The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga Reviews (P.37)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

焦らされ過ぎないのがいい

It's good not to be too impatient

This review contains spoilers. 絵はとても綺麗でストーリーもいいです。男だとわかって愛してくれているのがなんともいえないです。出来ることなら、もう少し量を増やして欲しいです。あまりにも短過ぎます。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are very beautiful and the story is nice. It's indescribable that he knows he's a man and loves him. If possible, I would like the amount to be increased a little more. It's too short.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

もどかしい！

It's frustrating!

お互いのこと好きなのになんでこうなるの！？ってずっと思ってる。長編になるだろうから覚悟して読まなきゃダメだけど、面白いから全然読める。

Why is this happening when we both love each other!? I've always thought that. It's going to be a long story, so you have to be prepared to read it, but it's interesting, so I can read it at all.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

オールカラーの綺麗な画

Beautiful picture in all colors

12話まで読了。主人公玉は儚さと強さ両方あるのが魅力です?これからが気になるけど現時点で100話近くあると課金が大変なので読み進めるかどうか正直分からない?

I've read up to 12 episodes. The appeal of the main character ball is that it has both ephemerality and strength? I'm worried about the future, but if there are close to 100 episodes at the moment, billing is difficult, so I honestly don't know if I can read on?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

もどかしいけど

It's frustrating

This review contains spoilers. 絵がとても綺麗で、話も面白いです。ただちょっと話の展開が遅いと言うか、なかなか仲直りしないので、辛いです。早く仲直りして欲しいと思ってます。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are very beautiful and the story is interesting. It's just that the development of the story is a bit slow, or they don't make up easily, so it's painful. I want them to make up quickly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい

uncanny

This review contains spoilers. 絵がとにかくキレイ✨ストーリーも面白い✨完結かと思ったら第二部が始まってた。第一部の後半ぐらいから玉がかわいくなくなって、何でもかんでも言い返すので読むのやめてたけど、第二部良いかも。第一部の二人とビジュアルも性格もちょっとかぶるけど、違った展開を見せてほしい。受があんまり強くなりませんように。うーん、やっぱりお父さんの方がカッコよかったなぁ。追記…二部45話まで見たけど…?皆さんのレビューどおり麒玉が愚かで酷すぎた?第一部よりも残酷なんじゃ…(泣)でも作者さんがすごいわ。きれいなだけじゃなくここまで描ききるとは?恋愛感情メインのストーリーなのに、王族モノでありがちな「おいおい政治どこいったん？」とゆうキラキラストーリーにはなってないのでほんとすごいと思う。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are just so beautiful ✨ the story is interesting ✨ when I thought it would be over, the second part had started. From about the second half of the first part, the ball became cute, and I stopped reading it because it said everything back and forth, but maybe the second part would be good. They have a bit of visual and personality from the two people in the first part, but I want them to show a different development. I hope the reception doesn't get too strong. Hmm, dad was cooler after all. postscript... I've watched up to part 2 episode 45, but...? as per everyone's reviews, was Kiritama too stupid and terrible? It's more cruel than the first part... (crying) but the author is amazing. Not only is it beautiful, but what does it mean to be able to draw up to this point? Even though it's a story about romantic feelings, the “hey hey where did politics go?” which is often a royal family thing It's not a To-Yu Kirakira story, so I think it's really amazing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

韓国の映画を彷彿させる

Reminiscent of Korean movies

そてぞれの人物と絵がマッチしていて、物語としてとても興味深いものがある。日本でいえば後宮の話となるのだろうが、もう少し内容をつめれば、十分に映画にすることも出来ると思う。

The characters and pictures match each other, and there is something very interesting as a story. Speaking of Japan, it would probably be a story about Harem, but with a little more content, I think it could be enough to make a film.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

意外と面白く読み進めていけます。絵も綺麗だし、内容自体はよくあるようなお話ですが今後の2人の関係等がどうなって行くのか楽しみで読み進めていくのが楽しいです。

It's surprisingly interesting to read on. The pictures are beautiful, and the content itself seems to be a common story, but it's fun to read on looking forward to seeing how the relationship etc. between the two will go in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

意外だった

It was surprising

絵柄が好みで読み始めたら、どんどんストーリーの続きが気になって、読み進めてしまいました。主人公がホントにかわいそかわいくて、目が離せません。

When I started reading it because I liked the design, I was more and more curious about the continuation of the story, and I read on. The main character is really cute and I can't take my eyes off it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマる

Addicted

玉が健気です。鎮北王さまもツンデレですね。慣れないお世話をしてみたり甘々です。もっと甘々にしてあげて！玉に幸せになってほしい。読み始めたらハマってしまいます。

The ball is healthy. King Chinboku is also a tsundere, isn't he? I'm so happy to try to take care of something I'm not used to. Please make them even sweeter! I want Jama to be happy. Once I started reading it, I became addicted to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

試し読みから

From trial reading

試し読みから一気にひきこまれます。あとカラーがとても綺麗です。ただ、長編になりそうなのでどんなラストなのか気になってます。

I was drawn in all at once from the trial reading. Also, the color is very beautiful. However, it seems like it's going to be a long film, so I'm wondering what kind of last one it will be.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

じれったい！ハマる…

I want to lose it! I'm addicted to it...

絵がすごく綺麗なので読み始め、1話が短いけど50pと手頃なためどんどん読み進めていったら、もぅすごくこじれるし、じれったいし、でも気になる！と沼にハマり、、あっという間に最新話にたどり着いてしまいそうです?BLだけどラブシーンの直接的な描写がないので、抵抗なく読めるという意見もありますが、物足りなく感じる人もいるのかな、とも思います。

The pictures are so beautiful that I started reading it, and even though episode 1 is short, it's affordable at 50p, and as I read more and more, it gets really messy and confused, but it bothers me! I'm addicted to the swamp, and it seems like they'll get to the latest episode in no time? Although it is BL, there is no direct depiction of love scenes, so there are opinions that it can be read without resistance, but I also wonder if there are people who feel that it is unsatisfactory.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ワクワクします。

I'm excited.

イケメン好きなら読むべし。強い、カッコいい、そしてドS！！！なのに純愛で最高に面白いです。キュンキュンしたい人はぜひ！

If you like good-looking guys, you should read it. Strong, cool, and awesome!!! But it's pure love and it's extremely interesting. If you want to cheer up, don't miss it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

多少の中弛みはあるにせよ

Even if there is some slack

This review contains spoilers. 最初の方はとても面白かったんですが、途中で中弛みしますねタイトルの通り愛から憎しみへ行ってしまったあたりから、んー早く抜け出してほしいなといやそれマジで酷い、という言動もしばしば。。。休み休み続き読みます

This review contains spoilers. The first one was very interesting, but as the title suggests, it also relaxes me, and as the title suggests, there are also a lot of words and actions that say, um, I want them to get out quickly, but that's really terrible... Rest break I will continue reading

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれい

The picture is beautiful

ストーリーは進みが遅くてちょっともどかしいのですが、衣装もきれいで見ごたえあります。片思い的展開が多くてちょっと辛い・・

The story progresses slowly and is a bit frustrating, but the costumes are beautiful and impressive. There are a lot of unrequited love developments and it's a bit painful...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

止まらない

nonstop

単純に絵が綺麗！今まで色んなやつ見てきて次どうくるかを予想したりするけど、こうくるか！？って事が多くてどんどん続きが気になってしまう！

The picture is simply beautiful! I've seen a lot of things until now and I've been predicting what will come next, but is this how it will come!? There are so many things that I'm worried about the continuation more and more!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

84話（最新）を読んだ感想です。

This is my impression of reading episode 84 (latest).

This review contains spoilers. 『あれ、お爺ちゃんボケてしまったの？？』男である玉（ぎょく）に従兄弟の兄と結婚して子供を作れって、、、。それとも、まさかのオメガバース的な男性でも子供が産める設定なのかな？だとしたら、ぜひ改心して玉に恋焦がれる攻（くげんきょう）と末永くお願いしたいです。玉も何だかんだと思いつつ、攻が好きなようなので、、続きが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. “Oh, did Grandpa go blurry?? ” The man, Tama (Gyoku), married his cousin's older brother and had children... Or is it just a setting where even an omega-verse male can have children? If that's the case, I'd like to ask for a long time to be converted and make an attack (kugenkyo) that makes you fall in love with a ball. They seem to like attacking while wondering what the ball is, so I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

完結？

complete?

2023年3月27日完結？二人の子供は？続編があるらしく期待しています。2023年3月20日、121話、読みました。沈玉が「嫁いできて１年」。え？もう何年も経ってませんか？親王がいい人になったせいか以前よりわかりやすく面白くなってきました。2023年2月3日、113話まで読み続けていますが、さすがに飽きてきたかも。2022年5月7日、ひたすらかわいそうだった玉が皇后になり親王と一緒になってからの物語が、だらだらと続いています。かわいそうな時代からの変化が激しく、別の物語のよう。元々親王の玉への虐待や愛情、理不尽不可解が多く理解できないのですが、日本人の感覚との違いかなと思いながらも、こちらもダラダラと単話が55円なので惰性で買い続けています。絵はキレイです。

Will it be completed on 2023/3/27? What about the two kids? I'm hopeful that there will be a sequel. On 2023/3/20, I read episode 121. “It's been a year since Shen Yu got married.” huh? Hasn't it been many years? It's easier to understand and more interesting than before, probably because the Imperial Prince has become a nice person. On 2023/2/3, I've been continuing to continue reading until episode 113, but I'm probably getting tired of it. On 2022/5/7, the story continues lazily after Tamara, who was just plain pitiful, became empress and became with the Imperial Prince. The changes since the poor times have been drastic, and it's like a different story. Originally, the Prince's abuse and love for the ball was unreasonable and inexplicable, and I don't understand it, but even though I think it's a difference from Japanese people's senses, this one is also a lazy and 55 yen single story, so I keep buying it due to inertia. The picture is beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

全体としてはおましろかったんだけれど…

Overall, it was interesting, but...

最近一回が短くて、よくんからなくなってきました…なんだか残念な感じです…内容がなくて間延びするなら本題だけですすんでほしいです

Recently, one session has been short, and it's getting worse... it's kind of disappointing... if there's no content and it's going to be delayed, I want you to just skip to the main subject

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになって欲しい

I want you to be happy

This review contains spoilers. 生い立ちが不幸なだけに男性版シンデレラストーリーかと思っていたけどなかなかに時代物にありがちなドロドロと口がきけない事で起きるすれ違いでモヤモヤしてますこのあと奇跡的に生き延びて幸せになって欲しいと切に願ってしまいます

This review contains spoilers. I was wondering if it was a male version of Cinderella's story just because my upbringing was unhappy, but it was quite confusing because it happened because of the muddiness and inability to speak, which is common in the period, and I really hope they miraculously survive and be happy after this

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

女の人かと思った

I thought it was a woman

This review contains spoilers. 最初見た時、受けの事を女の人かと勘違いしてました。裸を見なきゃとても男には見えない笑痛めつけられて可哀想な受けを見るのが好きなのでストーリー的には星5でした。

This review contains spoilers. When I first saw it, I misunderstood that the recipient was a woman. It was 5 stars in terms of story because if you don't look naked, you can't see a man lol I like to be hurt and feel sorry.

Helpful

Reviews for The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga