Brotherhood Failed Successfully Manga Reviews (P.35)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

テンポがよくてさくっと楽しめました。特にギャグ絵がツボです。二人とも可愛くて温かい目で見守りたい感じでした。

The tempo was good and I was able to enjoy it quickly. The gag picture in particular is a pressure point. Both of them were cute and I felt like watching over them with warm eyes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

よい

good

楽しく読めました！サクッときゅんが手に入ります。ふたりとも可愛かった！

I enjoyed reading it! You can get it quickly. They were both so cute!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい

readable

底抜けに明るいわけでもないし、気だるいストーリーでもない、いい意味で丁度良く力の抜けた作品でした。

It wasn't downright bright, it wasn't a dull story, and it was a work that just lost its strength in a good sense.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

いい！(※3巻読んでの追記あり)

That's good! (*There are additional notes after reading 3 volumes)

試し読みだけだと、チャラ受けとスパダリ攻めの義兄弟cpのありがちな俺様系の話かと思っていましたが、２巻とも読むと二人がすごくかわいいし結構ギャク色強めで面白かったです！受けが危機のシーンもひどく痛くなくてその辺りもライトで読みやすかったです。続編がさらにあったら喜んで買います！❗追記❗3巻読みました…うーん、続編希望してたけれど正直もうちょっとなかったかな？ていう印象を受けました。展開の大枠はいいとして、話の運び方をもうちょっとスマートにしてほしかったと思うのは私だけ？あと、作画が1,2巻よりも下手になってないか？ギャグ絵が浮いてる感じするし、顔と体のバランスに違和感を拭えないまま読了しました。3巻がいまいち期待外れだったので☆-1にします。

If it was just a trial reading, I thought it would be a common story about my brother-in-law CP who attacks Chara Tak and Spadari, but when I read both volumes, they were so cute and quite gaffy, and it was interesting! The scene of the crisis of reception wasn't terribly painful, and that area was easy to read with a light. I'd be happy to buy more sequels! ❗ Postscript ❗ I read volume 3... Hmm, I was hoping for a sequel, but honestly, there aren't any more? I got that impression. Assuming the general outline of the development is fine, am I the only one who wanted the way the story was carried out a little smarter? Also, aren't you worse at drawing than volumes 1 and 2? I felt that the gag picture was floating, and I read it without being able to erase the sense of incongruity with the balance between face and body. Volume 3 was quite disappointing, so I'm going to make it ☆ -1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 22, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

芹のヤキモチ妬くところはかわいかった。エロ部分も、けっこうなエロさだったと思います。風介もかわいい！楽しんで読める作品でした。

Seri's jealous feeling was cute. I think the erotic part was pretty erotic, too. Fuusuke is cute too! It was a work I enjoyed reading.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

キャラ

Chara

クズと噂と…のCPかと思うくらい同じ見た目のキャラですが、こっちのが断然かわいいです。おバカっぷりがかわいくて。

The characters look the same enough that I think they're CP for Scum and Rumor..., but this one is definitely cute. You're so cute, stupid.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

バランスがいい

The balance is good

This review contains spoilers. 個人的な感想になりますが、攻めが黒髪美形・受けが愛すべきおバカさんなのがバランス良くて好きです。同い年だけど義兄弟という設定は他の作品でもありそうですが、キャラがしっかり確立されているので読んでて気にならなかったです。続刊が今から楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. This is my personal impression, but I like that the attack is an idiot with beautiful dark hair and a lovable reception because it has a good balance. Although they are the same age, the setting of brother-in-law seems to be in other works, but since the characters are well established, I didn't mind reading it. I'm looking forward to the next edition.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

好みなのか表紙には期待できなかったので、軽い感じで読んで見たら、グイグイ読み込んじゃいました。風介と芹の義兄弟カップルに期待大です。

I wasn't expecting the cover to see if I liked it, so when I read it with a light feeling, it read quickly. Expectations are high for Fuusuke and Seri's brother-in-law couple.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良きキャラ

Good character

少女漫画まで書いちゃう風介のかわいさと、イケメンで溺愛する芹のかっこよさ、良いです。個人的には今どきの若者特有の軽いノリがちょい苦手ではありますが、カネ子先生のユーモアに面白くするセンスが光り、楽しく読み進められました。

The cuteness of Fuusuke, who even writes girls' comics, and the coolness of Seri, who is a handsome guy who dotes on her, are great. Personally, I'm a little bad at the light nature peculiar to today's young people, but Kaneko sensei's sense of humor that makes me interesting shone through, and I enjoyed reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

ギャグ多目で読みやすい。普段BＬをあまり読まないのですが楽しく読めました❗️ただ、私としては２巻完結で良かった印象です。３巻目は特に印象にも残らず・・・

Easy to read with lots of gags. I don't usually read BL, but I enjoyed reading it ❗️ However, for me, I have the impression that I am glad that 2 volumes have been completed. Volume 3 didn't leave a particular impression...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリーにはまってしまった。

I'm addicted to the story.

立ち読み増量で読みましたが、その先がすごく気になって即買いました。風介大好き。芹もかっこいい。エロなシ-ンがたくさんあったし、ストーリーも好みでした。?

I read it with more standing reading, but I was really curious about the future, so I bought it right away. I love Fuusuke. Seri is cool too. There were a lot of erotic scenes and I liked the story too.?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

勘違い⚡

Misunderstanding ⚡

1巻表紙の風介(茶髪)がまさかロン毛とは思わず、女装男子とばかり思って牽制していた作品?中身は全然違ったw本来チャラ男は好みじゃないけど、風介のちょいおバカぷりが功を奏してストーリーも明るく面白かった♦1巻は酔った勢いで関係を持った相手が義兄弟になり、ラブラブになるまで?巻末には冒頭にたどり着く前のショートストーリーが収録されていて、これが良かった?2巻はそんなラブエロ２人に割って入る人物登場により、ちょっとゴタゴタしますね?どちらも修正少ないエロたっぷり&ラブも多いですが、好みの問題で私はシンプルな1巻が好き?風介が意外としっかり兄をしていて、ハイスペック設定である弟・芹は余裕あるとみせかけて風介に執着溺愛してるのがイイ‼エロは濃厚で詳細まで描かれているためたっぷり味わえるかと❗お風呂での…良かったですよ?風介が変に女々しい受けじゃないところも好ポイント?まだ見ぬ花椿家長男も気になるなぁ♦次回も楽しみに待ってます?

Is this a work where Fuusuke (brown hair) on the cover of volume 1 didn't think he had long hair and restrained himself by thinking only that he was a transvestite? What's inside is completely different lol originally I don't like Chara Otoko, but Fuusuke's Little Idiot Puri paid off and the story was bright and interesting ♦ Volume 1 until someone they had a relationship with while drunk became a brother-in-law and became lovey-dovey? The short story before we got to the beginning was recorded at the end of the book, so was this good? Volume 2 is a bit cluttered with the appearance of characters splitting into two such lovelos, isn't it? Both have plenty of eroticism and a lot of love with little correction, but I prefer a simple volume due to taste issues? Fuusuke is surprisingly a solid older brother, and it's good that his younger brother Seri, who has a high spec setting, is obsessed and doting on Fuusuke by pretending that he can afford it ‼ The erotica is rich and detailed, so I wonder if I can enjoy it enough ❗ in the bath... that was great? the fact that fuusuke doesn't have a strangely feminine reception is also a good point? I'm also worried about the eldest son of the Hanatsubaki family who hasn't been seen yet ♦ I'm looking forward to the next one too?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

いいです。

That's good.

2巻の立ち読みをしてたまらず購入。エッチい描写が可愛くていいです。

I read 2 volumes and couldn't help but buy it. It's nice that the naughty depiction is cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

女の子大好き

I love girls

This review contains spoilers. なはずの風介が弟君にまんまとハマっていく感じが、かわいいですね。続編購入するか悩み中

This review contains spoilers. The feeling that Fuusuke, who is supposed to be so into his younger brother, is so cute. I'm worried about whether to buy a sequel

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 16, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

前作より

More than the previous work

This review contains spoilers. 前作が好みだったので買いました。兄の愛されおとぼけキャラが愛おしい。2人の仲がちゃんと深まっていきます。

This review contains spoilers. I liked the previous one, so I bought it. My older brother's beloved Otoboke character is adorable. The relationship between the two deepens properly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

内容も読みやすく、絵も綺麗で良かったのですが、星4なのは、受けの男の子が女の子に見えてしまうどころが、少し残念でした

It was nice that the content was easy to read and the pictures were beautiful, but it was a bit disappointing that the 4 stars made the recipient look like a girl

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった！

That was interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 2巻でちょっと修羅場りますがストーリーもエロもよかったです！お兄ちゃんのバカっぽいのが可愛い！弟は若干ストーカーじみてますがそれも可愛い！

This review contains spoilers. It's a bit of a shambles with volume 2, but the story and eroticism were great too! The fact that your older brother looks like an idiot is cute! My little brother stalks a little bit, but that's cute too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

軽く読める

Can read lightly

BLって兄弟もん多いし、ほぼ読まないんだけど、これは買ったな。なんだろー…軽い。題名かなぁ〜。良い感じですよね( ´∀｀)重くないし。「何？それ。ケンカ上等的な？」みたいな。クスってする題名だしね。「兄弟なのに」とか「兄弟で」とか、皆無だ。義兄弟なんだけど、それでも皆無だ。本人らも「そういえば」的な感覚だし( ´∀｀)面白いから、読み返してます。軽いけど、結構マジなラブですよ、こいつら( ´∀｀)

BL has a lot of siblings, and I hardly read it, but I bought this one. I wonder what... it's light. I wonder if it's the title. It's a nice feeling, isn't it ('∀`) and it's not heavy. “What? it. Are fights superior?” It's like that. It's a title called Kusu, isn't it? There's no such thing as “even though they're siblings” or “as siblings.” They're brothers-in-law, but they're still none at all. The people themselves also had a “speaking of it” feeling ('∀`), and it's interesting, so I'm rereading it. It's light, but it's pretty serious love, these guys ('sweet`)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ハーフアップ男子好きすぎ

I like half-up boys too much

ロン毛のオトコのコ大好きです。風介のおバカっぽいとこかわいすぎ。芹の兄弟の設定が分かりにくかった。小さい弟やお兄ちゃんとは母親違い？その辺よくわかんなかった。

I love men with long hair. Fuusuke's idiot is so cute. Seri's brothers' settings were hard to understand. Is a mother different from a younger brother or older brother? I didn't really understand that area.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗なのと

The picture is beautiful

兄が少しオツムが緩いところがエロさを増しているような気がします。この先も仲良くやって欲しい。

I feel that the fact that my older brother is a little laid-back is increasing the eroticism. I want them to stay on good terms in the future.

Helpful

Reviews for Brotherhood Failed Successfully Manga