Only the Flower Knows Manga Reviews (P.14)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです

That was interesting

評価も高かったし、作者さんの作品が好きで購入しました。気持ちが温まるような作品ですね、テンカウントよりこちらが好きってレビューの方が多く期待して購入したのですが、私的にはテンカウントの苦しい様な心理描写に毎回スリルがある展開が続く作風のが好みだったようです。それでも素敵なお話でした。

The reviews were high, and I liked the author's work and bought it. It's a work that warms my heart, and I bought it expecting more reviews because I liked it more than Ten Count, but personally, it seems that I liked the style where the development where there is a thrill every time continues with the painful psychological depiction of Ten Count. Still, it was a wonderful story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい

kindest

This review contains spoilers. 優しい世界観です。川端さんは有川にとっては憎い相手だろうけど壁を越えられない彼の葛藤もわかりますしあっさりと壁を越えていく有川への苛立ちもわかります。

This review contains spoilers. It's a gentle view of the world. Kawabata-san is probably Arikawa's hated partner, but I also understand his conflict of not being able to overcome the wall, and I also understand his frustration with Arikawa crossing the wall so easily.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

穏やか

calmer

ゆっくり穏やかに進んでいく作品です。時間があるときにじっくり読みたくなります。

It is a work that progresses slowly and gently. It makes me want to read it carefully when I have time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

ストーリーがおもしろい！そしてツンデレがいい！感情の変化や不思議な感覚がストーリーに引き込まれて、一気に読めて楽しめた！

The story is interesting! And tsundere is good! The emotional changes and strange feelings were drawn into the story, and I enjoyed reading it all at once!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 11, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

久しぶりに。

long time no see.

読んだら良かったです?かなり昔に読んだので良く話が分からなかったしか無かったんですが、再度読み直したら良いお話でした。ミサキくんのあまったれ部分がニヤニヤしちゃいました。笑

Was it good to read it? I read it quite a while ago, so I had no choice but to not really understand the story, but it was a good story to reread. Misaki-kun's crazy part made me smirk. lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくりと

unhurried

有川が自分の気持ちに気づいてからの言葉や行動にキュンとしましたー。

I was amazed by Arikawa's words and actions after she became aware of her own feelings.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

番外編も合わせて

Also add the extra edition

優しく穏やかで今どきっぽくない男の子でした。2人とも顔が幼くて大学生には見えないかなぁ。番外編「花のみやこで」も合わせて読んだ方が満足感が2倍です。

He was a kind, gentle, and unmodern boy. They both have young faces, so I wonder if they can't be seen by college students. If you also read the extra edition “Hana no Miyakode,” the sense of satisfaction is twice as satisfying.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

サラッと読める

I can read it smoothly

口コミがなかなか良かったので買ってみたのですが、期待しすぎてしまったせいか、そこまでの感じではなかったです。でも花がキーポイントで花言葉も出てきたりして、とても綺麗な感じのお話でした。3巻ありましたが、サラッと読めました。

The reviews were pretty good, so I bought it, but it didn't feel like it, probably because I expected too much. But flowers were the key point, and the language of flowers also came up, and it was a very beautiful story. There were 3 volumes, and I was able to read them smoothly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

静かで穏やか

Quiet and serene

This review contains spoilers. 劇的な何かが……というよりは、静かに心の動きを書いているような作品です。初めは病んだ人が出てくるのかな？と警戒しましたが、結果的に、しずしずとそれぞれの登場人物の感情や葛藤を描いて終わる印象でした。物語としては良作だと思います。個人的には、プレビューを読んで感じた評価ほど高い印象は受けませんでした。期待が大きすぎたのかもしれません。物語の起承転結で考えると、３冊分の長さを要するのかどうか、コスト的な面で、気にかかったのも正直なところです。ただ、3冊分かけてゆっくり描かれたからこその魅力でもあるのかな……という印象。むしろ、スピンオフの1冊が素晴らしかったです。あの1話目を読み切った瞬間に、この物語の為に、本編三冊買った甲斐があった！！と思いました。本編のゆっくり淡々としたのも良作だと思いましたが、短編で、もどかしさとか切なさとか純愛とかを詰め込んでいるのも素晴らしい。ぜひ、スピンオフまで読んで頂きたいと思います。スピンオフは★５だと思っています。

