A NATURAL MOTHER Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

まさに愛し子の肖像

Exactly a portrait of a beloved child

アマンダという女性の人を愛し尊敬することのできる人柄がナターシャの養母であった幸運が、アンジェラにもニックにも幸せを導いた物語でした。しっかりとした筋道の通った展開、過去を差し挟むタイミングの良さ、アンジェラの吹っ切ったフットワークといい申し分のない感動を与えてくれました。特に私はアンジェラが描いたナターシャの肖像画をナターシャ自身が担ぎ上げて歩いている場面にウルウルしてしまいました。それだけで、ナターシャの気持ちの有りどころが読めるではありませんか！ニックの秘書のフィリッパにはイライラさせられたけれど良い展開を作ってくれました。MY本棚PREMIUMが1作品増えました。

It was a story where the good fortune of being Natasha's foster mother, led to happiness for both Angela and Nick, whose personality could love and respect a woman named Amanda. It gave me an impeccable sense of emotion, such as a steady and well-planned development, good timing that put the past in between, and Angela's amazing footwork. In particular, I was taken aback by the scene where Natasha herself was walking carrying a portrait of Natasha drawn by Angela. With that alone, you can read where Natasha feels! Nick's secretary Philippa made me feel frustrated, but it made a good development. My Bookshelf PREMIUM has been added by 1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 05, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

私達は今世界一幸せな家族です?

Are we the happiest family in the world right now?

This review contains spoilers. 17才の時レ★プされ身籠ったものの生まれた娘(ナターシャ)を養女に出さなくてはならなかったアンジェラ←←両親には全く頼れず自暴自棄になり高校も中退して<引きこもり>の様な生活を送っていました｡そんなアンジェラを立ち直らせたのはナターシャの養母(ニックの姉)からの手紙でした………私が書き込む下手な粗筋より是非購読して下さい? 出来れば二度三度読んでみて下さい? そのたびに感動します?

This review contains spoilers. <引きこもり>When I was 17 years old ★ Angela had to give up her daughter (Natasha) for adoption, she couldn't rely on her parents at all and was living a life like dropping out of high school. What made Angela get back on her feet was a letter from Natasha's foster mother (Nick's older sister)... Please subscribe from the bad rough lines I write? Please read it twice or thrice if possible? Are you impressed every time?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

高評価に納得

Convinced by the high evaluation

娘への一途な気持ちとか、ヒーローの思いとか、悪役の存在、全てが上手にまとまってて、回収されない謎もないし、展開も好きです。何より悪役がちゃんと罰をうける所も良かった。ページ数少ないハーレクインだから描き切れない部分があるのは仕方ないのかもしれないけど、この作品は読みごたえありました。オススメです

My unwavering feelings for my daughter, the hero's thoughts, and the existence of the villain are all put together so well, there are no mysteries that can't be collected, and I like the development. Above all, it was nice that the villains were properly punished. Since Harlequin has so few pages, it's probably unavoidable that there are parts I can't draw, but this work was worth reading. I recommend

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

This review contains spoilers. ヒロインもヒーローも、辛い過去を背負って強く生きてきたから今がある。娘さんがとても可愛く描かれてました。ヒーローの秘書が最悪。それを見破れないヒーローってHQには多いかも…(^^;

This review contains spoilers. Both the heroine and the hero have lived a strong life carrying a painful past, so they are here now. My daughter was drawn so cute. The hero's secretary is the worst. Maybe there are a lot of heroes in HQ who can't see it through... (^^;

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

高レビュー

High reviews

高レビューに惹かれ購入しました。絵がとても美しく、悪の凄みも際立っていました。

I was attracted to the high reviews and bought it. The picture was so beautiful, and the awesomeness of evil also stood out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ありがちなストーリーだけどおススメ

It's a common story, but I recommend it

子供可愛い！ヒロインもヒーローもいい人なので好感が持てる。端折った感もなく自然な流れでラストまで進むので大満足！評価見た時に全部星5だったのも納得です

Kids are cute! Both the heroine and hero are nice people, so I like them. I'm very satisfied because it progresses naturally to the end without feeling broken! I'm also convinced that they were all 5 stars when I saw the reviews

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

もう一度娘に会いたい一心で

I want to see my daughter again with all my heart

このテの話はHQでは見かける話だが、感動のツボを間違わずに掬い取ってくれて、無難な展開と落ち着いたフィナーレだった。おしゃまな女の子であっても、「自己実現」を語らせるとは、少々驚くし、ホントは怖い身近な人格破綻者の悪人にも、物語の飛び道具的な波乱を匂わせ、意外と言えば意外、異物感といえば異物感なんとなく。没個性を恐れたこの物語の頑張りなのか？横井先生の絵は、以前にHQでお見かけしているはずなのだが、前に読んだ作品の名前を思い出せず、本作品の方が印象を残したのは、今回は艶やかさに品があり、人物設定とビジュアルが合っていたからなのか。(追記-既読は「マンハッタンの恋人」)人物が美しいのでそれほど気にならなかったが、背景の入ったコマが少ないというのが読後の印象。最初4をつけたが5に上方調整する。私の最近のレビューが5の連発だったので、4くらいがいいかと思ったのだったが、そんな理由で4とすることもないだろうと考え直した。直近読んだ数作品と比べずに読んだのであったなら、4とする理由がなかったろうと感じたので。ベタだけど「僕は君がいいんだ」という台詞や、ヒロインの「(自分にはそこにいる)資格がない」との考え方はなんだか作り手の意図通りに動かされた。

This story is a story you see in HQ, but it scooped up the moving pressure points without making a mistake, and it was a safe development and a calm finale. Even if it's a good-looking girl, it's a bit surprising to have her talk about “self-realization,” and even a villain with a familiar personality who is really scary smells like turbulence like a flying tool in a story, and speaking of surprise, it's unexpected; speaking of foreign matter, there's no foreign body feeling. Was it the hard work of this story that feared no individuality? I'm sure I've seen Yokoi sensei's paintings on HQ before, but I can't remember the name of the work I read before, and the reason this one left an impression on me is probably because it has luster and quality, and the visuals match the character settings. (Additional note - “Manhattan Lover”) The characters are beautiful, so I wasn't really interested, but my impression after reading was that there aren't many frames with backgrounds. I added 4 at the beginning, but adjusted upward to 5. My recent reviews were 5 in a row, so I thought about 4 would be good, but for that reason I rethought that I wouldn't even set it to 4. If I had read it without comparing it to the few works I've read recently, I felt that there would be no reason to set it as 4. It's solid, but the line “I like you” and the heroine's way of thinking “(I'm not qualified to be there)” were somehow moved as intended by the creator.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 26, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

善人達によるハーレ

Hare by good people

This review contains spoilers. 凄く良かったです。泣けました。ヒロインもヒーローも自立して大人。そして悲しい過去を乗り越え思いやりもあるし愛情もある。プレイボーイかと思われたヒーローはそんなことはなく、またヒロインの真実を知ってもきちんと受け入れてくれます。ヒロインと実娘の関係、娘とヒーローの関係、それぞれがちゃんと描かれて絆があり、一度は手放した愛情をもう一度手にするお話。1人を除いて凄く素敵なキャラクターばかりでした。娘ちゃんにママと呼ばれるシーンは泣けました。作者さんの絵柄が以前より洗練されてすっきりしててそれも良かった一因。

This review contains spoilers. It was really good. It made me cry. Both the heroine and the hero are independent and adults. Also, they have overcome their sad past and are compassionate and loving. Heroes that were thought to be Playboys aren't like that, and even if they know the truth about the heroine, they will properly accept it. It's a story about the relationship between the heroine and her biological daughter, and the relationship between the daughter and the hero, each properly depicted and has a bond, and once again gains love that you once let go of. Except for one person, all of them were really nice characters. The scene where my daughter called her mom made me cry. The artist's designs are more refined and cleaner than before, and that is one of the good reasons.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

うぅ

wow

泣けましたーアンジェラ良い人ー養父母も良い人ースリリングがあって良い展開でした！

I was able to cry - Angela good person - my foster parents are also good people, there was thrilling and it was a good development!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

手放した幸せ

The happiness of letting go

This review contains spoilers. 辛い過去がありながら、自力で立ち上がり、逞しく生きてきたアンジェラ。苦渋の決断で手放しても、娘のナターシャを想う深い愛情が、ニックとの出会いも繋げてくれたように思いました。お互い惹かれて行く中で、秘書のフィリッパが分かりやすいくらいの悪女で、まるで、ディズニーに出てくるヴィランズ並みに立ち回ってくれたと思います。ニックの過去と立場、ナターシャの境遇と想い、アンジェラの手放した幸せが、3人を家族として繋げ幸せを生み出す構図に、心が温かくなりました。

This review contains spoilers. Despite having a difficult past, Angela has stood up on her own and lived a strong life. Even though I made a painful decision to let go, I felt that my deep love for my daughter Natasha led to my encounter with Nick. While they were attracted to each other, my secretary, Philippa, was such an evil woman that was easy to understand, I think she went around like the villains that appear in Disney. Nick's past and position, Natasha's circumstances and feelings, and the happiness Angela let go made my heart warm in a composition that connects the three of them as a family and creates happiness.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

購入★4

Buy ★ 4

素敵な作品。登場人物が皆美麗！強烈ストーカー秘書は凄かったけど、他は幸せストーリー♪

Nice work. The characters are all beautiful! The intense stalker secretary was amazing, but the others are happy stories ♪

Helpful

Reviews for A NATURAL MOTHER Manga