Witch Hat Atelier Manga Reviews (P.8)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

今後も楽しみ！

I'm looking forward to the future!

絵は、安定の綺麗さで素敵でした。道具などは作者さんのこだわりが見えて楽しかったです。1巻が気になるところで終わったため、2巻も楽しみです！

The picture was beautiful and stable. It was fun to see the artist's commitment to tools, etc. I finished volume 1 where I was worried, so I'm looking forward to volume 2 too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

レベルの高い作品

High level work

非常にレベルの高い作品のように思います。他の方が語っているように絵が素晴らしいです。加えてキャラクターの描写も世界観とマッチしており、読者を引き込む力があります。この作品における「魔法」の扱いが自分の好みと合わなかったので、続きを読む気はありませんが、好きな人にはとことん刺さる作品になるのではないでしょうか。

I think it's a very high level work. As others have said, the picture is amazing. Furthermore, the depiction of the characters also matches the worldview, and has the power to draw readers in. The treatment of “magic” in this work didn't suit my taste, so I don't feel like continuing to read it, but I think it will be a work that will really stick to people who like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

心が躍った

My heart fluttered

This review contains spoilers. 先生の絵柄と作品のお話が相性良くて、最高でした。読んでいくうちにどんどんお話の世界観に飲まれていって読んでいて楽しいです。途中途中でくすっと笑える要素が入っていて面白かったです。

This review contains spoilers. The teacher's design went well with the story of the work, and it was great. As I read, I was more and more absorbed by the world view of the story, and it's fun to read. It was interesting because there were elements that made me giggle along the way.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 08, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

圧倒的に絵が上手い、もはや絵画。

I'm overwhelmingly good at painting, now painting.

This review contains spoilers. 内容もジＢリのような万人向けで、良いところしかない。のだけど、アガット普通にヤバくない？無事に戻ってきたから良かったものの、主人公は死んでた可能性もあるわけで。素人装備の素人を雪山に放り出す恐ろしさがあります。主人公も主人公で、どうしても知りたいやりたい、で、お母さん冷凍にしちゃって元に戻れるかもわからない、と。私が心配性なせいもあるとは思うけど、普通に深刻に危険なことを目的のために実行してしまう子供の危うさや幼さをメルヘンテイストの素敵さや子供の朗らかさで流してくるのが少し恐ろしいです。本当に絵も内容も上手いけど、怖い。怖いのに、怖いことを怖いと描かれていないのがまた怖い。

This review contains spoilers. The content is also for everyone, like Gibbli, and there are only good points. But isn't Agat usually dangerous? I'm glad they came back safely, but there's also a possibility that the main character died. There is the horror of throwing an amateur with amateur equipment into a snowy mountain. The main character is also the main character, and I really want to know what I want to do, and my mother freezes it and doesn't know if it can go back to normal. I think it's partly because I'm worried, but it's a little scary that the danger and childishness of children who usually carry out serious and dangerous things for the purpose is played out with the wonderfulness of a fairy tale taste and the cheerfulness of children. The picture and content are really good, but it's scary. Even though it's scary, it's also scary that scary things aren't depicted as scary.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵本にしたい

I want to turn it into a picture book

どこをとっても絵が美しく漫画というよりもむしろ　絵本の方が近いかもしれないすごいですどうやってこんな漫画書いてるのと思わせるぐらい美しいシーンがたくさんあります

The pictures are beautiful no matter where you look, and it's amazing that picture books might be closer than comics; there are so many beautiful scenes that make you wonder how comics like this are written

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らし

That's great

い！の１言です。画力が凄いし、細部まで丁寧に描かれていて凄く感心する。ストーリーも魔法に関わることで良いも悪いも表現されている。子供が読んでも勉強？になるかもね。素晴らしい！

hey! That's one word. The drawing power is amazing, and I'm really impressed that every detail is carefully drawn. Both good and bad stories are expressed by involving magic. Do kids study even when they read? Maybe it will be. great!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

購入してよかった！

I'm glad I bought it!

絵もお話しも繊細で綺麗でステキです。何も知らずただ魔法に憧れてただけだったけど魔法を知ることによって起こる成長と葛藤に読んでいてどきどきします！弟子の子たちもみんないい子でやりとりにほんわかします?

Both the pictures and the story are delicate, beautiful, and wonderful. I was thrilled to read about the growth and conflict caused by knowing magic, even though I didn't know anything and was just longing for magic! all of the disciples are nice kids, and they really don't understand how to interact?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵な世界観

A wonderful view of the world

ずっと前から気になっていたのですが、どことなく絵柄が古く感じられて苦手に思っていた作品でした。今回1巻0円だったので読んでみたのですが、とても世界観が魅力的で面白い作品でした。続きも購入したいです

I've been interested in it for a long time, but it was a work I didn't like because the design felt somewhat old. This time it was 0 yen per volume, so I read it, and it was an interesting work with a very attractive view of the world. I want to buy more

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

不思議な世界観

A mysterious view of the world

今まで読んだ魔法使いのお話とはちょっと違う設定で、それゆえ派手さより工夫ある魔法という感じです。比較的ストーリー展開がゆっくりなので、個人的には少しもどかしい気持ちもありますが、面白いストーリーだと思います。

The setting is slightly different from the wizard stories I've read so far, so it feels like magic with ingenuity rather than flashiness. The story unfolds relatively slowly, so I personally feel a little frustrated, but I think it's an interesting story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

難しい

difficult

世界のルールと自分が考える正義が異なるとき、人はどう答えを出すのだろう。答えの出ない問いに対し、このお話はどう決着をつけるのか、気になります。個人的には好奇心旺盛過ぎて、周りに与える影響に対して無自覚な主人公があまり好きではないです。。。どのエピソードも、彼女の行動が結果的でも手放しで良かったね、と思えなくて。モヤモヤするというか。。。そう言うの含めてちゃんと最後は回収されるといいな、と思います。

When the rules of the world and the justice they think of are different, how do people come up with answers? I'm curious about how this story will come to a conclusion in response to unanswered questions. Personally, I don't really like the protagonist, who is too curious and unaware of the impact he has on his surroundings... I couldn't think of any episode that I'm glad she let go, even if her actions were consequential. I think it's fuzzy... Including saying that, I think it would be nice if it was properly collected at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が上手い。保存レベル。

Good at painting. Level of preservation.

直感で美大出か？と思った。何年かに一度現る天才絵師なんでしょうね。ノーマン・ロックウェルと現代漫画の融合ですかね。絵が上手すぎて話が頭に入らなかった。

Did you go to art college intuitively? I thought so. He's probably a genius painter who shows up once every few years. It's probably a fusion of Norman Rockwell and contemporary comics. The picture was so good that I couldn't get into my head.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

魔法の使い方が面白い。

The way magic is used is interesting.

魔法を制約なく使える漫画が多いと思ってるが。使用に適度な不自由感もあり、読んでて面白い

I think there are a lot of comics where you can use magic without restrictions. There is also a moderate sense of inconvenience in use, so it's interesting to read

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでて楽しい

It's fun to read

面白いです。魔法強い！便利！だけではなく間違った魔法の使い方や1歩間違えれば人に害を与える魔法の悪いところもあるのが凄くいいです。リアリティが高くて自分も隣で魔法を習っているかのようで読んでいて楽しい！

It's interesting. Strong magic! convenient! Not only that, it's really nice that there are bad ways to use magic or magic that harms people if you make a mistake one step. It's so realistic and it's fun to read it as if I were learning magic next to me!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

絵本みたいな世界

A world like a picture book

魔法使いに憧れていた主人公が、母のために魔法使いの修行をする物語。とにかく絵がキレイで、外国の絵本の童話みたいな世界観。とても好きです。次巻が出るまでにかなり時間がかかるので、新刊が出る頃にはストーリーを忘れてしまいがちだ…

This is a story where the main character, who admired a wizard, trains as a wizard for his mother. Anyway, the pictures are beautiful, and the world view is like a fairy tale from a foreign picture book. I like it very much. It takes quite a while until the next volume comes out, so it's easy to forget the story by the time the new book comes out...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

画力は100点満点、話は20点、キャラは

The drawing power is 100 points out of 100, the story is 20 points, and the characters are 5 points.

魔法もので綺麗な画を見たいならハリポタ映画で十分。主人公の魅力のなさは昔の少女漫画の主人公よう。もちろん人気がでなかった凡百な少女漫画の、です。この神画力でストレートに王道を走っているのにここまでつまらない話も珍しい。ネームまでしっかり書いてくれる原作者をつけて欲しい。

If you want to see beautiful pictures with magic, the Haripota movie is enough. The main character's lack of appeal is like the main character in girls' comics in the olden days. Of course, it's an ordinary girls' comic that wasn't popular. Stories that are this boring even though they run straight on the royal road with this divine drawing power are rare. I want you to add an original author who can even write the name clearly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

正統派ファンタジー

orthodox fantasy

子供の頃、魔法やファンタジーの世界が好きだった人にドンピシャの作品。ペンの描き込みで陰影をつける手描きタッチの画風も作品とマッチしていて素晴らしいです。ただ、世界観は凝ってるものの、ストーリーには少し物足りなさを感じました。

This work was written by Don Pisha for people who loved the world of magic and fantasy when they were kids. The hand-drawn touch style, which is shaded by drawing with a pen, also matches the work, and is wonderful. However, although the view of the world is elaborate, I felt that the story was a bit unsatisfactory.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 07, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が好きです。

I like the picture.

物語の雰囲気にあった、絵が好きです。丁寧に書かれていて、話もワクワクします。

I like the picture, which fits the atmosphere of the story. It's carefully written, and the story is exciting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

絵が綺麗で話も面白い！おとぎ話を見てるような、絵本を読んでるような気持ちになります

The pictures are beautiful and the story is interesting! It makes me feel like I'm watching a fairy tale or reading a picture book

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい?

interesting?

内容がよくできている。とても面白く、読みやすく早く続きがよみたくなる

The content is well done. It's very interesting, easy to read, and makes me want to read the continuation quickly

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がすごく綺麗

The picture is so beautiful

キャラも立ってるし絵も綺麗で読んでて楽しい。魔法の設定も細かくてリアルなので実際に存在してそうでよい。これからますます楽しみです。

The characters are standing, and the pictures are beautiful, so it's fun to read. The magic settings are also detailed and realistic, so it seems like they actually exist. I'm looking forward to it even more.

Helpful

Reviews for Witch Hat Atelier Manga