The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

中華BL好きにはおすすめ！

Recommended for Chinese BL lovers!

This review contains spoilers. 中華BLにハマっており、この作品にたどり着きました！作画も私の好みで、ストーリーもキャラ設定も全てが最高です！

This review contains spoilers. I'm addicted to Chinese BL, and I arrived at this work! The drawing is my favorite, and the story and character settings are all great!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が最高

The picture is the best

This review contains spoilers. いや、男の人ってばれないことないでしょ(笑)と思うのですが、絵がきれいすぎる。原作はもっとドロドロのようですが、、、

This review contains spoilers. No, I don't think men go unnoticed (laughs), but the picture is too pretty. The original story seems more muddy, but...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

不器用さとせつなさと

Clumsiness and clumsiness

読めば読むほど、親王の歪んだ愛情表現や不器用さを感じて切なくなっちゃいます。きっと、親王の育ちのなかで、親王自身が包み込むような優しい愛情を受けてきた経験値がないのかもしれない…とか色々と妄想しながら読んでいます。これから、玉との関わりの中で、そんな優しい愛情を経験していく事を願いながら最後まで読みたいと思います～

The more I read, the more sad I felt the Prince's distorted expressions of affection and clumsiness. I'm reading it while making various delusions, like I'm sure the Prince grew up, and maybe they didn't have experience points where they received such kind affection that the Prince himself enveloped me... From now on, I would like to read it until the end, hoping that I will experience such gentle love in my relationship with the ball ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

終盤ギャグ強め

Strong final gag

This review contains spoilers. 「こんなにもだもださせる必要がある!?」と、中盤にかけて少しイラッとしてしまいましたが、最後まで読むと、それも必要なことだったんだなと理解できました。122話もあるので、長いと感じられて、読むのをためらう方もおられるかも知れませんが、一話がそれほど長くないので、一気に読めてしまいました。無事ハッピーエンドを迎えることができて、良かったです。番外編も準備中とのことなので、とても楽しみです。ただ、私は全く気にならないので大丈夫でしたが、主人公の周囲の人間がくっついてBLしてる話が苦手な方は、要注意かもしれないです。

This review contains spoilers. “Is it necessary to make them so fuzzy!?” I was a little annoyed in the middle, but when I read it to the end, I understood that it was also necessary. There are 122 episodes, so it feels like it's long, and some people may be hesitant to read it, but since one episode isn't that long, I was able to read it all at once. I'm glad we were able to reach a happy ending safely. It is said that an extra edition is also being prepared, so I'm really looking forward to it. However, I didn't care at all, so it was fine, but if you don't like BL stories where people around the main character stick together, you might need to be careful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

個人的に大好きです。

I personally love it.

This review contains spoilers. 時代背景が昔なので戦の話がはいることと、中国の作品をあまり読んでいないことで土地や人名に馴染みがないので初見は混乱しました。しかし、ちゃんと内容を把握しようと読み返すほどに面白いと感じました。最初の玉と陛下の関係性はかなり脆く、上手く構築したと思えば、大きくすれ違ってしまう。それは主に、玉が喋れないことで起きてしまうのが、もどかしく感じました。また、陛下も子供のように癇癪をすぐに起こすので、正直序盤の陛下は嫌いです。ただし、玉が話せるようになった後のお話が面白くなる要因だと思いました。玉も陛下も互いに内面的に成長をしていき、軽い冗談や嫌味などを言い合える、とてもいい関係になったと思います。後半の満足感は、前半のいざこざを読んだからこそ強く思います。また、登場人物がめちゃくちゃ多いわけではないし、各キャラちゃんと出番があるのも良かったです。商業BLはこれをはじめに、いくつか読みましたが、最終巻まで買って、面白いと感じたのはこの作品です。露骨な性描写(行為中のシーン)がなく、キスシーンですら顔が物陰などに隠れていたりと、読みやすいと思いました。とても好きな作品です。ありがとうございました。

