THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga Reviews (P.16)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

This review contains spoilers. 面白かった。まさかアーミッシュがテーマのBLに出会うとは、、、BLはほんとーに広く深く無限の世界だなぁ?作家さんの発想力、物語の構成力素晴らしい♦最初あざとく感じるほどの天然ボケキャラのテオがクライマックスへ向けどんどん人間的な深みを増し魅力的になっていくところなんか凄い‼あまりテオが葛藤するシーンは描かれてないけど、故郷を捨てる、家族や幼なじみや産まれ育った土地を捨てることの意味を誰よりもわかっているんだと、セリフの１つ１つコマの１つ１つで読ませてくれる。大変良い作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. That was interesting. When you meet an Amish themed BL... BL is really a big, deep, and infinite world, isn't it? The writer's imagination and ability to structure the story are amazing ♦ It's amazing where Theo, a natural bokeh character that makes you feel ridiculous at first, gains more and more human depth and becomes attractive as she reaches his climax ‼ Scenes where Theo struggles aren't depicted, but they know better than anyone else what abandoning their hometown, abandoning their family, childhood friends, and the land they were born and raised in, it makes me read each line frame by frame. It was a very good work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしいの一言

A wonderful word

80年代の洋画を観ているよう。ストーリー重視の方もエロ目的の方も読後は深いため息をつくのではないかしら。ここ最近では一の作品です。読まなきゃソンです❕

It's like watching a Western painting from the 80s. I wonder if both those who focus on the story and those for erotic purposes will sigh deeply after reading it. This is my most recent work. If you don't read it, it's Song ❕

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

是非読んで！

Be sure to read it!

BLでこんなにドキドキして読んだのは凄く久しぶりです。テオが実は他人の気持ちが分かる聡い子で、オズワルドに向ける言葉１つ１つが素敵で一生懸命で感動します。

It's been a really long time since I read it with such excitement in BL. Theo is actually a smart kid who can understand the feelings of others, and I'm moved by how wonderful and hard he works with each word addressed to Oswald.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

マジ感動

I'm really moved

This review contains spoilers. すごく感動しましたなんかいよんでも飽きないほんですこれからも読み続けよ

This review contains spoilers. I'm really moved I won't get tired of reading anything, keep reading

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい

wondrous

まるで映画を見ているようでした。物語の始まり、展開、終焉まで愛情のこもったシンプルな台詞回しやストーリーがもう素晴らしい。ほろっと心に染み渡りました。読み終わった後に思わず感嘆の溜め息をつく作品はそうそう出会えません。本当に買って良かった！NYのお話とか、もし続編があったら読みたいです。

It was like watching a movie. The simple lines and story, which are full of love from the beginning, development, and end of the story to the end, are already amazing. I felt at ease seeped into my heart. I don't often come across works that make me sigh with admiration after I've finished reading them. I'm really glad I bought it! If there is a sequel, like the story of NY, I'd like to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

もうホント素晴らしいです。

It's already really amazing.

ストーリーも絵もなにもかも素晴らしいです。レビューがこんなにも高いのが納得しました。続編やボーナストラックが見たい気持ちもありますが、このラストの余韻が幸せでもあり悲しくもあり最高なのでこのままで過不足なく良いなあと思いました。映画のようだと書いている方がいましたが本当にその通りだと思います。

The story, the pictures, everything is amazing. I was convinced that the reviews were so high. There is also a feeling that I want to see the sequel and bonus tracks, but since the afterglow of this last one is both happy and sad, it's great, so I thought it would be nice to leave it like this without any excesses or deficiencies. There were people who said it was like a movie, and I really think that's true.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

言葉にできない…

I can't put it into words...

うぅ…今回ほど自分のちんちくりんな語彙力を恨んだことはない！陳腐なレビューでこの作品を汚したくないので、とりあえず☆5残して消えます！！てかそもそも☆5じゃ足りないんだよーーー！！！ヴィレヴァンさんのポップに『読む映画』っていうのがあったけど、ほんとその通り。吾妻香夜先生の才能✨、神懸かってます。

Wow... I've never hated my dicey vocabulary as much as this time! I don't want to taint this work with cliché reviews, so I'll leave ☆ 5 for now and it will disappear!! Heck ☆ 5 isn't enough in the first place!!! There was something called “movies to read” in Vilévin's pop music, and that's true. Azuma Kaya-sensei's talent ✨ is at stake.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

迷ってるなら是非読んでほしい

If you're unsure, I want you to read it

This review contains spoilers. 配信されるのずっと待ってました。まるで映画を観たような感覚に陥る作品です。余韻が凄い。暗すぎず明る過ぎずエロも程良くあって、そしてハッピーエンドだけで終わらない痛みが残る話です。描きおろしで後日談みたいなのが無かったのも最後の余韻が残ったままで良かったのかなと。その後の2人は想像するしかない。何回読み返しても良いし泣けます。どうか2人が幸せに暮らせてますようにと願わずにはいられません…

This review contains spoilers. I've been waiting a long time for it to be broadcast. It's a film that makes you feel like you've watched a movie. The afterglow is amazing. It's a story that's not too dark, not too bright, has just the right amount of eroticism, and leaves a painful ending that doesn't end with just a happy ending. I wonder if it was good that the final afterglow remained even though it was drawn and didn't have anything to talk about at a later date. I have no choice but to imagine the next two. It doesn't matter how many times I reread it and it makes me cry. I can't help but hope they both live happily ever after...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 06, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

今までと違う(T_T)

Different from before (T_T)

This review contains spoilers. 作者買いです！ギャグBLが多かったので今回も軽い気持ちで読んでたら号泣(T-T)久々にこんなに泣きました。ワンコ×ビッチとかなり好きな組み合わせでしたが、過去の悲しみや生まれ育った掟のようなとこまで細かく描かれていて、一冊まるまるなのでかなり読みごたえがありました。何もかもが禁断になってしまう二人が何を選んで何を捨てるのかを決断するのに苦しくなった。それでも二人が幸せになってくれることを祈ってます！

This review contains spoilers. I'm buying the author! There were a lot of gag BL, so when I read it with a light feeling this time too, I cried (T-T) for the first time in a long time. It was quite a favorite combination of dog x big, but it was quite difficult to read since it was a whole book, even the sorrows of the past and the rules of being born and raised were depicted in detail. It became difficult for the two, whose everything was forbidden, to decide what to choose and what to throw away. Still, I'm praying that the two of them will be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 06, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

超大作

blockbuster

長年BLを読ませてもらっていますが、初めて鳥肌が立ちました。まるで舞台を見ているかのよう、、とにかくストーリが素晴らしいです。感動しました。

I've been reading BL for many years, and I got goose bumps for the first time. It's like watching a stage... the story is simply amazing. I'm moved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

余韻に浸ります！

I'm immersed in the afterglow!

前から凄く気になってた作品でした。うまく感想を書くことが難しいのですが、1人でも多くの人に読んでもらいたい気持ちです。これからの2人に幸あれと願うばかりです。

It was a work I had been really interested in from before. It's difficult to write my impressions well, but I want as many people as possible to read it. I can only wish them all the best in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

とても長く感じました。

It felt like a very long time.

こんなにも一字一句読み残すことなく端から端まで絵を見て台詞を辿ったのは初めてかもって思うくらいに集中して読みました。読み終えた後の切なくてもどかしい気持ち。一息ついても消えない心苦しさ。映画一本見終えた気分です。もっとたくさんの人に読んでもらいたい。

I read it so intensively that I thought it might be the first time I looked at a picture from end to end and followed the lines without leaving anything to read word for word. I feel sad and frustrated after I've finished reading it. A heartache that doesn't go away even after taking a break. I feel like I've finished watching a movie. I want more people to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

今一番好きな作家さんです

This is my favorite writer right now

ダンサーくずれのクズ男の力を借りて、アーミッシュという宗教の異文化に暮らす男の子が、自由に生きられる期間（ラムスプリンガ）を謳歌するお話。最後はハッピーエンドなのですが、その先に果たして希望はあるのか、幸せはあるのかという切ないハッピーエンドで、それもまた良いです。この作者さんは明るいエロから救いのない暗い話まで書き分けるスキルに長けていますね。私がいま一番好きな作家さんです。絵も綺麗、話も大きく丁寧でとても素敵です。

A story about a boy living in a different culture of religion called Amish enjoying a period (lamb springa) where he can live freely with the help of a broken dancer man. There is a happy ending at the end, but it's a sad happy ending as to whether there is hope or happiness beyond that, and that is also good. This author is good at writing everything from bright eroticism to dark stories with no salvation. He's my favorite writer right now. The pictures are beautiful, the stories are big and polite, and very nice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい！2018マイベスト！！

great! 2018 My Best!!

素晴らしいの一言です。メディアを通してだけですが、アーミッシュは、どういう方達かわかっていたつもりですが。その方達の心までは触れることはできませんでしたが、この作品で知ることができました。

That's a great word. It's only through the media, but I think I knew what kind of people the Amish were. I wasn't able to touch the hearts of those people, but I was able to get to know them through this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしいの一言

A wonderful word

読み終わった後の、言葉にできない感情がすごいです。せつなさと嬉しさと、涙を流したくなるほど綺麗な物語でした。アーミッシュ自体はなんとなく知っていたのですが、「ラムスプリンガ」という慣習やその後は知りませんでした。なんて悲しくて切ない選択肢なんだと胸が痛くなりました。読んだ後、アーミッシュについて調べてしまいました。生き方を考えさせられる作品です。

The feeling I can't put into words after I've finished reading it is amazing. It was such a beautiful story that made me want to shed tears with frustration and joy. The Amish themselves were somehow familiar with it, but they didn't know about the practice called “rum springa” or the aftermath. It made my heart ache to think what a sad and sad choice it was. After reading it, I did some research on the Amish. It's a work that makes me think about how to live.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

スタンディングオベーション！！

standing ovation!!

壮大な映画を観終えたような！！こちらの作家さんは前作が好きだったので購入したのですが、この作品でもまた「おもてたんと違う」！いい意味で裏切られました。これは今年何らかのランキングに選ばれるのでは？？選ばれて欲しい！色んな要素を詰め込んではあるのですが、それがぶつかる事なく、相乗効果と言うか個々にも引き立っていて、かなり心を持ってかれました。ノンケ年下ワンコの覚醒…いいですよね！！！間違いないやつ！！！久々にスケールの大きいBLを読みました。舞台が海外だからと言うわけではなく、受け攻め共に、心の成長、葛藤、決断と、短いながらもかなり劇的に人生が揺れ動くさまが描かれているからかなと。沢山の人に読んで貰いたいです！

It's like I've finished watching an epic movie!! This artist liked the previous work, so I bought it, but this one is also “different from Omotetan”! I was betrayed in a good way. Isn't this going to be selected for some kind of ranking this year?? I want them to be selected! It was packed with various elements, but they didn't collide, and each one stood out, or rather, as a synergistic effect, and it made me feel quite a bit of heart. The awakening of a young dog... that's great!!! Definitely one!!! I read a big BL for the first time in a while. It's not because the stage is overseas, but I think it's because it depicts emotional growth, conflict, and decisions, and how life fluctuates quite dramatically even though it's short. I want lots of people to read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せで切ない映画のようでした

It was like a happy and sad movie

This review contains spoilers. 人情味があるお話でとっても良かったです。今後の人生、今まで通り生きていくか、そうしないかの決断が切なかった。はじめは幼く見えたテオが、自分のことも周りもよく分かっている人物に成長して頼もしかったです。オズは挫折しつつも根は優しくて頑張り屋さんなところが魅力的でした。車も持たないアーミッシュという信仰については知りませんでしたが、話の中でやさしく理解できました。登場人物の背景がしっかり描かれていて、エロもあり、私は大満足でした✨欲をいうなら、その後の幸せな二人を少し見てみたかった～でも切なさを残して終わるなら、これがベストですね。

This review contains spoilers. It was a very nice story with a human touch. It was difficult to decide whether to live my future life as before or not. At first, Theo looked young, but he grew into a person who understood himself and his surroundings, and I was reliable. It was fascinating that Oz was a hardworking person with kind roots even though he was frustrated. I didn't know about the belief that Amish don't even have a car, but I was able to easily understand it during the story. The backgrounds of the characters were well drawn, and there was also eroticism, and I was very satisfied ✨ If I were to say greed, I wanted to take a look at the two happy people after that ~ but if you end up leaving a sense of sadness, then this is the best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ジーンも読みたくなった！

I want to read Gene too!

作者さんがカバー裏に書かれてたみたいに、マイナー映画にありそうな、そんな雰囲気のお話でした。以前「桜田先輩‥」を読んでちょっと合わなかったんですが、全然作風が違ってて。絵の感じが作風と合っててちょっとした映画をみた感じでした。ワンコ系攻めはあんまり好みではないですが、テオはその純粋さゆえにNYでも強く生きていけそう。どうか2人で幸せになっておくれ！

It was a story with such an atmosphere as if it were written on the back of the cover by the author, which is likely to be found in a minor film. I read “Sakurada-senpai...” before and it didn't suit me, but the style was completely different. The feel of the picture matched the style, and I felt like I was watching a little movie. I don't really like doggy attacks, but Theo seems to be able to live a strong life even in NY because of his purity. Please keep the two of you happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

大人の階段のぼる

Climbing stairs for adults

初レビューです。アーミッシュについては知らない事が多かったのですが、こちらの本を読んで知る事が出来ました。BL漫画ですけど、アーミッシュの宗教観、価値観を反映させた上での物語で家族愛やほんとに愛しい人との別れや人生の挫折を経てなお、愛する人を選択するドラマチックなストーリーでBL漫画の金字塔といった作品ですね。この作品に出会えて良かった。?

This is my first review. There were many things I didn't know about the Amish, but I was able to find out by reading this book. It's a BL comic, but it's a story that reflects Amish religious views and values, and it's a dramatic story where you choose someone you love even after going through family love, breakups with someone you really love, and life setbacks, and it's a work that is the gold standard of BL comics. I'm glad I came across this work.?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

肉まん食いたくなる

I want to eat nikuman

もっちり体格のいい長身イケメン二人がくんずほぐれつ。たまりませんな。。綺麗な絵で読みやすい。目が可愛い。

Two tall, good-looking men with firm physiques unwind. it's irresistible.. The pictures are beautiful and easy to read. My eyes are cute.

Helpful

Reviews for THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga