Brotherhood Failed Successfully Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

こちらは義理の兄弟もの。

This is my brother-in-law's.

This review contains spoilers. 親同士の再婚で兄弟になったと思ったら、一夜の過ちと思ってた男・芹だった。芹の執着はかなりで、風介は振り回されてるけど、結局体からの関係から、好きになっていくのが面白い。二人のやり取りがすきです。そして、風介の友達もなかなかドライでいい。恋人になってからの、芹が風介にオープンに好きだと甘々にしてくるところもよいです。ﾔﾝﾃﾞﾚ系が好きならはまれます。

This review contains spoilers. When I thought they had become siblings due to remarriage between parents, it was Seri, a man who thought it was an overnight mistake. Seri's obsession is quite intense, and Fuusuke is swayed around, but in the end, it's interesting that they fall in love with her body. I like the interaction between the two of them. Also, it's nice that Fuusuke's friend is pretty dry. It's also nice that after they became lovers, Seri openly sweetened Fuusuke that they liked them. If you like yandere, you'll fall in love with it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった～!

that was fun~!

This review contains spoilers. 受けがアホ可愛いくて大好きです!3巻は展開にムリヤリ感あって、ストーリー的には1、2巻の方が面白かったかな。攻め父の顔がキレイすぎて違和感…。でも幸せそうな未来の様子が垣間見られて良かったです。修正甘めで美珍＆美ふぐりがステキでした!

This review contains spoilers. The reception is so cute and I love it! Volume 3 had an unbelievable sense of development, so I think volumes 1 and 2 were more interesting in terms of story. The attacking father's face was so pretty that I felt uncomfortable... But I'm glad I was able to catch a glimpse of a happy future. The correction was sweet and Bichin & Bi Fuguri were wonderful!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

エチエチハッピー

Echiechihappy

1巻目買ってめちゃはまり3巻まであっという間に読んじゃいましたホントに創作というかＢLはこうあって欲しいってのがいっぱい詰まってて幸です

I bought the first volume and was so addicted to it that I read volume 3 in a blink of an eye. I'm really happy that it's filled with so many creations, or rather BL that I want it to happen

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

「創作だからいいじゃない」

“It's fine because it's a creation, isn't it?”

This review contains spoilers. と仰ったカネ子先生、その通りな作品をありがとうございます！（笑）1巻の表紙の印象とだいぶ違いましたが（個人的感想）、エロくて甘くて、わちゃわちゃで楽しい作品でした！芹も風介も、2家族もマイペース過ぎる人たちで、細かな問題は置いておき、ハピエンに収まってよかったです。お兄ちゃんや幼馴染はどうなったのかなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. Thank you, Kaneko sensei, for such a true work! (Laughter) It was quite different from my impression of the cover of volume 1 (personal impression), but it was an erotic, sweet, messy, and fun work! Seri, Fuusuke, and the 2 families are all self-paced people, so I'm glad they left the detailed issues behind and settled in Happien. I wonder what happened to my older brother and childhood friend.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ドタバタ義兄弟ラブ？

slapstick brother-in-law love?

大好きな中川カネ子先生。えっちのシーンはなかなかに直接的で良いです。カネ子先生らしいドタバタ感が楽しいです。

I love Nakagawa Kaneko sensei. The scene over there is pretty direct and nice. The slapstick feeling typical of Kaneko sensei is fun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せ〜

happy~

周りの人達が理解ある人ばかりで良かったなと思いました。そのおかげで2人は幸せに暮らしているんだと思います。個人的には梅兄めっちゃ好き笑

I was glad that all the people around me were understanding. Thanks to that, I think they are living a happy life. Personally, I really like Ume brother lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい！

It's interesting!

兄弟失格ってタイトルに入ってるから、兄弟ものでシリアスなの？中川カネ子先生なのに？と購入してみましたが、やっぱり期待を裏切らないおもしろさ溢れる作品でした。親の再婚で義兄弟になった芹と風介。はじまりは酔った勢いだけど、芹は計画的かな。兄弟だからとかいう仄暗い雰囲気は皆無で、ノンケの風介が芹の強引さに振り回されながらも距離が縮まっていくお話です。随所に笑えるシーンがあるんだけど、しつこすぎずわざとらしく過ぎず、恋愛とエロと笑いがバランスよく描かれていました。ワリキリが好きでこちらの作品も購入したのですが、ワリキリは無駄が省かれていて現実的でワンランク上の作品で笑いのセンスも格別。こちらの兄弟失格の作品は、あとがきにありましたが創作だこらこそ全てすんなりとことなきを得る話にしたかったとあるように、芹の兄弟の登場や思考は非現実的で引っ掻き回しつつも全て丸く収ます。ワリキリと比べると絵や笑いなど若干見劣りするというか洗練さに欠けますが、十分楽しめる作品でした。修正もあまあまでヨダレものでしたよ。

