Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

不幸な結末じゃなくて本当に良かった。

I'm really glad it wasn't an unhappy ending.

This review contains spoilers. 残酷な偶然が悲劇のままにならなくて良かったです。子供が産まれたらどうするんだろうとか、心配なこともありますが、二人の幸せが見られて良かったと思いました。本物のお兄さんが、あんなにも堕ちてしまう前に少しでも救いがあれば良かったのにとは思います。おそらく両親の離婚後、父親に暴力を振るわれ続け手にかけてしまったのでしょう。あの死体は本当に別人で、お兄さんはどこか違う土地でやり直してくれていると良かったのに。胸が苦しくてなるようなお話でしたが、引き込まれてしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad that a cruel coincidence didn't become a tragedy. There are times when I'm worried about what to do when a child is born, but I thought it was great to see the happiness of the two of them. I think it would have been nice if my real older brother had even a little bit of salvation before he fell so bad. After her parents' divorce, she probably continued to be assaulted by her father and took advantage of it. That corpse was really a different person, and it would have been nice if my older brother had redone it in a different place. It was a heartbreaking story, but I was drawn in.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きすぎた。数日間気持ち持ってかれました

I cried too much. I was able to have feelings for a few days

This review contains spoilers. 「家庭に恵まれず、最愛の兄と暮らせる日だけを希望に、毎日を一人懸命に生きる主人公の少女」と、「困っている人を見過ごせない、いわゆる善人の青年」。多くを望まず、慎ましく、苦しいぐらいただただ真面目に生きる二人が偶然出会って惹かれあったら、そこにはどうしよもない、法的に裁かれる犯罪があって・・・。こんな心根の人たちこそ、幸せになってほしい、、、でもそれを願うことすら、苦しい。道はないんじゃないかと思わされる状況。正しいって何だろう？正義って何だろう？善人って？だれにとってのものだろう。頭がジンと痛くなるくらい身につまされた。ふたりが死なずに生きていく形は、最終的にああいう形に収まったけれど、こんご一生続く仄暗さ。。。可哀想すぎる。と思うのも彼らに申し訳ない。。。誰か、何か、二人に救いを(泣)

This review contains spoilers. “The main character, the girl who is not blessed with a family and lives hard every day, hoping only for a day when she can live with her beloved older brother,” and “a so-called good young man who can't overlook people in trouble.” If two people who don't want much, are humble, and live seriously, meet by chance and are attracted to them, there is nothing wrong with that, and a crime that can be judged legally... I want people with this kind of heart to be happy... but it's painful to even hope for it. A situation that makes you think that there is no way out. What is correct? What is justice? What is a good person? Who is it for? I was so stuck in my body that it made my head ache. The shape of the two living without dying eventually settled into that kind of shape, but the darkness continues for the rest of their lives... That's too pathetic. I feel sorry for them because I think... Save someone, something, two people (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いけど、怖さが残る…

It's interesting, but it still leaves me scared...

This review contains spoilers. いろんな怖さがあるなー。りぜもかいりもまさきも立花ももう一人の警察官も怖かったー(-_-;)まさきは、辛い人生だったんだろうなぁ…救われないまま、死んじゃったんだよね。どこかでだれかがまさきを救い上げてくれるとよかったよね。立花もりぜへの思いとか、独りよがりな正義持ち出しはじめてちょっと狂っちゃったねー(；・∀・)かいりとりぜは、兄妹になっちゃうあたりから、狂気を感じた。

This review contains spoilers. There are so many fears. Rizemokairi, Masaki, Tachibana, and the other police officer were scared... I wonder if Masaki had a hard life... she died without being saved. It would have been nice if someone had rescued Masaki somewhere. My feelings for Morize Tachibana and I went a little crazy when I first brought up justice when I first started (; ・∀・) Kairitorize felt insane from the point where they became brother and sister.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

是非映画化を❗

Please make it into a movie ❗

This review contains spoilers. 1話を読んで、即全巻購入しましたそれほど次が気になる作品でした、何が正義か悪か良かれと思ってやってることが、実はほっておいて欲しい、忘れさせて欲しい事だってあるわかん無くなった深い作品です映画化して欲しいと思います理世ちゃんは吉〇京〇海斗くんは横〇流〇と頭の中では決めてます良いと思います！何度も読みたくなる作品です❗おすすめですよ。

This review contains spoilers. I read episode 1 and immediately bought the whole volume. I was so concerned about the next one; it's actually a deep film I don't understand that I want you to leave alone, and there are things I want you to forget, and I want you to forget it. I want it to be made into a movie. Riyo-chan decided in my head that Yoshi 0 Kyo O Kaito is Yoko Ryu-kun is Yoko Ryu-kun, and I think it's good! It's a work you'll want to read over and over again ❗ I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

冬の朝のような2人

Two people like a winter morning

寒くて冷たくて、でもどこか清々しい、いつか来る春を感じさせるようなラストでした。個人的には素晴らしいプロットだと思います。タイトルにもある「正しい」をしみじみと考えさせられる作品でした。

It was a cold, cold, and yet somewhat refreshing last time that made me feel spring would come someday. I personally think it's a great plot. It was a work that made me really think about “correct,” which is also in the title.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

絵はあまり好きではなかったですが、話しが面白くて全巻購入しました！

I didn't really like the pictures, but the story was so interesting that I bought the whole volume!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

独特な雰囲気のお話と賛否の分かれそうな終わり方でしたが自分的にはとても好きな展開でした。良い作品をありがとうございました。

It was a story with a unique atmosphere and the way it ended where the pros and cons seemed to be divided, but I really liked the development. Thank you very much for the good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

普通の恋愛ものかと思いきや

I wonder if it's just a normal love affair

普通の恋愛ものかと思いきや、展開が思わぬ方向へ進んでいきます。とても面白いです。

I wonder if it's just a normal romance, but the development takes an unexpected turn. It's very interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

正直なところ…

Honestly...

☆1と悩みました。凄く考えさせられる話だけど、結末が納得いかないというか、人として納得したらいけない気がして☆1と5で悩みました。でも漫画としては凄く惹き付けられるし、こういうラストも有りだと思います。漫画のレビューなのでそれを考えたら、☆5かなと思いました。でもやっぱりラストは納得できないかな。ありきたりなラスト(服役して出所後に幸せになるパターン)でもある意味「やっぱりね」って思っちゃって評価はいまいちだったかもしれませんが。作者さんは凄いです。思いきったなと思いました。主人公も友だちを巻き込んでるし、ラスト以降の2人ははたして幸せなんだろうか…とも思います。一生罪を背負って生きていくんだろうし、後悔の念が沸き上がることもあるんだろうなぁ…と。主人公がお兄さんと再会か、あるいは死ぬ間際の言葉を知る機会があったらどうなっていたのかな。主人公も一回友だちの唾液とるの思いとどまったのにね…。愛とは…なんぞや、、、。こんだけいろんな感情が沸き上がる漫画を描いた作者さんに☆5です。なんだか漫画の王道展開を、何度か訪れるキーポイントで外していってる感じ。RPGのように、いくつかあるエンディングストーリーのバッドエンド的な読後感。バッドエンドかどうかはわかりませんが。

I was worried about ☆ 1. It's a really thought-provoking story, but I was worried about ☆ 1 and 5 because I wasn't satisfied with the ending, or rather, I felt like I shouldn't be convinced as a person. But as a comic, I'm really attracted to it, and I think there are endings like this. It's a comic review, so when I thought about that, I thought it was ☆ 5. But after all, I wonder if I'm not convinced by the last one. Even though it's a common last (pattern of serving time and being happy after being released), I thought “after all,” the evaluation may have been poor. The author is amazing. I thought it was thorough. The main character also has friends involved, and I wonder if the two people after the end are really happy... I wonder if they will live with sins for the rest of their lives, and I wonder if there are times when a sense of regret boils up... I wonder what would have happened if the main character was reunited with his older brother or had a chance to learn words about the time he was about to die. Even though the main character was once discouraged from taking his friend's saliva... Love is... what is it... It's ☆ 5 for the author who drew comics that evoke so many emotions. Somehow, I feel like I've missed the classic development of comics with key points I've visited a few times. Like an RPG, it feels like a bad end to several ending stories. Not sure if it's a bad end though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 07, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

あら

Ahhh

思ってたのとは違いました。違っていても良いのだと思います。

It wasn't what I expected. I think it's fine if it's different.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

amazing manga

Amazing manga

This review contains spoilers. i really love this manga very deep and very beautiful i can't predict what will happen and that why I am willing to read it all

This review contains spoilers. I really love this manga very deep and very beautiful I can't predict what will happen and that why I am willing to read it all

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

独特の、、、

unique...

こちらの作家さんらしい独特の雰囲気の漫画です。まだ1巻しか読めていないので、最終的にどう収まるのか気になります。

This is a comic with a unique atmosphere typical of this writer. I've only read volume 1 yet, so I'm wondering how it will fit in the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

どうしよう

What should I do

もし自分が彼女の立場だったら、どうしよう、、、いろいろ考えさせてくれる素敵な作品です。

It's a wonderful work that makes me think a lot about what to do if I were in her position...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

！！

!!

何か深いです、実際にこういうことがあったらって考えながら読みました

It's something deep, I read it while thinking that something like this actually happened

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

予測できず、納得感もあり、面白かったです。好みは分かれそう。

It was unpredictable, there was a sense of satisfaction, and it was interesting. They seem to have different tastes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくて苦しくて、だけど温かい

It's sad and painful, but it's warm

This review contains spoilers. きれいな絵に惹かれて読み始めたら、え、サスペンスなの？とびっくり。物語にぐいぐい引き込まれて、一気に最後まで読みました。登場人物の心情の描写や表情がリアルで、どきっとしたりぞくっとしたり、、ただひたすら、二人が幸せでありますように、と祈りながらページをめくりました。正しい終わり方ではないかもしれないけど、わたしはこれで良かったと思う。二人で共に生きること、それが二人にとっての幸せであり、罪の償い方でもあるんだな、と思いました。切なくて苦しくて、だけど温かい、忘れられない作品。

This review contains spoilers. If you were attracted to beautiful pictures and started reading, huh, suspense? I was surprised. I was so drawn into the story that I read it all the way to the end. The depictions of the characters' feelings and expressions were realistic, and I turned the pages praying that they would be thrilled and horrified... just earnestly, that the two of them would be happy. It might not be the right way to end it, but I'm glad it was. I thought that living together was happiness for both of them, and it was also a way to atone for their sins. It's a sad, painful, yet warm, and unforgettable work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

「正義」とは何なのか。

What is “justice”?

This review contains spoilers. とってもとっても痛い気持ちで読みました。この結末は道徳感としては「正しくはない」けれど、納得のできる、落としどころとしては最善だったと思います。海利が行ったことは法では裁かれるべき犯罪ではあるけれど、被害者(正確には被害者の被害者)にしてみれば命の恩人であり、彼女にとって海利は揺るぎのない「正義」だった。「正しい」って何だろう？「正義」とは何なのだろうか？と考えさせられました。色々と考えつつも、ラブストーリとしても珠玉だと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I read it with a very, very painful feeling. This ending is “not correct” in terms of sense of morality, but I think it was the best place to drop it off because it was convincing. What Kairi did is a crime that should be judged by law, but for the victim (to be precise, the victim's victim), it was a life saver, and Kairi was an unwavering “justice” for her. What does “right” mean? What is “justice”? It made me think. While thinking about a lot of things, I think it's also a wonderful love story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い。

It's interesting.

ドラマにもなりそうなストーリーですごく面白かったです。作品名の「正しい」とはをいろいろ考えさせられました。

It was really interesting because it was a story that could be turned into a drama. It made me think a lot about “correct” in the title of the work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

こんな形もありかなと思いました。

I was wondering if such a shape could be possible.

ラストが気になって購入。こんな形の終わりもありかなと思ってしまいました。ハッピーエンドで良かったです。

I was worried about the last one and bought it. It made me wonder if there could be an end in this form. I'm glad it had a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ドラマ化希望！

Hope it's made into a drama!

This review contains spoilers. 何が正しいのか、何が正義なのか考えさせられます。この終わり方で正しいのかどうか、一般的には正しくないのかもしれないけど、個人的にはよかったです！

This review contains spoilers. It makes me think about what is right and what is justice. I wonder if this way of ending is correct, it may not be correct in general, but personally I'm glad!

Helpful

Reviews for Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga