Only the Flower Knows Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

今さらですが。

More on that now.

書かせていただきます。やっぱり人気作品てストーリー立てがしっかりしていて、ここぞって所でしっかり心をつかまれちゃいますネ〜？ＢLファンになって最初の頃に何を読んだらいいのか？分からなくて、花に関する物を選んで読むことにしました。正解でした。少し長かったですがふたりの惹かれ合っていく過程とか丁寧に描かれています。

I'll write it. After all, it's a popular work with a solid storyline, and it really grabs your heart everywhere, right? What should I read when I first became a BL fan? I didn't understand, so I chose something about flowers and decided to read it. That was correct. It was a bit long, but the process of the two being attracted to each other is carefully depicted.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

有川が良い！

Arikawa is good!

ずっと気になっていたので、まずは1巻だけと読み始めましたが、気付いたら3巻読破してました！二人の恋が、初々しくて、甘酸っぱくて、切なくて、優しくて本当に良かったです。高レビューに納得です。それにしても、二人の気持ちが通じ合った後の手慣れた感じでグイグイくる有川にかなりキュンときました。

I've always been interested, so I first started reading only volume 1, but before I knew it, I had read through volume 3! I'm really glad that their love was fresh, sweet and sour, sad, and kind. I'm satisfied with the high reviews. Even so, I was quite amazed by Arikawa, who was getting used to it after their feelings got through.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 11, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった！

That was great!

作者買いです(^^)まだ１巻しか読めてないですが続きが読みたくて読みたくてしょうがないです！さすが作者さん、雰囲気がものすごい出てます！大学での話ですが独特の世界観があります(^^)

I'm buying the author (^^) I've only read volume 1 yet, but I can't help but want to read more! As expected, the author has a tremendous atmosphere! It's a university story, but it has a unique view of the world (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 11, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

人目を気にせずキスした有川に心臓ギュン❗

My heart is pounding for Arikawa who kissed me without worrying about the public eye ❗

This review contains spoilers. 辛く寂しい思いを何度もしてきた御崎が有川のような天然王子さまに出会えたことに感謝感謝です。川端めー！と思いつつ川端に御崎は渡さないとハッキリ告げて追いかけた駅の通路で人目を気にする御崎を気にもとめず(ついでに周りの視線も気にもとめず)御崎にキスした有川あっぱれ！天然王子のかがみだよ…。今までの御崎の孤独を補って余りある幸せを与えてあげられる存在だと思います。ほんとうに素敵な作品。

This review contains spoilers. I am grateful that Misaki, who has felt sad and lonely over and over again, was able to meet a natural prince like Arikawa. Kawabata! Arikawa kissed Misaki without worrying about the public eye in the aisle of the station where he was chasing Kawabata while thinking about it (incidentally, not worrying about the gaze around him) and kissed Misaki! it's natural prince's kagami... I think it is an entity that can make up for Misaki's loneliness up until now and give her too much happiness. It really is a wonderful work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

スピンオフまで併せてどうぞ

Please also add it to the spin-off

This review contains spoilers. 御崎くんは川端さんに翻弄されていて・・・胸が痛い。どこまで素養があったのかは別にして、無垢な御崎くんを惑わせ心を縛り続けた川端さんは許したくない。彼は覚悟を決められないくせに欲しがるだけの子供っぽさ浮き彫りで逆に惑わされたなどと思い込む不誠実な人だから。有川くんはゲイじゃないけど、御崎くんにだけは心が揺れて、きちんと覚悟を決めて飛び越えてきてくれた誠実な人。身も心も小鳥のように怯え震えていた御崎くんが、有川くんのような人と出会えて心から安心しました。

This review contains spoilers. Misaki-kun is being manipulated by Kawabata-san... my heart hurts. Apart from how well educated he was, I don't want to forgive Mr. Kawabata, who misled the innocent Misaki-kun and continued to bind his heart. That's because he's a dishonest person who thinks he was misled in reverse by highlighting the childishness he just wanted even though he couldn't make up his mind. Arikawa-kun isn't gay, but only Misaki-kun is a sincere person whose heart was shaken, made proper preparations, and jumped over. Misaki-kun, who was frightened and trembling like a small bird in body and mind, was truly relieved to meet someone like Arikawa-kun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

御崎と有川、2人がお互いを思い合っていて。良い作品です。何度も読んでしまいます?

