The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga Reviews (P.34)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ついつい読んでしまう…

I just read it...

This review contains spoilers. 171話まで読みました。第一部は、良くある時代もので、主人公が酷い扱いを受けるも、スパダリの皇帝に見初められ、最後は苦難を乗り越え、幸せになりましたって感じで、まだ良かったのですが。第二部は、何か子供っぽい皇太子に、めっちゃ聡明な太子妃が振り回されて、見てて痛々しいです。途中ちょこちょこ、優しくする時もあるけど、基本太子妃を敵視してるし、あまりにもこの展開が長すぎて、そろそろしんどくなってきました。1話分の内容も短く、こんだけ？って毎週イライラします。でも結局、次回は報われるのでは？と、話が気になってついつい読んでしまいます。絵は綺麗だから、そこは救いです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 171 episodes. Part 1 is from a common period, and even though the main character was treated harshly, he was first seen by the Emperor of Spadari, and at the end, I felt like he overcame hardships and became happy, so I'm still glad. In the second part, a very intelligent Crown Princess is swayed by a childish crown prince, and it's painful to watch. There are times when they are kind here and there along the way, but they are basically hostile to the Crown Princess, and this development has been going on for too long, and it's about to get tough. The content of episode 1 is also short, isn't it? It's frustrating every week. But in the end, won't it pay off next time? I was curious about the story and ended up reading it. The picture is beautiful, so that's a relief.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

阿呆な攻め様

Stupid attack-sama

This review contains spoilers. 二部の麒玉が阿呆すぎて、イライラしながら毎週読んでおります。読んじゃうんですよね。。幸せな展開を今か今かと思いながら。阿呆にザマア展開お願いしたいです。そして最後は溺愛でフィニッシュお願いします！

This review contains spoilers. Kiryu in Part 2 is so stupid that I read it every week while being frustrated. You read it, right? While wondering if the happy development is now or now. Idiot, I'd like to ask for Zama's development. And finally, please finish with doting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

第二部

Part II

第二部もおもしろいです。麒玉よ…礼卿に優しくしてあげて…と思いながら読んでますけど、無意識に徐々に礼卿を大事にしてきてる片鱗が見えてきてます。

The second part is also interesting. I'm reading it while thinking, Kiryu... be kind to Reikei... but unknowingly, I'm beginning to see a glimpse of how they are gradually taking care of Reikei.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

紆余曲折あるのが愛

Love has twists and turns

愛憎入り混じってドロドロうだうだしながらも、着地点を見失わず寄り添える二人になれてホントに良かった。親王の拗れっぷりや沈玉くんのオドオド面にはちょっとイラつく事もあるけれど、愛故の…なのか (--；) 沈玉くんが言葉を得、御子を得て自我をぶつけていかれるようになったのは親王にとっては僥倖。二部は未読だけど、二人は元気に出てくるのかな？

It was really nice to be able to become two people snuggling up without losing sight of their landing point, even though they are muddling with a mixture of love and hate. There are times when it is a bit irritating to the Imperial Prince's relentlessness and Shen Yu's outrage, but maybe because of love... (--;) it was a shame for the Prince that Shen Yu got words, got his son, and began to hit his ego. I haven't read part 2, but I wonder if the two of them will come out well?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

史劇中華BLは絵がキレイ、もう素敵すぎます、前半は辛いけど後半からは幸せな展開、やっと幸せに終わったのに第二部が始まり、嬉しさ反面また心労伴う長い道のりが始まるかと思うと購入を躊躇してしまう、終わってから一気買いしよう〜。

The pictures in the historical drama Chinese BL are beautiful, and it's already too nice; the first half was painful, but the second part unfolded happily; even though it ended happily, the second part started, and on the other hand, I was happy, I hesitated to buy it when I thought that a long journey involving worry would begin, so let's buy it all at once after it's over.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

たまたま読んだだけなのに

I just read it by chance

BLにハマってしまいました。時代劇で外国（アジア）の物語ですが、遠いお話だからこそ受け入れられたのかも。物語は切なくて哀しくて苦しいことが多いけど、カタルシスもまた大きい。作画もとても美しい。どこまで続くのかな、次号が待ち遠しいです。

I'm addicted to BL. It's a period drama and it's a foreign (Asian) story, but maybe it was only accepted because it was a distant story. The stories are often sad, sad, and painful, but the catharsis is also huge. The drawing is also very beautiful. I wonder how far it will go, and I can't wait for the next issue.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

男どもよ、さっさと大人になれ！

Come on, guys, become adults!

This review contains spoilers. うーん、これは一部だけでやめておくべきだったかもしれません。親王は後半影の立場で玉ちゃんを守って、それで相当精神的に成長しましたが、第二部では息子の方がぐだぐだしていて、自分の精神年齢の幼さをまわりの人のせいにしていて、どうしようもないです。名前でなく「奴隷ちゃん」とずっと呼んでいる君のほうが彼に対して屈辱的な態度なのでは？最初から引っかかっていたことですが。これは早く決着がつかないと読者のストレスたまりまくる。絵のほうは画面すべてが美麗で文句はないのですが、そのキャラクターの性格がね。美麗な絵に似合わなくてもったいないです。すみません。あえて辛口で書かせていただきました。

This review contains spoilers. Hmm, maybe I should have stopped this in part. The Imperial Prince protected Tama-chan in the latter half, and she grew quite spiritually, but in the second part, her son was sluggish, and she blamed her mental childhood on people around him, so there's nothing you can do about it. Wouldn't you, who always called him “Slave-chan” instead of his name, have a humiliating attitude towards him? I was stuck right from the start. If this isn't settled quickly, readers will get stressed. As for the picture, everything on the screen is beautiful, and I have no complaints, but the character's personality. It's a waste if it doesn't look good on a beautiful picture. I'm sorry. I dared to write it dry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

溺愛やばい

Doting is terrible

This review contains spoilers. 女の代わりに売られるのかわいそうですが、攻めの溺愛は好きです。でも、王妃にいじめられる受け可哀想だけど攻めが助けに来るのがいいんですよね。二人の間に色々亀裂が入ったりするのでハッピーエンドで終わって欲しいです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a pity that they're sold in place of women, but I like aggressive doting. But it's a pity to be bullied by the queen, but it's good that the attack comes to help. There are various cracks between the two, so I want it to end with a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2部からが…

Starting with part 2...

This review contains spoilers. 他の方も書いてる通り1部は若干やり過ぎ感はあるものの（拒否り方とか）その分最後の方のいちゃいちゃぶりがめちゃめちゃぐっときます！うわあーとかきゃーとか思わず口に出ます。その勢いでワクワクして2部に行ったらあれ？ってなるのなぜ…。もしかして訳者が違ったりしますか？玉や他のキャラの口調も違うし、言い回しがいかにも中国語翻訳しましたって感じられてなんか私はなんか冷めちゃいました…。あと字が小さい。老眼じゃなくてもスマホじゃ見づらいです。大好きな作品なだけに2部いろいろ残念です。

This review contains spoilers. As others have written, part 1 feels a bit overkill (like how to refuse), but that's why the flirting at the end is so damn good! I can't help but say wow wow. Why don't you get excited with that momentum and go to Part 2? Why does it become... Could it be that the translators are different? The tone of the ball and the other characters was also different, and I felt that the wording had been translated into Chinese, and it kind of made me feel a bit cold... The letters after that are small. Even if you don't have presbyopia, it's hard to see on a smartphone. Part 2 is disappointing just because it's a work I love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

読むほどはまります

The more I read, the more I fit

夢中で読んでて全部購入してました。読み返すほどハマります！絵も綺麗だしストーリーも良くて何回読んでも最高です。

I was so engrossed in reading it that I bought them all. The more I read it, the more addicted it was! The pictures are beautiful and the story is good, and it's great no matter how many times I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

一時大ハマりしました

I was really addicted to it for a while

第1部攻めの俺様カッコイイこと！題名と絡めた展開の波乱万丈さ！山場が収束する辺りまで夢中で読みました。その後の穏やかな時期の話しは規制の関係のせいか温すぎて退屈でした。縦読み長すぎて読みにくい。第2部も途中まで読みましたが、ある程度まとまって、評価と勘案して購入決めたいです。

Part 1: The Attack Is Cool! The developments linked to the title are full of ups and downs! I was engrossed in reading it until the point where the mountains converged. The talk about the calm period that followed was so warm and boring, probably because of regulations. The vertical reading is too long and difficult to read. I also read part 2 halfway through, but I want to put it together to some extent and make a purchase decision based on evaluations and considerations.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

単行本まだでしょうか。

Is it still a book?

途中まで読んでいて、単行本が出たら一気に読みたいなと思ったら、なかなか出てくれないので、じっと我慢の子になっていますw玉ちゃんが不憫で健気でかわいかったですが、切ない時もあって、色々な感情が揺さぶられました。どうか幸せになってほしいと思っています。

I read it halfway through, and when the book came out, I thought I wanted to read it all at once, so it didn't come up easily, so I'm still putting up with it. Wadama-chan was pitiful, healthy, and cute, but there were times when I was sad, and various emotions were shaken. I want them to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵は美しい

The picture is beautiful

絵はとても美しいし、ストーリーも面白い。が、タテヨミがどうしても好きになれないというか馴染めず、タテヨミというだけで気分が下がる。それと、長い。長すぎる。そこも魅力なのだろうけど。

The pictures are so beautiful and the story is interesting. However, I just don't like Tateyomi, or rather, I don't get used to it, and just saying Tateyomi makes me feel down. Also, it's a long time. It's been too long. That is probably attractive too, though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

中華系BL

Chinese BL

This review contains spoilers. 中華系BLは衣装とか華やかで素敵です。表紙の印象通り綺麗な絵柄です。ただ翻訳の方はもう少し頑張って欲しかったかなと思う部分も多々ありました。それと攻めの君玄梟の好感度の上がり下がりが本気で激しくて、途中は本気で最悪な男だなと思いました。シーズン1完結の辺りではまぁ反省してるし、何より玉が望むなら…と好感度が上向きになりましたが(笑)玉は一貫して可愛かったです。個人的にはシーズン1で大団円になっていたのでそこで完結でも良かったなと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. The costumes of the Chinese BL are gorgeous and wonderful. It is a beautiful pattern as per the impression on the cover. However, there were many parts where I thought the translator would have worked a little harder. Also, the rise and fall in the affinity of the attacking Kimigen Owl was seriously intense, and I seriously thought he was the worst man along the way. Around the end of season 1, I was pretty sorry, and above all else, my likability increased, saying if the ball wanted it... (lol), but the ball was consistently cute. Personally, it was a big group in season 1, so I thought it would have been nice if it ended there.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい

beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 口もきけず男であることを隠し王の妾となり気に入られ、それを面白くない王妃に痛めつけられる様が見ていて辛かった。

This review contains spoilers. He hid that he was a quiet man and was liked by the king's concubine, and it was painful to watch how he was hurt by an uninteresting queen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

美しいしキュンキュン

It's beautiful and it's amazing

This review contains spoilers. フルカラーで絵が綺麗だから目の保養！なんだかんだ言って攻めが受けのことを大切にしているのが伝わってくるからそこもいい

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are beautiful in full color, so it's a feast for the eyes! By saying something, it conveys that they value receiving attacks, so that's good too

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

((( ；ﾟДﾟ)))怖い～

((;))) scary ~

ざ、大奥だね～怖い((( ；ﾟДﾟ)))です。嫉妬って、本当に昔の人は、残酷ですね((( ；ﾟДﾟ)))ｶﾞｸｶﾞｸﾌﾞﾙﾌﾞﾙ

Wow, that's scary ((;°))). Jealousy is really cruel in the olden days ((; °°°))) Gagghafle

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

長いーーー…ｗ

it's been a long time... lol

今月のパワープッシュだったので読んでみました！まだ全話読めていません。。。でも、読む前にいくつかレビューを読んで構えていたのですが（低評価レビューも多め）意外とイケます！確かに感情の機微、みたいなのはだいぶサイコ味あるDV攻めなので分かり難いし、受けも声が出せないから意思疎通がかなり困難ですれ違いっぷりが多過ぎてちょっと理解に苦しむ所もあるのですが、、、だからこそどうなるのか知りたい！と思わせられてついつい先を読んでしまいます！あと、絵がキレイ…！日本の作品じゃないからという点でも分かり難さはあるけれど、それでも読んでみる価値はあるかな？と思いますし、この長さがあるなら「読み応え」としては物理的に十分ではないでしょうか⁉

It was this month's power push, so I read it! I haven't read all the stories yet... But I read a few reviews before I read them (lots of low rated reviews), and it's surprisingly cool! Certainly, the subtlety of emotion is a pretty psychological DV attack, so it's hard to understand, and since you can't receive or make a voice, it's quite difficult to communicate, and there are places where it's a bit difficult to understand because there are so many differences, but... that's why I want to know what happens! It made me think so I just read ahead! Also, the picture is beautiful...! It's hard to understand even because it's not a Japanese work, but is it still worth reading? I think, and if it's this long, wouldn't it be physically sufficient for “reading” ⁉

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょっと理解できないなと思いつつ

While thinking that I don't understand

イラストに惹かれて読み始めました。暴力的な男の子と女の子のような外見の男の子のお話、という感じですね、とてもざっくり言うと。どれだけ暴力を振るわれても心が離れないという流れにちょっとどうなの、と思いつつイラストにつられて読み進めちゃいます。親王様見目麗しいです。

I was drawn to the illustrations and started reading them. It's like a story about a violent boy and a boy who looks like a girl, to put it very roughly. I read on while wondering how it is with the flow of not being able to leave my heart no matter how much violence is used. The Prince looks beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

健気な玉と冷酷非情な鎮北王の成長物語♦

A coming-of-age story of the healthy ball and the ruthless King Zhenbei ♦

This review contains spoilers. 無垢で健気で可憐な玉がイケメンで仕事が出来るが冷酷非情な鎮北王に恋をする、中国の王朝のドロドロな話しです。刑罰が酷いので、そういうのがダメな人は止めておいた方が良いかもしれません。刑罰もそんなにずっと描かれている訳ではありませんが。イケメン揃いでぜひ後半まで読んで欲しい話しです。絵がとにかくキレイですが、前半と後半で絵が変わってしまったのが本当に残念です。後半も絵がキレイですが、前半の方が絵がキレイです。話しが進むにつれて玉が知性を得て、自分の出自を知り、鎮北王に対する態度が変わります。それにより、鎮北王も玉への態度を変えないといけなくなります。更に、鎮北王に対等に話しが出来るライバルが出て来て、鎮北王も自分を変えざるを得なくなります。この話しは玉と鎮北王の成長物語です。話しはご都合主義な所もあります。が、まだ途中ですが楽しいので買い揃えたいと思います。

This review contains spoilers. It's a muddy story about the Chinese dynasty where an innocent, healthy, and pretty ball falls in love with King Zhenbei, a handsome man who can work but is ruthless and ruthless. The punishment is terrible, so it might be better to stop people who don't like that. Punishments haven't been depicted all that long, either. This is a story I definitely want all the handsome guys to read until the second half. The picture is beautiful anyway, but it's really unfortunate that the picture changed between the first half and the second half. The pictures are beautiful in the second half, but the pictures in the first half are more beautiful. As the conversation progresses, Jama gains intelligence, learns where she is from, and her attitude towards King Zhenbei changes. As a result, King Zhenbei will also have to change his attitude towards jade. Furthermore, a rival who can speak to King Zhenbei on an equal footing comes out, and King Zhenbei is forced to change himself. This story is a coming-of-age story of Jade and King Zhenbei. There are also places where discussions are convenient. But it's still in the middle, but it's fun, so I'd like to buy them all.

Helpful

Reviews for The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga