THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga Reviews (P.6)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

余韻がすごい…

The afterglow is amazing...

この作品に出会わなければラムスプリンガという知識を得ることは無かっただろうな…と素晴らしい作品に出会えたことに感謝。世界観に引き込まれすぎて読んだあと脱力しました…純真無垢なテオがどんどん男前に成長していくので、普通に惚れました。

If I hadn't come across this work, I wouldn't have gained knowledge called Ramspringa... and I'm grateful that I was able to come across such a wonderful work. I was so drawn into the worldview that I felt weak after reading it... The innocent Theo grew more and more handsome, so I fell in love with him normally.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けるー！

it makes me cry!

びっくりした。NYで演出家をやってたってベネットさん。舞台の名前がコーラスライン!えーっ!あのベネットさん?…あ、ニール・ベネットさんね、本当の演出家、振り付けしたのはマイケル・ベネットさんか！ミュージカル大好きなもんで、びっくりしました。アーミッシュの掟も知らなかった。古い生活をしているのは知っていたけれど…泣けました。二人の幸せって、ホントにささやか。だからこそ、二人で愛しあっていることが尊いです。

I was surprised. Bennett said she was working as a director in NY. The name of the stage is Chorus Line! huh! that Bennett? ... Ah, Neil Bennett, was the real director and choreographer Michael Bennett? I love musicals, and I was surprised. I didn't even know the Amish Code. I knew I was living my old life... but it made me cry. The happiness of the two is really whispering. That's why it's precious for two people to love each other.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

感動しました❤?

I'm moved ❤?

時代、文化ともに私とはかけ離れている設定。でも、すべてがフィクションではなくファンタジーでもSFでもない現実でもあるストーリー。アーミッシュという少し特別な背景で葛藤、苦悩し、喜びも慈しみも受け入れ選択してゆくラムスプリンガ。「親愛なるジーンへ」でひと泣きしてこちらを熟読しました。前半はアーミッシュのテオ君が”外”の世界を体験して色々なものを吸収していくお話。そのすべてを混じりけの無い素直な心が受け入れてゆきます。ひょんなきっかけでテオ君を拾った元ダンサーのオズは身も心も荒んで自棄になっているような状態でしたが、テオ君の純粋さで癒されていきます。まるでセラピーｗ後半はテオ君とオズ、２人の人生が自分で選択して動き出します。そして、アーミッシュのクロエとダニー。彼らがアーミッシュであることも自らの選択であること。クロエが尊くて✨髪をおろす意味、読者に含みを持たせてくれているのかな。読み終わったとき、あ～いい映画だった。と思ってしまいました。出会えて感謝?

The setting is far from mine in terms of time and culture. However, not all of them are fictional stories; they are reality stories that are neither fantasy nor science fiction. Lamb Springa struggles, suffers from a slightly special background called the Amish, and chooses to accept both joy and compassion. I cried for a moment in “Dear Jean,” and read this carefully. The first half is an Amish story about Theo experiencing the “outside” world and absorbing various things. An honest heart that doesn't mix all of that up will accept it. Oz, the former dancer who picked up Theo by accident, was physically and mentally rough and in a state of abandonment, but he was healed by Theo's purity. It's like therapy lol in the second half, the lives of Theo and Oz make their own choices and begin to unfold. And the Amish Chloe and Danny. The fact that they are Amish is also their own choice. I wonder if the meaning of Chloe is precious ✨ sheds light on readers. When I finished reading it, it was a great movie. It made me think. thankful to have met you?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

しばらく余韻に浸ります…

I'll soak in the afterglow for a while...

親愛なるジーンへからこちらを読みました！純愛でした~~~感動でした~~~登場人物が全員素敵(ゴロツキ共以外ね)でした！読んで損は無い！レビューの皆さんの仰る通りでございました！良い作品ありがとうございました！

I read this from Dear Jean! It was pure love~~~ I was moved ~~~ all the characters were wonderful (except Gorotsuki Kyō)! There's no harm in reading it! Everyone in the review was right! Thank you so much for the good work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読み返したくなる作品です。

It's a work you'll want to reread over and over again.

