FOR THE SAKE OF THE SECRET CHILD Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

This review contains spoilers. 単話でも普通に楽しめましたが、三部作のラストということで前の兄たちと婚約者も出てきて、そちらは読んでいませんでしたが話の作りが上手いので唐突な感じもなく楽しく読めました。子供の存在を知っても強引に連れ帰る考えが浮かぶのは一瞬だけで、自省してヒロインを大切にする考えになれるヒーローが素敵。男性目線では恐ろしい呪いの悪女呼ばわりのガヴァネスでしたがヒロインたちが味方になってくれて、ジャスパーに宝石を託して満足気に涙して消えていくさまにほろっとしました。

This review contains spoilers. I was able to enjoy the single story normally, but since it was the last part of the trilogy, my previous older brothers and fiancee also came up, and although I didn't read that, they were good at making up the story, I enjoyed reading it without feeling abrupt. Even when they know about the existence of children, the idea of forcibly bringing them back comes to mind for only a moment, and a hero who can reflect on himself and get used to cherishing the heroine is wonderful. From a male point of view, she was Governor Called the Evil Woman with a Terrible Curse, but the heroines took sides, and I felt relieved as they entrusted the jewels to Jasper and disappeared in tears with satisfaction.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

先生の作品は好きです。絵も綺麗、内容も良いです。最後は幸せで良かった。

I like the teacher's work. The pictures are beautiful and the content is good. I'm glad I was happy at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ハッピーエンド

happy ending

若い時から小林博美さんの絵が好きだったので、思わずクリックしました。世界が違うなと思いながら一気に読みました。でも本当に現実にもいるといいなと思います。こんな優しい責任感のある人がいれば、世の中に泣いている女性が救われるだろうなと思います。心の中がとてもホンワカして読んだ後幸せな気持ちになりました。

I've loved Hiromi Kobayashi's paintings since I was young, so I clicked on them unintentionally. I read it all at once, thinking the world was different. But I really think it would be nice if they existed in real life. If there were people with such a kind sense of responsibility, I think crying women in the world would be saved. My heart was so excited that I felt happy after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

もう一工夫

One more ingenuity

This review contains spoilers. 三部作の完結篇。めでたしメデタシなのだけれど、、、最後のガヴァネスのくだり絵は美しい、けれどもなにか物足りないというかホンノリ不満が、、

This review contains spoilers. The final part of the trilogy. It's a blessing, but... the last picture of governance is beautiful, but something is unsatisfactory, or rather, I'm really dissatisfied...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

子供がかわいい

Kids are cute

パパとわかった時の息子の表情がとても良かった！ヒーローもとても頼りになるステキな男性でした。

My son's expression when he found out he was dad was so good! The hero was also a wonderful man you could rely on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

そっくり父子

Just like father and son

お話しも良かったけど、パパと息子がそっくりなのが最高！誰が見ても間違えなく親子だね。

It was a great story, but it's great that dad and son look just like each other! No matter who sees it, it's definitely a parent and child.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

呪いの伝説の意味は？

What is the meaning of the legend of the curse

日本の呪いと違って西洋の呪いって不思議と愛が関係していますよね。童話でもそうだなと思いました。たとえば白雪姫。独リンゴで死んだはずが、リンゴがのどに詰まり王子様にキスでリンゴが取れてよみがえります。呪いって愛に傷ついたが再び愛を信じあえるまでの話かもしれないなと思いました。

Unlike Japanese curses, Western curses are strangely related to love, aren't they? I thought that was true even in children's stories. Snow White, for example. He must have died from a German apple, but the apple gets stuck in his throat and the prince kisses the apple and comes back to life. I thought the curse might be a story about being hurt by love but then believing in love again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

三部作完結編

The final part of the trilogy

This review contains spoilers. ヒーローは事故で、ヒロインは妊娠中に命の危険があったというスリリングなお話でした。

This review contains spoilers. It was a thrilling story where the hero had an accident, and the heroine's life was in danger during pregnancy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく良い話

Very good story

この話の言葉には私の心に刺さる明言が幾つかあって…本当にそうだな～と思いながら読みました。

There are a few clear statements in the words of this story that stuck in my heart... and I read it while thinking that it really is.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

大事故で，命拾いしたうえに

After saving lives due to a major accident

This review contains spoilers. 時々運命はこうあるべきかなというストーリーだよね。けがをしてリハビリに来なければ，昔の彼女に再会する事も無く，自分の血の分けた子供にもあうことがなかったなんて。不思議です。命はそまつにしてはいけません。カバネスが本当に愛されていたのかどうか真実はあかされなかったのは残念。番外編ででればいいのに。

This review contains spoilers. Sometimes it's a story about how fate should be. If I hadn't come to rehab due to an injury, I wouldn't have met my old girlfriend again, and I wouldn't have met the child I shared my blood with. It's strange. Don't give up on life. Too bad the truth wasn't revealed whether Cabanes was really loved. It would be nice if it came out in an extra edition.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

作家さん買いです。

The artist is buying it.

本当に偶然だったので、ちょっと出来すぎな部分もありましたが、とても良いお話でした。面白かったです。

It was really a coincidence, so there were parts that were a bit overdone, but it was a very good story. That was interesting.

Helpful

Reviews for FOR THE SAKE OF THE SECRET CHILD Manga