This review contains spoilers. The historical background is a long time ago, so there are stories about battles, and since I haven't read many Chinese works, I'm not familiar with the place or people's names, so I was confused at first sight. However, I found it so interesting that I reread it to properly grasp the content. The relationship between the first ball and His Majesty is quite fragile, and if you think it was built well, you will pass by a big margin. I felt frustrated that it was mainly caused by the ball not being able to speak. Also, His Majesty immediately causes tantrums like a child, so to be honest, I don't like His Majesty in the beginning. However, I thought it was a factor that made the story interesting after Jama was able to speak. Both Tama and His Majesty grew inwardly with each other, and I think they had a very good relationship where they were able to tell each other light jokes and dislikes. The sense of satisfaction in the second half is strong only after reading the first half of the story. Also, there aren't an insanely large number of characters, and it was nice that each character had their own turn. Starting with this commercial BL, I read a few, but I bought until the last volume, and what I found interesting was this work. There were no explicit sexual depictions (scenes during the act), and I thought it was easy to read, with faces hidden in shadows, etc. even in the kiss scene. It's a work I really like. Thank you very much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すばらしいです

great

絵が美しく、登場人物達の心の動きから目が離せず一気に読んでしまいました。少し長いですが、是非読んでいただきたい作品です。

The picture was beautiful, and I read it all at once without taking my eyes off the characters' movements of mind. It's a bit long, but I definitely want you to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

めちゃくちゃいい！絵がとても綺麗！しかもカッコイイー！88話までしか見てないけどこの先がどーなるのか楽しみで仕方ない！ハッピーエンドに期待！

insanely good! The picture is so beautiful! What's more, it's cool! I've only watched up to episode 88, but I can't help but look forward to seeing what the future holds! Looking forward to a happy ending!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

見たかった

I wanted to see

This review contains spoilers. 完読しました。長かった。出来ればお子様が生まれるところまで描いて欲しかった～。外伝は準備中となっていましたがそこで登場してくれるかなぁ？

This review contains spoilers. I read it completely. That was a long time. If possible, I wanted them to draw the point where a child is born. Gaiden was being prepared, but I wonder if they'll show up there?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

死ぬまでには読むべき

You should read it before you die

この作品はとにかくおもろいです。絵もすごく綺麗です。すごく面白く感動するので次々見てしまいます。攻めはすごくかっこよく受けはすごく可愛いです。読んで損はしないと思います。

Anyway, this work is interesting. The picture is also very beautiful. It's so interesting and moving that I watch it one after another. The attack is so cool and the reception is so cute. I don't think there's any harm in reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょっと読むつもりだったのにいつのまにか

I was going to read it for a while, but before I knew it

本当は一日5話ぐらいでって決めてたんだけど、いつのまにか全部購入してたし読み終わったら朝の5時になってた！BL本はだいたい致してれば満足だったので、ストーリー重視の本はほとんど買ってませんでした。私自身が夢女の星から生まれた夢女なので、、、悲恋(?)物がすごい好きだったからこのお話まじでぶっ続けで読んだし、次の日1限だったけど遅刻しました。ラブい。友達にも薦めます。

Actually, I decided it would be about 5 episodes a day, but before I knew it, I had bought them all, and when I finished reading it, it was 5 o'clock in the morning! For the most part, I was satisfied with BL books, so I hardly bought any story-focused books. I myself am a dream woman born from Yumejo's star, so... sad love (?) I really liked things, so I read this story over and over again, and even though it was limited the next day, I was late. I'm in love. I would recommend it to my friends.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

もう、初めから最高です

It's already the best from the beginning

キャラが私好みですぐにハマりました！即20話まで買いました！色んな人に進めて色んな人と語れるようになりたいです！

I liked the characters and got hooked right away! I immediately bought up to 20 episodes! I want to advance to various people and be able to talk to many different people!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になって仕方ない！

I can't help but worry about the continuation!

久しぶりにBL作品を読みました。とにかく絵が綺麗で空のイラストや建物のイラストがリアルで実際の空気感を感じます。ストーリーも展開が早く、飽きさせません。いろんな人の思惑が混ざり合ってすれ違う2人...ぜひ読んでみてください。

I haven't read a BL book in a long time. Anyway, the pictures are beautiful, and the illustrations of the sky and buildings are realistic, and I feel the actual atmosphere. The story also unfolds quickly, so you won't get bored. The speculations of various people are mixed and the two pass by each other... be sure to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高！

the best!

ずっと、comicoで読んでたのですが、課金が携帯料金と一緒にじゃ無いとダメで、ここで購入して最後の部分を読みました。いやぁ、玉ちゃんの幸せを祈りながら読み続け、やっと、と思ったら、玉ちゃんのツンの多い事wでも、君玄梟は甲斐甲斐しくお世話し、愛を勝ち取ってるのが堪らない！もっと、二人のイチャイチャが見たい所ですが、最後の幸せな二人を見て我慢します。外伝早く解放されないかなぁ。メチャクチャ楽しみに待ってます。この二人の子供ならきっと美形な玉のようなお子様だと期待してます。

I've been reading it on comico for a long time, but it's useless if the billing isn't along with the cell phone bill, so I bought it here and read the last part. Well, I kept reading while praying for Tama-chan's happiness, and when I thought, at last, it's unbearable that Kimigen Owl took good care of her and won her love even though Tama-chan has a lot of trouble lol! I'd like to see them flirt even more, but I'll put up with it when I see the last two happy people. I wonder if Gaiden will be released soon. I'm really looking forward to it. I'm expecting these two kids to be beautiful children.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きました

I cried

何度も読み返している作品です次第に心を開いていく2人の様子悲しい時の心の痛みがすごく伝わる作品ですストーリーがしっかりあるし過激な描写がある訳では無いのでBLが苦手という方でも十分楽しめると思います続編が楽しみです

It's a work I've reread over and over again. It's a work that really conveys the heartache of when they're sad. It has a solid story and doesn't have extreme depictions, so I think even people who don't like BL can fully enjoy it. I'm looking forward to the sequel

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

今まで読んできたBL漫画で1番好み

The most favorite BL comic I've read so far

This review contains spoilers. 古代の中華風が好きな人にはすごく刺さると思います。絵がすごく綺麗で、なかなか先に進めないくらい見返しています。そういう描写は多くはないですが、それでもこの漫画は絵はもちろん、先が読めないストーリーでハラハラする場面やニヤニヤしてしまう場面もあり、すごく満足です。読んでいて全く飽きもこず、むしろ続きが気になるほどです。この漫画に出会えて心から良かったと思います。ぜひ読んで見て下さい。

This review contains spoilers. I think it will really stick to people who like ancient Chinese style. The picture is so beautiful, and I look back at it so much that I can't go any further. There aren't many depictions like that, but even so, I'm very satisfied with this comic, not to mention the pictures, and there are also scenes that make you feel harassed and smirked because of the story where you can't read the future. I didn't get tired of reading it at all, and I was rather worried about the continuation. I'm really glad I came across this comic. Please read and take a look.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃヤバい

That's really dangerous

顔がめっちゃイケメン体つきも良い沈玉はめっちゃ可愛くて、女の人よりも女みたいな感じ普通に惚れる

Shen Yu, who has a very handsome face and is in good shape, is so cute, and I usually fall in love with her as if she were more like a woman than a woman

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

一気に読みたい

I want to read it all at once

縦読みの、こういうのは、セッカチには、キツいですね。ぱ、ばーんって　本にして欲しい。完結したみたいなので、ポイ活頑張ります

This kind of vertical reading is tough for a sackerel, isn't it? Well, I want it to be made into a book called Bam. It looks like it's completed, so I'll do my best for Poi activity

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です❗

It's awesome ❗

一気に読みたいのを我慢しながら、でも読み始めたら我慢出来なくて、何度も追加ポイントしながら、最終話まで一気に読んでしまいました。満足です。

I put up with what I wanted to read all at once, but once I started reading it, I couldn't stand it, and I read the final episode all at once while adding points over and over again. I am satisfied.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい！！

great!!

沈玉の心が成長？してくにつれてそれを最後は受け止めている君玄梟がなんかいい！！言葉の表現が難しいけど胸がキューってなった笑

Is Shen Yu's heart growing? It's nice that Kimigen Owl is accepting it at the end as you do it!! Expressing words is difficult, but my heart is now queuing lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

完結お疲れ様でした

Thank you for your hard work

月曜日に更新されるのが楽しみでした。終わってしまい寂しいです。できる事なら続きを読みたいです！続編希望！！！！！

I was looking forward to the update on Monday. It's over and I'm lonely. I'd like to read more if I can! I hope for a sequel!!!!

Helpful

Reviews for The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga