If I Hadn't Fallen in Love with You Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

今日は酸辣湯記念品！

Today's hot and sour soup souvenir!

筋先生の描くキャラは、脇役全て嫌な人がいなくて、一人一人の表情も生き生きしていて大好きです。特に「スン」とした顔が(笑)勢いあるし、社食から繰り広がる社内のゴタゴタとか人間模様とか、面白い！そして、後書きの担当さんではないけど「愛(ラブ)が少ない」です。でも、人間愛は野乃から溢れてますよ！まさかの、そっち！？ですが、それだからBLは止められねぇっ！

I love the characters drawn by Suji sensei because none of the supporting characters are disgusting, and each person's facial expressions are lively. There's a lot of momentum in the face that looks “hot” in particular (lol), and the internal clutter and human patterns that unfold from the company meal are interesting! Also, although he is not in charge of the afterword, “there is little love (love).” But human love is overflowing from the field! No way, that one!? But that's why BL can't be stopped!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローはネコ

The hero is a cat

This review contains spoilers. 社食の料理人と本社に異動してきた監査部エリートのお話。社食の料理人野乃は、元ヤンキーということもあり漢気に溢れ、多くの人に慕われ頼られる。それとは正反対に、美里は若くしてエリート路線を歩んでいることもあり多くの人に疎まれる。そんな二人が食事をきっかけに距離を縮める。普段はクールな美里が、野乃といる時はのびのびと言いたいことを言い思う存分喧嘩しあっている様子は、心を許しているんだろうなというのが伝わります。二人のえちシーンでは、攻めと受けが意外性ありすぎてビックリしました。まさかのそっち⁉という展開でしたが、20年という想いの強い方が攻めだと考えれば納得でした。BL要素は少なめですが十分に楽しめる作品です。

This review contains spoilers. A story about the chef at the company meal and the audit department elite who moved to the head office. The chef of company food, Nono, is also a former Yankee, so he is full of Chinese energy, and is loved and relied upon by many people. Contrary to that, Misato is alienated by many people because she walked the elite line at a young age. These two people shorten their distance as a result of a meal. The way Misato, who is usually cool, says what she wants to say when she's with Nono and fights to her heart's content conveys that she is probably forgiving her heart. I was surprised that the attack and reception were so unexpected in the two of them. It was an unexpected development called that ⁉, but I was convinced when I thought that the one with the strong feelings of 20 years would attack. There are few BL elements, but it's a work that you can fully enjoy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

物語にはいりこんでサクサク読んじゃいました。すごくおもしろかったです。まさかの。。そっちが？！って思ったけど良き。

I got into the story and read it quickly. It was really interesting. No way.. that one?! I thought, but that's good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっこり

Relaxed

受けが、めちゃめちゃ中身良い男！男女問わず、一緒にいたら幸せにしてもらえそうな人柄です。絵は荒めで昔っぽいけど、内容が良くて全然気にならないです。

A man with an extremely good reception! Regardless of gender, they have personalities that would make them happy if they were together. The picture is rough and old-fashioned, but the content is so good that I don't care at all.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

温かいですね

It's warm

This review contains spoilers. 読み放で以前読んでたんですが、筋先生の作品は全て揃えたくてポチリ。何度読んでも素敵な作品。今回もまた涙と鼻水が出てしまった私。美里の想いがねぇ、20年分の想いがねぇ溢れると同時に、私の涙も溢れました(笑)みーんな素敵な人ばかりで、嫌な人がいない(いたんだろうけど、美里に淘汰された)。受けの野乃がこれまた男気溢れるいい奴で、こんな真っ直ぐで面倒見が良くて正義感強い奴、ヒーローじゃーん。小さい頃から美里を知っていて、泣いてる姿を見てきた野乃には、美里が今でも心で泣いてる気がしてほっとけなかった。そして、美里にとっては野乃はヒーローで、温かくて大好きな人。ほんとに20年ずーっと想い続けてたのなら、想いが報われてよかった。その間に、野乃にいい人ができてなくてよかった。馨が当て馬的存在か！？と思ったら、あらっ、この人もいい人。上の人も周りも理解ある人達で、安心のハピエンです。野乃の美味しいご飯は、美里へのたっぷりの愛情の隠し味も入ってるんだねぇ。野乃の美味しいご飯食べて、ずーっと体も心も健やかに穏やかに…。

This review contains spoilers. I used to read it alone, but I wanted to have all of Suji sensei's works. It's a wonderful work no matter how many times you read it. I had tears and a runny nose again this time around. Misato's feelings, 20 years worth of feelings overflowed, and at the same time, my tears overflowed (laughs) there were all such wonderful people, and there were no disgusting people (they were probably there, but they were eliminated by Misato). Kakinono is also a nice guy full of masculinity, and he's such a straight, caring guy, and a hero with a strong sense of justice. I've known Misato since I was little, and I couldn't help but feel that Misato is still crying with her heart. Also, for Misato, Nono is a hero, a warm and loving person. If you've really been thinking about it for 20 years, I'm glad your feelings have paid off. I'm glad Nono didn't have a good person in the meantime. Is Kaoru like a guitarist!? When I thought about it, ah, this person is also a nice person. My superiors and those around me are understanding people, so I feel at ease. Nono's delicious food also contains plenty of secret ingredients of love for Misato. Eat Nono's delicious food and keep your body and mind healthy and calm the whole time...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これぞ男気

