I'm Only A Substitute Consort, but the Emperor Won't Let Me Leave Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

こういう王宮系の話しはファンタジー要素が強くて大好きです！！2人が徐々に心を通わせていく過程がキュンとしますね！今後の2人が楽しみです！

I love this kind of royal palace story because it has a strong fantasy element!! The process of the two gradually getting in touch is so exciting! I'm looking forward to the next two!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何度読み返しても面白い

It's interesting no matter how many times you reread it

好きすぎて、週３で読み返しています。まず、設定が本来あり得ない話ですが、面白い。秘密が隠されているけど、登場人物たちと自分しか知らないという優越感も味わえ、水戸黄門のような絶対的権力を持っている。複数の要素が絡み合う中で、話が積み上げられている。読んでみてください。

I liked it so much that I reread it 3 times a week. First, it's a story where the setting was originally impossible, but it's interesting. The secret is hidden, but you can also enjoy a sense of superiority that only you know the characters and yourself, and they have absolute power like Mito Komon. While multiple elements are intertwined, the story is piling up. Please read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いい！

That's good!

面白いです！１２まで一気読みしました！最後までよみたいです！面白いし楽しい。みんなイイキャラで読んでいて本当に楽しいです。

It's interesting! I read it all at once until 12! I want to go all the way to the end! It's interesting and fun. Everyone is reading it with nice characters and it's really fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキ、ハラハラ…

Doki Doki, Harahara...

This review contains spoilers. 珠蘭も惺にも色々秘密があるなか、だんだんと惹かれ合うことに…。お話のテンポも良くて、秘密があきらかになっていくところが、ドキドキ、ハラハラ、面白いです。続きが楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. While both Juran and Sei have various secrets, they gradually become attracted to each other... The tempo of the story is also good, and the fact that the secrets are revealed is exciting, jarring, and interesting. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

毎回楽しみ

Enjoying every time

身代わり婚の後宮話だけど、ヒロインも明るく前向きで可愛いし、ストーリーも面白いと思います。周りのキャラもみんな魅力的だと思ってます。毎回、更新を楽しみにしているので、今後の2人の発展が楽しみです。

It's a surrogate marriage story, but the heroine is also bright, positive, and cute, and I think the story is interesting. I think all the characters around me are fascinating. I look forward to updates every time, so I'm looking forward to the development of the two of them in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなかー

It's pretty good

ス・リ・ル満点、かわいいヒロインと素敵なヒーロー楽しい物語にワクワクした、続きが早く読みたい。二人はきっとうまくいくなー

I'm excited about this fun story with a perfect score, a cute heroine and a wonderful hero, and I want to read the continuation as soon as possible. I'm sure the two of them will get along

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです

It's interesting

はまって頻繁に見ています。元気な主人公が、見ていて気持ちいいです。今できることをするのが、応援したくなります。色んな秘密もありそうで続きが気になります！

I'm addicted to it and watch it often. The cheerful protagonist feels good to watch. Doing what we can now makes me want to cheer them on. There seem to be a lot of secrets, and I'm curious about the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

身代わりの方が愛されて

The person who replaced me was loved

よくある設定だし、なんとなく先も読めるけど、やっぱり読んじゃう！元気なヒロインに絆されていく皇子のマンガはホント面白いし好き。

It's a common setting, and somehow I can read ahead, but I read it after all! The prince's manga, who bonds with an energetic heroine, is really interesting and I like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きな作品なので長く続いて欲しいです。

It's my favorite work, so I want it to last a long time.

後宮のお話ですが、今のところ血なまぐさくなく、キャラが皆すごく魅力的で、女の子達みんな可愛くて、陛下も麗しく、時折みせる優しい所がたまらなく良いです。珠蘭と陛下の二人を見ていると本当に癒やされます。ただ更新が本当にゆっくりなので、もしかしたら短いお話なのかなとも思ってます。本当に大好きなお話なので長く続いて欲しいです。

It's a story about Harem, but so far, it's not bloody, the characters are all very attractive, the girls are all cute, Her Majesty is beautiful, and the kind places she shows from time to time are irresistibly nice. Watching Juran and Her Majesty is really soothing. However, updates are really slow, so I'm wondering if this is a short story. I really love this story, so I hope it continues for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです！

It's interesting!

身代わりからの好きになっていくお話。従姉妹とは性格が違ってたまに見せる武術のような身のこなし、かっこよかったです！面白いです。続きがきになります。

It's a story about people falling in love with it from the time they took their place. I have a different personality from my cousin, and the martial arts style she shows once in a while was so cool! It's interesting. It will be continued.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白く

interestingly

This review contains spoilers. なってきて、良いと想うんだけどな～。蘭はもしかして・・陛下も何かあるっぽいし、まだまだありそうで、楽しみ。

This review contains spoilers. It's getting better, and I think it's good, though. Ran is probably... it looks like His Majesty has something else, and it seems like there's still more, so I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になります！

I'm curious about the continuation!

身代わりから始まる後宮もの。続きが気になり一気に読みました。様々な謎や陰謀がこれから色々ありそうで、とても楽しみです。

Something in the Hallows that starts with being replaced. I was curious about the continuation and read it all at once. There seem to be various mysteries and intrigues in the future, and I'm really looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

障害が無さすぎる恋で物足りなかった

Love with No Obstacles Was Not Enough

This review contains spoilers. 18話完結で読みやすかったです。嫌な展開が一切なく、宮中で陛下とは知らず理想的に恋仲になっていく、王道のシンデレラストーリーって感じでした。途中とてもキュンキュンしたし、気分の良いハッピーエンドで良かったなぁと思いますがあまりにもことが上手く運びすぎで物足りなさを感じました。とにかく幸せな話だけが見たいんだ！！って読者には全力でオススメしますが人間という生き物の黒い部分は極力描かずに、綺麗な部分だけを見せられたような、そんな印象の物語でした。皇太后があっさり捕まったのもモヤモヤします。読者からしたら彼女、別に大したことしてないように見えますし…汚い悪事を描いてないせいで…。むしろ息子を溺愛してたのになんだか可哀想。悪役を描きたかったのなら、なんでわざわざ溺愛してる描写を描いたのやら。そんなの見たら普通に良い母に見えてしまいます。そして離宮に流したくらいじゃ、全然まだ悪巧みして復活しそうですしね…。それに李姫様をただのいい子として描いたのも変な感じ。仮にも名家のお姫様なのに、自分の宮で丁寧に扱われてなかったとか信じられないし親に圧力かけられてたら、主人公のことを恨んだり妬ましく思ったり、いい子だとしてもいい子なりの黒い感情をぶつけてくるのが普通だと思うんですよね。最後も言われるがまま、ありがと〜って感じに主人公の侍女みたいな立場になることを受け入れてたし、それこそ本当にお人形さんだったのでは…と思ってしまいました。てゆーか皇后になる人に望まれたら、彼女の一存で侍女になることを家は許してくれるんだろうか？何もかもあっさり上手く行きすぎで信じられませんでした。こういう王宮モノにしては圧倒的に波乱が足りないんですよね。だからこその18話完結なんですけど。ずっと隠していた金兎の件も、この国にとってどれくらい重要視されている存在なのか今ひとつピンときませんでした。最後にみんなの前で明かしたけど、金兎と知っても大臣たちに反対されてたし、あれっ？国が何としてでも得たいような存在じゃなかったんかーい？って肩透かし食らった気分になりました。じゃあ必死に隠してた意味もあまり理解できません…。金兎を得て得する人って一体誰だったんだ。駆け落ちしたお姫様の方が面白かったです。あんなに賢いのに商人の息子と急に…。彼らの話も見てみたかったです。

This review contains spoilers. It was easy to read with 18 episodes completed. There were no bad developments at all, and it felt like a royal Cinderella story where they ideally fell in love without knowing His Majesty in the palace. There was a lot of excitement along the way, and I think it was nice to have a happy ending, but I felt that things went so well that it wasn't enough. I just want to watch happy stories!! I recommend it to readers with all my might, but it was a story with the impression that only beautiful parts were shown without drawing the black parts of creatures called humans as much as possible. The fact that the Empress Dowager was so easily caught is also puzzling. From the reader's point of view, she doesn't seem like a big deal... because she didn't draw dirty evil things... Rather, I was doting on my son, but it's kind of a pity. If I wanted to draw a villain, I wonder why I went out of my way to draw a depiction of him doting on him. I usually look like a good mother when I look at it like that. And it seems like it's still going back to the Imperial Villa, and it seems like it's still going to be revived in a bad way... Also, it's strange that I drew Lee Hee-sama as just a good kid. Even if she were a princess from a famous family, I don't believe that she wasn't treated carefully in her own palace, and if pressure was applied by her parents, I think it's normal for her to have a grudge or be jealous about the main character, and even if she's a good kid, she will have dark feelings like a good kid. As I was told at the end, I accepted that I would be in a position like the main character's handmaiden with a feeling of thank you, and I thought that was really the doll... If someone who will become an empress wants her to be a handmaiden, will the house allow her to become a handmaiden at her sole discretion? Everything went so easily that I couldn't believe it. There's overwhelmingly not enough turbulence for a royal palace thing like this. That's why episode 18 has come to an end, though. The Golden Rabbit case, which had been hidden for a long time, didn't come to my mind right now about how important it is to this country. Finally, I revealed it in front of everyone, but even though I knew it was a golden rabbit, the ministers opposed it, huh? wasn't the country the kind of entity they wanted to gain at any cost, huh? It made me feel like my shoulder had been swallowed up. Well then I don't really understand the meaning of what I was desperately hiding... Who the heck was the person who got the golden rabbit and profiteed it. The princess who eloped away was more interesting. he was so smart, and suddenly with the merchant's son... I wanted to see their stories too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