皆さん書かれているように映画のような作品です。物語がしっかりしていて、感動するシーンが何度もあります。二人の幸せを願わずにはいられない作品です。

As everyone wrote, it's like a movie. The story is solid, and there are many moving scenes. It's a work where I can't help but wish for happiness for the two of them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

美しくて切ない

Beautiful and sad

絵もきれいでストーリーにも胸がぎゅっとしました。純真無垢な攻めが良かったです。

The pictures were beautiful and I was very excited about the story. An innocent attack was good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読んで本当によかった

I'm really glad I read it

This review contains spoilers. ハピエンですが、苦味が残る最後でした(良い意味で)。知らない文化がたくさん出てきてストーリー的にも本当に面白かったです。本当に映画を見ているような、ぎっしりと重みのあるお話でした。えっちなシーンも、受けの曲線美というか、線がとても良かったです。闇を抱えて生きる受けと純粋な(物語的に生粋のというわけではありませんでしたが)攻め…良い…！！買って良かった！続編が読みたい…！！

This review contains spoilers. Happien, but it was the last time bitterness remained (in a good sense). A lot of cultures I didn't know came up, and it was really interesting in terms of story. It was a story with a lot of weight, like I was really watching a movie. Even in the eccentric scene, the lines were very nice, or rather, the curves in the reception. living with darkness, reception and pure (although it wasn't historically authentic) attack... good...!! I'm glad I bought it! I want to read the sequel...!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

テオの言葉

Theo's words

This review contains spoilers. 素晴らしかったです。育った環境も考え方も真逆な二人が惹かれていく様が自然過ぎて優しくて何度も泣きそうになった。独特な設定ではあるけど、アーミッシュであるが故にからかわれたり、人によっては無害だと受け入れたりそういうシーンからも二人の生活している世界の背景が広がって見える。テオの言葉でどこか諦めたような切なげな顔をしてたオズが素直になれる。迷いのない言葉はテオだからこそ100%信じられる言葉。説得力があって感動してしまう。そんな二人が欲望のままに求め合うのも本当にエッロい…背徳感？キラキラした二人の未来を想って胸がｷﾞｭｯとなる。しばらく余韻に浸りたくなる作品。

This review contains spoilers. It was amazing. The way they were attracted to two people who were the exact opposite of their environment and way of thinking was so natural that they almost cried over and over again. Although it is a unique setting, you can see the background of the world where the two live unfold even from scenes where they are teased because they are Amish, and some people accept that it is harmless. Oz, who had a sad face that seemed to have given up somewhere in Theo's words, can be honest. Words without hesitation are words that only Theo can trust 100%. I'm moved by how persuasive they are. Is it really ridiculous that these two people seek each other out of their desires... a sense of immorality? My heart flutters as I think about the sparkling future of these two people. It's a work that makes you want to soak in the afterglow for a while.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

素直に...あ～良かった！

Honestly... ah, that was great!

期待して読んだのに...それ以上に良かったです！二人の愛が眩しい！その後の続編もあったら嬉しいけれど、１巻なのに上手に纏まっていて読み応え十分でした。表紙だけ一見したときはちょっと古くさい絵柄だな...と思いましたが...ごめんなさい！ストーリーに合っているし、身体のラインとかの描き方も綺麗でとっても好みでした！

I read it with anticipation... but it was better than that! The love between them is dazzling! I would be happy if there was a sequel after that, but even though it was volume 1, it was well put together and was easy enough to read. When I only looked at the cover, I thought the design was a bit old... but... sorry! It fits the story, and I really liked the way the body lines were drawn so beautiful!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

予想以上

More than expected

This review contains spoilers. すごくいいとレビューを見て気になって読んだのですが…試し読みと全く印象が違う。本当に良質な映画を観たような読後感です。アーミュッシュの青年テオと元ダンサーでウェイターと『別の仕事』をしてるオズ。テオが文明と隔離されたアーミュッシュの村から出て、普通の生活を体験するラムスプリンガでの出来事。何も知らなかった純真無垢で天使のようだったテオの成長と、傷ついて夢を諦めて生きていたオズが自分を取り戻していく様が見事でした。以前、アーミュッシュの方々のドキュメンタリーを見たことがありますが、村での生活も閉鎖的ではあるけれど長閑でとてもいいものにも思えるんですよね。便利ではあるけど良いことばかりではない、こちらの世界とどちらが良いのか。オズの戸惑いや迷いも、ダニーやクロエの淋しさもよく分かります。ああいう隔離されたコミュニティで暮らす幸せと良くも悪くも自由な外の世界の対比が見事で色々と考えさせられました。ハラハラしたけどラストシーンがとても良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I was curious when I saw a review that it was really good... but my impression was completely different from the trial reading. I feel like I've watched a really good movie after reading it. Amish young Theo and Oz, a former dancer, have a “separate job” with a waiter. An event in Ramspringa where Theo leaves his village of Amush isolated from civilization and experiences a normal life. The growth of Theo, who was innocent and like an angel who knew nothing, and how Oz, who was hurt and lived by giving up on her dreams, regained herself was amazing. I've watched documentaries about Amish people before, and it seems like life in the village is quiet and very nice, albeit closed. It's convenient, but it's not all good, which is better, or this world? I understand Oz's confusion and hesitation, and the loneliness of Danny and Chloe. The contrast between the happiness of living in such an isolated community and the free outside world for better or worse made me think a lot. It was disturbing, but the last scene was really good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

純真からの成長が眩しい

Growth from innocence is dazzling

特殊な環境で暮らすアーミッシュを題材に、生きるということを描いてみせた映画っぽい作品。作者ご本人も「定番ド王道を真剣に描きたい」とのことで、良かったですねー。途中の1カットがとてつもなくエロくて夢に見そうなくらい好き。この後の2人をまた読みたいです。ちょろっと出てくるダニーの兄ジーンが、親愛なるジーンへ、になっているのもまた良し。

It's a cinematic film depicting life, based on the Amish living in a special environment. The artist himself also said, “I seriously want to draw the classic King Road,” which is great. I liked the first cut in the middle so erotic that I almost dreamed about it. I want to read the next 2 people again. It's also nice that Danny's older brother Gene, who comes out a little bit, is now for Dear Jean.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

歴史

history

本当に読んでよかった作品！先生の作品の中ではダントツです。フェチがドぎつい作品を書く先生とは思えない。歴史も学べるし、今のアーミッシュについても考えさせられる。思わず調べてしまいました。こちらは完結してるので安心して読めます。

I'm really glad I read this work! It's by far the best among the teacher's works. I don't think I'm a teacher who writes works with strong fetishes. You can learn history, and it also makes me think about today's Amish. I looked it up without thinking. This one is complete, so you can read it without worry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

若者の人生の決断

Young people's life decisions

This review contains spoilers. アーミッシュという特殊な世界からラムスプリンガという休暇？を利用して街へやって来た青年。ピュアっピュアです。初めて出会ったのがウリをやってるオズ。そんな正反対の二人が惹かれ合い、お互いを想い下した決断が二人にとって新しい未来への第一歩となりますように。希望に満ちた若者がまぶしい。そんなキラキラとした話でした。

This review contains spoilers. A vacation called Ramspringa from the special world of the Amish? A young man who used it to come to town. It's pure, it's pure. The first time I met Oz was Uri. I hope that these two diametrically opposite people are attracted to each other, and that a decision made to think of each other will be the first step towards a new future for both of them. The hopeful young people are dazzling. It was such a sparkling story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

いい話だ〜

That's a great story~

ハッピーエンドでよかったです。テオの純粋な愛がオズに沁みていくような感じが伝わって空いてあたたかい気持ちになりました。年下ワンコ攻め…よかったな…

I'm glad it had a happy ending. The feeling that Theo's pure love was seeping into Oz was conveyed, and it made me feel empty and warm. attacking younger dogs... good...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

しがらみから抜け出して一歩踏み出すまでのキャラクターたちの描写が細やかでとても濃厚なストーリーで胸が熱くなる…時代背景とか文化的なことがわからない無知でも読みやすくて楽しめた！

The depiction of the characters from getting out of their grip to taking a step forward is detailed, and it's a very rich story that makes my heart heat up... it was easy to read and I enjoyed it even if I was ignorant who didn't know the historical background or cultural things!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

口コミが良くて気になってたけど、ツライ話だとちょっとなあと思っていて。でも勇気を出して読んだら良かった!本当映画みたいだった！話がよくまとまってるし、心理描写も良かった!前半、明るい会話が多かったせいか、それ程ツライ感じにはならなかった。今の私達にも共感することがあって。人生、夢、恋、自分の能力、別れ…。たくさん悩み、もがき苦しんでる。二人の濃い人生と恋、良かった!随分前にテレビ(正確には未公開映画を紹介する番組)でラムスプリンガのドキュメンタリーを見たけど、時代は今から二十数年前位かな。だいたいの子が男女とも酒にタバコにセックスに薬物にパーティーざんまいの生活をしてたな。一人は薬物の売人までになって命を狙われてた。でも大学に行って勉強したいって子も一人いた。あの子達は今どうしてるんだろ。村から近い地方都市で過ごすと就職先が無くて、多様な生き方も受け入れてくれなくて9割は村に戻るらしい。でもNYや大きい都市で過ごすと仕事もあるし、多様な生き方も受け入れてくれるので９割は戻らないで都市に残るそうです。