This review contains spoilers. Rather than something dramatic... it's a work that quietly writes the movement of the heart. I wonder if sick people will come out at first? I was wary, but as a result, I had the impression that it ended by depicting the emotions and conflicts of each character with Shizu Shizu. I think it's a good story. Personally, I wasn't as impressed by the high ratings I felt when I read the preview. Maybe my expectations were too high. When I think about it in terms of origin, beginning and end of the story, I was honestly concerned about whether it would take the length of 3 books in terms of cost. However, I have the impression that it is also attractive because it was drawn slowly over 3 books... Rather, one of the spin-offs was amazing. The moment I read through that first episode, it was worth buying the three main books for this story!! I thought so. I thought it was a good work that was slow and carefree in the main story, but it's also wonderful that it's a short film, packed with frustration, sadness, and pure love. By all means, I would like you to read the spin-off. I think the spin-off is ★ 5.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

きれい

beautiful

少女漫画のような絵で見やすい。静かに淡々と進んでいく感じ。先生の作品にはいつも儚い雰囲気が漂っている。独特の空気。

The pictures look like girls' comics and are easy to read. It feels like it's progressing quietly and slowly. There is always an ephemeral atmosphere in the teacher's work. unique air.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻＋1。4冊まとめ読みで真価発揮！

Volume 3 + 1. Show off your true value by reading 4 books at once!

This review contains spoilers. 1巻読み終えた時点では、ん？かなりのスローペース！と驚きましたが、そのテンポだからこそ、なんの接点もなかった2人が相手に惹かれ、自覚し、想い合う恋路をじっくりと味わえたのだと思います。戸惑う表情とか絵が丁寧。お互いの専攻内容とかリアル感ありますね。受の過去とそれにまつわる人物が気になりましたが、意外とアッサリで。笑。悪い人は決して出ないお話ですね。3巻で終わり、というより続編（「花のみやこ」に収録）まで読んで本当のフィナーレという気がします。

This review contains spoilers. When I finished reading volume 1, huh? Quite a slow pace! I was surprised, but I think it was precisely because of that tempo that the two people who had no point of contact were attracted to their partner, became aware, and were able to thoroughly enjoy the love path of mutual feelings. The puzzled expression and pictures are polite. There's a sense of realism about each other's majors. I was curious about Uke's past and the people associated with it, but it was surprisingly quick. lol. It's a story where bad people never appear. Rather than finishing with volume 3, I read the sequel (recorded in “Hana no Miyako”), and I feel like it's the real finale.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

全部好き

I like them all

絵も内容もキャラクターも全部好き読んでて幸せになれます。。

It makes me happy to read all the pictures, content, and characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

受けに感情移入しました

I empathized with the reception

This review contains spoilers. 依存、とか、嫉妬とか、そういった感情が出てくる話ですが………登場人物が全員しんどい想いを抱えていたからということを考えると、絵でも台詞でも描ききれなかった部分にたくさんの感情が詰まっていると思います。学生のお話ですが、あと10年したら、また見方が変わるのではないかなぁと感じます。難しいお話です。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where feelings like dependency, jealousy, etc. come up... considering that it's because all the characters had tough feelings, I think there are a lot of emotions packed into parts that couldn't be fully depicted in pictures or dialogue. It's a student story, but I have a feeling that in 10 more years, the way I look at it will change again. It's a difficult story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

二人の距離が

The distance between the two

ゆっくり少しずつ縮まっていくのを、読み手も静かにやさしく見守りたくなる作品。美しい花々がほんとに似合う二人です。

It is a work that makes readers want to quietly and gently watch as it slowly shrinks little by little. They are two people who really look good with beautiful flowers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

