Welcome Back, Alice Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

男の子って大変だー

it's tough being a boy

女も大変だけど、男も辛いよね。どっちでもない所に戻りたいって言うのは多くの人にあるのでは。うまくやっていける人ってどれくらいいるんだろう…

It's tough for women, but it's hard for men too. There are probably a lot of people who say they want to go back to a place where they are none. I wonder how many people can get along well...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

また！押見に！壊される！

again! to watch! It's going to be destroyed!

押見先生にまた私の人生で築き上げた観念の城が落城させられる。性別を降りるってなんだよ・・・分かりたいよ・・・・固定観念で汚され尽くした私を置き去りにして今作の主人公たちも次の次元へと行ってしまう読むとしんどくなるのに止められない押見の世界・・・だれか助けてくれ！

Oshimi sensei makes the castle of ideas that I built in my life fall once again. What is gender removal... I want to understand... leaving me completely tainted by stereotypes, and the main characters in this work also go to the next level, a world of unstoppable speculation that becomes tough to read but can't be stopped... someone help me!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキが止まらん

I can't stop being excited

男は男の子らしく、女は女の子らしくと日本では育てられ、性教育は中途半端で性は恥ずかしく、いけないことのように感じてた。性風俗が盛んなのに、パートナーとの回数は少ない国。何故なのか？愛情＝性欲では無いという事か？自分にとっての性の始まりはいつだったか？あとがき漫画を読み色々と考えさせられました。

Men were raised in Japan to look like boys, and women were raised like girls, and sex education was half-hearted and I was ashamed of sex, and I felt like something I shouldn't have done. A country where sexual customs are popular, but the number of times with a partner is rare. why is that? Does that mean love isn't sexual desire? When did sex begin for you? Reading the comic with the afterword made me think a lot.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

わーすごい

Wow that's amazing

あれ、いつもと違うかなと思ったら、やはり押見さんの世界だった。いやいや、えぐいしささるし、辛いなこれは。読んじゃうんだけどね。

Oh, when I thought that was different from usual, it was Oshimi-san's world after all. No, no, it's awful, and this is painful. I read it, though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

全部読んで見ようかな

Maybe I'll read them all

まだ1巻しか読んでいませんが、担任とクラスメイトは慧の事を理解して良いなと思いました。全部読んでみたいです。

I've only read volume 1 yet, but I thought it would be nice for my homeroom teacher and classmates to understand Kei. I want to read them all.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

予想以上におもしろい

More interesting than expected

読んでみたらまさかの展開で面白かった！！絵がとにかく綺麗で上手いのでリアリティがある。けいちゃんがイケメンでかわいくて魅力的。ジェンダーレスを描いたとても感慨深い話なので、今後の展開がどうなっていくのかワクワクする！！

When I read it, it unexpectedly unfolded and it was interesting!! Anyway, the pictures are beautiful and good, so there's reality. Kei-chan is a handsome guy, cute, and charming. It's a very moving story about genderlessness, so I'm excited to see what the future holds!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

新しいあおはる

New Aoharu

This review contains spoilers. ジェンダーを扱った作品、BLのくくりではなく、増えてきましたね！学生時代の複雑な感情にジェンダーが絡んでつい引き込まれてしまう。絵もきれいだし、女性になりたいわけではない！て気持ち女性だけどわかる！

This review contains spoilers. The number of works dealing with gender, not a BL collection, has increased! Gender is involved in the complicated emotions of my school days, and I'm just drawn in. The picture is beautiful, and I don't want to be a woman! It's a woman's feeling, but I understand it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

意表を突かれた作品

A work that caught me by surprise

This review contains spoilers. 1話からある意味トラウマ物ですこんなのあったら絶対女性不信になりますまさかジェンダーをぶち込んでくるとはその角度から一気に引き込まれましたこのヒロイン的な子もある種曲者です自分的には嫌いなタイプ変わった角度からの青春群青劇って感じですねさすが押見修造ワールド！！！

This review contains spoilers. It's traumatic in a sense from episode 1. If something like this happened, I would definitely be distrustful of women. No way throwing in gender, I was drawn in all at once from that angle. This heroine is also a kind of composer. It feels like a youth ultramarine drama from a type change angle that I personally don't like, isn't it? As expected, Oshimi Shuzo World!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

深い、、。

deep...

性に対する考察が、描かれていると思います。成長期の性に対する嫌悪感であったり、身体の成長に伴う違和感だったり。誰しもが経てきた道なんじゃないのかと思います。押見先生の丁寧な描写にはっとさせられます。

I think it depicts considerations about sex. It's an aversion to sex during growth, or a sense of incongruity associated with physical growth. I don't think this is the path everyone has taken. I'm amazed by Oshimi-sensei's careful description.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

慧ちゃんが可愛すぎる！！！！！！

Kei is too cute!!!!!

とにかく慧ちゃんが可愛すぎるし見とれてしまう。。現実にも慧ちゃんみたいなのがいたらなと思ってしまう。俺も大人になって性欲がありすぎるのが悩みで何度も男を辞めたいって思うことがあったしすごく共感する部分もある。後は押見先生の後書きが毎度の事ながらめちゃくちゃすき！

Anyway, Kei is too cute and I'm fascinated.. It makes me wish there was someone like Kei in real life. As an adult, I was also worried that I had too much sexual desire, and there were times when I wanted to quit being a man many times, and there are parts that I really sympathize with. After that, I really like Oshimi-sensei's afterword every time!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

This review contains spoilers. 続きが楽しみ主人公（洋ちゃん）、人を傷つけたりする事もあるけど基本的に優しくて人を想える性格っていうのが伝わってくるので、ストレスなく読めます。男を降りたいと思う一方で、男として三谷の期待に応えなきゃと思う洋ちゃんに共感しちゃう

This review contains spoilers. I'm looking forward to the continuation, the main character (Hiro-chan), who sometimes hurts people, but basically conveys his personality that is kind and thinks of people, so I can read it without stress. While I want to get off the man, I sympathize with Hiro-chan, who thinks he has to meet Mitani's expectations as a man

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

男である意味

Meaning of being a man

男である意味、女である意味、そういうこだわりって捨てられたら自分らしく生きていけるんだろうな。押見先生は人間のモヤモヤしたぐずぐずの感情を形にしてくれるから、色んなことを考えさせられます。

The meaning of being a man, the meaning of being a woman, if that kind of obsession is thrown away, I wonder if I can live my own way. Professor Oshimi gives shape to the fuzzy emotions of humans, so it makes me think about a lot of things.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

本編もあとがきも気になるマンガ

Manga I'm interested in both the main story and the afterword

3人の行く末や三谷さんの真意も気になるんですが、作者のちん●んの話の行く末が気になって眠れません。笑後書きのオチを次回まで引っ張ると言う新手の商法にビックリしました。思春期男子を描かせたら、本当に天下一品の漫画家さんだと思っていたので、まさか男×男モノが読めるとは思いもよらず、ニヤニヤしながら読んでます。性欲MAX男子同士のいっときの過ちで終わってしまうのか、それともノンケではいられなくなってしまうのか。オチが気になります。

I'm also worried about the future of the three and Mitani's true intentions, but I can't sleep because I'm worried about the future of the author's story. lol I was surprised at the new commercial method that says that the punch line on the afterword will be pulled until next time. When I was asked to draw an adolescent boy, I really thought he was Tenkaippin manga artist, so I never thought I'd be able to read Man x Man Mono, so I read it while smirking. Will it end with a quick mistake between boys with maximum sexual desire, or will they just not be able to stay alone? I'm worried about the punch line.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

何が愛か。

What is love.

この漫画はその深いところへ降りて、探そうとしています。何も考えない人はいいのかもしれないけど、言葉や行動に先立つ「実存」を描こうとしています。男とか女とかの「存在」に先立つものを知りたい、作者の意図に強く惹かれます。

This comic has gone down to that deep place and I'm trying to find it. Maybe people who don't think anything are good, but I'm trying to depict “existence” that precedes words and actions. I am strongly attracted to the author's intention to know what precedes the “existence” of a man or woman.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

学校のジェンダーレス対応に驚く

Surprised by the school's genderless response

時代はジェンダーレス！？そんな単純な話ではないことが垣間見える1巻だった。押見先生の”あとがき”相変わらず闇が深えな。

The era is genderless!? It was volume 1 where I was able to catch a glimpse of something that wasn't such a simple story. Oshimi-sensei's “Afterword” is still as dark as ever.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 21, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the continuation

お試しで読んで気になったので購入しましたが、予想外の展開になっています!性について考えさせられそうな続きを楽しみにしています。絵の感じも好きです。色々なことがオープンになっている世の中が良いのかどうなのか。永遠に答えはでなさそう。

I read it as a trial and was curious, so I bought it, but it was an unexpected development! I'm looking forward to the continuation which seems to make me think about sex. I also like the feel of the picture. Is it good to have a world where so many things are open? There doesn't seem to be an answer forever.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

慧ちゃん小悪魔

Kei little devil

ミステリアスでめっちゃ可愛いです。まだ始まったばっかって感じで先が読めないけど、とりあえず慧ちゃんかわいい♡

It's mysterious and so cute. I feel like it's just started and I can't read ahead, but anyway, Kei is cute ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごい

uncanny

This review contains spoilers. 少年少女の性に対する揺らぎがエログロに描かれてる。男をおりるって表現がやめるじゃないんやと思った。でもこんなに自分の内面を赤裸々に描けるってすごい!

This review contains spoilers. The fluctuation between boys and girls about sex is depicted in erotic style. I thought the expression to throw down a man wasn't going to stop. But it's amazing to be able to paint my inner world so starkly!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

むーー

Mmm

難しすぎる私には本当に理解が、、、難しいそんなに深く性を考えた事なくてごめんなさい自分の性に違和感を覚えるのはどんな感じなんだろうただ、世の中から性別なんてなくなればいいのにとは思ってましたが、、、レビュー書くのもまた頭抱えてしまう

It's really difficult for me to understand... it's difficult for me to understand... I'm sorry I haven't thought about sex so deeply; I just thought it would be nice if gender disappeared from the world, but... writing a review also bothers me

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いたけれど…怖いです

I cried but... I'm scared

三谷さんが怖くて…でも悲しくて…どう言葉にしたらよいのかわかりませんでした。ただ、私に通じるものがあって、今まで隠してたものが表に出てきそうで怖いです。読み返すことも怖いです。

Mitani was scared... but sad... I didn't know how to put it into words. However, there is something that works for me, and it's scary that what I've hidden until now seems to come out. I'm also afraid to reread it.

Helpful

Reviews for Welcome Back, Alice Manga