Wistoria: Wand and Sword Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい‼︎

It's interesting ‼ ︎

すごく丁寧に書かれてて、似たり寄ったりと評価してる人もいましたが、全然そんなことなくて、似た感じだと読み流しちゃうことも多いですが、すごくじっくり読めて読み応えのある漫画です。これからどうなるのかワクワクです。

It was written very carefully, and there were people who rated it as being similar or close, but that's not the case at all, and if it feels similar, I often read it over, but it's a comic that I read very carefully and is worth reading. I'm excited to see what's going to happen next.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！！

interesting!!

魔法が使えない少年が、魔法が絶対の世界で、幼なじみとの約束のために、至高の五杖を目指す。魔法は使えないが、剣で戦うところがいいです。どんなに周りに、馬鹿にされようとも、夢のために頑張る姿勢がいいです。早く続きが読みたい。

A boy who can't use magic aims for the supreme five wands for a promise with his childhood friend in a world where magic is absolute. I can't use magic, but I like fighting with swords. No matter how much people around you make a fool of you, you have a good attitude of working hard for your dreams. I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

とても面白いです！！

It's very interesting!!

ダンジョンに出会いシリーズの大ファンで購入してみました。とても面白い！！とても優しくて誠実で純粋な少年が色々な出来事を経験しながらどんどん成長して強くなっていく姿とストーリーに胸が熱くなります。主人公像は、ダンジョンに出会いと通じるものがあります。これからのストーリー展開がとても楽しみです。

I bought it as a big fan of the Dungeon Encounter series. very interesting!! My heart is heated by the sight and story of a very kind, sincere, and pure boy growing steadily and becoming stronger while experiencing various events. The main character image has something to do with an encounter in a dungeon. I'm really looking forward to the future storyline.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃ面白い！

It's so funny!

めっちゃ面白い！変に巨乳やエロ入ってこないので、ストーリーが邪魔されない。早く三巻出ないかなぁ。12月が待ち遠しい。

It's so funny! Strangely enough, there are no big breasts or eroticism, so the story doesn't get in the way. I wonder if volume 3 will come out soon. I can't wait for December.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良い作品

good work

ストーリー構成と画力はかなりいいです。萌え系、ハーレム系系統じゃないのは好印象です、バトルも見応えはあるので次回にも期待したいです。

The story structure and drawing power are pretty good. It's a good impression that they aren't from the Moe or Harem lineage, and the battles are impressive, so I'd like to look forward to the next one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

さすがの一言

As expected, one word

流石としかいいようがありません絵は私は正直好きなタッチではありませんが星を減らすほど酷くもないです

As a matter of fact, the picture is honestly not my favorite touch, but it's not bad enough to reduce the number of stars

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗で読みやすい

The pictures are beautiful and easy to read

This review contains spoilers. 設定としては在り来りかもだけど、無能の主人公と才気に恵まれた幼馴染。主人公は落ちこぼれと言われつつも、幼馴染と一緒に居られるよう努力と経験を積み上げる姿勢がいい！幼馴染も主人公のことをずっと待ってるってのが最高じゃないか！このままNTRや裏切りなし、純愛突っ走ってほしいね！

This review contains spoilers. It may be true as a setting, but the protagonist is incompetent and a childhood friend blessed with talent. Even though the main character is said to be an outcast, he has a good attitude of building up effort and experience so that he can stay with his childhood friend! Wouldn't it be great that my childhood friend is also waiting for the main character all this time! I hope they continue to run for pure love without NTR or betrayal!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

最高！

the best!

読めば読むほどその世界観にのめり込んでいきます。ワクワクが止まりません。シンプルでいて深淵な世界に魅了されること間違いなし！

The more I read, the more I fell in love with that view of the world. I can't stop being excited. There is no doubt that you will be fascinated by the simple yet profound world!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれい！

The picture is beautiful!

