Nina the Starry Bride Manga Reviews (P.42)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

11巻まで読了

Read up to 11 volumes

This review contains spoilers. 大好きな世界観で気になっていた作品だったので購入しました。ニナの行動力はとても主人公らしくて、気持ちがいいです。周りのみんなを前向きに変える力があるところが好きで読んでいました。しかしまた物語が大きく動いた11巻、自分を貫いて進んでいたニナが、自分を信じられなくなってしまい…ここからニナがどのように生きていくのかが気になります。アズとセトも、変わってしまったニナとまたどうやって関わっていくのか……。

This review contains spoilers. It was a work I was interested in because of my favorite worldview, so I bought it. Nina's ability to act is very similar to that of the main character, and it feels good. I was reading it because I liked the fact that it has the power to positively change everyone around me. However, in volume 11, where the story moved drastically, Nina, who was progressing through herself, can't believe in herself... I'm curious about how Nina will live from here on out. How will As and Seto get involved again with Nina, who has changed...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い！がんばれ❣️

cute! Good luck ❣️

私も頑張らねば、と思います。人に必要とされるとうれしいし、がんばれます。主人公には幸せになってほしいです。コミック出てるから、購入します?

I think I have to do my best too. I'm happy when people need me, and I do my best. I want the main character to be happy. the comic is out, so are you going to buy it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

考えさせられる

It makes me think

余計なものを削ぎ落としたテンポの良いプロットでどんどん読んでしまいます。国家とは何か、権力とは何かを考えさせられる作品だと感じます。

I read more and more with a well-paced plot that cut out unnecessary stuff. I feel that it is a work that makes you think about what a nation is and what power is.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

キャラクターが魅力的

The characters are attractive

アズ派セト派に分かれるの納得です。本当に魅力的なキャラが多いです。私は特にセトとソルがお気に入りです。申し訳ないけど主人公にはちょっとイライラしました。あっちにふらふらこっちにふらふら、考えなしに行動して周りを引っ掻き回すのになぜか愛されキャラ、星の民のチカラゆえなんでしょうか。

I'm convinced that they split into the Azu faction and the Seto faction. There are a lot of really attractive characters. I particularly like Seto and Sol. I'm sorry, but I was a little frustrated with the main character. I wonder if it's because of the power of the star people who are loved for some reason even though they wobble around here and wobble around, acting without thinking.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が可愛いが、おとぎ話

The picture is cute, but it's a fairy tale

孤児だったヒロインが王族にというシンデレラストーリーなのは良いとしても、いとも簡単に皆の心を掴めるのはおとぎ話が過ぎるなーと思ってたら、特殊能力の設定だったんですね。悪気なく2人の王子を振り回す辺りは、年齢設定からすると幼過ぎるように思います。もう少し大人の女性というか、リアリティあるヒロイン設定だと尚好きになったと思います。15歳の心ある女子ならもっと苦しむ筈ですよね…絵は可愛いし、ニナとアズ以外は人物像もブレを感じないし、好きな人が多い作品である事には納得です。

Even though it's a good Cinderella story where the heroine, who was an orphan, goes to the royal family, it was a special ability setting when I thought that there would be too many fairy tales to win everyone's hearts so easily. I think the area of swinging around the two princes without offense is too young in terms of age settings. I think I fell in love with it even more if it was a slightly more mature woman, or rather a realistic heroine setting. A 15-year-old girl with a heart must suffer even more... the picture is cute, the characters don't feel blurry other than Nina and As, and I'm convinced that it's a work that many people like.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん買いです。

The author is buying it.

This review contains spoilers. 明治シリーズが大好きだったので、その流れでレビューします。別作品なので、混同しちゃダメなんですが。アズ→津軽(王道のヒーローキャラ)セト→春時(過去に闇があるキャラ)かなぁと思います。何となく顔も似てる。明治シリーズでは身を引いた春時キャラのセトが、ヒロインと結ばれても良いと思います。アズの過去がセトより辛かったなんて、どれだけ過酷でも後付け感があるかな。当時春時派の一読者より。☆-１は、結局明治シリーズのそのままの結末になるかなと思ってしまいました。スッキリできる形でエンドでお願いいたします。

This review contains spoilers. I loved the Meiji series, so I'm going to review it in that way. It's a separate work, so don't mix them up. I think As → Tsugaru (royal hero character) Seto → Harutoki (character with darkness in the past). Somehow they look similar. I think Setto, a Haruji character who withdrew from the Meiji series, could be tied to the heroine. The fact that Azu's past was more painful than Seto is probably an afterthought no matter how tough it is. From one reader of the Haruji school at the time. I was wondering if ☆ -1 would eventually end up like the Meiji Series. Please end it in a way that makes you feel refreshed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

セト推しだけれども…！！

I recommend Seto, but...!!

久々に読んだ少女漫画でしたが面白かったです。セトendを期待したいですが1巻の表紙がアズニナなので作者さん的にはこの方向なんだろうなーとちょっと残念に思います。またキャラ設定を守っての事でしょうが姫のフリをしているのに敵国でも言葉遣いが粗暴なのがリアリティを薄く感じさせ、良い作品なのにチープな印象を受けてしまいます。心理描写は細やかで好きです。

It was the first girls' comic I read in a while, and it was interesting. I'd like to look forward to the set-end, but since the cover of volume 1 is Azunina, I'm a little disappointed that the author is probably going in this direction. Also, it's probably about protecting the character settings, but even though she's pretending to be a princess, the fact that the language is rough even in enemy countries makes me feel that reality is weak, and even though it's a good work, I get the impression that it's cheap. I like the detailed psychological descriptions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

王子かっこいいのにな

Even though the prince is cool

表紙の銀髪王子にひかれて読んでたのですが、最初はまだ読めたけど、、どういう展開なん？？てくらい奇想天外で、これ、、続けれるん？て不安になる。。私の好きな王子がとても良い子なのに、主人公クソでむかつくわ～ドタバタヒロインきらいやねん

I was reading it because I was drawn by Prince Silver Haired on the cover, but I was still able to read it at first, but what kind of developments are there?? It's so bizarre, can this... continue? It makes me anxious.. My favorite prince is a very nice kid, but the main character is so damn sick ~ I don't like slapstick heroines

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！けど…もやもやが

interesting! but... haze haze

This review contains spoilers. リカチ先生は単発で描いてた頃から画力がすごくて印象的で知ってましたが、今回何となく読んだところ、一気に最新巻まで読破してしまいました。面白いです！またタッチがファンタジーにマッチしている。ただ、私はセト推しなんですよ。だからセトを幸せにしてほしいのです。おまけに今の所アズールの方はかなり自分勝手に感じるので（フォルトナ国はもっと勝手ですね？）、少々モヤモヤしております。11巻以降に期待してます。

This review contains spoilers. I've known that Mr. Licachi's drawing ability is amazing and impressive since he was drawing one-off, but when I somehow read it this time, I read through the latest volume in one fell swoop. It's interesting! Also, the touch matches fantasy. However, I recommend Seto. That's why I want Seto to be happy. What's more, I feel like Azure is pretty selfish right now (Fortuna country is even more selfish, right?) I'm a little confused. I'm looking forward to volume 11 or later.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

一気にまとめて読みました

I read them all at once

最初は、おもてになる女は罪作りだねぇなんて思ったけど、そんな簡単な話じゃなかった！結末が予想できない！次刊が楽しみです！

At first, I thought the hostess was making a crime, but it wasn't that simple! I can't predict the ending! I'm looking forward to the next edition!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

どっちなの⁉️

Which one ⁉️

This review contains spoilers. ニナ！あなたどっちを選ぶの⁉️フラフラしてるから二人の男が傷付くのよ⁉️でも他の方のレビューにもありますが、アズには「恋」でセトには「愛」。別出版社の某作品のヒロインもこんな感じだったなと思い出してみて、やはり最後は「恋」なのではないかなと。愛は親愛も含むので。ニナの母性愛という意味になるかな？でもセトも幸せになってほしい。でもやっぱり私はアズが最初からの推しなのでアズニナで。だけど王様だから仕方ないけど、新刊での対応はまさに悪手だよ、アズ。ニナも心配だし、続きが気になります！→普段はコミックス待ちますが、今回待てずに本誌買いました。セト派の皆さんは当然のこと、アズ派（私もです）の皆さんもセトにやられるのではないでしょうか。弱ってるニナにはたまらないと思う。気になる方はぜひ本誌をご確認ください。語彙力は霧散するあのセトは。

This review contains spoilers. Nina! Which one do you choose ⁉️ the two men get hurt because they're flustering ⁉️ but there are reviews from other people, but there are “love” for As and “love” for set. I remember that the heroine of a certain work by another publishing company was like this, and I think the last one was “love.” Because love also includes affectionate love. Does it mean Nina's maternal love? But I want Seto to be happy too. But after all, I recommended As from the beginning, so I went with Aznina. But since he's the king, it can't be helped, but dealing with the new issue is just bad, az. Nina is worried too, and I'm worried about the continuation! →I usually wait for comics, but this time I couldn't wait and bought this magazine. Everyone in the Seto faction is a matter of course, and I think everyone in the Azu faction (me too) will also be beaten by Seto. I think it would be irresistible for Nina, who is weak. If you are interested, be sure to check out this magazine. That set will blow up your vocabulary.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

