Silent Voice Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

初めての作品

My first work

この作品は初めての京山先生の作品で購入した物でした。この作品を読んでから京山先生の作品を幾つも読ませていただきました。野球部の先輩と後輩の物語で、決して可愛いとは言えない引田の事が大好きな今井先輩が我慢できずに少しずつ引田にちょっかいをかけながら距離が縮まっていく物語です。最初は絵に慣れなかったけど、物語が進んでいくうちに気にならなくなり、どんどんハマっていきました。大きな波があるわけでもないのに何故かすごく惹かれた作品です。そして、不思議なことにどんどん引田が可愛く見えてくるので、やっぱりお話が魅力的だとそういう細かいことが気にならなくなるんだなと気づきました。大好きな作品の１つになりました。

This work was my first Kyoyama sensei's work and I bought it. Since reading this work, I've read a number of Kyoyama sensei's works. It's a story about seniors and juniors in the baseball club, and it's a story where Imai senpai, who loves Hikita, who can't be said to be cute, can't stand it and gradually shortens the distance while putting a little bit of time on Hikita. At first, I wasn't used to painting, but as the story progressed, I didn't care about it, and I became more and more addicted to it. There aren't any big waves, but for some reason I was really attracted to this work. Then, strangely enough, Hikita looked more and more cute, so I realized that if the story was fascinating, I wouldn't care about such details. It has become one of my favorite works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

秀逸なセリフがいっぱい

There are a lot of excellent lines

ドキッとするセリフとシチュエーションがいっぱい。直接的な描写が少なくあっさりした画風にもかかわらず、言葉選びとか絶妙な間のせいで色気の漂う作品。そしてとにかく攻めが魅力的。世渡り上手な器用タイプなのに受けに一途で誠実で積極的な男前。受けが羨ましいと思ってしまうほど。ストレートな物言いもカッコいい。

There are so many exciting lines and situations. Despite the simple style of painting with few direct depictions, this work has sex appeal due to the choice of words and the perfect balance. And anyway, attacking is fascinating. Even though he is a dexterous type who is good at passing through generations, he is a man who is sincere and aggressive. So much so that I feel envious of the reception. Straight talk is cool too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

先輩がかっこいい

Senpai is cool

This review contains spoilers. 後輩を好きで好きでたまらない先輩（攻め）の心情がたくさん描写されていて、もどかし可愛い。押せ押せだけど余裕がありそうに見せようと、格好つけている感じが醸し出されている。

This review contains spoilers. It depicts a lot of the feelings of a senior (attacking) who likes and likes juniors and is irresistible, and it's so sad and cute. It exudes the feeling of being dressed up, trying to make it look like they're being pushed and pushed but there seems to be room.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

じれったくていじらしい、それがいい。

It's creepy and messy, that's good.

This review contains spoilers. 最初はきっと誰もが絵柄やキャラクターに驚き、なかには一話で読むのをやめてしまう人もいるのではないでしょうか。私も初めて読んだ当時、これがなんでずっと一位なんだろう？と不思議に思った一人です。しかしそんな疑問は一話、また一話と読み進めると共に消えていき、一位なのも納得、そのまま最終話まで夢中で一気に読破した事を覚えています。気づいたらハマっている中毒性のあるストーリーと絵柄。受けの引田のことも、攻めの石井さんの気持ちと重なるようにどんどん可愛いなあ、と思えてくるのです。とにかく2人ともキャラが良い。絵はこの物語に合っていて、私は綺麗だなとまで感じます。作者さんの巧みな心理描写や絵の表現力、独特の空気感に気づけば心を鷲掴みにされていることでしょう。自分の拙い言葉ではこの作品の素晴らしさが伝えられないので是非たくさんの人に読んで欲しいです。じれったいほどにゆっくりと距離を縮めていくタイプのBLが好きな方は特にオススメです。BLはあくまでも萌えであって胸キュンとはまた違うと思っていましたが、今までで一番キュンキュンしたBL作品であり、私がBLを本格的に読むようになったきっかけの作品でもあります。未だに何度でも読み返してしまいます。正直最終話まで読んでもこれからの二人ももっとずっと見続けていたいと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. At first, everyone will surely be surprised by the design and characters, and some people will stop reading it after one episode. When I first read it, why was this always number one? This is one person who thought it was strange. However, that question disappeared as I read episode one episode after another, and I was convinced that it was in first place, and I remember reading it all at once with a frenzy until the last episode. Addictive stories and graphics that you'll be hooked on if you notice it. It makes me think more and more that Hikita is cute, as if it overlaps with the attacking feelings of Mr. Ishii. Anyway, they both have good characters. The picture fits this story, and I even feel that it's beautiful. If you notice the artist's skilful psychological depiction, the expressive power of the picture, and the unique atmosphere, you will be taken by the hand. I can't convey the awesomeness of this work in my own humble words, so I definitely want many people to read it. It is especially recommended for those who like the type of BL that slowly shortens the distance. BL was just an old story, and I thought it was different from my heart, but it's the most exciting BL work so far, and it's also the work that led me to read BL in earnest. I still reread it over and over again. To be honest, even after reading the final episode, I wanted the two of them to keep watching for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

なんともいえない空気感

An indescribable feeling of air

絵が独特で、ひょろっとしてて、高校野球部なんですが、泥臭さとか暑苦しさもなければ青春してるってキラキラしてるわけでもない。愛嬌がある顔…というか、そういう顔の後輩を、悶々と見つめる何事も器用にこなせちゃう先輩。偏愛か？と思うほどですが、そういうのでもない。ふたりの関係はとても特殊。距離感も、独特。ふたりとも言葉足らずで、自分でいっぱいいっぱいになってるとこは高校生らしいのかな？？性格は真逆のようで…ちぐはぐに進む心と体の距離？エチとかあるわけでないのですが、笑えたり、微笑ましかったり。言葉にするのはすごく難しいなんとも言えない空気感です。続編読みます。三部作のようです。

The picture is unique, and it's lackluster, and it's a high school baseball club, but if it doesn't smell muddy or heat, it doesn't mean that you're young; it doesn't sparkle. A charming face... or rather, a senior who can do everything dexterously while staring at a junior with agony. is it favoritism? As much as I think, but that's not the case either. The relationship between the two is very special. The sense of distance is also unique. I wonder if they're high school students when they both don't have enough words, and they're full of themselves?? Personalities seem to be the exact opposite... the distance between mind and body progressing indefinitely? It's not like there's any etiquette, but it makes me laugh and smile. It's so difficult to put into words, it's an indescribable atmosphere. I'll read the sequel. It looks like a trilogy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

高校球児の恋愛

High school baseball boy romance

ドキドキハラハラしますよねっ！今井さんが一途にオトコらしく引田くんをグイグイ押してくのが好きです。絵も話と合ってて良かったデス。続きも読みます。

It's going to be exciting and jarring! I like that Imai is constantly pushing Hikita-kun like a man. I'm glad the picture fits the story too. I'll read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

高校球児三部作の馴れ初め編◎

Familiar High School Baseball Trilogy Part 1 ◎

【聞こえない声】【見えない星】【枯れない花】と続くシリーズの1冊目は、連日酷暑の中で熱い激闘で感動をくれる甲子園球児くん達に申し訳なく思う程に、こちらのオフシーズン冬季の球児二人が可愛すぎます(^^)v憧れの存在 2年今井先輩とイカツイ顔のぶさかわ後輩の1年引田くんのお話。怖いと言われる引田くんの事が可愛くて仕方のない今井先輩の「聞こえない声」が冒頭から面白い。憧れの先輩と野球が大好きな引田くんの気持ちと脱がせたい程引田くんを好きな先輩との気持ちのズレを表すエピソードの数々が、飾らずリアル感あってとてもドキドキして甘酸っぱくて良いのです◎努力家の先輩と裏方も楽しむいじらしい後輩引田くんの気持ちが重なっていく展開が◎ぶさかわ引田くんの初々しさと男前は可愛い♪モテモテ先輩は人を見る目がある!!!飾らないモノローグに何度も唸りました(^^)v素晴らしい♪

The first book in the series, which continues with [Inaudible Voices], [Invisible Stars], and “Flowers That Never Wither,” is a story about these two off-season winter baseball players too cute, to the extent that I feel sorry for Koshien Kyuji-kun and the others who are moved by the intense heat every day (^^) v Longing Existence 2 Imai Senpai and Busakawa-kun 1 year Hikita-kun, the good-looking Busakawa Junior. Hikita-kun, who is said to be scary, is cute and the “inaudible voice” of Imai senpai, who can't be helped, is interesting from the beginning. There are a number of episodes that express the gap between the feelings of the admired senior and Hikita-kun, who loves baseball, and the senpai that likes Hikita-kun so much that they want to get rid of it, are unadorned and have a sense of realism, so exciting, and sweet and sour ◎ A development where the feelings of Hikita-kun, an annoying junior who enjoys behind the scenes, overlap ◎ Busakawa Hikita-kun's innocence and handsomeness are cute ♪ Motemote Senpai has an eye for people!! I've groaned over and over at the unadorned monologue (^^) v wonderful ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

この漫画に出会えて良かったと思うぐらい好きなシリーズです。何度も読み返しています。京山あつき先生特有のテンポや描き方が好きで、思春期の少年たちの恋心や葛藤などを上手く表しています。この漫画はシリーズの一巻目なので、是非二巻、三巻も読者にお勧めしたいです。

I love this series so much that I'm glad I came across this comic. I've reread it over and over again. I like Kyoyama Atsuki sensei's unique tempo and drawing style, and it shows the love feelings and conflicts of adolescent boys well. This comic is the first volume in the series, so I would definitely recommend volume 2 and 3 to readers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 29, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

すっごく良かった！

That was sooo good!

冒頭の心の声で一気に引き込まれました。印象的に残るシーンがいくつもあって、心理描写を絵にするのが凄く上手な作者さん。一見萌えと無縁そうな引田くんをどんどん可愛く見せてくれます。

I was drawn in all at once by the voice of my heart at the beginning. There are a number of memorable scenes, and the artist is extremely good at drawing psychological depictions. Hikita-kun, who seems to have nothing to do with Moe at first glance, makes me look more and more cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

わぁぁ

wow

予想外に良かった〜！すぐくっついてやっちゃうBLが多い中、本作みたいにもどかしいくらいゆっくり受けの気持ちが変化していくのってすごーくリアリティある。京山先生は心理描写が絶妙だな。見た目はファニーフェイスな引田が読んでいくうちにどんどん可愛く見えてくる不思議（笑）だって可愛いよ引田、性格すっげーかわいい。先輩見る目あるわ〜。シリーズの他の２作も読みたくなった。

It was unexpectedly good! While there are a lot of BLs that stick together quickly, it's so realistic that the feeling of acceptance changes so slowly that it's frustrating like this one. Kyoyama sensei's psychological depiction is exquisite. It's strange that Hikita, who has a funny face, looks more and more cute as she reads it (laughs), but it's cute, Hikita has such a cute personality. Senpai has an eye for sight. It made me want to read the other 2 books in the series.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

題名違うから二巻から読んだ

The title is different, so I read it from volume 2

シリーズの1巻。今井さんの欲望が、衝動的に。でも、まんざらじゃ無いのを感じ取って、何だかんだ両思い。引田くんも、すごく考えて答えを出す。なんか続きをどんどんみたくなるカップルです。

Volume 1 of the series. Imai's desires are impulsive. But I sensed that it wasn't crazy, and somehow they both felt. Hikita-kun also thinks a lot and comes up with answers. It's a couple that makes me want to watch something continue.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマる

Addicted

最初まじ何この絵後輩ナイでしょ！って思ったのに不思議…最後はハマってしまった…先輩カッコいいです！描写が最高ですね！三部作なのかぁー読みたいな…悩み中です。

At first, seriously, this picture is a junior, isn't it! I thought it was strange... I was addicted to it at the end... Senpai is so cool! The depiction is awesome! I wonder if it's a trilogy, I want to read it... I'm worried.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

なんかかわいい

Something cute

ヘブンリーホームシックを読んでファンになりました。この作品も心にきます。王子様のような絵ではないけど私は好きです。

I read Heavenly Homesick and became a fan. This work also comes to mind. It's not a picture like a prince, but I like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

皆さんのレビューを参考にしてよかった

I'm glad I referred to everyone's reviews

最初、絵に引いたけどホントいい話だった。物語に引き込まれてしまえば絵も表情表現が豊かですごく好ましかったです。

At first, I was drawn to the picture, but it was a really nice story. Once I was drawn into the story, the pictures were very expressive and I really liked them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

出会えてよかった

I'm glad we met

出会えてよかった一作。BLだからとかBLなのにとかこだわらず読めました。作品自体に力があるんだなあと思いました。震えるような空気をパッケージしたような漫画でした。

It's a work I'm glad I came across. I was able to read it regardless of whether it was BL or BL. I thought the work itself had power. It was a comic that looked like it was packaged in shivering air.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ついつい読んでしまうから

Because I just end up reading it

カッコいい先輩と地味で真面目な後輩の野球部青春モヤモヤキュンキュンのお話

A story about a cool senior and a sober and serious junior baseball club Seishun Moya Moya Kyun Kyun Kyun

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

高校野球シリーズの1話目

Episode 1 of the High School Baseball Series

大好きな高校野球の部活が舞台。そりゃ萌えない訳がない。スター選手の今井が好きになったのが、冴えない小柄な真面目後輩引田。今井だけが引田をかわいくて色っぽいと見ていて引田は戸惑うばかり。部活の先輩に迫られて悩みまくる引田の心情が丁寧に描かれてます。ストーリーはめちゃ引き込まれるのに、引田があまりにブサイク地味キャラなので、今井の気持ちが今ひとつ理解できない感じ。だからかえってイイのかも？

The stage is my favorite high school baseball club activity. Well, there's no reason not to be angry. The star player Imai fell in love with Hikita, a serious junior who was dull and petite. Only Imai sees Hiketa as cute and sexy, and Hiketa is just puzzled. The feelings of Hikita, who is troubled by being pressured by his senior in club activities, are carefully depicted. The story draws me in so much, but Hikita is such an ugly, plain character that I can't understand Imai's feelings right now. So maybe it's better?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

シリーズ、まとめて買い。

Buy the series in bulk.

この作品で、この作者さん、集めちゃいました。たしかに最初は、この絵柄でＢＬ？絵本じゃなくて？ＢＬ？？と驚きましたけど…この青春模様が、絵柄とハマって、感動しました。今井君が紳士で素敵。

I collected this artist with this work. Certainly the first one was BL with this pattern? not a picture book? BL?? I was surprised, but... I was moved by the pattern and addiction to this pattern of youth. Imai is a nice gentleman.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 10, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

青春！

youth!

男前ではないまっすぐな男の子と、いわゆる男前な先輩の、自分の気持ちと相手の気持ちを大切にゆっくり紡いだお話しでした。ドラマチックな展開などはないですが、おなじシチュエーションで積み重ねる日々に少しずつ動く気持ちを見ていくことが出来て安定して見続けられました。温かみのある絵柄がこのストーリーにマッチしていて良かったです。キスはありますがエッチなシーンはありません。なのでそれを望む方にはお勧めしません。。。

It was a story about a straight boy who wasn't handsome and a so-called handsome senior, carefully spun their own feelings and the other person's feelings. There are no dramatic developments, etc., but I was able to watch the feeling of moving little by little over the days that accumulate in the same situations, and I was able to keep watching steadily. I'm glad that the warm design matched this story. There are kisses, but there are no naughty scenes. So I don't recommend it to those who want it...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きな作品です

It's my favorite work

素敵な青春作品です。この作品で京山あつき先生のファンになりました♪絵が最初苦手で、同一人物でも顔が所々違って見えてしまい気になりましたが、進むにつれその違和感も気にならなくなり、それよりもストーリーにぐいぐい引きこまれ、最終的には絵の雰囲気も大好きになりました！是非読んでほしい作品です☆

It's a wonderful youth work. I became a fan of Kyoyama Atsuki sensei with this work ♪ I wasn't good at painting at first, and I was worried that even the same person's face looked different in places, but as I progressed, I didn't care about that sense of incongruity, and more than that, I was drawn a lot more into the story, and eventually I fell in love with the atmosphere of the picture! This is a work I definitely want you to read ☆

Helpful

Reviews for Silent Voice Manga