Misaki and Arikawa both care for each other. It's a good work. End up reading it over and over again?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

きゅんとしました

I was dumbfounded

御崎の同性が好きな気持ちの葛藤が切なくて、有川の初めての気持ちの戸惑いにもきゅんとしました。同棲してからのお話花のみやこでもまた良かった。そっちもオススメします。

Misaki's conflict over liking people of the same sex was sad, and I was amazed at the confusion of Arikawa's first feelings. Hana no Miyako, the story after living together, was also great. I recommend that one too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュア

pure

凄くピュアなお話。BLの醍醐味がよく出ています。分かりやすい激しい感情の動きはないけど、静かに熱烈に恋してるって感じがとても可愛い?えろしーんも緊張とかでプルプルしてる感じが可愛いです。

It's a really pure story. The real thrill of BL is often shown. There aren't any intense emotional movements that are easy to understand, but is the feeling of being quietly and fervently in love so cute? The feeling that Erosin is also nervous and plump is cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

あったかい気持ちになります

It makes me feel warm

BLを読み出すきっかけになった作品で、こんなに純粋に相手を想えるんだって感動しました☆ ゆっくりと二人の距離が近づいていくので、ストーリー重視派にオススメです。こちらのスピンオフと後日談が「花のみやこで」です。

It's a work that inspired me to read BL, and I was moved that I can think of the other person so genuinely ☆ The distance between the two slowly gets closer, so I recommend it to those who focus on the story. This spin-off and discussion at a later date is “Hana no miyako de.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読み！

Read it all at once!

テンカウントが面白かったのでこちらも読んでみたらやっぱりイイ！話が面白い上に、絵も綺麗。言う事なしの星５つデス?続編あれば絶対買う(笑)

The ten count was interesting, so I read this one too and it was definitely good! Besides the interesting story, the pictures are beautiful. 5 stars death without saying? If there's a sequel, I'll definitely buy it (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

花のみぞ知る

Only flowers know

This review contains spoilers. 宝井理人さんの作品です。基本この方の絵が好きで、今回も作者ページから購入させていただきました。最初は、「なんか幸薄げだな。シリアス系より胸がきゅんきゅんさせられる奴が見たいけど、まぁ最初の1巻だけならいっか。」って気持ちでした。正直、完結まで読む気は無かったです。だけど1度読んでしまうと止まらなくなって、気づけば最初の1巻どころか、完結まで一気読みしてしまいました。個人的にグッと来たのが、やはり有川（攻め）の天然ひた前向きなところです。読む前は、よくあるワンコ系かなとか思ってたのですが、そうではなくて。ただ前向きで明るく、何も考えてなさそうな軽さや適当さがあっても、実は結構真面目だったり優秀だったり、彼女のことも結構ちゃんと大事にしていて、私的に好印象しか無いキャラクターでした。そしてそうありながらも、やはり男性としての欲を持っていたり川端に嫉妬したり、御崎（受け）からの一語一句やキスに、激しく動揺している様は見ていてほんとキュンとしました。久々に、「当たり！」と思える作品に出会えてよかったです。これはまた読み返しちゃいますね。

This review contains spoilers. It is a work by Masato Takarai. Basically, I like this person's picture, and I bought it from the artist's page this time as well. At first, he said, “Somehow unlucky. I'd like to see the one that makes my heart flutter rather than the serious ones, but well, if it's just the first volume, that's fine.” That was the feeling. To be honest, I didn't feel like reading it until it was over. But once I read it, I couldn't stop, and before I knew it, I read it all at once until the end, let alone the first volume. What came as a surprise to me personally is that Arikawa (attack) is naturally positive. Before I read it, I was wondering if it was a common dog type, but that wasn't the case. However, she was a character that was positive and bright, and had a lightness and suitability where she didn't seem to think about anything, but she was actually quite serious and excellent, and she also took care of her quite properly, so it was a character that left nothing but a good impression on me personally. And even so, I was really surprised to see how they still had masculine desires, were jealous of Kawabata, and were violently upset by every word and kiss from Misaki (receive). After a long time, “hit!” I'm glad I came across a work that made me think. I'm going to reread this again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ぜひスピンオフも！本編の続編あり。

Definitely a spin-off too! There is a sequel to the main story.

178、177、170ページ、すべて表題作。（それぞれラストにオマケショートも収録）不器用なミサキが後半ますます可愛い（笑）主人公が天然さわやかくんで好人物。表紙の色使いが良くてすごく綺麗ですが、絵のように2人の恋も上品な綺麗さがありました。巻数があるだけにゆったりした話ですがじんわりくる。話が綺麗なのでBLが苦手な方も読みやすいと思う。ストーリー重視の方にオススメ。3巻にはその後の番外編で卒業後の2人がありますが、さらにその後の続編がスピンオフ花のみやこでの後半に収録！花のみごろに（前後編70ページ）。読み応えある幸せなお話なので、ここまで読んだ方にはぜひ合わせて読まれることをオススメします！

Pages 178, 177, and 170 are all titled works. (A bonus short is also included at the end of each) The clumsy Misaki is increasingly cute in the second half (laughs) The main character is naturally cheerful and a good person. The color use of the cover is good and it is very beautiful, but just like in the picture, the love between the two was also elegant and beautiful. It's a relaxed story because it has a number of volumes, but it's slow. The story is beautiful, so I think it's easy for people who don't like BL to read. Recommended for those who focus on the story. There are 2 people after graduation in volume 3 as an extra edition, and a sequel after that was recorded in the second half of the spin-off Hana no Miyako! In the middle of the flower season (70 pages before and after). It's a happy story that's worth reading, so if you've read it this far, I definitely recommend reading it together!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 20, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

キュンキュンです(♯^.^♯)

It's Kyun Kyun (♯ ^.^ ♯)

みさきくんは本当に心も外見も美人です！ありかわくんは素直で行動力がある優しい子。そんな二人が色々葛藤しながらもどうしようもなく惹かれていく姿が丁寧に描かれていてせつないながらもキュンキュンしました。とにかく、綺麗な花と二人が目も楽しませてくれます！

Misaki-kun is really beautiful in heart and appearance! Arikawa-kun is a kind child who is honest and has the power to act. The images of these two people being helplessly attracted to each other while having various conflicts were carefully depicted, and it made me cringe even though it was annoying. Anyway, the beautiful flowers and the two of them are a feast for the eyes too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きました…

I cried...

この作家さんの世界観にハマりました。切なくて、儚くて、美しいお話です。ストーリーが良く、絵柄も綺麗で、すごく好きなお話の１つです。

I'm addicted to this artist's view of the world. It's a sad, ephemeral, and beautiful story. The story is good, the design is beautiful, and it's one of my favorite stories.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 14, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

とても素敵な作品でした！

It was such a wonderful piece!

本当にとても素敵な作品でした！ストーリーも内容も絵も大好きです！

It really was such a wonderful piece! I love the story, the content, and the pictures!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

胸キュンキュン！

My heart is throbbing!

んもぉぉう！最高に良いです！恋がしたくなっちゃいます！絵も綺麗だし、内容も良いし！宝井先生の漫画はどれも良くて♪その中でも、花のみぞが一番好きです！

Hmmm! It's the best! It makes me want to fall in love! The pictures are beautiful and the content is good too! All of Takarai-sensei's comics are good ♪ Among them, Hana no Mizo is my favorite!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆったりした空気感

Relaxed air

御崎くんと有川くんの気持ちがゆっくり育っていく過程が、微笑ましくてイイです(^-^)植物も綺麗で見ていて癒されます。

The process where Misaki-kun and Arikawa-kun's feelings slowly grow is smiling and nice (^-^) I am healed by looking at the plants beautifully.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

心がほんわかする?

do you really understand my heart?

全巻既読済みです！！！御崎くんと有川のじれったいけど甘々な恋愛物語ですごくキュンキュンしました！！御崎くんがすごく可愛くて可愛くて...?有川への想いをどんどん膨らませていく描写はホントに繊細に描かれていて、御崎くんと同じ気持ちで読んでました！この作品はエッチシーンが少ないので、エッチシーンを求めてる人にはおすすめしないです。でも、絵が素敵だし、ストーリーも素晴らしいので、エッチシーンは別にいいよって方はおすすめなので是非読んでみてください！！

I've read the whole volume!!! I was so excited about Misaki-kun and Arikawa's secret but sweet romance story!! Misaki-kun is so cute and cute...? The depiction of making my feelings for Arikawa expand more and more was really delicately drawn, and I read it with the same feeling as Misaki-kun! There aren't many sex scenes in this film, so I don't recommend it to people looking for sex scenes. However, the pictures are wonderful, and the story is wonderful, so if you don't mind the sex scene, I recommend it, so be sure to read it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 24, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗な感じ?

does it feel pretty?

作者さんの絵と出てくる花や植物の雰囲気が合っていて、綺麗で良かったです！頭が良いけど興味のあるものに真っ直ぐになってしまう有川が、みさきに出会ってから気になって②…?徐々に距離が縮まり、3巻は甘くて良いです！何度も読み返してます！

The artist's paintings matched the atmosphere of the flowers and plants that came out, and I'm glad they were beautiful! Arikawa, who is smart but gets straight to the things he's interested in, became curious after meeting Misaki ②...? The distance gradually shrinks, and volume 3 is sweet and good! I've been rereading it over and over again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 15, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

やっぱりいい！

After all, it's good!

この作家さんの作品は大好きです。花のみぞ知るは、みさきの弱い部分を有川が支えてあげたり、丁寧に接していき、2人が結ばれるまでのストーリーがたまりません！

I love this artist's work. What Hana Mizu Knows is an irresistible story where Arikawa supports Misaki's weak points and treats them carefully until the two are united!

Helpful

Reviews for Only the Flower Knows Manga