A GEM OF A GIRL Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

献身的な愛が、みんなを包みます。

Devotional love envelops everyone.

見た目を気にするのは女の子は当然で、、、でも自分をもう一度見つめ直し、回りをよく見たら、、ほら、自分に向いている暖かい視線が‼さちみりほ先生のほのぼのする絵が読んでいて、ホカホカします。

It's natural for girls to worry about their appearance... but when I look back at myself again and look around, look, a warm gaze directed at me ‼ I'm reading a heartwarming picture by Sachi Miriho sensei, and I'm so excited.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

やだ

That's bad

泣けちゃう?不美人ヒロインだけどかわいい。家事に仕事に健気に働いて、コンプレックスからシンデレラを夢見るのを否定して、、、共感しちゃうよね。優しいヒーローがちゃんとフォローしてくれる。最後の言葉が?

make me cry? She's an unbeautiful heroine, but she's cute. They work well at home, work, and deny dreaming of Cinderella from their complexes... I sympathize with you. A kind hero will follow you properly. last words?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 25, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける

I can cry

ヒロインはコンプレックスを抱えているものの、健気に頑張る姿に好感を持ちました。さちみりほさんの描くヒロインなので、ぽっちゃりしつつもとっても可愛らしくて良かったです。すごく泣けました。

Although the heroine has complexes, I was impressed by her healthy and hard work. She's the heroine drawn by Sachi Miriho, so I'm glad she's so cute even though she's chubby. It made me cry so much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛すぎる！

It's too cute!

ヒロインが太ってるの気にしながらも、生きていく事には、明るく一生懸命で、とてつもなく可愛すぎる！私が男だったら、この子と結婚したい！

Even though I'm worried that the heroine is getting fat, she is bright and hard at living, and she's too cute! If I were a man, I'd marry this girl!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ぽっちゃり女子のヒロイン?

chubby girl heroine?

This review contains spoilers. 両親亡き後２人の妹と３人の弟の面倒を見ながら、看護婦の仕事もキチンとこなしてるヒロインが、悲壮感は無いものの何とも健気です。そしてそんな彼女に惹かれていくイケメン医師。ヒロインの自分の見た目に対するコンプレックスや葛藤には共感する部分も多く、読んでて泣けました??

This review contains spoilers. While taking care of her 2 younger sisters and 3 younger brothers after her parents passed away, the heroine is doing her job as a nurse, and although she doesn't feel sad, she is very healthy. And a handsome doctor who becomes attracted to her. There are many parts I sympathize with the heroine's complexes and conflicts over her own appearance, and I was able to cry reading it??

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ぽっちゃり。

chubby.

ぽっちゃりシンデレラって可愛いな。と思ってしまった。ちょいちょい、注意書きで「→主人公」って書いてあるのが笑えた（笑）そりゃ、妹さんのほうが美形だけど?

Chubby Cinderella is cute. That made me think. Hey hey, it was funny how “→ main character” was written in the cautionary note (laughs) Well, my little sister is more beautiful, isn't she?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

クラシック

classic

原作は半世紀前ぐらいのもなのですが、現代でも通じるテーマがあると言うことですね。それだけ人間の中身はそれほど変わっていないことかしら？(笑)ベディ·ニールズ作品の人気はそこにあるのかもしれませんね。

The original story is about half a century ago, but it means that there are themes that are still common today. I wonder if that's why what's inside humans hasn't changed that much? (Laughter) Maybe that's where Bedi Neals works are so popular.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

笑いものにする輩には

For those who make laughing

This review contains spoilers. ６人きょうだいで一番下とは二十歳違う、看護師という職業だって激務なのに家事からなにから全部まるっと、で自分のことは構ってられないからぷっくらしててオシャレもせずに。そんな彼女に王子さまが。からかいのタネにされそうなところを脱出させてくれたのも彼。肝心の決めがちょっと時間かかったのは大目にみますか。

This review contains spoilers. They have 6 siblings and are 20 years different from the youngest, and even though the job of being a nurse is hard work, everything from housework to anything, so they don't care about themselves, so they're plump and don't look stylish. A prince is such a girlfriend. He was also the one who let me get out of a place where I was likely to be used as a source of teasing. Do you overlook the fact that it took a while to make the essential decisions?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ぽっちゃりさん

Chubby

ぽっちゃりさんが主人公はめったにないですが、最後までぽっちゃりなのもほとんどありません。主人公二人が恋愛に奥手だったのはよかった。いつもの通りさちみ先生の心温まる内容でした。

Chubby people are rarely the main characters, but there are almost no chubby people until the end. It was good that the two main characters were good at love. As always, it was Sachimi sensei's heartwarming content.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けました

I was able to cry

This review contains spoilers. ストーリー的にはHQ定番なんだけど、今まで読んだことない感じ。感動です。ヒーローもヒロインも素敵なキャラクターで、ヒロインの家族もヒーローの妹もとってもいい人? 。ヒーローのいとことその友達に傷つけられるヒロイン。謝ってだけど、今後親戚付き合いするんだよね。いとこが★−1です。

This review contains spoilers. It's an HQ staple in terms of story, but I feel like I've never read it before. I'm impressed. Both the hero and heroine are wonderful characters, and both the heroine's family and the hero's sister are really nice people? . A heroine who is hurt by her hero's cousin and her friend. I'm sorry, but I'm going out with my relatives from now on. My cousin is ★ -1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けました

I was able to cry

This review contains spoilers. HQには珍しい太ったヒロインのお話。ヒーローのいとこにもて遊ばれた場面は、あまりに残酷でした。いくらヒーローと結婚できたとしても、一生心の傷になる…なので星4つにしました。

This review contains spoilers. A story about a fat heroine that is rare in HQ. The scene where I was played by the hero's cousin was so cruel. No matter how many heroes you get married to, you'll be heartbroken for the rest of your life... so I gave it 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローまでも

Even heroes

こんなに自信がない人だったなんて…でも、2人ともが心の温かい人だったから、時間はかかったけれど結ばれてよかった。それぞれの兄弟姉妹も、ヒーローの両親も素敵で、泣けた。従兄弟だけバカヤローだな。反省した？のならよし！たぶん何回でも読めます！

I can't believe they were such unconfident people... but both of them were warm-hearted people, so I'm glad they got together even though it took time. Each brother and sister and the hero's parents were wonderful and made me cry. My cousin is the only idiot. did you reflect? If so, good! I can probably read it over and over again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

身近に感じれるお話

A story you can feel close to

優しい大人な医師ヒーローと頑張り屋のぽっちゃり看護師ヒロインのお話。いつでも周りを優先するヒロインが最後は大きな幸せを掴みます！心温まるストーリーですが、そもそもそんなに自分に構えず忙しく家計も厳しいのなら太らないのでは？と思ってしまったので☆4つです。

A story about a gentle, adult doctor hero and a hardworking chubby nurse heroine. The heroine, who always prioritizes her surroundings, grabs great happiness at the end! It's a heartwarming story, but if you don't care about yourself and are busy and your household budget is tight in the first place, why don't you gain weight? I thought it was ☆ 4.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

魅力的

tempting

健気で生活力のあるヒロインが地道に幸せを掴むストーリーがこの作家ならではの魅力。終盤のリーニータのセリフが響きます。ハーレクインとしては良くも悪くも奥手なヒーローのせいで読後「もっといい雰囲気になってる二人を見たいのに」「このまま結婚に行っちゃうの……？」とフラストレーションを感じるけど、結末後読み返せば、ヒロインのコンプレックスが障害として大きかったわけでヒーローはそれなりに頑張ってたとも感じる。結婚までの二人をもっと見たかったってこと！アレンジ加える作風の方なんで原作にも興味出ました。面白かったです。

The story where the heroine, who is healthy and has a strong sense of life, steadily grabs happiness is an appeal unique to this writer. Linita's last line resonates. After reading it because of the hero who is good and bad for Harlequin, “I want to see the two people in a better atmosphere” and “are they going to get married like this...?” I feel frustrated, but if I read it back after the ending, I also feel that the heroine's complex was huge as an obstacle, so the hero worked hard enough. I mean I wanted to see more of the two until they got married! I became interested in the original story because of the style of adding arrangements. That was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

シャイなヒーロー

shy hero

This review contains spoilers. がシャイなりに決めてくれました。静かに「恥を知れ」と目で怒りを訴えるヒーロー、一生懸命ヒロインに気持ちを伝えようと頑張る姿はとても素敵でした。でも実際、ヒーローはふくよかなヒロインをお姫様抱っこ出来るのだろうか。ラストのヒロインはなかなかのものだぞ。

This review contains spoilers. They made the decision in a shy way. The sight of the hero, who quietly complains anger with his eyes saying “shame on you,” and trying so hard to convey her feelings to the heroine was so wonderful. But can a hero actually hold a plump heroine as a princess? The heroine at the end is pretty good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっこりします

It makes me feel relaxed

ヒーローもヒロインもとにかく優しくて素敵なキャラクターです。読んでてほっこりします。

Both the hero and heroine are very kind and wonderful characters. I'm relieved to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買いです。

I'm buying the author.

This review contains spoilers. 絵がきれいでとても読みやすいストーリーでした。ぽっちゃりの主人公もいいです♥

This review contains spoilers. The pictures were beautiful and the story was very easy to read. The chubby protagonist is nice too ♥

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

現実的

realistic

This review contains spoilers. な内容半分、願望半分。兎に角、ヒロインが素敵な良い子。自分に自信はないが、自身で卑下するのも良くない事も分かっており、努めと自然に振る舞います。色々と心ない人達にひどい仕打ちを受けますが････そんなこともあり、悲しい思い出共にその場から去ろうとします。ヒーローも超ハンサムなのに全然鼻にかけておらず、というか自覚がないと言うか自然体、まじめ‼優しい！そして、とても真っ直ぐにヒロインが好き(涙)ヒーロー、ヒロイン共に心がキレイで、幸せになって良かったほんと泣ける良いお話しでした。癒された～

This review contains spoilers. Half content, half desire. A good girl with a lovely heroine and rabbit. I don't have confidence in myself, but I know that it's not good to despise myself, and I behave naturally with effort. I am treated badly by various heartless people... but there are times like that, and I try to leave that place with my sad memories. Even though the hero is super handsome, they don't wear it on their nose at all, or rather they say they aren't aware of it, it's natural, seriously ‼ kind! Also, I really liked the heroine (tears), both the hero and heroine had beautiful hearts, and I'm glad they were happy, it was a good story that really made me cry. I was healed ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 29, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

シンデレラストーリー？

A Cinderella story?

泣いた( ノД`)…ぽちゃ娘がヒーローに振り向いて欲しくて変身の話ではありません。最後までぽちゃ娘でした。でも女として頑張ろうって思える、心暖まるお話しです

I cried (no `)... this isn't a story about a chubby girl who transforms because she wants her to turn around as a hero. She was a chubby girl until the end. But it's a heartwarming story that makes me think I'll do my best as a woman

Helpful

Reviews for A GEM OF A GIRL Manga