A REGENCY CHRISTMAS CAROL Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

夢の力

The power of dreams

This review contains spoilers. あの夢が現実だったらと思うと胸が苦しく、居た堪れない気持ちになりますね。そのおかげでヒーローは間違った決断をしなくて済みましたね。お父さんが息子のために見せた夢。夢で良かった！

This review contains spoilers. It hurts my heart and makes me feel unbearable when I think that dream is a reality. Thanks to that, the hero didn't have to make wrong decisions. A dream that a father showed for his son. I'm glad it was a dream!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

流石の筆力！

Excellent writing ability!

This review contains spoilers. 貧しくても気高いヒロインの愛情が、悪魔のような経営者となってしまった氷のようなヒーローの心を溶かしていく、ファンタジー要素のあるラブストーリーです。繊細な絵柄と、その表現力と、世界観は流石でした！ファンタジー風なのが苦手な私ですが、最後には引き込まれてしまいました。秀作です。

This review contains spoilers. It's a love story with fantasy elements where the love of a poor but noble heroine melts the heart of an icy hero who has become a devilish manager. The delicate design, its expressive power, and view of the world were amazing! I don't like fantasy stuff, but I was drawn in at the end. Excellent work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

騙された…

I was scammed...

This review contains spoilers. 新たな城館主に幽霊がみせる3つの正しい導きに時間軸を狂わされ、まんまと騙されてしまいましたw。間違いに気付いたヒーローならば、夢にみたような悲しい未来にはならないでしょうね。

This review contains spoilers. The timeline was upset by the three correct guides shown by the ghost of the new castle owner, and I was completely deceived lol. If you're a hero who realizes his mistakes, the future won't be as sad as you've dreamed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

展開は王道

Development is king

先も何となく読めてしまう王道のシナリオながら、最終的には泣きながらラストを迎えました。道中辛くても、多少都合が良くてもハッピーエンドなので本当に良かった。

It's a classic scenario that I can somehow read ahead, but in the end, I reached the end while crying. It was really nice because it had a happy ending, even if it was difficult along the way or if it was somewhat convenient.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読み返してます

I've been rereading it over and over

さちみりほ先生の作品が好きで購入しました。こちらの作品もほんと好き。童話みたいなストーリーと絵、魅せ方が絶妙すぎる…。良すぎて、何度も繰り返し読むと思います。

I liked Sachi Miriho sensei's work and bought it. I really like this work too. The storyline and pictures are just like children's stories, and the way they are fascinating is too exquisite... It's so good that I think I'll read it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

安定のさちみりほ先生

Stable Sachimiriho sensei

This review contains spoilers. よ、よかった…途中とんでもないバッドエンドになるのかと思って震えました。でもやっぱりさちみりほ先生は話の持っていき方がお上手です！2組とも幸せになって本当によかったです。

This review contains spoilers. Yo, good... I shuddered thinking it would be a ridiculous bad end along the way. But after all, Sachimiriho sensei is good at bringing stories to life! I'm really glad that both groups are happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ほぅ～クリスマスですもの

Wow, it's Christmas stuff

原題のクリスマスキャロルさながらに、幽霊が見せてくれたものは、、、、産業革命のころはそうだったのでしょうね。クリスマスに邸宅に住民を招く、クリスマスのごちそうやプレゼントも素晴らしいけれど、根本的に生活も改善する。そうしていなかったらサタンというわけかな

Just like the original Christmas Carol, the ghost showed me... that was probably the case during the Industrial Revolution. Residents are invited to the mansion at Christmas, and while the Christmas treats and gifts are wonderful, they also fundamentally improve lives. If I hadn't done that, I wonder if it would be Satan

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

^_^

^_^

ヒーローが過去・現在・未来を夢に見て進んでいくお話でした^_^色々な葛藤のなか最後の方でヒロインに話す未来の夢がグッときました。オススメします^_^

It was a story about the hero moving forward by dreaming about the past, present, and future ^_^ Amidst various conflicts, the dream of the future he talks to the heroine towards the end came as a hit. I recommend it ^_^

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 24, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハズレなし

No loss

This review contains spoilers. さみちりほ先生の作品にハズレはないです。表紙とタイトルから、ファンタジー？と思ったのですが、違いました(笑)貧民出のヒーローは、自らの才能で成り上がりましたが、心の芯の部分ではコンプレックスがあります。手に入れた工場の労働者たちの暴動でヒロインと出会い、その清廉な心根の彼女のことを忘れられなくなりました。ヒロインもまた美しいサタンのようなヒーローに心奪われ、そして、その悲しい過去を知り、より愛するようになりました。屋敷の主は三つの夢を見て正しき道を選べば繁栄がもたらされるという言い伝え通りに彼は夢を見ます。ラストはもちろんハッピーエンドですが、彼が見た三つ目の夢が余りに辛いもので夢だとわかっていても読んでいて辛かったです。作家さんの力量を感じました。

This review contains spoilers. There is nothing wrong with Samichiriho sensei's work. From the cover and title, fantasy? I thought, but that was different (laughs) Heroes from the Poor were made up of their own talents, but they have complexes at the core of their hearts. I met the heroine during the riots of the factory workers who got it, and I couldn't forget her clean heart. The heroine was also captivated by a hero like the beautiful Satan, and she learned about her sad past and came to love her even more. The owner of the mansion sees three dreams, and he dreams according to the legend that if he chooses the right path, prosperity will be brought. Of course, the last one had a happy ending, but the third dream he saw was so painful that it was hard to read even though I knew it was a dream. I felt the artist's ability.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いちゃった

I cried

This review contains spoilers. クリスマス・キャロルのようなハートフルなお話。もちろんさちみ先生なのでハートフルになるのは分かっていて読むんですが、やっぱり想像を超えて良いお話。ラストにジョセフがバーバラのためについた嘘が美しくて切なくて、本当に見た夢は悲しく救いのない未来だったけれど、絶対にそうはさせない、っていう強いジョセフの決意が感じられて、きっとその決意、願いの通りになってゆくであろう未来が想像できて、光が射すようで眩しくて、涙がほろり…。

This review contains spoilers. A heartwarming story like A Christmas Carol. Of course, it's Sachimi sensei, so I read it because I know it's going to be heartwarming, but after all, it's a good story beyond my imagination. The lie that Joseph told for Barbara at the end was beautiful and sad, and the dream I really saw was a sad and hopeless future, but I could feel Joseph's strong determination not to let that happen, and I was able to imagine a future where that determination and wish would surely come true, and I was so dazzling as if the light was shining, and my tears welled up...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハラハラしました

It was jarring

This review contains spoilers. 幽霊が見せる夢が正しい道を教えてくれるという城館で、ヒーローも夢を見ました。でもヒーローは間違えてしまったのだと、読んでいる途中で悲しくなりました。さすがさちみ先生。いいお話でした。ヒーローも友人もどうかお幸せに。

This review contains spoilers. The hero also had a dream in the castle, where dreams shown by ghosts tell them the right path. But the hero made a mistake, and I felt sad as I read it. As expected, Sachimi sensei. That was a great story. May your heroes and friends be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

さすがと言うしかない

As expected, I have no choice but to say

さちみ先生の数多い作品の中でも、さらに秀逸(個人的見解)。私は終盤泣きっぱなしだった。HQ=ハピエンという大前提があるので、涙は悲しみから喜びに変わったが。“3つの夢”がキーワードなので、随所に夢のシーンが入り、一部、読み手によっては理解しにくいかもしれないが、それこそが読み手の心理を逆手にとった見事な構成力。さすがです、さちみ先生！私は見事に騙されました(笑)ちゃんとあるんだな、切り替えのラインが。ただ単に時間の経過を示すには、背景と一体になっているから、うっかり見逃してた…物語に引き込まれて、夢中で読むほど気付かないかも。どこのシーンのことかは、読んだ人にしか解らない(笑) 通常より多いページ数と安定した作画、『クリスマスキャロル』を彷彿させるストーリー。クリスマスシーズンじゃなくてもオススメです！ティッシュの箱を用意するのもお勧めしておきます。

Among Sachimi sensei's many works, it is even more excellent (personal opinion). I kept crying at the end of the game. There is a major premise that HQ = happy, so my tears changed from sadness to joy. Since “three dreams” is the keyword, there are dream scenes everywhere, and some of them may be difficult to understand depending on the reader, but that is a splendid compositional power that takes advantage of the reader's psychology. As expected, Sachimi sensei! I was so fooled (laughs) There's a proper line to switch between them. To simply show the passage of time, it's integrated with the background, so I inadvertently missed it... I'm drawn into the story, and maybe I don't notice it until I'm engrossed in reading it. The story is reminiscent of “A Christmas Carol,” with a larger number of pages than normal and stable animation, which is only understood by those who read it (laughs). I recommend it even if it's not Christmas season! I also recommend preparing a tissue box.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

