THE MIDWIFE'S CHILD Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

障害はヒロインだけ

The only obstacle is the heroine

This review contains spoilers. 一夜だけ出会った二人が六年後に再会するシークレットベビーもの。ヒーローとヒーローの家族が温かくて包容力があって本当に素敵な人たちでした。六年前のことや子供のことを黙っていたことを理解してくれて、サプライズでヒロインのバースデーパーティ開いてくれて、ヒロインと子供が住んでた雨漏りボロ家の修理をしてくれて、勝手な誤解をしてヒーローを傷つけたヒロインを何も言わず受け入れてくれるというまさに至れり尽くせり。対してヒロインの自己卑下が頑なすぎたかな。過去父親に否定され続けたという酌量の余地はあるにせよヒーローがなだめてもなだめても頑固で…。とりあえずヒロインがヒーローに言ったこの一言に尽きます。「ずっとあなたを信じてればよかったのに」子供はすっごく可愛かったです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a secret baby thing where two people who only met for one night reunite six years later. The hero and the hero's family were warm and tolerant, and they were really wonderful people. They understood that it was six years ago and that they kept quiet about children, held the heroine's birthday party as a surprise, repaired the rain-leaking dilapidated house where the heroine and child lived, and accepted the heroine who hurt the hero through selfish misunderstandings without saying anything. On the other hand, I wonder if the heroine's self-deprecation was too stubborn. Even though there is room for extenuating that his father continued to deny him in the past, the hero is stubborn no matter how appeased or appeased... For now, it's all about this one word the heroine said to the hero. “I wish I had believed in you the whole time.” The kid was sooo cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 20, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

絵が綺麗で、話しもハッピーで良かったです！また続きを見たい作品です！

I'm glad the pictures were beautiful and the conversation was happy! I want to see the continuation of this work again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 01, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

暖かいお話

A warm story

ヒーローがとにかく優しくて大きくてカッコいいです！ヒーローの家族も暖かい。一途に愛されてるヒロインが羨ましいです～！

The hero is just so kind, big, and cool! The hero's family is also warm. I envy the heroine who is so loved!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです。

That was great.

絵の美しさにひかれて読みました。ストーリーもとてもよかったと思います。

I was fascinated by the beauty of the picture and read it. I think the story was very good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

乙女の妄想そのままのような

It's like leaving the maiden's delusion as it is

This review contains spoilers. 女性がキュンと来る要素が沢山盛り込まれた、王道だけどとても良い作品でした。女性の生い立ちが可哀想でしたが、こういう家庭はに育った人は意外と多いのではと思いました。言葉の暴力でも子どもはとても傷つくものですよね。対照的に温かい家庭に育った相手を受け入れるのに時間がかかったり、疑ってしまうのはすごくよくわかるし共感しました。最終的にはハッピーエンドでおすすめです。

This review contains spoilers. It was a classic but very good work that included a lot of elements that would make women feel excited. The woman's upbringing was pitiful, but I thought there were surprisingly many people who grew up in families like this. Even verbal violence hurts children very much, doesn't it? In contrast, I understood very well and sympathized with the fact that it takes time to accept and doubt someone who grew up in a warm family. Ultimately, I recommend it with a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ありえないほどハッピーエンド

An unbelievably happy ending

さすがハーレクインロマンスですね、女性のツボを心得てる^_^こんなの現実に無いよって思うけど読んだ後ニヤケてしまうほどハッピーエンドでした。

As expected, it's a Harlequin romance, I know women's pressure points ^_^ I don't think this is real, but it had such a happy ending that I smirked after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公のトラウマが癒された

The main character's trauma has been healed

This review contains spoilers. 子どもの頃のトラウマはキツイ。でも、それが癒されていくサマがすごくよかった。すでに愛する人との間の息子トニーの存在によって、癒され始めていたのね。子どもがいるハーレクインもいいなぁ。(^｡^)

This review contains spoilers. The trauma of being a child was severe. But it was really nice that it healed me. You've already begun to be healed by the presence of your son Tony with someone you love. Harlequins with kids are nice too. (^.^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

もう

anymore

This review contains spoilers. 感動しました！１夜限りの･･･。でも、お互い思い合っていて･･･。

This review contains spoilers. I'm impressed! For one night only... But we both cared for each other...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