The reviews were good and I was curious, but I was wondering if it was a bad story. But I wish I had gathered my courage and read it! It really looked like a movie! The story was well-organized and the psychological depiction was good too! It wasn't that difficult, probably because there were a lot of bright conversations in the first half. There is something that resonates with us today. Life, dreams, love, my abilities, breakups... I'm struggling and suffering a lot. The intense life and love between them was great! I watched the Ramspringa documentary on TV (to be exact, a program introducing unreleased movies) a long time ago, but the time was probably twenty years ago. Most kids, both men and women, lived a life full of alcohol, cigarettes, sex, drugs, and parties. One person went so far as to become a drug dealer, and their life was being targeted. But there was also one kid who wanted to go to college and study. I wonder how those kids are doing now. If you spend time in a regional city close to the village, they don't have a place of employment, and they don't accept diverse ways of life, and it seems that 90% return to the village. However, when they spend time in NY or big cities, they also have jobs, and they accept diverse ways of life, so it seems that 90% of them will stay in the city without returning.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

見て良かった！

It was great to see!

面白かった！！不憫受けと穏やかなワンコ系攻めで、ワンコにどんどんほだされて行く過程もにやにやして見れる！不憫で途中上手く行くのか不安になっちゃうところもドキドキ楽しめて良かった。受けも攻めも可愛くて愛おしい。

That was interesting!! With their pity and gentle doggy attacks, you can also smirk the process of being slandered more and more by dogs! I'm glad I was able to enjoy the feeling that my pity made me uneasy about whether it would go well along the way. Both receiving and attacking are cute and adorable.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きました

I cried

数年前のこのblがすごいで見つけて購入。泣きました。何度も読み返してます

I found this BL a few years ago and bought it because it was amazing. I cried. I've been rereading it over and over

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

映画のよう

Like a movie

作者も書かれているように、王道中の王道ですがそれがとても良かった。クラシック映画のようでとても情景も情緒もある素敵なストーリーでした。そしてこの後、シリーズの「親愛なるジーンへ」を読んだのですが、これがまた。。お勧めしますよ。

As the author also wrote, it's a royal road in the middle of a royal road, but that was very good. It was a wonderful story with very scenes and emotions, just like a classic movie. And after this, I read the series “Dear Jean,” and this is again... I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

生き方を問われるようだった

It seemed like they were being asked how to live

This review contains spoilers. 絵が独特ですが、表紙で足踏みしてしまっている方は騙されたと思って読んで欲しい。アーミッシュという戒律の厳しい信仰宗教（実在する）を軸にした物語で、ラムスプリンガという一生に一度だけ彼らがハメを外せる期間にスポットを当てて描かれている。人生の岐路に立たされた時のそれぞれの選択は、胸が苦しくなるほどに切ない。そして何がすごいって適当な脇役とか当て馬として生まれたようなキャラは一人もいないところ。ここからはネタバレになるのですが、ダニーとクロエの行動と心情が実は凄く練り込まれている。ダニーは兄（ジーン）がアーミッシュを抜けてしまったことがトラウマになり、自身は両親を傷つけてはならないというプレッシャーもあったと思われる。フォモフォビアに近い状態にまでなっていたが、納屋でオズにキスするシーンから察するにダニーは本来ゲイで、本当に愛していたのはやはりテオだったのでは、と。クロエの言動からも不安や嫉妬が見て取れる部分がある。ただ、クロエはそんな感情を小出しにしながらもダニーを支える姿が綺麗で「恋は素晴らしい呪い」という部分はガッツリ印象に残る。みんながみんな凄く優しくて切ない、胸の奥が熱くなるような話だった。

This review contains spoilers. The picture is unique, but I want those who are stuck on the cover to think they have been deceived and read it. It is a story centered around the Amish religion (which exists) with strict precepts, and it focuses on Ramspringa, a period where they can lose their sex only once in a lifetime. Each choice you make when you are at a crossroads in your life is heartbreaking. And what's amazing is that there aren't any characters that seem to have been born as suitable supporting characters or guitars. There will be spoilers from here on, but the actions and feelings of Danny and Chloe have actually been really worked out. Danny was traumatized by the fact that his older brother (Gene) left the Amish, and it seems that he himself was under pressure not to hurt his parents. It was close to phomophobia, but as you can guess from the scene where he kisses Oz in the barn, Danny was originally gay, and the one he really loved was Theo after all. There is a part where anxiety and jealousy can also be seen from Chloe's words and actions. However, Chloe has a beautiful appearance supporting Danny while showing such feelings, and the “love is a wonderful curse” part leaves a strong impression on her. Everyone was so kind and sad, and it was a heart-warming story.

Helpful

Reviews for THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga