THE PATERNITY QUESTION Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あめおとこ

Ameko

そっくりな兄弟だと、周りから比較されてそれはもうたいへん、片方がいじけてひねくれてしまったら、誰のせいなのか。いくら双子でも入れ替わるって、それがバレないのもねえ

If they are siblings that look just like each other, it's really hard when compared by people around them; if one side messes around and becomes perverse, whose fault is it? No matter how many twins they replace, they won't even find out

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とりかへばや物語

Torikahebaya Monogatari

This review contains spoilers. 兄弟で取り替えて生活するお話です。ヒーローはオレ様ではなく、お茶目で純粋な人柄でした。二人ともじれったい感じはありましたが楽しく読めた本でした。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about living by replacing siblings. The hero wasn't me; he had a playful and pure personality. The book was fun for both of them, but it was a fun read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なお話

A wonderful story

兄弟に嫉妬し本来の自分を見失っていたヒーロー過去の自分と決別したヒーローと愛を信じなかったヒロインの恋のお話。オススメです。

A story about love between a hero who was jealous of her siblings and lost sight of her true self, a hero who broke up with her past self and a heroine who didn't believe in love. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

男性主人公が、いい加減な人かと思いきや

I wonder if the male protagonist is a sloppy person

なかなか兄弟思いで、誠実で、情のいいヒーローでした。主人公との売り言葉に買い言葉がとてもおもしろかった。さっぱり、スッキリする物語です。

He was a very brotherly, honest, and affectionate hero. The sales words with the main character and the buying words were very interesting. It's a refreshing and refreshing story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

とても

Very

This review contains spoilers. とてもよかった。絵が綺麗。ヒロインが健気で、素朴で美しい。内面が大切で、見た目だけじゃなく中身も好きになっていくところがよかった。共感できることも多く、メッセージ性がある。ラストも見どころ

This review contains spoilers. It was very good. The picture is beautiful. The heroine is healthy, simple and beautiful. The inner world was important, and it was nice that they fell in love not only with the look but also with what was inside. There are many things I can sympathize with, and it has a message. The last one is also a highlight

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

雨の日の結婚式「降りこみ」は幸せを呼ぶ?

Does a rainy day wedding “rain down” bring happiness?

シェルダン兄弟の物語だけど、確かに双子といっても仲の良い周辺の人間には（私でも）後ろ姿で分かったくらいにどちらかだって分かるんだよね。でもそれじゃあこのお話は始まらないから片目をつぶりましょう笑。子どもが欲しいだけのヒロインはちょっと痛い。そのヒロインにヒーローは惚れるんだから仕方ないよね。幼なじみのエピソードも伏線？かなぁと思ったけどただのエピソードだった。私的にはそこにモチベーションがあたら上がったけどな。双子とバレてはいけないし、双子といえどもお互いの実態を知らないし、とヒーローの焦りがコミカルでそこにページ割いちゃったのかな。ヒーローは兄と違い地元の仲間と違う高校へ行ったり、家族の中でも疎外感があったエピソードもきちんと回収していないようで...ちょっとモヤっと終わった感じだった。

It's a story about the Sheldon brothers, but it's true that people in the neighborhood who are on good terms even if they are twins can tell either one (even me) from the back. But then this story won't start, so let's close one eye lol. The heroine who just wants children hurts a bit. The hero falls in love with that heroine, so it can't be helped. Is the childhood friend episode also a foreshadowing? I was wondering, but it was just an episode. Personally, that really motivated me, though. Twins and twins shouldn't find out, and even twins don't know each other's reality, so I wonder if the hero's impatience was comical and they split the page there. Unlike his older brother, the hero went to a different high school with his local friends, and he didn't seem to properly collect episodes where there was a sense of alienation within the family... it felt like it ended in a bit of a blur.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

シリーズもの

Series stuff

兄編があるようで、そちらも読んでみたいです。こちらの弟ニールはNYで成功しており、兄の妻の命日に自宅にいたくない兄と代わって故郷に戻ります。ヒロインがなぜか頑なで愛より子どもがほしいということでしたが、次第にニールとの愛を感じるようになりました。

