The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga Reviews (P.19)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

興味無かった

I wasn't interested

BLに興味が無かったんですが、綺麗な描き方をされて居るので初心の私にも読みやすかったです！顔は冷たいのに行動が優しいしか無く、わかっている筈なのに、きちんと彼女と呼んだら、可愛がって居る所にキュンです

I wasn't interested in BL, but it was easy to read even for a beginner because it was drawn in a beautiful way! Her face is cold, but she has no choice but to act kindly, and even though you should know it, if you call her properly, it's amazing that she is adorable

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

絵が綺麗どうなるかはらはらする感じがおもしろいです。続きがとても気になります。ハッピーエンドであって欲しいです。

The feeling of staring at how a beautiful picture will turn out is interesting. I'm really worried about the continuation. I want it to have a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

沼・・・

swamp...

お勧めでずっと気になっていた作品でした。軽率に読み始めたら止まらなくなりました。原本の和訳があったら是非読みたい作品です。

I recommended it and it was a work I've always been interested in. Once I started reading it carelessly, I couldn't stop. If there is a Japanese translation of the original, this is a work I definitely want to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

まだ少ししか見てないけど絵がともて綺麗だしストーリーもなかなか良くてどんどん見ちゃいますBLっぽくないから誰が読んでも良さそう！

I've only watched a little bit yet, but the pictures are so beautiful and the story is pretty good, and I'm watching more and more. It doesn't look like BL, so it looks good no matter who reads it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった！

That was great!

This review contains spoilers. 強い攻めが受けにだけ優しいのとか(ひどいこともするけど)、愛が重いのとか、拗らせラブめちゃくちゃ大好物でして…試し読みからまんまと最新話まで購入してしまいました。絵が綺麗で特に４２話、わたしはめちゃくちゃ叫びました。(良すぎて)BLとは言っても、プラトニック強で直接的な絵は出てないので(今のところ)BLが苦手な人でも読みやすいかと思います。玉ちゃんを取り戻せ君玄梟〜ッ！て感じで５１話を待っています。

This review contains spoilers. They are gentle only when taken by strong attacks (although they do terrible things), love is heavy, and relentless love is my insanely favorite food... I bought everything from trial readings to the latest episode. The pictures were so beautiful that I screamed a lot, especially episode 42. Even though it's called BL (too good), there are no direct, platonic pictures, so I think it's easy to read even for people who don't like BL (so far). Take back Tama-chan, you Gen-ho! I feel like I'm waiting for episode 51.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗✨

The picture is beautiful ✨

何気なく見た漫画の絵が好きだったので読み始めたのがきっかけだっかけど、内容も面白い！早く続編が読みたいです

I liked the comic pictures I had seen casually, so it started when I started reading them, but the content was interesting too! I want to read the sequel soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

日本のBLとは違う

It's different from Japanese BL

This review contains spoilers. タテヨミ読みにくいなーと思いながらも絵が個人的に好みなのでどんどん読み進めてしまいました。配信としてはcomicoの方が先に進んでいるので今はそちらで課金しています。原作は中国のBL小説で、現在も連載中とのこと。そのせいか漫画は第二章に入り90話以降も終わりが見えてきません。日本の漫画と同じレベルを期待して読むと途中でしんどくなると思います。まず、話が進むスピードが遅すぎる。お国柄なのか、原作に追いつかないようにしているからなのか、一話読んでも進展なし！なんてこともありました。また、翻訳の問題なのか時々ん？と思うような台詞の飛び方をします。絵は綺麗ですが細かい表情や動きの描写は皆無です。BLなのにキス以上のシーンは出てきません。匂わせる表現がある程度です。色々書きましたが、私はお国柄の違い(中華系のドラマとかもグダグダネチネチしてるの多いなと思うので)かなと思いこれはこれで楽しんでいます。星5の理由は絵(特に歴史的装飾のある衣装)の綺麗さとまっすぐな俺様系キャラの設定が個人的にどストライクだからです！中華系ハマる人はハマると思いますよ。長編小説に付き合う覚悟で二人の幸せを願って見届けたいと思います。

This review contains spoilers. Even though I thought it would be hard to read vertically, I personally liked the pictures, so I read more and more. As for distribution, Comico is ahead, so now I'm charging there. The original is a Chinese BL novel, and it is said that it is still being serialized. Probably because of that, the comic has entered the second chapter, and there is no end in sight even after episode 90. If you read them expecting the same level as Japanese comics, I think it will get tough along the way. First, the speed at which the conversation progresses is too slow. Maybe it's because of the country or because they try not to catch up with the original story, there's no progress even after reading one episode! There were things like that. Also, is it sometimes a translation issue? The lines fly in a way that makes you think. The picture is beautiful, but there are no detailed expressions or movements. Even though it's BL, there aren't any scenes more than a kiss. There is a certain amount of expression that makes you smell it. I've written a lot, but I'm enjoying this because I think it's a difference between countries (because I think there are a lot of Chinese dramas and stuff like that). The reason it's 5 stars is because the beauty of the pictures (especially the costumes with historical decorations) and the straightforward setting of our characters are a personal strike! I think people who are addicted to Chinese will be addicted to it. I'm prepared to go out with a long story, and I want to watch it while hoping for the happiness of the two of them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

次が気になりすぎます！

I'm too worried about the next one!

BL…否定派の私です（申し訳ございません）絵の綺麗さで興味本位で初めて読んだ作品です。私が思っていたのとは違うある意味かけ離れた世界でした。重複しますが、とにかく絵が綺麗ですし、登場人物がとても美しいです！時にすごく可愛いイラストや擬音。ストーリーも、胸が締め付けられる沈玉の想い…。ハラハラする親王様の振る舞い…。語彙力ないのでこの作品の素晴らしさをお伝えできません！たくさんの方に見てほしいです！

BL... I'm a denier (sorry) This is the first work I read out of interest due to the beauty of the picture. It was a different world than I had anticipated, and in a sense it was far from what I had anticipated. It overlaps, but anyway, the pictures are beautiful, and the characters are so beautiful! Sometimes very cute illustrations and onomatopoeia. The story is also about Shen Yu's heartbreaking feelings... the harassing behavior of the Imperial Prince... I don't have vocabulary, so I can't tell you how wonderful this work is! I want lots of people to see it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい絵で引き込まれる

Be drawn in by beautiful pictures

先ずは美しい絵と世界観に引き込まれます！続きが気になって次々購入してしまいました。BLものではありますが、性的な描写は殆ど無いのは好き好き別れるところと思います。ただ話せない奴隷という主人公が粗野な将軍に本人たちも気付かぬまま惹かれて行く様子は先々どうなって行くのか気になるところです。美形の主人公が怪我する事に萌えがある人には堪らない作品であるとも思います。何にせよ個人的には主人公が最後に報われる事を願っています。

First, you'll be drawn into the beautiful pictures and the view of the world! I was worried about the continuation, so I bought one after another. It's a BL thing, but I think the fact that there are almost no sexual depictions is a matter of separation between likes and likes. I'm worried about how the main character, a slave who just can't talk, is attracted to the crude shogun without them even noticing it, and I'm worried about what will happen in the future. I also think it's an unbearable work for people who have a crush on the beautiful protagonist getting hurt. At any rate, I personally hope that the main character will be rewarded at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

Twitterから来ました

I came from Twitter

一気読みしてしまった…。ちょこちょこ更新勘弁して欲しい続きが気になり過ぎる。1冊の本になるのいつ？？

I read it all at once... I want you to forgive me for updating here and there, I'm too worried about the continuation. When will it become 1 book??

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

気になるー

I'm worried

1巻、1巻が短いです。この先どうなるのか、気になります。早く続きが、読みたいです❗購入して本当に良かった❗

Volume 1, volume 1 is short. I'm curious about what will happen in the future. I want to read the continuation soon ❗ I'm really glad I bought it ❗

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がキレイ

The picture is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. とにかく絵がとても綺麗で衣装もカラーで見れるのが嬉しいです。鎮北王が凄まじくカッコいいです。冷酷な王が毒で侵された沈玉を自ら介抱するのにキュンとしてしまいました。まだまだ続くようなので先がとても気になります。名前にチンがたくさんで出てきてちょっと笑ってしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. Anyway, the pictures are so beautiful and I'm happy to be able to see the costumes in color. King Jinbuk is really cool. The ruthless king took care of Shen Yu, who had been attacked by poison, on his own. It seems like it's still going on, so I'm really worried about the future. There were so many chins in the name that I laughed a little bit.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる作品

Works I'm worried about continuing

ライトノベル「そらの大事な旦那様」にちょっと主人公の境遇が似てるなぁと思いましたが、続きが気になる作品ですね。王妃が出てくる場面は残酷なシーンが多いので飛ばして読みました(意地悪王妃の出番が今後少ないことを祈ります)…長いので少しずつ読んでいこうかなと思います。

I thought the circumstances of the main character were a bit similar to the light novel “Sora's Precious Husband,” but I'm worried about the continuation of this work. There are a lot of cruel scenes where the queen appears, so I skipped over and read them (I hope the mean queen doesn't appear in the future)... it's a long time, so I think I'll read it little by little.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

きれい。

It's beautiful.

絵がとてもきれいです。強い男性も弱い男性も美しい描写です。内容も次回が読みたくなります。一気に読みたいです。

The picture is very beautiful. It's a beautiful depiction of both strong men and weak men. The content will also make me want to read it next time. I want to read it all at once.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ハラハラドキドキ

Harahara Doki Doki

お互い惹かれあってるはずなのに…と誤解がいつか解けたときのギャップに期待❗どんだけラブラブな日々が待ってるんだろ。今から続きが待ち遠しくて( *´艸｀)

We're supposed to be attracted to each other... and I'm looking forward to the gap when the misunderstanding is resolved ❗ I wonder how many lovey-dovey days await. I can't wait for the continuation from now on (*'`)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

生々しくないのに濃厚

Rich even though it's not raw

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗で試し読みしてたら、続きが気になりすぎて登録しました。、玉はかわいくてキレイで賢くて優しい子なのに、自信が無くてすれ違ってしまうのが不憫…王妃に帝の悪役ぶりが徹底してて、最後はスカッと幸せな結末を願ってやみません。BLといえど生々しいシーンもほとんどなく、親王様も男の色気あふれてて中華風がエロい。玉もほぼ女の子にしか見えず、安心です?

This review contains spoilers. The pictures were beautiful, and when I tried reading them, I was too worried about the continuation, so I registered. Even though Tama is a cute, beautiful, smart, and kind child, she doesn't have confidence and it's unfortunate that they pass by each other... The emperor's villain was thorough with the queen, and I can't stop hoping for a quick and happy ending at the end. Even with BL, there are almost no vivid scenes, and the Prince is also full of male sex appeal and the Chinese style is erotic. The ball is also almost only visible to girls, so is that safe?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

はじめてのBL

First BL

なんとなく敬遠してきたBLですが、とても惹き込まれました。設定も好みの時代物。先が楽しみで、どんどん読み進めてしまいます。主人公に幸あれ。

I've been shunned by BL for some reason, but I was really drawn to it. The setting is also a period style that I like. I'm looking forward to the future, and I keep reading it. Good luck to the protagonist.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

複雑だけど深い

Complex but deep

This review contains spoilers. 展開も攻め、受けの心もコロコロ変わるので、内容を理解するのに苦労しましたが絵も綺麗だし、カラーでとっても読みやすいです！ただそういうシーンが少なく絵として見せてないので、そこはみたいなって感じ！

This review contains spoilers. The development is also aggressive, and the sense of reception changes from place to place, so I had a hard time understanding the content, but the pictures are beautiful, and they are very easy to read in color! However, there aren't many scenes like that and I haven't shown them as pictures, so it feels like that!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗です

The picture is beautiful

何度も宣伝される絵が気になってついつい読みに来てしまいました。絵ももちろん綺麗で見やすいですが、内容も読みやすく続きが気になって仕方ありません

I was curious about the pictures that have been advertised so many times that I just came to read them. Of course, the pictures are beautiful and easy to read, but the content is easy to read and I can't help but be worried about the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

胸が締め付けられる

My chest is tightened

口の利かない主人公が本当に健気で可愛いです。王様とのすれ違いには胸が締め付けられます。普段BL系は全然読まないのですが、この作品にはハマりました！

The protagonist, who doesn't speak well, is really healthy and cute. My heart is tightened when I pass by the king. I don't usually read BL books at all, but I'm addicted to this work!

Helpful

Reviews for The Silent Concubine-Full Color Manga