Their Christmas Wish Come True Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

最初から最後まで優しいお話

A kind story from beginning to end

This review contains spoilers. このお話には嫌なやつが一切出て来ません。家族全員を亡くして莫大な遺産を相続し悲しみのどん底に居たヒーローと、恵まれない子供たちのためのサンタ協会を運営してるヒロインとの出会いから、互いを必要とし合うまでの日々が優しく暖かく描かれてる絵本のようなお話。村田先生の描くヒーローはハンサムだけどちょっとSっぽくて女性に冷たいから最初はハラハラしましたが、マイケルは最初から最後までずっと紳士的で優しく、明るさもあり、でも心の中にいつも悲しみを抱えてて、でも誰にも八つ当たりしない。なんていい男なんだ…としみじみ。カーステンは自分を動揺させ、簡単に寄付を集める魅力的なマイケルをちょっと憎らしいと思ってる。けど態度には出さないので二人の仲は拗れない。こちらもいい女だー！と思います。ラストの「こうあってほしい」エンディングまでの流れはキラキラと輝くようで、奇跡のように綺麗です。マイケルの莫大な遺産はこの先ずっとこの地区の子供たちのクリスマスを幸せなものにするために使われるのでしょう。

This review contains spoilers. Nothing bad comes up in this story. It's a picture book-like story that gently and warmly depicts every day from the encounter between the hero who lost his entire family and inherited an enormous inheritance and the heroine who runs the Santa Association for disadvantaged children until they need each other. Murata sensei's hero is handsome, but he's a little bit smug and cold to women, so it was jarring at first, but Michael is gentlemanly, kind, and bright from beginning to end, yet he always has sadness in his heart, yet he doesn't hit anyone in his heart. What a nice man... I really thought. Carsten upsets himself and finds Michael, the charming person who easily collects donations, a bit hates him. However, since they don't show any attitude, the relationship between the two is unrelenting. This is a nice woman too! I think so. The flow up to the end of “I Want It to Happen” at the end seems to sparkle brightly, and it's as beautiful as a miracle. Michael's huge legacy will probably be used to make Christmas happy for children in this district for a long time to come.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

心に灯がともる

A light shines in my heart

おきまりのハーレクイーンもいいけど　妬みや傷つけ合いも無い、皆自分の孤独や現実に向き合いながら前を向いている。そして愛を周りの人に分け合えるそんなお話です。

The usual Harley Queen is fine, but there is no jealousy or hurt each other, and everyone is looking forward while facing their own loneliness and reality. And it's a story where you can share your love with those around you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

サイコー！

awesome!

クリスマスの正しいお金の使い方。どんな無理でも聞いて貰えるわけでは無い、いくらクリスマスでも。その気持に沿うようにできるだけのことをする。1年間チョコチップクッキーが届く、には泣かされる。彼にはヒロインの存在が何よりのプレゼント

The right way to spend money at Christmas. No matter how difficult it is, it doesn't mean you can listen to it, no matter how much Christmas it is. I will do my best to match that feeling. It makes me cry when chocolate chip cookies arrive for 1 year. The presence of a heroine is the greatest gift for him

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

暖かい作品でした。

It was a warm work.

シンシンと雪が降る光景が浮かびました。優しい作品です。メインキャラの二人は激しい性格でもないし、どちらかというと、おっとりし感じだし、クリスマスがテーマなので、幸せに向けて、山も谷も余りなく進む内容でした。でもそれがとても心地良かったです。

A scene of fresh snow falling came to mind. It's a gentle work. The two main characters don't have intense personalities, and if anything, they feel relaxed, and since the theme is Christmas, the content progresses smoothly through mountains and valleys towards happiness. But it was very comfortable.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

お金で買えないもの

What money can't buy

これが欲しかったんだ。人々の嬉しそうな顔。家族の温もり。いい話です。

This is what I wanted. The happy faces of people. The warmth of family. That's a great story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

こういう話は大好きだ

I love stories like this

子ども達のサンタさんへの望みを叶えるボランティア。生きる気力を失った彼は、ボランティア活動を通じて、人とふれあい、再び自分の生を取り戻した。お金があったって、家族がいなけりゃ価値はないよね。辛い経験を聞いてそっとハグしてヒロインが彼を温かくする。人が喜ぶ顔をみて、自分もハッピーになる。隣人愛の究極の図のよう。会ったときから二人は互いに気になる存在で、二人とも与えることに一生懸命なボランティアしている。でも、本当に欲しいものはあった。彼は、戻ってはくれない家族が、ヒロインはある物が。でも、手にして、そして、一瞬にして願いが砕けた時に、彼女は知るのだ。彼も欲しいものを手に入れるため、動き始める。一切活力を失っていた何週間前が嘘のように、エネルギッシュに。ヒロインも、自分をガラスに閉じ込めるのを止めた。全てが動き出したのだ。彼ももう大工やれるね。ヒロインも新しい自分だ。少し夢や、希望の実現をして見せることで、きっと手にした者は明日からの日々が変わる。女のサンタと男のサンタが、一緒になるというような趣のストーリー。途中、秘密のサンタ協会の、メンバーの背景について彼が語るところ、一人名前が出るのに言及されない。1行まるごと脱字だろう。出版前に気づいて欲しかった。

Volunteers make children's wishes for Santa come true. Having lost his energy to live, he came into contact with people through volunteer activities and regained his own life. If you have money, it's not worth it if you don't have a family. The heroine warms him by listening to his painful experience and gently hugging him. Seeing people's happy faces makes me happy too. It's like the ultimate picture of love between neighbors. The two have been interested in each other since they met, and they both work hard to volunteer to give. But there was something I really wanted. He has a family that won't come back, but the heroine has something. But she knows when she holds it in her hands and her wish is shattered in an instant. He also starts moving to get what he wants. Energetic, like a lie how many weeks ago when I had lost all my energy. The heroine also stopped locking herself in glass. Everything started moving. He can already be a carpenter too. The heroine is also her new self. By showing them that their dreams and hopes have come true a little bit, the days starting tomorrow will surely change for those who get their hands on them. The story is about Santa, a woman, and Santa, a man getting together. On the way, when he talks about the background of the members of the Secret Santa Association, the name of one person comes up but is not mentioned. An entire line is probably out of character. I wanted you to notice it before publication.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

心温まる

Heartwarming

ヒーローもヒロインも周りの人たちもみんないい人たちで、素敵なハッピーエンド！ハーレ独特なドロドロがなくて、心温まります。

The hero, heroine, and everyone around them were all nice people, and it was a wonderful happy ending! There is no muddy mess unique to Harley, and it's heartwarming.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

This review contains spoilers. 儚げなヒーローに涙して、叶えられない願いを一人で背負いこむヒロインに涙しました。ヒーローの瞳に段々と光が戻っていくのも彼の心情を表していて泣けました。

This review contains spoilers. I cried at the ephemeral hero, and I cried at the heroine, who carried her unfulfilled wishes alone on her back. The fact that the light gradually returned to the hero's eyes also showed his feelings and made me cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ありきたりな素敵な内容

Ordinary and wonderful content

一度も引っかかることなく、穏やかにみることが出来ました。素敵な内容です。

I was able to watch peacefully without getting caught even once. The content is wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵だわぁ

that's wonderful

This review contains spoilers. 莫大な遺産を手にして悲しみを背負いながらもボランティアを投げやりにやるわけじゃなく、人のために自分の出来ることをやるヒーロー（´・ω・）ヒロインも子供たちのために心を痛めながら頑張る姿が素敵でした。ヒーローの献身的なプロポーズに胸がときめきました

This review contains spoilers. It was wonderful to see how the hero ('・ω・) heroine, who does what she can do for people while carrying grief with her enormous heritage, is also working hard while heartbreaking for her children. My heart was thrilled with the hero's dedicated proposal

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

心温まる話

A heartwarming story

ヒロインの背景がいまひとつ不明瞭なのでもう少し過去とか何故ボランティアしてるのかとか掘り下げてほしかったです

The heroine's background is now unclear, so I wanted them to delve a little deeper into the past or why they are volunteering

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 06, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

クリスマスプレゼント

Christmas gifts

最高にhappyなクリスマス。哀しみにくれていたヒーローが『秘密のサンタ協会』を手伝い始め、ヒロインや色んな人にふれあい、愛に目覚めちゃう。気持ちが温かくなりました。

The happiest Christmas ever. The hero, who was feeling sorry, starts helping the “Secret Santa Association,” interacts with the heroine and various people, and awakens to love. My feelings have warmed up.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 25, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がキレイです。

The picture is beautiful.

展開も絶望の淵にいた彼が、彼女と出会ってお互いに前向きに進み始める、ステキな物語でした。本当にクリスマスの奇跡って感じで、幸せな気持ちになれました。

It was a wonderful story where he, who was also on the edge of despair, met her and began to move forward positively with each other. It really felt like a Christmas miracle, and it made me feel happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっこりしました

I'm relieved

クリスマスには特別な事がおこるみたいで、欧米人になりたくなりました。

It seemed like something special was going to happen on Christmas, and I wanted to be a Westerner.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

クリスマスにぴったり

Perfect for Christmas

孤独な2人が幸せになるラストが良かったクリスマスに向けホンワカとなるお話でした。

It was a story where two lonely people are happy and it was a funny story for the last good Christmas.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵

nice

そんなに暗い話じゃないのに泣けてきました。凄くクリスマスに相応しい素敵なお話です！最後、少しあっけないので☆４で。

It made me cry even though it wasn't such a dark story. It's a wonderful story, perfect for Christmas! Finally, I'm a little surprised, so I went with ☆ 4.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

クリスマスの奇跡

Christmas miracle

クリスマスを前にハーレークインはいかがでしょうか？心が溶けて、温かくなる…そんな素敵なお話でした！まさに、クリスマスが起こした奇跡って感じです♪

How about Harley Quinn before Christmas? It was such a wonderful story that melted my heart and made me feel warm! Exactly, it feels like a miracle caused by Christmas ♪

Helpful

Reviews for Their Christmas Wish Come True Manga