As a Reincarnated Aristocrat, I'll Use My Appraisal Skill to Rise in the World Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

う〜ん…？

hmm...?

私には合わないです。高評価が不自然に感じました。流れが安直というか短絡的というか…作り込みが甘い的な…？武将の例えなど無駄に思うところも多々ありました。絵は基本綺麗ですが、その分たまにある人物の作画崩壊と思うところが目立ってしまうような…この絵柄にもっと合うお話が読みたいとは思いました。

It doesn't suit me. The high ratings felt unnatural. the flow is straightforward or short-circuited... the construction is sweet...? There were many places where I thought the example of a warlord was useless. The pictures are basically beautiful, but I wanted to read a story that was more suited to this pattern, where I sometimes think that the drawing collapse of a certain character is conspicuous...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

5巻時点で

As of volume 5

容疑者の気配は全く無いであります！最初の数ページでの横顔を見た時は読むの止めようかと思ったでありますが読んでよかったと思えるであります！登場人物は皆かっこよくいい話が多いであります！元ネタ？のゲームはやったことないでありますが人材発掘していく話であります！

There is absolutely no sign of a suspect! When I saw the profile on the first few pages, I thought I'd stop reading it, but I think I'm glad I read it! The characters are all cool and there are so many great stories! original story? I've never played the game, but it's a story about finding human resources!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読む度ワクワクする！

I get excited every time I read it!

This review contains spoilers. 可愛い絵柄。文字も多く読み応えがあり補足説明もわかりやすく入り込みやすい。差別問題の最中にいるキャラクターもご都合主義の異人族ではなく人間でリアルに描かれていて考えさせられた。足りない所を素直に認め悩み成り上がっていく姿も応援したくなる。

This review contains spoilers. A cute pattern. There are many characters that are easy to read, and the supplementary explanations are easy to understand and easy to get into. It made me think that the characters in the midst of a discrimination issue were also realistically depicted as humans, not from a different race based on convenience. I also want to cheer for the sight of them honestly admitting what is lacking and getting worried.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 自分は強くないが、人のスキルが見えてそれぞれの適正に合った場を提供していく。そして将来領主として良い街にしようと人材を集め今の状況を変えていこうと奮闘する。大人から転生してるとは言え3歳児の発言としては無理はあるものの、それぞれのスキルが発揮されるとみんな納得していく。色々なスキルの人が集まってパワーアップしていくので楽しく読めます！

This review contains spoilers. I'm not strong, but I can see people's skills and provide a place that suits their suitability. Then they gather human resources and struggle to change the current situation in order to make it a good city as a feudal lord in the future. Although it is impossible for a 3-year-old to say even though they have been reincarnated as adults, everyone is convinced when their skills are demonstrated. People with various skills gather and power up, so it's fun to read!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

成り上がり

The rise

This review contains spoilers. スキル真眼を隠していて3歳から文学を学んでいて歩兵の適している弓をあて差別されいる人種など関係なく才能のある人を探していたら、まるで織田信長のような非の打ち所が無い才能の高さで最強とうたわれる領主に勝ち時期領主の最強の家臣になるそして「ああああああぁぁぁぁ」や「うわー」な展開が多くわくわくする

This review contains spoilers. If you're looking for talented people regardless of race, etc., who hide their serious skills and are discriminated against by hitting a bow suitable for infantry, etc., you can win against the feudal lord who is said to be the strongest with an impeccable level of talent like Oda Nobunaga, become the lord's strongest vassal during the period, and it's exciting to have a lot of “ah ah ah ah” and “wow” developments

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

長い目で。。。

in the long run...

途中までは良かったんだけど徐々に失速していく感じがしました。3巻くらいまではよかったです。領主としての活躍ストーリーになって以降が物足りない気がします。成長しても主人公の挙動が頼りないのも魅力が半減かな。ストーリーの見せ方、描き方の問題かと思います。設定は面白いのでもう少し展開を見守ろうと思います。

It was good until halfway through, but I felt like it gradually stalled. It was good up to about 3 volumes. I feel like the story of his activities as a feudal lord wasn't enough after that. The appeal of not being able to rely on the main character's behavior even when growing up is probably cut in half. I think it's a question of how to show and draw a story. The setting is interesting, so I'll keep an eye on how it unfolds.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです(☆5→☆4…絵の関係)

I like it (☆ 5→ ☆ 4... picture relationship)

This review contains spoilers. 1巻がでたときからずっと買ってます。区切りのいいところまできたのでレビューします。途中までは☆3～☆4(知略の人や婚約者の話とか)くらいだったのでまだレビューやめていましたが、巻を追うごとに面白くなります。4巻で最初の回収があります。4巻までは面白かったけど5巻では新たな話があるので「地名」と「名前」を覚えておかないと何の話してるのかわからなくなります。一区切り後あらたな話になる系は苦手ですがこれに関してはどう成り上がっていくのか楽しみですし成り上がり先がようやく表示されたのが明確で良いです。(もう少し上に行くかもですが。)5巻の新キャラの女性は豪快タイプでちょっと苦手です…。でも野望が高いのが明かされるのが楽しみです。今のところ買い続けていて続きが待ち遠しくなります。出る周期は遅すぎないですが早くもないです。次の巻で演習終わればいいですが7巻まで演習続くようならちょっと評価考えます。絵は綺麗ですが時々崩れます。【追記】話は面白いのに、絵がめっちゃ進化して……私としては雑な進化をしたように感じました。リーツさんが(成長したとはいえ)目が細くなり、手癖みたいな描き方のときにエロ目に見えるのとか前は髪の毛の光が綺麗だったのに黒白(しかも白がかなり多い)になってしまったのとかが特に残念です。新キャラのムーシャは2000年代アニメみたいな顔に見えます。

This review contains spoilers. I've been buying volume 1 ever since it came out. I've come to a point where the separation is good, so I'll review it. Halfway through, it was about ☆ 3 to ☆ 4 (stories about intelligent people and fiancé), so I hadn't reviewed it yet, but it became interesting as I followed the volume. There is an initial collection in volume 4. Up to volume 4 was interesting, but there are new stories in volume 5, so if you don't remember “place names” and “names,” you won't know what they're talking about. I'm not good at the series where it becomes a new story after a break, but I'm looking forward to seeing how it develops, and it's nice that the story is finally displayed clearly. (It might go a little higher though.) The female character in volume 5 is an exciting type and I'm a little bad at it... But I'm looking forward to it being revealed that my ambitions are high. I've been buying it so far and I can't wait for the rest. The exit cycle isn't too late, but it's not fast either. It would be nice if I finished the exercises in the next volume, but if the exercises continue until volume 7, I'll think about the evaluation for a moment. The picture is beautiful, but sometimes it falls apart. [EDIT] The story was interesting, but the picture evolved a lot... I felt like it had a rough evolution. It's particularly unfortunate that Reetz's eyes have become narrower (even though she has grown up), and she looks erotic when drawing like a habit, or that her hair turned black and white (and there is quite a lot of white) even though the light of her hair was beautiful before. The new character, Musa, looks like a 2000s anime.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです。

That was interesting.

他にはないストーリーだったのでとても面白く、話にどんどん引き込まれました。続きが出るのが楽しみです。

It was a story like no other, so it was very interesting, and I was drawn more and more into the story. I'm looking forward to the continuation coming out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

ちょっと先を急ぎすぎて話が薄くなってる感はありますが、好感の持てるキャラばかりなので、安心して読めます。

There is a feeling that I've rushed a little too far and the story is getting thinner, but there are only characters I like, so I can read it without worry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

うーん、どうしょぉー…

Hmm, what do you do...

線が堅くて、また子どもの主人公の幼い顔が…髪型のせいもあるのか、短冊？が並んでるように見えてしまって…大人はそんなことはないんだけど…(困汗)もはや30代の日本人が転生して前世の記憶があるのは関係ない？だけど……意味はあるのかしらん？しかし、それは横に置いといて、物語には引き込まれてしまい、少しずつ購入していこうと思っていたところ、結局、続きが気になって…出てる分、一気買いしちまったぜ！迷って、星４つに…リーツくん推しです♡続き、待ってます！

The lines are stiff, and the child protagonist's young face... maybe because of his hairstyle, tanzaku? It looks like they're lined up... adults aren't like that... (sweaty) doesn't it matter that Japanese people in their 30s have reincarnated and have memories of their previous lives? But... I wonder if it makes sense? However, I left it on the side, and I was drawn into the story, and when I was thinking of buying it little by little, I ended up wondering about the continuation... so I bought it all at once as it came out! I got lost and got 4 stars... I recommend Ritz ♡ continue, I'm waiting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

主要キャラがかわいい

The main characters are cute

主要キャラ4人中2人は頭のいいショタ、1人は口の悪い魔法最強美少女、もう1人は色黒の物腰柔らかなイケメン。みんなかわいいです。物語としてはこれから動き出す感じかな？

Of the 4 main characters, 2 are smart Shota, 1 is a good-natured, beautiful girl with the strongest magic, and the other is a dark-skinned good-looking guy with a soft demeanor. Everyone is so cute. As a story, it feels like it's about to start moving forward?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

設定やストーリーが面白い！

The setting and story are interesting!