心が温かくなります

It warms my heart

作者買いです。さちみりほさんの作品は、いつも心が温かくなる、優しいラブストーリー。ステキな絵ととびきりのストーリー構成で、毎回、買って良かったと思える作品に仕上げられています。ぜひぜひ、読んでみてください。

I'm buying the author. Sachi Miriho's works are gentle love stories that always warm my heart. With wonderful pictures and an extraordinary story structure, it is finished in a work that I'm glad I bought every time. Please be sure to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

いつも感動しています♦

I'm always impressed ♦

さちみりほ先生の作品はほぼ全て購読しています?いつも素晴らしい構成力……感服しています。この作品も私の拙い言葉の羅列より購読なさって下さい。お薦めします。

Have you subscribed to almost all of Sachi Miriho sensei's works? It's always a great composition... I admire it. Please subscribe to this work as well from my list of poor words. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読み応えあり！

It's a good read!

他の人のレビューを読んだ上での作者買いです。盛沢山なのに上手く話がまとまっているのは、さすがのさちみ先生！登場人物も多いのですが、読み応えのある感動ものストーリーに仕上がってます。クリスマスに読みたいかも？

I bought the author after reading other people's reviews. As expected, it was Sachimi sensei who put together the story so well even though there was a lot of work! There are many characters, but it's a moving story that's worth reading. Maybe you want to read it for Christmas?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

クリスマスキャロル

A Christmas carol

This review contains spoilers. 意地悪なお金持ちのスクルージがお金はあっても不幸な未来を夢に見て改心するあのクリスマスのお話のハーレクイン版！途中、老けて結婚できず不幸せ（それでもラブラブ）になった主人公のところが新鮮！に感じてすごく面白かったです！最後はお決まりのハッピーエンド！毎回おんなじハーレクインに飽き飽きしてる方にもオススメです?

This review contains spoilers. Harlequin version of that Christmas story where the mean rich Scrooge is converted by dreaming of an unhappy future even though he has money! Along the way, the part about the main character who got old and couldn't get married and became unhappy (but still lovey-dovey) is fresh! It felt like that and it was really interesting! At the end, it's always a happy ending! Is it also recommended for those who are tired of the same Harlequin every time?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

夢のお告げ?

a dream announcement?

館を買った悪魔のような雇ね主ジョー、館の見せる夢のお告げで、本当の愛に目覚める!胸のすくような展開で、あ～良かった!やはりハーレクインだな、と。アンと親友のお坊ちゃまも結ばれて、大団円!なにげにアンが良い子で好きだった!さちみりほ先生の描く黒髪ロング、最高です!

Joe, the devilish employer who bought the mansion, awakens to true love with the announcement of the house's dream! It was a heart-pounding development, and oh, great! After all, it's Harlequin. Anne and her best friend, the monk, have also tied the knot, and it's a big group! After all, Anne was a good girl and I loved her! The long black hair drawn by Sachi Miriho sensei is amazing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

正しい選択

The right choice

人生にはいくつもの選択があり、その選択の積み重ねが、今の自身を作っている。けど、それが後悔ばかりの日々だったならこんな悲しい事はないですよね。ハッピーエンドで良かった！！

There are many choices in life, and the accumulation of those choices has made me who I am now. But if those were days full of regrets, it wouldn't be this sad. I'm glad it had a happy ending!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

不思議な時間

Mysterious time

さちみりほさんのHQ はほとんど購入してます。この作品は、ヒーローの過去、現在、未来の時間の流れと心の闇とが織り成す物語で、美しく仕上がっています。

I have bought most of Sachi Miriho's HQ. This work is a story where the hero's past, present, and future flow of time and the darkness of his heart are woven, and it is beautifully finished.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

This review contains spoilers. この作家さんの作品はどれも温かい気持ちにさせてくれます。苦労して手に入れた地位もヒロインとの出逢いによって今までの辛かった過去からの恨みのし上がってきた苦労もよじ曲がってしまった気持ちも将来の妄想の夢によって導かれて行きます。二人が明るい未来に舵を切れて良かった素敵な作品です。

This review contains spoilers. All of this artist's works make me feel warm. My hard-earned position and the feeling that my grudge from my painful past has been raised by my encounter with the heroine, and the hardships and twisting feelings are led by delusional dreams for the future. It's a wonderful work where I'm glad the two were able to steer into a bright future.

Helpful

Reviews for A REGENCY CHRISTMAS CAROL Manga