Sibling Disqualification is in the title, so is it serious about siblings too? Even though it's Nakagawa Kaneko sensei? I bought it, and after all, it was a fun work that didn't disappoint. Seri and Fusuke became brothers-in-law due to their parents' remarriage. The beginning was drunken, but I wonder if Seri had a plan. There is no dark atmosphere like they are siblings, and the distance shrinks even though Fuusuke from Nonke is swayed by Seri's aggressiveness. There are laughable scenes everywhere, but they were neither too insistent nor too deliberate, and the depiction was well-balanced between romance, eroticism, and laughter. I like Wali Kiri, so I bought this one too, but Wari Kiri is a realistic, higher-grade work with no waste, and the sense of laughter is exceptional. There was an afterword to this work about Disqualifying Brothers, but just as I wanted to make it a story about getting everything smoothly and without incident, the appearances and thoughts of Seri's siblings are unrealistic and all fit together while scratching around. Compared to Wali Kiri, the pictures, laughter, etc. are slightly inferior, or rather lacking in refinement, but it was a work I fully enjoyed. The corrections were also pretty ridiculous.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

シュウセイアマイ

Ambergris japonica

表題の通りでございますね。ストーリーも自分好みです。スパダリで一見軽そうな攻めの方が受けに対する気持ちを抑えられなくなってくる様子が垣間見えるのでそれはもう最高でございますええ。もちろん受けは性格含め可愛いでごわすよ

As the title suggests, isn't it? I also like the story. I can catch a glimpse of how an attackers who seem light at first glance in Spadari will be unable to suppress their feelings about receiving, so that's already awesome. Of course, the reception is cute and scary, including her personality

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最初はどうなることかと…

I wonder what will happen at first...

This review contains spoilers. 大円満でヨカッターお人好しで流され気味のふうだけど、ちゃんと物事を考えている姿勢に好感が持てましたてっちゃんというお隣さんの存在もいい一番好きなシーンは怒り心頭のふうが見合いを潰しに行くときだから余計に芹の父親に気持ちを聞かれて切った啖呵にはジーンとしましたいつまでも幸せに！！

This review contains spoilers. It was a great success, and they seemed to be swept away, but I liked the attitude of thinking about things properly. My favorite scene where the presence of a neighbor named Tecchan is also good is when she gets angry and goes to destroy the deal, so Seri's father asks me how she feels, so I'm so happy forever!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいいーなぁーおい！

that's cute, hey!

風介ちょろ！かわいい！芹ちゃんも激重執着最高ですわ。こんな家族、こんな兄弟、こんな恋人いいと思う！仕事で疲れて癒されたい時に読み返してます。しっかりエロいし。

Chorō Fuusuke! cute! Seri-chan is also super obsessed. I think it would be nice to have a family like this, siblings like this, and a lover like this! I reread it when I'm tired from work and want to be healed. It's definitely erotic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルなtn

Realistic tn

ワリキリがおもしろかったのでこちらも購入しました。こちらのほうがギャグが多めなのかな。それより描写がそのままでビックリしました

Wali Kiri was interesting, so I bought this one too. I wonder if this one has more gags. More than that, I was surprised that the description was the same

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです！

I like it!

This review contains spoilers. こちらの作者様初めて購入させていただきました！攻めの嫉妬が最高でした！！受けはかわいい！！是非、1巻だけではなく続きも読んでもらいたい作品です！

This review contains spoilers. This author bought it for the first time! The aggressive jealousy was awesome!! The reception is cute!! I definitely want people to read not only volume 1, but also the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おススメ！！

I recommend it!!

この方の漫画は初めてでしたがすごい雰囲気ありますね！風介くん男にも女にもウケそうな独特の雰囲気！！好きです！！トーンの影の使い方が絶妙でエチシーンもリアルです！白線修正で見えまくりでした。多いし！！好きです！！受けのノンケが焦らされまくって堕ちていくのが大好きなのでドンピシャでした。買ってよかったー！！

It was my first comic by this person, and it has an amazing atmosphere! Fuusuke has a unique atmosphere that seems to appeal to both men and women! I like it!! The way the tonal shadows are used is exquisite, and the scenes are realistic too! It looked all over with white line correction. There are a lot of them!! I like it!! It was crazy because I love how impatient Nonke gets impatient and falls away. I'm glad I bought it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

エロいです、さいこうです。

It's erotic, that's enough.