転生ものはあまり読んだことがないのですが、とても面白かったです！絵も綺麗で分かりやすく、あっという間に最新刊まで購入してしまいました。物語の展開は割と早めです。少し気になるのは、主人公の母が出てこないことです。死別しているのかと思いきや、そうではないのに何故か登場しない。重要人物ではないのでしょうが、全く描かれないと何だかモヤッとします。また、台詞の言い回しに違和感を覚えるところがいくつかあります。原作者の書下ろし小説を読むと文章の粗さや言葉遣いに注意が向いて、話の内容が頭に入ってきませんでした。漫画になっているから楽しく物語に没頭できましたが、原作を読むことはないかなと思い★4つにしました。重ねて言いますが、設定やストーリーはとても面白かったです。続刊を楽しみにしています。

I haven't read much about reincarnation, but it was really interesting! The pictures were beautiful and easy to understand, and I bought the latest edition in no time. The story unfolds relatively quickly. What bothers me a bit is that the main character's mother doesn't appear. I wonder if they have been widowed, but even though that's not the case, they don't appear for some reason. He's probably not an important person, but it's kind of confusing when he's not depicted at all. Also, there are a few places where I feel uncomfortable with the wording of the lines. When I read a novel written by the original author, I paid attention to the roughness of the sentences and wording, and the content of the story didn't come into my head. Since it's a comic, I was able to enjoy immersing myself in the story, but I thought I'd read the original story ★ I made it 4. Again, the setting and story were really interesting. I'm looking forward to the next publication.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

転生チートたけど自分の工夫で進んでいくタイプのチートだからチート無双タイプじゃなく新しい(๑•̀ㅁ•́๑)✧

It's a reincarnation cheat, but since it's a type of cheat that progresses with one's own ingenuity, it's not a Warriors type, it's new (••) ✧

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

不覚にも、泣いてしまった！！

Unbeknownst to me, I cried!!

This review contains spoilers. 特に細かい設定とかもなく、よくある異世界ものだと読み始めたが最後、新刊購入までしてしまった！！そして、ちょいちょい泣いてしまうシーンがある！！！主人公が小さい男の子だと興味ないなぁっと思っていたら、月日がたち、成長してる！！側近たちも見た目や技術の成長が楽しく、読んでて続きが気になる！

This review contains spoilers. There were no particularly detailed settings, and I started reading that it was a common Isekai thing, but in the end, I even bought a new edition!! Also, there is a scene where I cry a little bit!!! When I thought that the main character was a little boy I wouldn't be interested, the months and days have passed, and he's growing up!! My close aides also enjoyed the appearance and technical growth, and I'm curious about the continuation as I read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まとめ買いしました

I bought them in bulk

This review contains spoilers. 転生系ですが、この手の話は初めてでとてもテンポよく読めました。気になるのが最新刊までの間に父親は沢山出て来るのに、母親に触れる回数少なすぎでは。と少し思いました。

This review contains spoilers. It's a reincarnation series, but it was my first time to read this kind of story and I was able to read it at a very good tempo. What bothers me is that the father comes up a lot until the latest publication, yet he touches his mother too few times. I thought that for a moment.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

いいねー

That's good

歴史好きにも異世界ずきにもマッチしていて、個人的にはありです。

It's a perfect match for both history lovers and Zuki from Another World, and I personally love it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

なんとなく

somehow

主人公が子供なのに？大人の思考で鑑定を使いながら頑張ってる姿は健気です。

Even though the main character is a child? The sight of them doing their best while using appraisals with adult thoughts is healthy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

見所がある

There is something to see

This review contains spoilers. 主人公は、戦う力は無いけど、その代わりに人のステータスを見ることが出きる。それで優秀な人材をスカウトして力をつける。これはこれで面白い。許嫁も特殊能力をもってるって設定が良いです。読んで損はないと、個人的に思った。

This review contains spoilers. The main character doesn't have the power to fight, but instead he sees people's stats. Then they scout excellent human resources and gain strength. This is interesting. The setting is good because the fiancee also has special abilities. I personally thought there would be no harm in reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろいです

It's interesting

鑑定スキルで最高の人材を手に入れていくのは楽しいです。ただ説得するための台詞や思考が、あまりにも年齢とかけ離れていて・・・（確かに中身は大人だけど）。

It's fun to get the best talent with appraisal skills. The lines and thoughts to just persuade are so far from my age... (although the content is certainly an adult).

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良作！！

good work!!

「鑑定ね。はいはいありがちですね。」と思っていたら、設定はありがちでもストーリーがめちゃくちゃしっかりしてました！試し読みから一気に既刊全巻(5巻まで)買ってしまいました‼ロセル君の回は泣けた?鑑定したステータスを歴史上の偉人に例えるところと、ステータスの見方が読者に伝わりづらく、若干ついて行けない感があるので⭐︎マイナス1です。人タラシでみんな主人公が好きなハーレム状態だけれど、自分のステータスが見れないからこその葛藤もちゃんと描かれていて良き！！

“It's an appraisal. Yes, yes, it's common.” When I thought about it, the story was insanely solid, even though the settings tend to be there! I bought all the volumes already published (up to 5 volumes) all at once from the trial reading ‼ Did Roselle's episode make you cry? The appraised status is compared to a great person in history, and the way they look at the status is difficult to convey to readers, and there is a feeling that they can't follow along ⭐ ︎ minus 1. It's a harem where everyone likes the main character in Hitorashi, but it's nice that the conflict that comes from not being able to see one's own stats is also properly depicted!!

Helpful

Reviews for As a Reincarnated Aristocrat, I'll Use My Appraisal Skill to Rise in the World Manga