Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

怖いけど、面白い

It's scary, but it's funny

This review contains spoilers. モリエさんの“A嬢～”も好きでファンです！“お兄ちゃん”の存在だけを頼りに生きてきた理世ちゃんと現在の“お兄ちゃん”の非道さを知っている海利さん。“家族とは…”“正しい愛とは…”という問いを投げ掛けられている気がします。わたしはこの結末でよかったと思っています。（賛否両論あると思いますが）

This review contains spoilers. I also like Morie's “Miss A ~” and I'm a fan! Riyo, who lived by relying only on the existence of her “older brother,” and Kairi knows the outrageousness of her current “older brother.” I feel that the questions “what is family...” and “what is proper love...” are being asked. I'm glad this ended. (I think there are pros and cons)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた

wept

This review contains spoilers. かけがえのない人が自分が焦がれてた兄を殺してしまっていた、なんて、想像を絶する状況で。でも目の前にいる事実を優先することしか考えられないのが切なすぎて、、、二人の幸せとは何か、正義とは何か、法律とは?と考えさせられた。

This review contains spoilers. An irreplaceable person had killed my impatient brother, in an unimaginable situation. But it's so sad that I can only think about prioritizing the facts right in front of me... what is happiness for two people, what is justice, what is law? It made me think.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

予想以上の最終形

The final form is more than expected

This review contains spoilers. 兄と生き別れた妹 (主人公) と、その兄に似た所が有るバイト先の男。見えてきた人間相関図にビックリ！！…主人公がそーゆう選択をするのは、何か分かる気がするけど、二人の関係の最終形がこうなるとは思わなかった。意外なストーリー展開にびっくりだけど、何か…ちょっと納得。一抹の不安を感じるけど、重い十字架を背負いながらでも、二人で幸せになって…としか言えないです。あと、いくら正しくても、当人の気持ちより自分本位な価値観を優先して、無理矢理、事を進めようとする男はウザかった。彼女への想いもあったからだと思うけど…もうほっといてやれよ…と思ってしまった。場合によっては、正しい事が絶対とは限らない気もします。

This review contains spoilers. A younger sister (the main character) who broke up with her older brother, and a part-time man who has a place similar to that older brother. I was surprised at the human correlation chart that came into view!! ... I feel like I understand how the main character makes such choices, but I didn't think the final form of the relationship between the two would be like this. I was surprised by the unexpected storyline, but something... I was a little convinced. I feel a lot of anxiety, but I can only say that even while carrying a heavy cross, the two of them became happy... Also, no matter how correct it is, men who prioritize self-oriented values over the feelings of the person in question and try to move things forward by force were annoying. I think it's because I had feelings for her too... but I thought I should just leave it alone... In some cases, I also feel like the right thing isn't always absolute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

お兄ちゃん…

brother...

This review contains spoilers. 4巻でまとめるのが難しそうな内容なのに、うまくまとまっていて予想外の結末だったりして読み応えがあります。個人的には良い終わり方だと思いました。大体こういう作品だと自首して罪を償って〜という流れになることが多いと思いますが、こういうエンディングでも良いのではないでしょうか。好みはわかれると思いますが、私は好きです。

This review contains spoilers. Even though the content seems difficult to put together in volume 4, it is well organized and has an unexpected ending, making it worth reading. Personally, I thought it was a good way to end. For the most part, I think this kind of work often involves turning yourself in and making amends for your sins, but I think this kind of ending would be fine. I think they have different tastes, but I like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで読ませる、だから最後まで読む可し

I'll let you read it until the end, so you can read it until the end

有り体の漫画家なら、自首させて、ヒロインがお腹の子と待っています、と終わらせるのかな。読み切ればタイトルの意味も分かる、読者の「正しさ」を問う作品。

If I were a real manga artist, I wonder if I'd let them turn themselves in and end up with the heroine waiting with her stomach. It is a work that questions the reader's “correctness,” and once you read it through, you can understand the meaning of the title.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

すごかった

That was amazing

後半の怒涛の展開にびっくりしたけど、読んで良かったです。漫画だしフィクションを受け入れた上で、仄暗い妄執に囚われたストーリーがすごく好みでした。

I was surprised by the turbulent developments in the second half, but I'm glad I read it. After accepting comics and fiction, I really liked the story where I was trapped by dark delusions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

難しい感情

Difficult emotions

This review contains spoilers. 普通に生きてきたら理世やかいりの気持ちはわからない、そこを面白く描くのは作者の腕なんでしょうね、ラストが非常にうまくまとまって静かに終わったのが善かった。

This review contains spoilers. If I lived a normal life, I wouldn't understand Riyo or Kairi's feelings; drawing them in an interesting way is probably the author's skill, and it was nice that the last one came together so well and ended quietly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

二人の幸せ

The happiness of two

This review contains spoilers. 試し読みをしてそのまま最後まで読んでしまいました。いろいろ込み上げるのがあり言葉にするのが難しいですが、最後には二人が幸せでいてくれて本当に良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I did a trial reading and just read it all the way to the end. It's hard to put into words because there are so many things going on, but it was really nice that the two of them were happy at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

This review contains spoilers. 4巻で上手くまとまったなぁ。と思う程展開が読めなくてハラハラしました。実の兄を相当なクズに描いてくれたことで読みやすくなったと思います。大学の友達とか証言者の女性とかが変に絡んでこず、これ以上のドロ沼化にならなかったのもよかった。立花さんは気の毒でしたが、彼なら大丈夫と思わせてくれるキャラで良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. It came together nicely in volume 4. I was so annoyed that I couldn't read the development as much as I thought. I think it made it easier to read by drawing my real brother in quite a bit of scum. My college friends and women who were witnesses didn't get involved strangely, and it was good that it didn't become any more muddy than this. I felt sorry for Mr. Tachibana, but I'm glad it was a character that made me think he would be fine.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ショッキング

shocking

昔試し読みして面白かったので買って全部見たらこういう結末なんだって終わり方でした。良いとも悪いとも言えない結末。

I used to try reading it and it was interesting, so when I bought it and watched it all, it ended like this. An ending that is neither good nor bad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

欺騙

deceive

好意を寄せた者から浮かび上がる忌まわしい陰。しかし愛は盲目、現実をありのままには受け止められない。その先にまっているのが破滅だとしても歩みを止めることなどできようものか。

An abominable shadow that comes out of those who have favoured them. However, love is blind and cannot accept reality as it is. Is it possible to stop walking even if what lies ahead is ruin?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おおぅ…

ooh...

可愛らしい雰囲気の絵とはそぐわない重いテーマ。読後感が（私には）好みではなかったけれど、イヤミスが好きな人なら好きかも知れません。読後感を抜きにすれば、とても面白く読めました。

A heavy theme that doesn't go well with a picture with a cute atmosphere. I didn't like the feeling after reading it (for me), but if you like bad mistakes, you might like it. It was a very interesting read without feeling after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

難しい

difficult

This review contains spoilers. 好きになった人が大好きなお兄ちゃんを殺したかもしれない自分はどう行動したらいいのかわからなくなる結構ドロドロした作品ですね

This review contains spoilers. It's a pretty muddy work where the person you fall in love with may have killed your favorite older brother and you don't know how to act

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

私は好きです

I like

昼ドラ並のサスペンスタッチで進むお話。ぜひネタバレで読んで欲しい作品で賛否は別れるかもですが私は好きです。これは読了済の方の感想聞きたいってなりますね。

The story progresses with a suspense touch similar to a daytime drama. It's a work I definitely want you to read with spoilers, and the pros and cons may be divided, but I like it. This makes me want to hear the impressions of those who have read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ハズレ無しっ！?❤

there are no gaps!? ❤

This review contains spoilers. モリエサトシさんの漫画の作品が好きで購入。恋愛だけじゃなく話の内容もしっかりしていて、何度見返しても飽きないです！この作品は内容的に賛否両論あるかもしれませんが、物語としてとても好きです。個人的にモリエサトシさんの作品は切なくてなんとも言えない気持ちになる作品が多いですが、そこが魅力✨

This review contains spoilers. I like Morie Satoshi's comics, so I bought them. Not only is it about love, but the story is also solid, and I never get tired of watching it over and over again! There may be pros and cons to this work in terms of content, but I really like it as a story. Personally, many of Morie Satoshi's works make me feel sad and indescribable, but that is attractive ✨

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

正しさとは…

Correctness is...

This review contains spoilers. サスペンスですね。面白くて一気に読んでしまいました。全てが善と悪で分けられる世界だったら、こんなに悩まないでしょうね。2人には幸せになって欲しかったけど、それと同時に罪を償って欲しい気持ちもあったので、この結末にはモヤモヤ…悪人を殺せば正義になるわけではありません！しかも、最後にお兄ちゃんとして生きる事を選んだ2人…サイコパスやん！めっちゃ怖かった〜でも怖いもの見たさで読んでしまうんやね〜

This review contains spoilers. It's suspense, isn't it? It was so interesting that I read it all at once. If it were a world where everything was divided by good and evil, I wouldn't be so worried. I wanted the two of them to be happy, but at the same time, I also wanted them to atone for their sins, so I was confused about this ending... killing the villain doesn't mean justice! What's more, they're the last two people who chose to live as older brothers... psychopaths! I was so scared ~ but I saw something scary and ended up reading it~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる

I'm worried about the continuation

This review contains spoilers. 最初立ち読みだけ〜と思ってましたが続きが気になって気になって結局全部購入してしまいました。幸せに落ち着いてよかったです、、

This review contains spoilers. At first I thought it was just standing reading, but I was curious about the continuation, so I ended up buying them all. I'm glad you settled down happily...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ただの恋愛漫画と思いきや…

I thought it was just a romance comic...

モリエサトシさんの大ファンで、作者買いしました。ただの恋愛ものかと思ったら、まさかの展開にハラハラドキドキ。ラストは衝撃。とても面白かったです。

I'm a big fan of Morie Satoshi, so I bought the author. When I thought it was just a love affair, I was thrilled by the unexpected development. The last one was a shock. It was very interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

正しいとはなにか

What is correct

ドラマを見て原作が気になって読んだのですが、ハマって一気に最終巻まで読んでしまいました。3巻までは題名の意味がわからなくて、4巻でやっと分かりました。なんだか言葉に表せないような感情がフルーツの絞り汁のようにジュワッと湧いてきました。

I watched the drama and read it because I was curious about the original story, but I read the last volume of Hama all at once. I didn't understand the meaning of the title until volume 3, and I finally understood it in volume 4. Somehow an indescribable feeling sprang up like squeezed fruit juice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくて

I'm sad

サスペンスなのでハラハラドキドキしました。終わり方に心がグッと鷲掴みにされた気持ちになりました。きっと二人にはあの終わり方が一番なんだとおもいました。

It was suspenseful, so it was really exciting. It made me feel like my heart was taken by the eagle by the way it ended. I'm sure they both thought that was the best way to end.

Helpful

Reviews for Searching for My Perfect Brother Manga