Phantom of the Idol Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

第2部が楽しみ

I'm looking forward to part 2

ZINGSファン、特に仁淀ファンのお姉さんたちが大変面白い、ドルオタ名言メーカーな漫画。あさひちゃんも可愛い（幽霊だけど）のにすごく変、真のアイドルというか、とても変。そこがまた良い。死んでしまった女アイドルに取り憑かれて〜！？みたい展開が一切ないの評価できるポイント。仁淀とあさひちゃんは今後もずっとそうであってほしい（多分作者的にもそうなる）無駄な恋愛イベントやラッキースケベ的な展開が無理な人間でも安心して読めます。

ZINGS fans, especially the older sisters of Niyodo fans, are very interesting, and this is a Dorota quote maker comic. Even though Asahi is cute (although she's a ghost), she's really weird, and she's a true idol, so weird. That's good again. Possessed by a female idol who has died!? A point where you can evaluate the fact that there are no developments like this at all. I hope Niyodo and Asahi will always be like that in the future (probably in terms of the author), even people who can't handle useless love events or lucky scruffy developments can read it with peace of mind.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

アイドルヲタ的に

Like an idol otaku

アイドルヲタとしては時々出てくるヲタク達にも共感をしてしまう漫画でした。こんな規格外なアイドル実際にいたら怖いもの見たさで推してみたい…！

It was a comic that made me sympathize with otaku who come up from time to time as idol otaku. I've seen such non-standard idols that would be scary if they actually existed, so I'd like to recommend them...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ツイッターで気になって

I was curious on Twitter

1話試し読みをして面白かったんで購入。やる気のないアイドルとやる気に満ち溢れるアイドル（幽霊）を足して2で割ったら素敵なアイドルになった話( ´∀｀)ファンの掛け合いが面白すぎる！続き早くでてほしー！

I tried reading episode 1 and it was interesting, so I bought it. A story about adding an unmotivated idol and an idol (ghost) full of motivation and dividing it by 2 to become a wonderful idol ('∀`) The interaction of fans is too interesting! I hope it continues to come out soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

規格外アイドルでおもしろい￥

Funny with a non-standard idol

This review contains spoilers. ネット上で評判がよかったので購入。顔はいいけど、とにかくやる気のないアイドルと、アイドルの中のアイドルだったのに事故死してしまい成仏できていないアイドルが出会って、一緒に（？）アイドルをやっていくという設定がまずおもしろい。２巻の終わりくらいいまでかけて、ようやくじーんわり、アイドルとしての気力が出てくる、簡単な変化でないのもいい。個人的にはファンのみなさんの言動がもうツボに入りまくりで、おかしくてしょうがなかった。ファン同士の会話だけ１話いけると思うくらい。

This review contains spoilers. It had a good reputation on the internet, so I bought it. An idol who has a nice face but isn't motivated anyway, and an idol who died in an accident and wasn't able to attain Buddhism even though they were idols, met, and together (?) First of all, the setting where you're going to be an idol is interesting. It's nice that it's not an easy change until about the end of volume 2, and finally calms down, and my energy as an idol comes out. Personally, the words and actions of all the fans had already crept into pressure points, and I couldn't help but feel strange. So much so that I think I could go through one episode just by talking between fans.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

オタクには刺さる漫画

Comics that stick to otaku

本当に面白いので是非読んで欲しい漫画です。絵の可愛さと主人公のやる気のなさも癖になります。またモブのオタク達の心情はとても共感でき、爆笑しながら頷いて読みました！

It's really interesting, so I definitely want you to read this comic. The cuteness of the picture and the lack of motivation of the protagonist are also a habit. Also, I was able to really sympathize with the feelings of the mobs nerds, and I read it while laughing and nodding!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい！

cute!

Twitterで一話が紹介されていて続きが読みたい！と購入しました。登場人物のキャラもいいし、絵が綺麗で読みやすいです。

Episode 1 was introduced on Twitter and I want to read more! I bought it. The characters are good, and the pictures are beautiful and easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

アイドルやる気ゼロのアイドルによどくんと、アイドルやりたくてしょうがないけど幽霊になっちゃったアサヒちゃん。によどくんの身体に入って交代で仕事するのがおもしろいです。ファンのひとたちの会話も楽しい。

Yodo-kun, an idol with zero motivation, and Asahi-chan became ghosts even though she couldn't help but wanted to be an idol. It's interesting to get into Yodo-kun's body and take turns working. The conversation among the fans is also fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

二人のキャラが真逆すぎて、すごく面白いです。ついつい読み進めてしまいました。何気に女社長さんのキャラが、いい味だしてますね。

The two characters are so opposite, it's really interesting. I just kept reading it. I wonder why the character of the female president has a good taste.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

なんか読んじゃう

I'm going to read something

やる気ないアイドルによどくんとやる気満々アイドルあさひちゃん。によどくんの気持ちが変わると言うよりもめんどくさいという自分の心しか見てなかったによどくんがまわりを見るという行動を知っていくそういう話なのかなんなのかによどおたメンタルつえ〜笑う私もそうなりたい、、、自担、、、元気か、、、飯食ってるか、、、、サボテンは花咲いたか、、、、会いたいな、、、、

Yodo-kun, an unmotivated idol, and Asahi-chan, a motivated idol. I was only looking at his own mind, which is more troublesome than saying that Yodo-kun's feelings change, but I wonder if it's the kind of story where you get to know the act of Yodo-kun's mentality of looking around ~ I want to be like that too... I want to be like that... take care... are you doing well... are you eating a meal... have cacti bloomed... I want to meet them...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

塩のままで良い派

The group that is good with salt

ギャグ漫画クオリティある作品で面白いです。ファンのお姉さん達のリアクションに腹の底から大爆笑した。「顔の良いくさや」とか表現が本当に良い。お笑いやショーを見るより断然面白かったです。自然体で笑わす為の言動じゃないから、そこが良くて、本当にお姉さん達を見てて自分も楽しい。変に恋愛要素を入れない作風なのも好感が持て楽しめます。アサヒちゃんがとにかく清涼剤感半端なくて、この漫画が一応アイドルものとして成立しているのは彼女と吉野くんのおかげ。吉野くんは報われて欲しいけれど、彼が輝けるのは死んだ魚が横にいるからなのは1巻で明白なので、やはりコンビは凹凸がデフォなんだなと思いました。

It's a gag comic quality work and it's interesting. I burst out laughing from the bottom of my stomach at the reaction of the older sisters of the fans. Expressions like “nice face” are really good. It was definitely more interesting than watching a comedy or show. It's not a word or action to make me laugh naturally, so that's good, and I really enjoy watching the older sisters. I also like the fact that it's a style that doesn't include elements of romance strangely, and you can enjoy it. Asahi didn't feel like a freshener at all, and it was thanks to her and Yoshino that this comic was established as an idol for the time being. Yoshino-kun wants to be rewarded, but it's clear in volume 1 that the reason he can shine is because a dead fish is on his side, so I thought unevenness was the default for the duo.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

わかりみしかない

There is nothing but understanding

推しがいる人は読むべきだと思います。怠け者のアイドルが成長する姿と、それを見守るオタクをコミカルに捉えていて、サクサク読めます。

I think people who need suggestions should read it. It comically captures the image of a lazy idol growing up and the otaku watching over it, and it's easy to read.

Helpful

Reviews for Phantom of the Idol Manga