テンカウントにはまり、作者の他の作品も読んでみたくなり購入しました。やっぱり買って良かったです。丁寧なストーリーの作品が好きなので、心理描写や人物の表情など、テンカウント同様すごく好きな作品でした。あと、何と言っても作者の絵が大好きです。焦ってる表情とか、言葉に出来ずにコクコク頷くところとか可愛くてキュンとします。

I fell in love with the ten count and bought it because I wanted to read the author's other works. I'm glad I bought it after all. I like works with careful stories, so I really liked the psychological depiction and facial expressions of the characters, just like Ten Count. Also, after all, I love the artist's paintings. The impatient expression or the fact that she nods without being able to put it into words is cute and makes me cringe.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗でゆったり

Clean and relaxed

絵も作品全体の雰囲気も綺麗でした。ストーリーもゆっくり進んで丁寧なので読みごたえがありました。御崎はなんとも言えない可愛さがあり魅力的な人物です。有川も何でも出来て器用だけどちょっと変わっていていいキャラです。川端は最終的に何がしたいのか、やってることが中途半端なキャラでしたが、えっそこまでやっちゃう？みたいな作品が多い中、その中途半端さが逆にリアルでした。終盤の花言葉にこめた気持ちのところは、有川と同じく御崎ー‼となりました。

Both the picture and the overall atmosphere of the work were beautiful. The story also progressed slowly and was careful, so it was worth reading. Misaki is an indescribably cute and charming person. Arikawa is also a character who can do anything and is dexterous but can change a little bit. Kawabata was a character who was half-hearted about what he wanted to do in the end, but what did he go that far? While there were many works like that, the half-heartedness in the middle was actually real. The feeling contained in the final language of flowers became Misaki ‼, just like Arikawa.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

テンカウントにはまって、作者の他の作品を読んでみたくなり購入しました。心理描写がすごく丁寧で、登場人物の気持ちが痛いほどに伝わってきます。途中すごく切ない場面もあるけれど、最後には心がほんわかしてくる作品です。

I was addicted to the ten count, and I bought it because I wanted to read the author's other works. The psychological depiction is very careful, and the feelings of the characters are painfully conveyed. There are some really sad scenes along the way, but it's a work that warms my heart at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

だんだんひかれてゆく

I'm getting hit more and more

2人がだんたんとひかれていく過程がものすごくきれいでした。好きって気づいてからの表情がたまらないです。

The process of the two getting carried away was so beautiful. The expression on my face after I realised I liked it was irresistible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい感じ

A gentle feeling

優しい感じのストーリーです。宝井さんの作品は、テンカウントを先に読んでますが、主人公(御崎)のキャラがちょっと城谷に似ています。どこか女っぽい。女っぽいのは好きでないので、それは残念ですが、もう一人の主人公・有川が、あまり難しいこと考えない前向きなキャラなのが良かった。好感持てます。展開は、伏線はありますが、そんなにドラマチックではなく、全般的に静かな感じです。くっつくまでが丁寧なのは良かったです。★4と5の間くらいです。1巻178ページ、2巻177ページ、3巻170ページ。

It's a gentle story. In Takarai's work, I read the ten count first, but the character of the main character (Misaki) is a bit similar to Joya. Somehow feminine. I don't like being feminine, so that's a shame, but it was nice that the other main character, Arikawa, was a positive character who didn't think too difficult. I like it. The development is foreshadowed, but it's not that dramatic, and it's generally quiet. It was nice that they were careful until they stuck together. ★ It's about between 4 and 5. Volume 1 has 178 pages, volume 2 has 177 pages, and volume 3 has 170 pages.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

絵が綺麗でストーリー性もあって続きが気になります。作者さんが好きで購入しました。

The pictures are beautiful and there is a story, so I'm curious about the continuation. I bought it because the author liked it.

Helpful

Reviews for Only the Flower Knows Manga