The Playboy's Proposition Manga Reviews

Meily

Report

Jan 13, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 172

Not so fond

This review contains spoilers. The female was so annoying for me. She didn't act honest and it was unbelievable story just to make the two of them love each other.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

まるで90年代の、恋愛映画をみているような感じでヒーローも素敵だけど、ヒロインもカッコ良くて素敵な女性でした。10年は長かったけれど結ばれて良かった。

It was like watching a romance movie from the 90s, and the hero was wonderful, but the heroine was also a cool and wonderful woman. Ten years was a long time, but I'm glad we got together.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

１０年好きで居続けてくれた人

The person I liked and stayed with me for 10 years

女性がチャーミングで、建物描写も素晴らしい。好きな人なら、１０年という歳月は、気持ちを持ち続けるのに時間としては決して長くない。二十代一杯学生時代の感情を引き摺るのは珍しくない。(昔言えなかったと、時効後の打ち明け話、五万とある！)好きな人が別の人と付き合い出した。これもありがち。でもこの話は男性がその立場、しかも女性に困らないタイプ。ヒロインのこれまでの行動と気持ち、わかる。もてて当人も積極的にとっかえひっかえするようなタイプの男性には、たとえ彼のことが気になるタイプで目を奪われていたとしても、警戒レベルMAXにして、ちょっとやそっとの彼の親切な態度は誰に対してもだと受け止めるようにする。思わせ振りな言動でゆさぶりがうまいから、勘違いしないようにする。それでもヒロインは心の奥底にずっと彼を意識していた。気になっていることを自分で押し止めていただけだ。そして、そんな無理無理な相手は交際相手として現実的に浮上せず、身近な人と付き合う、よくわかる。このストーリーの核心は、女性よりどりみどり状態の中でも、彼が思いを封印し続けてきたことの凄さ、その思いを抱き続けられたこと自体の、格好よさ。そして、大概はお互い親しさを認める間柄であっても、その次の本気でぶつかる一歩は踏み出せない。でもこれじゃいけないとごまかしきれない自分の気持ちに向き合う。ヒロインの告白の勇気が素晴らしい。それにしても、あの妹はうっとおしい。ストーリー進行を混ぜ返す役割。アクセントになっており、不要というつもりはない。裏切り者の元カレも、前半でとんでもないやつ、という感じで描写されるも、後半に、なるほど、と元カレ側の交際時の総括を説明されると納得。58頁のキスシーンは良かった。男性陣、線弱い。コマが大切りが多く簡単に頁をめくることになりボリューム感が削がれる。そして、顔アップ多すぎ。電子書籍としてスマートフォンでみる分には顔アップの多さも画面が小さいなりに苦痛とまではいかないが、これ紙のコミックサイズを想像すると手抜きと感じなくもない。絵の好感度の高さで救われているだけだ。それに、大ぶりの人物絵が多いとドラマがメリハリを失って、紙芝居化してしまう。あと、誤植が気になる。このストーリー、ヒロインのアクションが要所で２回事態を打開する。その勇気に心を動かされた。

The woman is charming, and the depiction of the building is wonderful. If it's someone you like, ten years is definitely not a long time to keep up with feelings. It's not uncommon for people in their twenties to be drawn to the emotions of when they were students. (If I couldn't say it a long time ago, there are fifty thousand confessions after the statute of limitations!) The person I liked started dating someone else. This also tends to happen. But in this story, men are in that position, and the type that doesn't have trouble with women. I understand the heroine's actions and feelings so far. For the type of man in question who is also aggressive, set the alert level to max, even if he is the type he cares about and catches your eye, and try to accept that his kind attitude, which is a little gentle, is for everyone. They are good at misleading words and actions, so don't misunderstand them. Even so, the heroine was always aware of him in the depths of her heart. I was just holding back from myself what I was worried about. Also, such an unreasonable partner doesn't realistically emerge as a dating partner, and they go out with people close to them, and I understand it very well. The core of this story is the awesomeness of the fact that he has continued to seal his thoughts even when he is more mature than the woman, and the coolness of being able to continue to hold those thoughts itself. Also, in most cases, even in relationships where they acknowledge mutual familiarity, they cannot take the next step of seriously colliding. But if I don't do this, I face my own feelings that I can't cheat enough. The heroine's courage to confess is amazing. Even so, that little sister is annoying. A role that mixes up the progression of the story. It's an accent, and I don't mean to say it's unnecessary. The traitor's ex-boyfriend is also depicted as being ridiculous in the first half, but I'm convinced that in the second half, I see, a summary of when the ex-boyfriend's relationship was explained. The kiss scene on page 58 was good. The men are weak. There are many large cuts on the frames, making it easy to turn the pages, and the sense of volume is reduced. Also, there are too many face-ups. If you look at it on a smartphone as an e-book, it's not painful because the screen is small, but when you imagine the size of a comic on paper, I don't feel like cutting corners. I'm just being saved because of the high likability of the picture. Also, if there are many large portraits, the drama loses its sharpness, and it becomes a picture-story show. Also, I'm worried about typographical errors. In this story, the heroine's actions resolve the situation twice at key points. I was moved by that courage.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なヒーロー

nice hero

This review contains spoilers. ハーレクインは色々読みましたがその中でも好きなヒーロー上位に入りました笑ヒロインに女たらしのレッテルを貼られて自分の友人にヒロインを奪われて…それでも10年間ずっとヒロインのことが好きだなんて一途です！友人の彼女になってしまったからには自分の気持ちを打ち明けられないし、きっといっぱい傷ついてきたはず。やっと君にたどり着いたというセリフには思わずにやけました?

This review contains spoilers. I've read a lot about Harlequin, but it's one of my favorite heroes lol the heroine was labeled a womanizer and my friend robbed me of the heroine... even so, I've always loved the heroine for 10 years! Now that I've become my friend's girlfriend, I can't confide my feelings, and I'm sure I've been hurt a lot. I was unexpectedly taken aback by the line that I finally got to you?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2010 (PST) | Translate to English

かっこよすぎる

that's too cool

タイラーがとてもかっこよすぎる 10年もの間一途に思い続けていてくれるなんてまして、想い人に付き合っている人（タイラーとは同級生）がいたのに‥

I can't believe Tyler is so cool that I've been thinking about it all the time for 10 years, and even though there was someone who was dating the person he loved (Tyler is a classmate)...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

感動しました

impressed

This review contains spoilers. ミッシェルがタイラーに惹かれる気持ちを隠しながらも好きという気持ちを抑えられないところやタイラーが密かにミッシェルを思っていた事、気持ちが通じた2人ハッピーエンドで穏やかな気持ちになりました。

This review contains spoilers. Michelle hid her feelings of attraction to Tyler but couldn't suppress her feelings of liking her, and the fact that Tyler secretly thought of Michelle, and the happy ending for the two made them feel peaceful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

ストーリーは良かったです。ヒロインの元カレは小賢しい世渡り上手タイプで「こういうクズいるよなー」という典型。こういうクズを突き放せないヒロインにも問題がある。ヒーローも10年もウダウダやってないでよー。

The story was good. The heroine's ex-boyfriend is a smart, carefree type, and is typical of “this kind of scum exists.” There is also a problem with the heroine who can't let go of this kind of scum. Heroes haven't played Udauda in 10 years either.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

一途

Itto

This review contains spoilers. 主人公を長年愛し続けている男性がもどかしくていいです。主人公と自分の友人がずっと付き合っているから、遠慮して気持ちを伝えることさえできていません。そのせつなさや屈折した感じがよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. It's nice that the man who has been in love with the main character for so many years is frustrated. Since the main character and his friend have been in a relationship for a long time, they haven't even been able to express their feelings. I liked that stubborn and refracted feeling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーロー10年も‼

Hero 10 years too ‼

一途なヒーローで格好良い。まぁ、10年もなにやってたんだよっと言いたくもなりますが。まぁ、ヒロインがヒーローに対してコンプレックスを持ってしまったからしょうがないよね。自分を苦しめた元カレのお陰で、本当に求めてた相手と結ばれて良かったです。

He's a brave hero and good-looking. Well, it also makes me want to say what they've been doing for 10 years. Well, it can't be helped since the heroine has a complex against the hero. Thanks to my ex-boyfriend who tormented me, I'm glad I was able to connect with the person I really wanted.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 01, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

一途な愛

Unconditional love

元カレの結婚式の招待状が届いてから展開するストーリーですが、ヒーローの気持ちがストレートに伝わらなく切なかった場面もありました。とくに結ばれたあとの誤解は胸がいたかったです。ヒーローの今までの態度がヒロインに誤解をしてしまったたのでしょうが、最後に元カレが後押ししてくれてよかった。ヒーローの一途な愛が実ってよかった。

It's a story that unfolds after my ex-boyfriend's wedding invitation arrives, but there were also scenes where I was sad because the hero's feelings weren't conveyed straight through. In particular, the misunderstandings after they were tied together were heartbreaking. The hero's attitude up until now was probably misunderstood by the heroine, but I'm glad my ex-boyfriend gave me a boost at the end. I'm glad that the hero's unwavered love came to fruition.

Helpful

Reviews for The Playboy's Proposition Manga