This is masculinity

とにかくもう、受けが格好いいです。男にもてる男というか、漢気・リーダーシップ・義侠心がっつりのイイ男です。これから二人がどうなるのかも読みたい。

Anyway, the reception is already cool. He's a man who lends itself to men, or rather, he's a good man with a strong sense of character, leadership, and gentlemanship. I also want to read what will happen to the two of them in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

2013年作品

2013 works

青年漫画のようなタッチで最初慣れなかったけど、BL抜きでも通用する面白さでした！ただ！野乃さんの受けが意外性ありだけどちょっと残念…美里さんが受けが良かった～?しかし！読まないのは勿体ない面白さでした。レビュー点数もっと高くて良さそうなのに。

I didn't get used to it at first because it had a touch like a youth comic, but it was fun enough to work without BL! just! Nono-san's reception is unexpected, but it's a bit disappointing... Misato's reception was good ~? BUT! It was so much fun not to read it. It seems good that the review score is higher.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 11, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと手を握っていて

Hold hands the whole time

This review contains spoilers. ●癖があるかもしれませんが勢いのある絵柄で、ストーリーによく合っていて好きです。受け攻めの組み合わせもいい！ほっこり幸せになれる読後感でした。●社食の中華部主任の野乃（受）と、監査部部長の美里（攻）。小学校の頃に出会っていて、美里にとって野乃はその頃から自分を救ってくれるヒーロー。野乃は美里の気持ちにも自分の気持ちにも無自覚に、幼い頃と同じように美里を助けてやりたいと奮闘する。●イタリアン部新主任の薫は、野乃に恋を自覚させる良いキャラでした。他部の主任たちも、監査部のメンバーもいい人ばかり。読者までも一緒になって二人を応援したくなっちゃうんですよね。●告白は野乃が先だったのが良かった。一度離してしまった美里の手をしっかり繋いで「好きだ」って伝えたの、きゅんとしました。えっちは一度だけですが、想い伝えあってる感じ！えっちに流れたきっかけも、野乃が美里の手をぎゅっと握ったことでした。●いかんせん野乃が無自覚なので、中盤まで表紙のような甘い感じは全然ありませんが、最後は二人でごはんを作る幸せっぷり。私もおすそ分けしてほしい…

This review contains spoilers. ● It may have a habit, but I like it because it has momentum and fits the story well. A combination of attack and attack is good too! I felt relaxed and happy after reading it. ● Nono (Suki), the head of the Chinese department of the company meal, and Misato (attack), the head of the audit department. I met him when I was in elementary school, and for Misato, Nono is a hero who has saved her since that time. Nono is unaware of Misato's feelings and her own, and struggles to help Misato just like when she was young. ● Kaoru, the new head of the Italian club, was a good character to make Nono aware of his love. The supervisors of the other departments and the members of the audit department are all nice people. Even readers want to get together and cheer for the two. ● It was good that Nono confessed first. Once they had let go, they held Misato's hands tightly and told them “I like it,” which made me laugh. It's only once over there, but it feels like they're conveying their feelings! The reason it flowed over there was also when Nono held Misato's hand tightly. ● Since Iansen Nono is unaware, there isn't a sweet feeling at all like the cover until the middle stage, but at the end, the two of them make a meal full of happiness. I want you to share it too...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

好きだァァ

I like it huh

This review contains spoilers. 今回の作品も素晴らしかったです！カプもバリ好みで攻めに見せかけの受けって素晴らしいおいしいです。まんじゅうで可愛かった美里も、最後は堂々とした姿勢で2人の関係を公にした様子がとても悶えました。

This review contains spoilers. This work was amazing too! Caps also like Bali, and they look like they're attacking, and they're wonderful and delicious. Misato, who was cute and cute, was also very agitated at the end when she made the relationship between the two public with a proud attitude.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

温かい食卓

A warm dining table

作者買いです。絵にクセがあるなと思いつつ、好きな作家さんです。ハートフルストーリーにBLが乗っている感じの作風が多いと感じています。熱血漢な元ヤン料理人野乃と、エリート社員美里のお話。幼馴染モノです。20年分の愛が溢れるところが見所です。温かい食卓が人を幸せにするのですよ。

I'm buying the author. Even though I think his paintings have a habit, he is a favorite artist. I feel that there are many styles where BL is on Heartful Stories. A story about the hot-blooded former Yang cook Nono and the elite employee Misato. It's my childhood friend's thing. The highlight is that 20 years worth of love overflows. A warm dining table makes people happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 25, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

好き。

I like it.