This review contains spoilers. 兄受けってありがとうございます。めっちゃかわいかった！イチャイチャいっぱいで最高でした！！面白かった！

This review contains spoilers. Thank you for accepting my brother. It was so cute! There was so much flirtatious it was awesome!! That was interesting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

関係性

relationships

こういう関係性が要となるBL作品が好き。近いような遠いようななんとも言えない関係性がとってもツボなので。

I like BL works where this kind of relationship is essential. That's because an indescribable relationship that seems close or far is a great pressure point.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

ワリキリを呼んで癖になり、こちらを買ってみたらどハマりました。兄弟の禁断感はあまりなくて、ギャグ要素多めな感じです。ふうすけのラフなスタイル大好きです。立ち姿とか可愛くてデフォルメキャラも昔のマンガを思い出させる感じで読んでて楽しいです。もっと続きを読みたいです

I got into the habit of inviting Wali Kiri, and I was addicted to it when I bought this one. The siblings don't have much sense of forgiveness, and it feels like they have a lot of gag elements. I love Fuusuke's rough style. The cute, deformed characters, such as standing figures, are also fun to read because they remind me of old manga. I want to read more

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い‼︎ 期待以上でした‼︎

Author purchase ‼ ︎ it was more than I expected ‼ ︎

ワリキリ読んで中川センセの大ファンになりました！今は先生の本全部収集中です！この本も最高でした！ストーリーもエロさも期待を裏切らない。受けの可愛いチャラさ、攻めの底知れないカッコよさにメロメロです！リピート本棚に保存決定〜！

I read Warikiri and became a big fan of Nakagawa Sense! Right now I'm collecting all of my teacher's books! This book was great too! The story and eroticism don't disappoint. I'm amazed at how cute and how cool the attack is. I decided to save it to my repeat bookshelf ~!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんか3巻に向かって

Somehow towards volume 3

This review contains spoilers. 顔が芹はイケメンになっていくし、風介は可愛くなっていく！めっちゃエロシーンも好みだし♡♡風介と風介のお父さんは茉莉花が好きで芹のお父さんと茉莉花は風介のお父さんを取り合いしててとかマジで近所でガチャガチャしすぎてるのも笑えるよかった！

This review contains spoilers. Seri's face is turning into a handsome guy, and Fuusuke is getting cute! I really like erotic scenes too ♡♡ Fusuke and Fuusuke's father liked Marika, and Seri's father and Marika were arguing with Fuusuke's father and it was funny that they seriously gobble up in the neighborhood too much!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

This review contains spoilers. とてもよかったです！何度も読み返ししてます。ふうすけのぶりっ子が可愛すぎです。気持ちよすぎるハピエンです。

This review contains spoilers. It was very nice! I've reread it over and over again. Furikko from Fuusuke is too cute. It's a happy place that feels too good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

義兄弟エチラブ

Brother-in-law Ethilab

This review contains spoilers. 特に大きな問題もなく、エチエチありの面白さ笑いありのスピード感も程よいので読みやすかったです。まず、攻めの芹が綺麗な顔立ちで、嫉妬深く執着丸出しのグイグイ系なの最高。元遊び回ってたヤリ〇ン受けの風介だけど、快楽に弱く、意地っ張りだけど素直になる時は可愛すぎるし、しかもエロい。というか、風介が全体的にいい子で可愛い＋見てて飽きない面白さ。テッペーの適応能力も高いんですが、お疲れ様と言ってあげたい（笑）あ、途中風介が襲われそうになる場面というか手前まで行く場面がありますのでご注意を(しっかり芹が助けに来て回収します)。あと、義兄弟なので家族問題ですが、皆さん癖ありで呆気なく受け入れられ、むしろ笑えるほどアッサリしてますので円満幸せ溢れてます^^これは続きが読みたい作品です。

This review contains spoilers. There were no major issues, and the sense of fun with etiquette and good speed with laughter was just right, so it was easy to read. First of all, the aggressive Seri has a pretty face, and the best part is that they are jealous and show obsession. Fusuke is a girl who used to play around, but he's weak against pleasure, and while being mean, he's too cute when he's honest, and he's also erotic. Or rather, Fuusuke is an overall nice kid and cute + it's fun to watch. Teppe's adaptability is also high, but I want to say thank you for your hard work (laughs) Oh, there are scenes where Fuusuke is about to be attacked along the way, or rather, scenes that go all the way to the front, so be careful (Seri will come to the rescue and collect them). Also, since they are brothers-in-law, it's a family issue, but everyone has habits and is accepted without surprise, and they are so sharp that they are rather laughable, so they are full of happiness ^^ This is a work I want to continue reading.

Helpful

Reviews for Brotherhood Failed Successfully Manga