悲しみから救い出す王子になろうと決めた

I decided to be the prince who rescues me from sorrow

98ページと、100ページが、この作品の私の感動ポイント。望まれない子供であったことを苦悩の素とする設定は多いけれど、この話は、ヒロインが、そんな自分の育った環境を子供には味合わせたくない、その動機一本だけで彼への連絡を絶つ。もしかしたら、どうなるのかは、まず試しの一歩踏み出していかなきゃわからないことでしょうに。。。苦しませたくないと言いながら、ヒロインは息子を父なし児で育て、子どもが得られたかもしれない父子交流の喜びをも遠ざけてしまい、子どもが不憫だったと私は思う。父親の権利云々もあるが、まず子供のために動いてみるべきだったと思う。その後に、駄目だと判断すればその時はその時なのでは。でも、世の中にはそんな一方的な理由で行動する人がいないとは言えない。苛っとするが、そういう話。責任とって結婚、それが、「遊び」の代償、若さゆえの過ちというのは、新しくもない話。責任は責任で、腹を括って向き合うべきだったのに、最後まで責任を取りきれたとは100%言えないヒロインの父が、最も悪い。このストーリーのヒロインは、はじめの出会いも、妊娠も、隠そうとすることも、とどめの、責任取る云々も、全て全てが、全部独りよがり。それを生育環境のせいにするのは、話の成り立ち上仕方ないけれども、彼も子供も一種の被害者。子供にとり悪い父に実際彼がなるのか先のことは分からない、賭けのようなものだ。順序よく結婚後に父親になっても、いい父になれてるかどうかはその時知れる、というケースもある。忘れられない一夜の相手、それがために六年前真剣に探し回り、そしてなおその後も忘れなかった彼の熱意がそのまま、ストーリーを一本貫いている。彼が、ヒロインの突っ張りに怯まないのは、6年もかかった末だから今更慌てないのか、彼女の瞳の奥に見抜いた、「帰れる場所を探している/子供みたいに」が彼の心を留めているのか。パーティに出てよかったね、と、結末から逆引きで喜べるが、探していたときには発見できず、HQあるあるの偶然の再会が二人の運命を動かす、というところに、出会えなかったかもしれない可能性のほうの高さを想像してしまう。絵柄は私好みだが、彼のお母さんが年齢不詳で、ヒロインと並ぶと姉妹に見えるのは、一家の温かさや男性ばかりの家庭にはなんとなく違和感を覚えた。ただ、彼を育んだ彼の生家はヒロインには神家族。

The 98 pages and 100 pages are my moving points of this work. There are many settings where the fact that she was an unwanted child is a source of distress, but in this story, the heroine doesn't want to taste the environment she grew up in with the child, and she cuts off contact with him with just one motive. Maybe you won't know what's going to happen until you take the first step of testing... While saying she didn't want to make her suffer, I think the heroine grew up with her son without a father and kept away from the joy of father-son interaction that the child might have obtained, and the child was pitiful. Fathers' rights are also there, but I think they should have acted for their children first. After that, if you decide that it's no good, that time will probably be that time. However, it cannot be said that there are no people in the world who act for such one-sided reasons. It's irritating, but that's the kind of story. Marrying responsibly, the cost of “play,” and mistakes due to youth is a story that is nothing new. Responsibility is responsibility, and the heroine's father, who can't say 100% that she was able to take responsibility until the end even though they should have faced it with a full stomach, is the worst. The heroine in this story is all on her own, from her first encounter, her pregnancy, her attempts to hide it, and to end up taking responsibility. Blaming it on the environment where they grew up is unavoidable, but both he and the child are a kind of victim. It's like a gamble with no idea whether he will actually become a bad father for a child or not. There are also cases where even if you become a father after marriage in good order, you can tell at that time whether or not you have become a good father. An unforgettable partner for one night, he seriously searched for it six years ago, and his enthusiasm, which he never forgot even after that, continues throughout the story. The reason he isn't frightened by the heroine's thrill is that it took 6 years, so isn't he even more in a hurry now, or is “looking for a place to return to/like a kid,” which he saw through the back of her eyes, holding his heart? I'm glad I went to the party, and I'm glad I went backwards from the ending, but I couldn't find it when I was looking for it, and I imagine the possibility that they might not have met is higher in the place where a chance reunion with HQ Aru moves the fate of the two. I like the design, but his mother's age is unknown, and the fact that they look like sisters along with the heroine made me feel somewhat uncomfortable with the warmth of a family and a family full of men. However, his birthplace where he was raised is the heroine's family.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

純愛

pure love

This review contains spoilers. 出逢った日のたった一夜の関係なのに、長い間お互いの心に居続け、子供まで授かったなんて本当に奇跡。とにかくヒーローが根気強い。ヒロインを捜し続けたのもそうだし、再会してからのヒロインへの接し方もヒロインが本当に大切だからでしょう。終始素敵なストーリーでした。

This review contains spoilers. It's really a miracle that they stayed in each other's hearts for a long time, even though they only had a one-night relationship on the day we met. Anyway, the hero is patient. That's probably because they kept searching for the heroine, and it's probably because the heroine really matters how to treat the heroine after they meet again. It was a wonderful story from beginning to end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

(*≧∀≦*)

(*≥∀≤*)

This review contains spoilers. 一番好きな作品！！一目惚れに一夜の関係から妊娠はハーレクインにはありがちな作品ですが、ヒーローの一途さや家族の温かさ、奇跡的に再会してからのヒロインの葛藤あり、それを見守るヒーローの優しさが良い(*^^*)絵も綺麗で読みやすい。何度も読み返してしまう位好きです。後１つワガママを言えば、ウエディングドレス姿やその後の幸せな姿まで見たかった?

This review contains spoilers. My favorite work!! Pregnancy from Love at First Sight is a work common among Harlequins, but there are conflicts between the hero, the warmth of the family, and the heroine's kindness after they miraculously meet again (*^^*) The pictures are also beautiful and easy to read. I like it so much that I reread it over and over again. Speaking of selfish one more thing, did you want to see them in their wedding dress and even their happy appearance after that?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がとっても美しかった

The picture was so beautiful

ハ―レクインの作品は、もう終わり？！と思うものも多いのですが、後半しっかり楽しませてくれる作品でした。また絵がいい！私はハマりました♪

Is Harlequin's work over yet?! There are a lot of things I think about, but it was a work that really entertained me in the second half. The picture is nice again! I'm addicted to it ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローが言うことない❗

Heroes have nothing to say ❗

ヒーローが素敵❗ヒロインの苦悩を受け入れて。まさにハーレクイン！

Heroes are wonderful ❗ Accept the heroine's suffering. Exactly Harlequin!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

お奨めです！！

I recommend it!!

自分の出生がトラウマで一夜を共にした男性から逃げてしまったヒロイン。そんなヒロインが忘れられずに、ずっと探していたヒーロー。こういう話ではヒーローかヒロインのどちらかには好感が持てない話が多いですが、この話の二人は、どちらにも好感がもてました。ドロドロした話ではなく、読んでいて暖かい気持ちになりました。

The heroine ran away from the man she spent the night with due to trauma from her birth. I can't forget that heroine, and the hero I've been looking for so long. There are many stories like this where I don't have a good impression of either the hero or the heroine, but the two people in this story were likable to both of them. It wasn't a muddy story, and it made me feel warm when I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

作品買い

Buying works

This review contains spoilers. 高井さんの作画作品にハズレなし！絵もストーリー展開も申し分ありません。基本大筋以外原作とは別物なので作画する方のセンスで読み応えに雲泥の差がでるハーレクインコミック…一夜の関係から子供が5歳になるまでをここまでまとめあげるのはさすがです。

This review contains spoilers. There is nothing wrong with Takai's drawing! Both the pictures and the storyline are perfect. Other than the basics, it's different from the original, so Harlequin comics where there is a huge difference in readability due to the sense of the person who drew it... it's really amazing to summarize everything from the one-night relationship until the child turns 5 years old.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が格別！

The picture is exceptional!

パーティーで出会って一晩を共にし、名前も知らないまま姿を消したシンデレラを探し続けるジェド。父親とのトラウマから素直になれないブルックとの恋の行方は。絵がとにかくきれい、ジェドの家族とブルックの家族の対比もストーリーをよりリアルにしていて、良かった。

Jed met at a party, spent the night together, and continues to search for Cinderella, who disappeared without even knowing her name. What is the whereabouts of her love with Brooke, who is unable to be honest due to her trauma with her father. The picture is absolutely beautiful, and the contrast between Jed's family and Brooke's family also made the story more realistic, which was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

６年も思い続けられるものなのか

Is it something I can keep thinking about for 6 years

幸せなお話でした。登場人物がみな優しい。一夜で子供ができて、誤解から別れていたという、ＨＱあるあるですが、満足です。現実には一度しかあったことのない女性を、目だけ見てそうとわかるなんて、あり得ないでしょうと突っ込みたくなりますが。

It was a happy story. The characters are all kind. They had a child overnight, and there is an HQ where they broke up due to misunderstandings, and I am satisfied. It makes me want to rush into a woman I've only met once in reality, thinking it would be impossible to understand just by looking at her eyes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

とても良いお話でした。6年もお互いに思い続けることができるなんて、現実にはなかなかないと思います。悪い人が出てこないので読みやすいです。

That was a very good story. In reality, I don't think it's easy to be able to keep thinking about each other for 6 years. It's easy to read because bad people don't come up.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーも絵も最高ランクのハーレクインです。なのに、何故、星５つじゃないのかと言うと、ヒロインがあまりにも卑屈過ぎてちょっと疲れちゃったから。生い立ちを考えれば分からなくはないんだけど、あまり好きなタイプのヒロインではなかった。でも反面、卑屈じゃなかったらこの話にはならないんですけども(笑)ヒーローは満点のヒーローです！包容力と忍耐力のあるヒーローで、ヒロインのマイナス思考を払拭してくれました！

This review contains spoilers. It's Harlequin, which has the highest ranking in terms of story and pictures. And yet, when it comes to why it's not 5 stars, it's because the heroine was so humble that I was a little tired. I don't know when you think about her upbringing, but she wasn't the type of heroine I really liked. But on the other hand, it wouldn't be this story if they weren't humble (laughs), but heroes are perfect heroes! A hero with inclusiveness and patience, she dispelled the heroine's negative thoughts!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

愛してる

I love you

こんなにヒロインの心を溶かすのに時間がかかるとは。なかなか、頑固なヒロインでした。ヒーローは最初から最後までブレないで愛を貫く姿勢がカッコ良。ヒーローの家族も温かくてステキ。

It would take such a long time to melt the heroine's heart. She was quite a stubborn heroine. The hero's attitude of penetrating love without blurring from beginning to end is cool. The hero's family is also warm and wonderful.

Helpful

Reviews for THE MIDWIFE'S CHILD Manga