This review contains spoilers. 最初元ヤン野乃さんの勝気さと美里さんの塩対応ぶりが凄まじくてこれBLになるのか？ってくらいなんだけど、少しずつ美里さんが気を許して素を見せていく感じと野乃さんの自分の気持ちへの鈍感さにきゅんきゅんしました。お幸せに。。って気分になれる。おすすめ。

This review contains spoilers. At first, former Yang Nono's ambition and Misato's salt compatibility were so great that it's going to be a BL? That's about it, but I was amazed by the feeling that little by little Misato was forgiving her and showing her true self, and Nono's insensitivity to her own feelings. Be happy.. It makes me feel like that. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

とってもよかった

That was very good

受が元ヤンで情にあつい、好物です！ストーリーも安心感があって好きです

It's my favorite food, and it's my favorite food because it's my favorite food! I also like the story because it has a sense of security

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

あ、そっち？

ah, over there?

また個人的予想と逆カプで、こんなに多いのは自分が最近の流れに逆行しているんだろうかとふと考えてしまいましたがそんなことはどうでもよく、とても美味しいお話で良かったです。

Also, due to personal predictions and backwards, I suddenly thought that I was going against the recent trend because there were so many of them, but I didn't care about that, and I'm glad it was a very tasty story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

受け攻め満足です

I'm satisfied with being attacked

ううう嬉しいーーー受けはあっちになるのかな。。とか思っていたので嬉しい誤算でした。ありがとう！

I'm so happy... I wonder if the reception will be over there.. I was wondering something like that, so it was a happy miscalculation. thank you!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ほわっと心を温めたい方へお薦め。

Recommended for those who want to warm their heart.

This review contains spoilers. 全体的にカクカクした感じの絵に見えたけど、話は面白くて好きだった〜コミカルなシーンの絵が可愛いくて面白い♫受けと攻めが逆だったのは少し驚いたけど、変な感じはなくすんなり読めた!最終ページに、子供の頃の二人と大人になった二人で雪合戦しててニンマリしちゃった(๑´ڡ`๑)

This review contains spoilers. Overall, it looked like a jittery picture, but the story was interesting and I liked it ~ the picture of the comical scene was cute and interesting ♫ I was a little surprised that receiving and attacking were the opposite, but I was able to read it easily without the strange feeling! On the last page, there was a snowball fight between the two when they were kids and the two who became adults, and it made me cringe ('`)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きな作品です！

I love this work!

受けも攻めも美しい。心理描写もしっかり入っていますし、話も綺麗に収まっています。そしてただのイチャイチャだけのBLとはとは違い、ストーリーも濃く、イラストも綺麗です。是非読むべき作品だと思います。

Both receiving and attacking are beautiful. The psychological depiction is also well included, and the story fits neatly. Also, unlike BL, which is just flirting, the story is strong and the illustrations are beautiful. I think this is a work you should definitely read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗に収まってる

It fits neatly

一巻にちょうど綺麗に収まって、読後感がとても良いです。他の穏やかな作品から読んだので、その差からかもしれませんが、昼ドラのごとく展開していくお話に飽きる事がありませんでした。イタリアン後任の彼の説明がもう少し欲しかったかな、ぐらい。どっちが受けになるのか、ギリギリまでわからなかったのも逆に良かったです。

It fits just neatly into one volume, and the feeling after reading is very good. I read it from other calm works, so maybe it's because of that difference, but I never got tired of the story unfolding like a daytime drama. I wonder if I wanted a little more explanation of his Italian successor. Conversely, it was good that I didn't know which one would be accepted until the last minute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

とても良かったです！

It was very good!

絵がやや古い気もしますが、それを上回るぐらい話は良かったです！イチャイチャは少なくても、二人の恋の行方は丁寧だったし、感情移入も出来ました。受けが漢気あるのも、とても良かったですし、最後の盛り上がりも熱かったです！

I also feel like the picture is a bit old, but the story was so good that it surpassed that! There was little flirtation, but the whereabouts of their love was polite, and they were able to empathize. It was also very nice that the reception was strong, and the excitement at the end was intense!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった！

That was great!

評価よりも全然素敵なお話でした！続きが読みたい(>_<)歳上の赤面トロ顔は最高です♪

It was an even more wonderful story than the evaluation! I want to read more (>_<) The blushing face of an older person is the best ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

大人の純愛

Pure love for adults

This review contains spoilers. ラブ少なめでストーリー重視の作品です主人公がテンション高めなので、ごちゃつきは感じますが、相反する冷静沈着な美里とのやり取りで調和取れてると思います途中、主人公がデレてきた辺りから、もしかしてこっちが受けかな？と思ってたら案の定でしたでも、この二人ならどっちもアリっぽい表紙絵はキレイなので、中も線をもっと少なめにすれば、ごちゃごちゃしなさそうなのに

This review contains spoilers. It's a story with little love. The main character's tension is high, so I feel like it's a mess, but I think they're in harmony by interacting with the opposite, calm, and calm Misato. On the way, from where the main character came from, maybe this one received it? When I thought about it, it was true, but both of these two people have beautiful ant cover pictures, so if the lines on the inside were even smaller, they wouldn't seem to be a mess

Helpful

Reviews for If I Hadn't Fallen in Love with You Manga