The Shadows of Who We Once Were Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

教師とは

What is a teacher

教師の在り方を考えさせられた話だった。激務、責任などなど、なりたいと思う人が減るのは当然。

It was a story that made me think about the way teachers should be. It is natural that the number of people who want to be due to hard work, responsibilities, etc., will decrease.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まさかの

No way

This review contains spoilers. どんどん殺し殺される同窓会。まだ最新刊買ってないのですがホントに黒幕が誰なのか全くわからない。どんでん返し期待。

This review contains spoilers. A class reunion where people are getting killed more and more. I haven't bought the latest edition yet, but I really don't know who is behind it at all. Expect the plot to return.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

人間の怖さ

Fear of humans

同窓会のために集まった元クラスメイトたち。閉鎖空間の中で疑心暗鬼に陥ったメンバーはどんどん悪い方向へ向かっていく。極限状態の人間の暗い部分、醜い部分が浮き彫りになっていく展開にハラハラドキドキします！誰が誰を陥れ、傷つけたのか目まぐるしく変わる展開に目が離せません。

Former classmates gathered for a class reunion. The members, who have fallen into doubt in an enclosed space, take a worse and worse direction. I'm thrilled by the development where the dark and ugly parts of humans in extreme conditions come to light! Keep an eye out for the rapidly changing developments as to who fell and hurt who.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

おお……

oh...

なんか表紙では想像できない内容でした笑とてもハラハラし面白いです

Something I couldn't imagine on the cover lol it's so harassing and interesting

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで

until the end

犯人がだれなのかが、分からずにとても面白かったです。途中のやりとりも登場人物の心理をうまく描いていて興味深かったです。

It was so funny because I didn't know who the culprit was. The conversation along the way was also interesting because it nicely depicted the psychology of the characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ホラー

horror

ドラマから来ましたドラマが衝撃的だったので原作も気になりましたドラマより緊張感があり怖いです壊れてる怖さ

I came from the drama The drama was shocking, so I was curious about the original story too. There's a sense of tension than the drama, it's scary, it's scary, it's broken

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

けど、入り込むタイプの人には、きついです。映像だったら共感出来ない時点で客観視に変わるけど、目でセリフと紙を追っていくと、ヘビーな部分が逃せないから途中しんどかった。

But it's tough for the type of person who gets in. If it were a video, it changed to objective vision when I couldn't sympathize, but when I followed the lines and paper with my eyes, I couldn't miss the heavy parts, so it was tough along the way.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもい

I think

3巻を試し読みしてたら間違って購入をほちってしたい、仕方ないから3巻だけ読んでたけど、ついつい1巻をポチッてしまい、結局、全巻制覇してしまった。よく練られたストーリーだけど、読みながら苦しくなってしまった。クラスメイトを殺さず解決できなかったのかなとか。でも自分のしてしまった過去は変えられないし、正面から向き合わないと、事は解決しない。極限状態に置かれたら何が正しいのか混乱するし、気持ちを強く持つことも難しい。自分にとっては気にも留めないことが他者を傷つけてしまう怖さとか、だから何もしない臆病とか、克服する勇気、いろいろごちゃ混ぜに考えさせられました。しばらく休憩してから再読しようと思う。疲れた。それにしても水島はかっこいいな。惚れそう。

When I tried reading volume 3, I wanted to omit the purchase by mistake; I had no choice but to read only 3 volumes, but I just hit volume 1, and in the end, I conquered the entire volume. It's a well-crafted story, but it became painful as I read it. I wonder if I couldn't solve it without killing my classmates. But I can't change my past, and if I don't face it head-on, things won't be solved. When placed in an extreme state, it is confusing as to what is right, and it is difficult to have strong feelings. For me, it made me think in a jumble of things, such as the fear of hurting others if I don't care about it, the cowardice of not doing anything, and the courage to overcome it. I think I'll take a break and read it again. I'm tired. Even so, Mizushima is cool. I'm going to fall in love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

サスペンス

suspense

人間の裏側を見たりとか、ミステリー、サスペンス系が好きな方には楽しめる作品だと思います！！ダークもグロさもアリ。

I think this work can be enjoyed by those who like mystery and suspense, such as looking at the other side of humans!! It's dark and glossy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドイツ語で読んだ、オリジナル欲しかった

I read it in German, I wanted the original

This review contains spoilers. 初めてのレビューです！それと、日本人じゃないんだから日本語は少し変かもしれない。ごめん！?この漫画最初にドイツで読んでた（ドイツ人です）。みきお君がすぐに一番好きなキャラになった。友達の信頼を試験するって「うわっ、そんな理由で？！」っと思った。一番好きなシーンは「天使」がグループの一番不要な人を選んで、しょーやんが選ばれた。だからたくさん傷をついたね。みきお君の言葉巧みでしょーやんが絶望しかいない見るな目で床に頭を打ちつけた。ショックしたけど目がページから離れなかった。みきおの甘い言葉と優しいな声と笑顔、本当に怖かった。でもなんか、、可愛かった？頭が変になってかも。?__?とにかく、この漫画大好き。これみたいないいサイコロジカルホラーが少ないんだね（また、変な日本語でホントにごめん。この漫画で読み方を練習しますw）

