good deeds, and since he wasn't easy until he became an old man, good results after becoming an old man happened one after another? However, the main character's old man's personality is weak, and it feels like the characters around him are getting the results of moving around, so I didn't really like the main character?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！！

good!!

すごく良い人の主人公。心優しく、みんなにも好かれる主人公を応援したくなります。

The main character is a really nice person. I want to support the main character who is kind hearted and is liked by everyone.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトルが。。。

The title is...

タイトルで損をしてると思います。お話、絵柄は大変良作です。まあ、流行りのキーワードである「おっさん」を入れたくなるのは判るけどね。ただそれで他の「おっさん物」と同列に見られてしまうかと。

I think I'm losing money on the title. The story and design are very good works. Well, I understand that you might want to include “old man,” which is a popular keyword. However, I wonder if that's why they'll be seen in the same way as other “old man things.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 11, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いいっ‼

That's good ‼

実にいいですっ‼こんな人間に私はなりたい‼(いろんな意味で)皆さん是非とも読んでみてください‼

It's really good ‼ I want to be this kind of person ‼ (in many ways) Please read it by all means ‼

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いい感じに

Feels good

This review contains spoilers. 最近ほのぼの系が面白く感じる今日この頃ほのぼのしつつもバトル？ありで面白いです。

This review contains spoilers. I feel like the heartwarming system is interesting lately, is it a heartwarming yet heartwarming battle around this time today? It's interesting to have it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公無双ではない

The protagonist is not Warriors

よくある主人公無双や落ちこぼれと思われていた主人公が実は！？というものではなく、善人だけど普通に弱い主人公を最強3人娘(内2名)がお節介で振り回すという展開は面白いと思いました。

The main character who was often thought to be Warriors or the main character who was left behind is actually!? It's not like that, and I thought it would be interesting to see the development where the 3 strongest girls (2 of them) swing around the protagonist who is a good person but usually weak.

Helpful

Reviews for The Good Deeds of Old Adventurer Kane Manga