セトと幸せになって欲しい

I want them to be happy with Seto

This review contains spoilers. この作者さんは、さすがお話を作るのがうまいですね。絵もやっぱり可愛い。上手い。黒髪男子派ですが、圧倒的にセト派です。セトにはニナしかいない。セトと幸せになって欲しいけれど、この作者さんはいつも私にモヤモヤをくれるので、セトとくっつかないんだろうな。と思いつつ課金してしまっています。セトとくっつかなかったら悲しい。

This review contains spoilers. As expected, this author is good at making stories. After all, the pictures are cute too. good. They are black haired boys, but they are overwhelmingly Seto. Nina is the only one in Seto. I want them to be happy with Seto, but this author always makes me confused, so I guess I won't stick with Seto. I made a charge while thinking about it. It would be sad if it didn't stick with Seto.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

アズールの存在が4番手位に感じる

I feel that Azure is in 4th place

セトがいい男すぎて、アズールの器の小ささとか不安定さがヒロインに相応しくないと思う。やっぱりセトとくっ付いて欲しいわ

He's a man with too good a set, and I don't think Azure's small size or instability is suitable for the heroine. I want them to stick with Seto after all

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

どうなるの?

what's going to happen?

最初は『よくある王国ファンタジーかぁ』と読み始めました。1巻ではそうでもなかったんですが、2巻から面白くなります!王様〜笑顔の裏はこんなに黒かったか。人として大切なものが欠落しているので、上にたつ人ではなかったですね。これをどうやって切り崩し、変えていくのか？、作画も綺麗で先が楽しみな作品です。

At first, I started reading “Common Kingdom Fantasy, huh?” That wasn't the case in volume 1, but it gets interesting from volume 2! King ~ was the back of his smile this black? He wasn't a superior person because he was missing something important as a human being. How are we going to cut this down and change it? The drawing is also beautiful, and it's a work I'm looking forward to.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

きらきら

sparkly

とても綺麗な作品。ニナの装飾、小物が何もかも可愛らしくて美しい。上質なファンタジーでとても好きです。

Very beautiful work. Nina's decorations and accessories are all cute and beautiful. It's a high quality fantasy and I really like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

ワクワクする話です。読者を置いて行かないで説明もきちんとしてくれるのがありがたいです。絵も可愛いしこれからも楽しみにしています。

It's an exciting story. I'm thankful that the explanations are correct without leaving readers behind. The pictures are cute and I'm looking forward to them from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

セト推し

Seto's recommendation

ニナは事故死したアリシャの代わりにアズの嫁になるために修行をするが、結局国のためにセトの国に行くことになり、、、セト推しです。人間らしい感情を持つためには、ニナが側にいてほしいと願うばかり、、、

Nina does ascetic practice to become Azu's wife in place of Alisha, who died in an accident, but in the end, she went to Seto Province for her country... I recommend Seto. In order to have human-like feelings, I just want Nina to be by my side...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

大人も楽しめるおとぎ話のようです

It's like a fairy tale that adults can enjoy

ストーリーの根幹はお姫様1人と王子様2人の三角関係という王道なんですが。3人それぞれのバックボーンが重くて切ないです。得にセトのは辛い。でもそれらがお話に厚みを持たせていて、単なるラブストーリーの枠を超えて引き込まれてしまいます。まだ5巻までしか読んでませんが、私は今のところはアズ派です。これは読者それぞれに好みが別れるところだと思いますが…。ニナが最後にどちらを選ぶのか？それとも違う選択肢が用意されているのか…？ラストまで見守りたいと思います。

The root of the story is the royal love triangle between a princess and two princes. The backbones of each of the 3 people are heavy and sad. It's hard to get the best of it. But they add depth to the story, and they draw you in beyond the boundaries of a simple love story. I've only read up to 5 volumes, but so far I'm in the Azu group. I think this is where each reader has their own preferences... Which one will Nina choose in the end? Or are there other options available...? I would like to keep an eye on it until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

不幸な星の下

Beneath an Unfortunate Star

This review contains spoilers. そんな切ない言葉をまだ子供たちが発するって悲しいね。最初からなんとなくニナは女の子かなぁって思ってたら、やっぱり女の子だった。身代わりでもなんでもいいから幸せになってほしいね。

This review contains spoilers. It's sad that kids are still uttering such sad words. I was wondering if Nina was a girl right from the beginning, but she was definitely a girl. I want them to be happy because anything is fine, even if it's a substitute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

先が気になる

I'm worried about the future

ニナとかアズの生い立ちとかニナがアズを思ってわざわざ敵国に嫁ぎに行くシーンうるうるしますよね。さてどんな転末が待っているのでしょう。

Scenes like Nina and Azu's upbringing and Nina go out of their way to get married to an enemy country are exciting, aren't they? So what kind of consequences await us?

Helpful

Reviews for Nina the Starry Bride Manga