This review contains spoilers. This is my first review! Also, since I'm not Japanese, Japanese might be a little strange. sorry!? I first read this comic in Germany (I'm German). Mikio soon became my favorite character. Testing a friend's trust is “Wow, that's why?!” I thought so. My favorite scene was “Angel” choosing the most unnecessary person in the group, and Shoyan was selected. That's why it hurt a lot. Mikio's words are clever, aren't they, but he hit his head on the floor with nothing but despair. I was shocked, but I couldn't take my eyes off the page. Mikio's sweet words, kind voice, and smile were really scary. But something... was that cute? Maybe my head is weird.? __? Anyway, I love this comic. There aren't many good psychological horrors like this (also, I'm really sorry for the weird Japanese. I'm going to practice reading with this comic lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

試し読みして

Try reading

スッカリ嵌まった作品です。実験なんて云う内容からツッコミ所はあるけれど若者たち特有の心理や精神作用に「あぁー分からないでもないなぁ」とサスペンス含めてのドキドキ感が良かったです。

It's a work that fits perfectly. There is a sense of excitement about the psychology and mental effects peculiar to young people, including suspense, saying “Oh, I don't know,” even though there are places where things go wrong with the content called experiments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

読み進めてしまった

I've read on

This review contains spoilers. いやー。なんて言えばいいか。なんかスゴイ！人間不信になるわ。最後まで犯人わからんしモヤモヤするしで世界観に引っ張られるしで最後まで飽きずに読める！成長するものもいれば落ちてくものもいる。水野はやっぱり陽キャのイケメン。溝口がちょっと陽になって成長してったのが素敵だった！

This review contains spoilers. well. What should I say. Something amazing! It makes me distrustful of people. I don't know the culprit until the end, I'm confused, and I'm drawn to the worldview, so I can read it until the end without getting tired of it! Some grow and others fall. After all, Mizuno is a good-looking guy from Yo-Kya. It was wonderful that Mizoguchi had turned into a little bit of sunshine and grew up!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

考えさせられた。

It made me think.

子供の頃の記憶は良くも悪くも残り、成長してからもその人の価値観を形成するようになると実感させられました。誰が嘘をついているのか、何を抱えているのか、誰が善人で誰が悪人なのか、一概には言えない所に人間性がよく現れていると思います。絵も綺麗ですし、結末もハッピーエンドとは言えませんが、後味は良かったです。全巻買って良かったと思える作品でした。

It made me realize that my childhood memories remain, both good and bad, and that they will form that person's values even after they grow up. I think humanity is often evident in places where it is impossible to say unequivocally who is lying, what is harboring, and who is a good person and who is a bad person. The picture is beautiful, and the ending isn't a happy ending, but the aftertaste was good. It was a work that made me think I'm glad I bought the whole volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

人間不信になる

Become distrustful of humans

いや、これホントに読むと人間不信になりかねないくらい…人間の汚いところが繊細にリアルに描かれてます。恨みを憎しみを植え付けた人間ほど恐ろしく狂って美しいものはないです。

No, if you really read this, you could be distrustful of humans... the filthy parts of humans are depicted delicately and realistically. There is nothing so frighteningly crazy and beautiful as a person who instills resentment with hate.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

のめり込んだ

Immersed in

病的にハマる感じもし自分だったらどうだったろぅとか学生時代あったあった話の事があってなんだか怖かった

I was kind of scared because there was a story that happened when I was a student, like I was morbidly addicted to it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

先がわからない

I don't know where to go

どういう展開になるのか、まったくわからなかった。最後も納得できる終わり方だったから満足。人間の闇も希望も描かれてた。

I had no idea how it was going to unfold. I was satisfied because it was a convincing way of ending at the end. It depicts human darkness and hope.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ミステリー

mystery

推理物としてみるには動機がいまいちで後出しみたいなところもあるので解き明かそうとはせず謎に思うまま読み進めるのがいいかも。『骨が腐るまで』でみられた世界観は少し陰りを感じるも、生徒それぞれの個性を大切にされていてやはり引き摺り込まれ最後まで更新を楽しみにして見られた作品でした。

If you look at it as a mystery, the motive is bad, and there are places where it seems like a latecomer, so it might be a good idea to read on while thinking about the mystery without trying to unravel it. Even though the worldview seen in “Till the Bones Rotten” felt slightly overshadowed, the individuality of each student was valued, and it was a work that still dragged me in and looked forward to the update until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

考えさせられるストーリー

A story that makes you think

何が正しくて何が悪いことなのか、ストーリーが進むほどわからなくなっていきます。沢山のところに伏線が落ちているので、2週目は新しい視点からみることができ、別の楽しさを味わえます。人間らしさが溢れ出る、素晴らしい作品です。

As the story progresses, you don't understand what's right and what's wrong. There are lots of foreshadowing, so you can look at week 2 from a new perspective and enjoy a different kind of fun. It's a wonderful work that overflows with humanity.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読み進めてしまう

I'm going to read on

This review contains spoilers. よくあるパニック状態になった人達があーだこーだいう場面が多くてそれが苦手だけど、でも読んでしまう面白さがある

This review contains spoilers. There are a lot of common situations where people are in a state of panic and I'm not good at it, but it's fun to read

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキ

pounding

前の作品（骨が腐るまで）から知っていて、これも面白いはず！大正解でした！！骨が腐るまでが好きな方、是非これも読んでほしい！！一度を読んだら、手が離せない。

I've known it since my previous work (Until My Bones Rot), and this should be interesting too! That was a great answer!! If you like Till Your Bones Rot, I definitely want you to read this too! Once you read it, you can't keep your hands off it.

Helpful

Reviews for The Shadows of Who We Once Were Manga