もちろんバトルが好きな方は好きかもしれませんが少し内容が単純過ぎるかなと思ってしまいました。絵は超好みです。

Of course, those who like battles might like it, but I thought the content was a bit too simple. I really like the picture.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

魔法至上主義

Magical supremacy

魔法の世界で剣で戦うけど強い！落ちこぼれだが努力で実力者に挑む王道バトルとしてとても面白い。バトルシーンのテンポ感とは迫力にとにかくすごくてのめり込みます。

They fight with swords in a magical world, but they're strong! It's very interesting as a classic battle where you challenge powerful players with effort even though they've been left behind. The sense of tempo in the battle scene is so impressive that it's so impressive that I'm really immersed in it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

応援したくなる

I want to cheer

This review contains spoilers. 魔力が使えないというハンデがあっても自分は出来ると信じて、色んな困難に立ち向かう姿はとても応援したくなる作品です！

This review contains spoilers. It's a work I really want to cheer for, believing that I can do it even if I have a handicap where I can't use magic, and confronting various difficulties!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 29, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

すごいの一言！

That's an amazing word!

This review contains spoilers. 「魔法　vs　剣」の圧倒的迫力:　魔法使いばか　りの世界で、ウィルが超絶的な剣技と身体　能力で魔法をねじ伏せる戦闘シーンがとにかく熱いです。

This review contains spoilers. The overwhelming power of “Magic vs. Sword”: In a world full of wizards, the battle scenes where Will knocks down magic with his transcendental sword skills and physical abilities are just so exciting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

約束

undertakings

幼馴染との約束を果たすために懸命に努力姿がいい。主人公の剣を使ったアクションもカッコよくて申し分ない。

It's nice that they work hard to fulfill their promise to their childhood friend. The action using the main character's sword is also cool and perfect.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

これぞ王道ファンタジー！

This is a classic fantasy!

魔法第一主義の世界で、魔法が使えないウィル君が自らの経験や努力で諦めずに戦い、塔を目指す王道ファンタジー物語。ウィル君が段々と成長して強くなっていく姿に胸が熱くなりました。他のキャラクター達にも葛藤があり、困難があり、どのキャラクターも好きになってしまう作品。今後もとても楽しみです

A classic fantasy story where Will, who can't use magic, fights without giving up with his own experiences and efforts, and aims for the tower in a world where magic comes first. My heart was heated by the sight of Will gradually growing and getting stronger. It's a work where the other characters also have conflicts and difficulties, and every character falls in love with it. I'm really looking forward to the future

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

頭の触覚

The sense of touch in the head

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーは少年漫画の王道中の王道を行くので、同じ系統のファンタジー作品をいくつか読んできている人には先が読めて楽しくないかもしれません。魔法が絶対の世界で、魔法が使えない主人公が剣術で努力し周りに認められていくという、序盤のスタートからして既視感アリアリです。主人公だけ生えている頭の巨大な触覚が気になります…。

This review contains spoilers. The story takes you along the royal road of shonen manga, so it may not be fun for people who have read several fantasy works of the same lineage to read ahead. It's a world where magic is absolute, and the protagonist who can't use magic makes an effort with swordplay and is recognized by others, so it's a sense of deja vu from the beginning. I'm worried about the huge sense of touch on the main character's head...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗な描写と残虐な顔の対比だわ

It's a contrast between a pretty depiction and a cruel face

This review contains spoilers. 線は細い。どうもリアル感が薄いけど、歪んた顔の描写でちゃんと人間らしさも現わしているなと思いました。これは王道物語ですね。　謎の未知の力をもっている主人公は血の滲むような努力をして高みを目指している。ありがちな悪役もいるけど、それさえも糧にするような謀略もあった。淡々とした感じで☆一つ減点しました。いまいち情熱が無い気がしたのです。

This review contains spoilers. The line is thin. It really doesn't have a sense of realism, but I thought the depiction of a distorted face really showed humanity. This is a royal tale, isn't it? The protagonist, who has mysterious unknown powers, aims for heights by making bloody efforts. There are villains that tend to be common, but there were also plots that used even that as food. I felt indifferent and ☆ 1 point was deducted. I felt like I didn't have much passion.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

魔法のバトル漫画！友情が熱い！！

Magical battle comics! The friendship is hot!!

幼なじみに追い付く為に高みを目指す主人公。魔法バトル漫画で杖が最強の世界で魔法が使えない彼は剣で挑む！！派閥があったり結構厳しめの世界なのでより戦友、友達が引き立つけど、えっここで死んじゃう？みたいな事がある。ストーリーも展開も面白いです。絵は綺麗ですが多少読みづらさがあるかな。続きが楽しみです！！

The main character aims for heights in order to catch up with his childhood friends. In a world with the strongest wand in magic battle comics, he who can't use magic takes on the challenge with a sword!! It's a pretty tough world with factions, so comrades in arms and friends stand out even more, but huh, they die here? There is something like that. The story and development are interesting. The picture is beautiful, but it's probably a bit difficult to read. I'm looking forward to the continuation!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

とりあえず1巻だけ読了

For now, I've only read volume 1

This review contains spoilers. ・魔法が使えないのに魔法使いの学校にいるのおかしいってレビューをいくつか見ました。自分もそう思いますが、おそらく筆記試験の結果が並外れて良かったのでしょう。で、校長先生あたりが特例を出した、とか。そもそも魔法が使えないのわかってるんだから、入学させてからガタガタネチネチ言うなって話ですよね。・黒服の先生がやたら主人公に攻撃的なのは、自分はすごい魔法使いで、上に届くギリギリまで行けたのに、魔法が使えない奴が上を目指してるのが我慢ならなかったんですね。納得だけど器の小さい男だ。・魔法使いの最上位の五人が空の結界を保っている、みたいな話だったけど、なぜか空席が一つ。しかも現在危機的状況らしい。主人公が辿り着くまで無事であればいいのですが、まず無理でしょうね。

This review contains spoilers. ・I've seen some reviews saying it's strange to be in a wizard school even though you can't use magic. I think so too, but I'm probably glad that the written exam results were exceptional. So, the principal issued a special case, or something. I know you can't use magic in the first place, so don't talk about rattling after enrolling. ・The reason the teacher in black clothes is so aggressive about the main character is that I'm an amazing wizard, and even though I was able to get to the top, I couldn't put up with the guy who couldn't use magic aiming for the top. I'm convinced, but he's a man with small arms. ・It was like the top five wizards are holding the Barrier in the Sky, but for some reason there is only one vacant seat. Moreover, it seems that the current state of crisis is in jeopardy. It would be nice if the main character was safe until they arrived, but that's probably impossible at first.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

魔力

magic

This review contains spoilers. 魔法至上主義の世界で魔力を持たない少年が、剣一本で這い上がるというおはなしとなっております。とてもかっこよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about a boy with no magical powers in a world of supremacy of magic who crawls up with a single sword. It was so cool.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

頑張るウィルを応援したい

I want to support Will who works hard

This review contains spoilers. 周囲からいくら「魔法が使えない者」「筆記のみの優等生」としてみなされている身であろうと、心の底では諦めきれていない主人公はむしろ応援したくなります。性格は優しそうでコツコツ努力もしているウィルだからこそ、エルファリアに味方されるのもわかる気がしますね。大勢の人々の思いこみが常に正しいとは限らない場合もありますし、自分を一番証明できるのは自分自身でもあるので、場所が祭典であろうとダンジョンであろうとたじろぐことなく突き進み、自分だけが持っている力を解放してほしいと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. No matter how much he is regarded by those around him as a “person who can't use magic” or an “honor student who only writes,” I would rather cheer for the protagonist who hasn't given up at the bottom of his heart. Because Will seems to have a kind personality and works hard, I feel like I understand that Elfaria is on his side. There are times when the thoughts of many people aren't always right, and the person who can prove themselves the most is myself, so whether the location is a festival or a dungeon, I wanted them to push forward without flinching and release the power that only they have.

Helpful

Reviews for Wistoria: Wand and Sword Manga