17巻でひと段落

One paragraph in volume 17

話の流れが上手く出来ていて面白いです。最後にはまぁくっつくんだろうなって言うのは多分誰が見てもわかるところではあると思うのですが、その過程がしっかり描かれていて面白いです。なにより蘭ちゃん可愛い〜！17巻まで買ってます。この先の展開も楽しみ！試し読みで気になったら買って損はないです?

The flow of the story is well made and it's interesting. I think the fact that they'll stick together at the end is probably something that can be understood no matter who sees it, but it's interesting that the process is well depicted. Above all, Ranchan is so cute! I've bought up to 17 volumes. I'm looking forward to future developments! there's no harm in buying it if you're interested in a trial reading?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

This review contains spoilers. かっこいい皇帝と可愛いおくさまー！幸せになるにちがいない！！おもしろい！続きが気になる。早く読みたいなぁ！！

This review contains spoilers. A cool emperor and a cute old man! You will definitely be happy!! It's interesting! I'm worried about the continuation. I want to read it soon!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白そう！

That looks interesting!

身代わりの後宮モノと王道ではありますが、ふたりのキャラも好感持て、もたもたせずに序盤でのネタバレでサクッと展開していくのも安心して愉しめますね。

It's a substitute for Harem Mono, and the royal road, but the two characters also have a good impression, and you can enjoy the fact that they quickly unfold with spoilers from the beginning without being bothered.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

金の兎

The Golden Rabbit

なんでお互いの正体に気づかないの？普通背格好とか声ですぐわかるよね？染めてる髪の毛はきっと３か月伸びない設定。

Why aren't we aware of each other's true identity? You can tell right away by looking tall in your voice, right? The hair that has been dyed is set so that it won't grow for 3 months.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いつ気づくのかな

I wonder when I'll notice

終わり方はなんとなく予想ができるけど、お互いの秘密に気づいたときの反応が見たくてつい買って見てます。二人のイチャイチャもみたいな〜。１１巻で少し進んだから次の展開が楽しみです。

I can somehow predict how it will end, but I just bought it and watched because I wanted to see how they realized each other's secrets. It looks like the two of them are flirting too. It's a bit advanced in volume 11, so I'm looking forward to the next development.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろいので合冊版に行きました

I went to the combined edition because it was interesting

5話まで読んでおもしろかったので、合冊版に移りました。2巻まで読みましたがおもしろくなりそうですよ。3巻どうなるのか。

I read up to 5 episodes and it was interesting, so I moved to the combined edition. I've read up to 2 volumes, and it looks like it's going to be interesting. What will happen with volume 3?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

渦巻く陰謀、そして恋愛！

A swirling conspiracy, and romance!

中華の身代わり後宮もの、です。元気な女の子が、後宮に無理やり連れて行かれる、そして皇帝に見初められる、王道な展開ですが、安心して読めます。珠蘭が可愛くてかっこいい！進みが遅いので星４つ。キュンキュンする展開を期待します！

It's a replacement for Chinese food, something from the Harem. It's a royal development where an energetic girl is forcibly taken to the Imperial Palace and is first seen by the emperor, but you can read it without worry. Juran is so cute and cool! Progress is slow, so 4 stars. We look forward to a thrilling development!

Helpful

Reviews for I'm Only A Substitute Consort, but the Emperor Won't Let Me Leave Manga