There seems to be an older brother edition, and I'd like to read that one too. This younger brother, Neil, has succeeded in NY, and will return to his hometown in place of his older brother who did not want to stay at home on the day of his older brother's wife's death. The heroine was stubborn for some reason and she wanted children over love, but gradually I began to feel love with Neil.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

雨男のお話

The story of Ame-Man

双子で入れ替わったヒーローは都会でプレイボーイ気取ってますが雨男（笑）自己評価の低いヒロインは素直で可愛い子。面白いお話ですがハッピーエンドのその後がもっと描かれていたらいいなぁ

The hero who was replaced by twins is pretending to be a Playboy in the city, but Ameo (laughs), the heroine with low self-esteem is an honest and cute girl. It's an interesting story, but it would be nice if more episodes after the happy ending were depicted

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

身近なヒーロー

Familiar heroes

ゴージャスで力強い、強引なヒーローが苦手なのですが、ハーレクインにはそのような方々ばかり。このお話はセレブだけどちょっと頼りないヒーロー。本当の彼は思いやりに満ちた人というのがよくわかってステキな話です。ヒロインの行動は、ちょっと頭は大丈夫？と思ってしまうのですが、アメリカはそういう国なのでしょうか……。

I don't like gorgeous, powerful, and aggressive heroes, but Harlequin only had people like that. This story is a celebrity, but the hero is a bit unreliable. It's a wonderful story to understand very well that the real boyfriend is a compassionate person. Is the heroine's behavior a little bit okay? It makes me wonder, but I wonder if America is that kind of country...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

双子の片割れに劣等感を抱くヒーロー。その双子の遺伝子を欲しがるヒロイン。ストーリーが所々コメディっぽくて面白かった。

A hero who has an inferiority complex between twins. The heroine wants those twin genes. The story was comedic in some places, and it was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

HQで恒例の双子話

The annual story of twins on HQ

雨男のヒーローが幸せになってほんと良かった。いくら双子だとしても，周りにはばれると思います。もう片割れの双子の話も読んでみないとね！

I'm really glad that Ameo's hero is happy. No matter how many twins they are, I think people around them will find out. I must also read the story of The Fractured Twins!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

合理的な

rational

This review contains spoilers. 子供だけが欲しい人は、こういう考えになるんでしょうね。なるほど！とも思ってしまいました。相手の感情を抜きにできればですが。ヒーローはもっとヘタレな人かと思いきや、ヒロインには誠実に接しています。しかし、劣等感におしつぶされていっぱいいっぱいになってしまいます。そこからが盛り上がるポイントでしょうか。おばあさんも、気づいていながら放置してくれたみたいだけど？気になります。書かれてはいませんが、ニックがニールの代わりをやれるとは思えないのは私だけでしょうか(笑)それも気になります?

This review contains spoilers. People who only want kids probably think like this. I see! I also thought that. If only I could let go of the other person's feelings. I think the hero is a more disgusting person, but I treat the heroine sincerely. However, it is crushed by an inferiority complex and becomes full. I think that's where it gets exciting. It seems like the grandmother was aware and left it alone, right? I'm curious. It's not written, but am I the only one who doesn't think Nick can take Neil's place (lol) that bothers me too?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 14, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインが

The heroine

結構な無理を言ってます(笑)双子の兄弟を困らせる発言で物語は進み、何だかんだでハッピーエンド?花津さんの絵はいつも素敵で、読みやすい！ニックサイドの物語もあるようです。

I'm saying it's pretty unreasonable (lol) The story progresses with statements that annoy the twin brothers, and why is it a happy ending? Hanazu-san's paintings are always wonderful and easy to read! There also seems to be a story about Nick Side.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

替え玉自体

Kaedama itself

性格が違いすぎて無茶あるが、面白かった。しかし、兄弟で最初からお互いに話とかして置かないものなのだろうか？

Their personalities are so different that they are ridiculous, but it was interesting. However, are siblings not talking to each other from the beginning?

Helpful

Reviews for THE PATERNITY QUESTION Manga