Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga Reviews (P.9)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

わお！

wow!

This review contains spoilers. こんな終わり方だと思わなかったー！！！でもこういうダークなのは大好物です！！笑

This review contains spoilers. I never thought it would end like this!!! But dark things like this are my favorite food!! lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

絵の感じとサスペンス要素があってて良かった。話も他にありそうな設定ですが、独特な雰囲気もあるためか面白さと切なさとが良くて先が気になります。

It was nice that it had the feel and suspense elements of a picture. The story is also likely to have other settings, but the fun and sadness are good, probably because it also has a unique atmosphere, so I'm worried about the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

こわいけど面白い

Scary but funny

スリル満点で怖いところもありますが、その分ホッとするあたたかいところがありました。ゾッとしたりドキドキしたり、面白かったです！

There were places that were thrilling and scary, but there were also warm places that made me feel relieved. It was creepy, exciting, and funny!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

えー！！

Eh!!

This review contains spoilers. せつないお話でした。理世がどんどん弱くなっていって心配になりました。あんなに幸せだったのに真実は辛すぎます。お兄ちゃん以外の心の支えを見つけてしまったらふたりの関係はどうなってしまうんだろう。

This review contains spoilers. That was a sad story. I was worried that Riyo was getting weaker and weaker. Even though I was so happy, the truth is too painful. What would happen to the relationship between the two if they found emotional support other than their older brother.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

マサキ…

masaki...

This review contains spoilers. 展開も結末も素晴らしかった。ただずっとマサキに感情移入しながら読み進めていたせいで、最終的な結末が本当に後味が悪かった。マサキの素行と絶命直前の行為が、海利のように情状酌量の余地がありそうな事情によるものだと思っていたけれど実際はそうではなかったのが結構精神的にショックだった…泣実兄と実妹の再会が叶わなかったのが本当に残念でならないです。まだ立ち直れない…メイン2人は本当に幸せになって欲しいなと思う結末でした！

This review contains spoilers. The development and ending were fantastic. However, since I had been reading it while empathizing with Masaki all the time, the final ending had a really bad aftertaste. I thought Masaki's behavior and actions just before his death were due to circumstances where there seemed to be room for extenuating circumstances like Kairi, but it was quite a mental shock that actually wasn't the case... I'm really sorry that the reunion between the crying brother and real sister didn't come true. I still can't get back on my feet... it was an ending where I really wanted the main two to be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないですね

It's sad

海利やお兄ちゃんの絵が素敵で読み始めたのですが。切ない展開になってきました。どうか理世と海利が幸せになってくれます様にと願うばかりです。

The pictures of Kairi and her older brother were so wonderful that I started reading them. It's been a sad development. I can only hope that Riyo and Kairi will be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気が漂う〜

The atmosphere is in the air

悲しみやトラウマはその人の雰囲気をつくるし醸し出すそこに引き寄せられるのも、自分に近い波長だったり、ほっとけなさだったり何かしらの引力ってあるものだろうかそれがいいとは言えないにしろわかるっていうこと、わかってしまうってことそれは、とてつもなく、切ないのだけど落ち着くってこと

Sadness and trauma create and create that person's atmosphere What you are drawn to is that you can understand whether it's a wavelength close to your own, or if you don't feel alone, or have some kind of gravitational pull even if you can't say it's good, and you understand it, it's extremely sad, but it calms you down

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

愛しさと切なさと謎

Love, sadness, and mystery

“お兄ちゃん”とタイトルにつくとついエッチ系なのかととりあえず思ってしまう自分が恥ずかしい…そっち系の話ではありません。大好きなお兄ちゃんと離ればなれになり探している主人公の女の子と暗いヒミツを抱え目立たないように暮らしている男の子。ふたりが愛しくて切ないです。まだ1巻しか読んでないので謎がどうなるのか気になります。

When I get the title “older brother,” I'm embarrassed to think that it's just naughty... I'm not talking about that kind of thing. The girl who is the main character who is separated from her favorite older brother and is looking for a boy who has dark secrets and lives inconspicuously. It's sad that they both love each other. I've only read volume 1 yet, so I'm wondering what the mystery will be like.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった、お勧め❗️

It was interesting, I recommend it ❗️

This review contains spoilers. 何故か「白夜行」を思い出しながら読んでました。あれよりは幸せになれたのでよかったのですが、やはり全体に薄幸感溢れるというか。物語はオリジナルで面白く、ミステリとしても恋愛としても読み応えあります！そういう意味で、いろんな人に面白かったよ、と勧めたい作品。正しい家族の形、というのは本当はないのかもしれません。「家族の正しさ」という世界中を席巻している幻想が、DVやneglectを生み、家族は神聖であるがゆえに民事不介入として他人は手を出せない現実がある。でも多くのケースで、この標準的な価値観で生きていけてしまうから、マイノリティになった時の困難は計り知れません。正しさ＝立花巡査がずっと求めてきた警察の価値観、幸せ＝理世や海里が拠り所とした価値観。どちらが絶対正しいとも言えず、考えてしまいます。それでも、2人が怯えずに暮らせるようになって良かった、と心から思います。ただなあ、子供欲しくなったらどうするんだろう？そこまでは望めない、と思ってるなら、それはそれで不憫な。。絵は、時々怖かったですが(笑)、この物語にはあっていたと思います。世間的な基準とは少し違ってもいいから、理世と海里に幸せなままに暮らしてほしいです。

This review contains spoilers. For some reason, I was reading it while remembering “Byakuyagyo.” I'm glad I was able to be happier than that, but after all, the whole thing is full of unhappiness. The story is original and interesting, and it's worth reading both as a mystery and as a romance! In that sense, I would like to recommend this work to many people, as it was interesting. There may not really be a proper form of family. The illusion of “the correctness of the family” that is sweeping the world has given birth to DV and violence, and since the family is sacred, there is a reality where others cannot get their hands on it due to non-intervention in civil matters. However, in many cases, people are able to live with these standard values, so the difficulties when they become a minority are immeasurable. Correctness = police values that Officer Tachibana has always sought, and happiness = values based on Riyo and Kairi. I can't say which one is absolutely correct, and it makes me think. Even so, I sincerely think it was great that the two of them were able to live without fear. It's just, what do you do when you want kids? If you think you can't hope that far, then that's a pity... The picture was scary at times (laughs), but I think it fits this story. I want Riyo and Kairi to live a happy life because it may be slightly different from popular standards.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

不安な展開

An uneasy development

This review contains spoilers. 海利くんがお兄ちゃんになるというのはなんか良いのか悪いんか難しいけどふたりだけの家族という形でささやかな幸せを作っていけるようになったのはとりあえずハッピーエンドかなふたりが幸せになれるか心配でした立花さんも幸せになってね…

This review contains spoilers. It's kind of good or bad for Kairi to become an older brother, but being able to create a modest happiness in the form of a family of just the two of them was a happy ending for the time being, and I was worried about whether the two would be happy for the time being, and Tachibana became happy too...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

昼ドラみたい。

It's like a daytime drama.

This review contains spoilers. 殺人犯。そして、被害者の妹。暴力、ネグレクト、貧困、イケメン、メンヘラ。展開が気になりすぎてまとめて買いました。正義ってなんでしょうね。カイリとリゼ二人の20年後もみたい。っておもいました。

This review contains spoilers. murderer. And the victim's sister. Violence, neglect, poverty, good-looking guys, menhera. I was so worried about developments that I bought them all at once. I wonder what justice is. It looks like it will be 20 years from now, Kairi and Rize. I thought so.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

平和

peaceful

絵がときどき苦手だったのですが、とても内容がよかった。恋人でもあり、同士であり、仲間である関係って、私にもあって、婚姻関係を結んだだけでは家族ではないと感じているので、とてもよかった。

Sometimes I wasn't good at painting, but the content was really good. The relationship of being lovers, between each other, and friends also happened to me, and I feel that just entering into a marriage relationship is not a family, so it was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん買いです。

The author is buying it.

This review contains spoilers. 最後に二人で決めた終わり方が良かったです。彼氏ではなく、家族として寄り添って生きていく生き方を選んだのも、それならずっとずっとほんとにずーっと寄り添えて生きていけるからだって二人の熱い思いを感じました。だけど、彼氏と彼女としての恋愛の部分も残しておきたいから指輪を、ってことですよね、ほんと納得できる終わり方だと思いました。モリエ先生の作品の中で一番好きだと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. The way the two of us decided at the end was good. I felt the passion of the two of them that they chose to live a way of life where they snuggled up and lived together as a family, not as a boyfriend, because then they could really, really snuggle up all the time. However, I wanted to keep the part of my love affair with my boyfriend and girlfriend, so I thought it was a really convincing way to end the ring. Among Morie sensei's works, I thought I liked it the most.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗に無理なく終わりました

It ended beautifully and without difficulty

This review contains spoilers. 一巻があまりに混沌としていてどう物語を結ぶのかな？と思ってましたが4巻で綺麗に、えぐすぎない形で、でもきっちりと無理なくまとめておられてさすがモリエ先生！と思いました。先生の作品は途中が辛くても最後は優しい救いがあるので安心して読めます。ただ2人は結婚や出産が望めないのでそこは悲しいかなと思ったり。でも結婚しなくても相手を伏せて出産は出来るしその後2人で育てることも無理じゃないか、などと妄想しました。

This review contains spoilers. The first volume is so chaotic that I wonder how to connect the story? I thought it was 4 volumes, so it's beautiful, in a shape that wasn't too rough, yet it was perfectly put together without difficulty, and as expected, Morie-sensei! I thought so. Even if the middle of the teacher's work is difficult, there is gentle salvation at the end, so I can read it with peace of mind. However, the two can't hope to get married or have children, so I think that's sad. But I was delusional that even if I didn't get married, I could give birth with my partner face down, and that it would be impossible for 2 people to raise them after that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

ストーリーがなかなかない内容で引き込まれました。どうなっていくのか気になり購入するか迷ってます。

I was drawn in because the story wasn't easy. I'm worried about what's going to happen and I'm at a loss as to whether to buy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでよかった

I'm glad I read

This review contains spoilers. モリエサトシ先生のマンガを初めて読みましたが、絵や世界観がとても好きになりました。ストーリーにも引き込まれて最終巻まで一気に読みました。過去の回想シーンなどは重い気持ちになりますが、ハラハラドキドキの展開の中にもほっこりするシーンもあり、購入してよかったです。特に3巻の終わりは悲しいシーンだったけど、最後はほっとできる結末でよかった…と言っていいのか分からないけど、私はよかったなと感じました。

This review contains spoilers. I read Morie Satoshi's manga for the first time, and I really fell in love with the pictures and the world view. I was drawn into the story and read it all at once until the last volume. Reminiscences from the past make me feel heavy, but there are also scenes that make me feel relaxed during the jarring, heart-pounding development, so I'm glad I bought it. The end of volume 3 in particular was a sad scene, but I don't know if I can say that I'm glad the ending made me feel relieved at the end... but I felt that was good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

何と言ったら

What should I say

すごい良かったとか、面白かったって書いていいのか考えてしまう作品でしたが、私は好きになりました。個人的にはとても良かったです。普通や平凡という日常生活がいかに貴重で大切な時間なのかと感じました。絵も好きです、みんな可愛くてかっこよかった?

It was a work that made me think it was okay to write that it was really good or that it was interesting, but I fell in love with it. Personally, it was very good. I felt how precious and important time a normal and ordinary daily life is. I like pictures too, was everyone cute and cool?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ミステリー

mystery

This review contains spoilers. 絵柄も推理漫画ぽいところも気に入りました！最終まで読み切ります

This review contains spoilers. I loved the design and the fact that it looks like a mystery comic! I will read it all the way to the end

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる

I'm worried about the continuation

This review contains spoilers. とにかくおすすめ！二人の心境が分かるのも良い！どうか、幸せになってほしい…

This review contains spoilers. Anyway, I recommend it! It's good to understand how they both feel! Please, I want them to be happy...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

こうあって欲しかった最後

This is the last thing I wanted

This review contains spoilers. 今までのドラマや漫画はどんな理由があっても「犯罪は、犯罪であり、罪を償う事が正しい」との終わり方が当然、という前提があったと思う。だからこの二人がどんなに純粋であっても最後は警察に捕まってしまうんだろうと思っていた。でも、この作者は敢えてある意味安直な最後を選ばなかった。この二人に安らぎの場所を与えつつ、結婚して社会的な立場も二人の子供を持つという選択も与えない（産んでも海利の子供としては公に出来ない）という罰を与えたんだけど、辛いかもしれないけどそれが殺人の償いなんでしょうし、この二人は多分これからもそのことを忘れる事は出来ないと思う。でも二人が一緒にいる事を作者さんが選んでくれて良かったと思う。

This review contains spoilers. I think dramas and comics up until now had the assumption that “crime is a crime, and it is right to atone for a crime,” no matter what the reason was, was natural. So I thought that no matter how innocent these two were, they would end up being caught by the police. However, this author dared not choose an honest end in a sense. While giving these two people a place of peace, they gave them the punishment of not giving them a social position or choice to have two children (even if they give birth, they can't publicly do it as Haili's children), and although it may be painful, that is probably compensation for murder, and I don't think these two will be able to forget that from now on. But I think it was good that the author chose to have the two of them together.

Helpful

Reviews for Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga