THE SICILIAN'S STOLEN SON Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最後まで一気に。

All at once until the end.

うっかり立ち読みして先が読みたくて購入。いくら何でもヒロインの双子を間違えるわけないよねと苦笑しながらも、最後まで一気に引き込まれました。

I inadvertently read it and bought it because I wanted to read it ahead. I was drawn in all at once until the end, even though I smiled wryly, saying that there's no way I could mistake the heroine twins for anything.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

作家さん買い

Buy the artist

今回も美しくて文句なし！ハーレクインのゴージャス感もありとてもステキなお話でした。

Beautiful this time too, no complaints! There was also Harlequin's gorgeous feel, and it was a very wonderful story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

思っていたよりあっさりしていました。

It was lighter than I expected.

もっとラブラブしているのかと思いきや色々あっさりしていました。絵柄はキレイです。期待を裏切らない展開なのでハーレクインがお好きな方にはよいと思います。

I thought they were even more lovey-dovey, but things were easy. The pattern is beautiful. It's a development that won't disappoint, so I think it's good for those who like Harlequin.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

濃いなぁ～

that's so thick

ルチアーノとの出会いも最悪だったけど、出会ったことによって２人とも幸せそう。始まりは生き別れた双子の身勝手な姉との再会で、借金、契約違反な代理出産、子供放置で預けたままとか。子供の父親がルチアーノで迎えに来たり、成り済まし代理出産だったり。またHQらしく変な駆引きで、自滅するとか？今回は珍しく、ルチアーノのプロポーズ三昧で面白かった。色んなものが、てんこ盛りです。

My encounter with Luciano was also terrible, but they both seem happy since they met. The beginning was a reunion with her twin selfish older sister who had survived, and was left unattended due to debt, surrogacy in violation of contract, and leaving children unattended. The child's father came to pick him up at Luciano, and they pretended to do surrogacy. Also, it self-destructs due to strange driving like HQ? It was unusual this time around, and Luciano's proposals were full of fun. A lot of things are in full bloom.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

「許し愛すること」に目を閉じ選んだ代理母

A surrogate mother who chose to close her eyes to “forgive and love”

This review contains spoilers. 純粋で自分の出自を嫌悪しているルチアーノ。良くも悪くも全てを彼は持っている。指を一本鳴らせばー、というところは自覚して熟れているといえる。当初、17か月その手に抱くのを待っていた子供を取り返しに来る場面でも、有無を言わせずに引き取っていくつもりだった。しかし、ジェマイマに出会ってしまった。本来ルチアーノが欲していた暖かな家庭を思わせるもの。自分の出自では入手困難なものだ。牧師の言葉によって自らの進むべき道を見出した彼にとって、牧師であるジェマイマの両親を見た時から、彼女への攻撃は威力を亡くしていた。横柄で強い口調をしていても強引なことはせずひたすらに冷静に、穏やかにと自制している姿には可愛らしささえ見受けられる。すでにジェマイマに惚れてしまったのだ。その後は淡々と進んでいくがこれは羽生先生の絵の特徴故と感じる。感情による起伏表情の乏しさ、セリフは強いのに絵からはその熱さが伝わらない。好みはあるだろうが、物足りなさを感じてしまう。ジェマイマの環境の変化に特化した情景描写が多く、ルチアーノにときめき、心揺れるものが乏しい。ルチアーノを取り巻く人たちも強面であるが憎めない人柄が伝わりはするが、もっとジェマイマが居心地よさを感じていることを分からせてほしい。裏家業は辞めたとはいえ、それらに従ってきた人たちを路線変更させるためには、不本意でも染まらねばならない部分があったはず、その対比を色濃くするのもジェマイマの表情（居心地よさの様）の大きさにあると考えるのである。

This review contains spoilers. Luciano is pure and hates his own origin. For better or worse, he has everything. It can be said that they are aware of the fact that they are familiar with the fact that they should ring one finger. At first, it was my intention to take in a situation where they came to retrieve a child who had been waiting to be held in their hands for 17 months without telling them if they were there or not. However, I ran into Jemima. Reminiscent of the warm home Luciano originally wanted. It's hard to get when you're from. For him, who found his own path through the pastor's words, attacks on Jemima lost their power from the time he saw Jemima's parents, who are pastors. Even though they are arrogant and have a strong tone, their cuteness can even be seen in their appearance where they are calm and restrained without being aggressive. I've already fallen in love with Jemima. After that, it progressed slowly, but I feel that this is because of the characteristics of Hanyu-sensei's paintings. There are few ups and downs due to emotion, and even though the lines are strong, that heat is not conveyed from the picture. I may have a taste, but I feel that it's not enough. There are many scenes depicting changes in Jemima's environment, and there are few things that thrill Luciano and shake his heart. The people surrounding Luciano are also strong, but it conveys a personality that cannot be hated, but I want you to understand even more that Jemima feels comfortable. Even though they quit the back house business, in order to get people who followed them to change routes, there must have been parts that had to be dyed even if they were unwilling, and I think that deepening that contrast is also due to the size of Jemima's expression (comfort).

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

試し読みからつい購入してしまいました。ただの恋愛ストーリーとは違っていて面白かったです。絵も綺麗で好きです。

I just bought it after a trial reading. It was interesting because it was different from just a love story. The picture is also beautiful and I like it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

双子でもこうも違う？！

are twins this different?!

This review contains spoilers. 代理出産も妊娠も、よく耐えたと思いますが、子育てはできなかったのね、双子の片割れは。パスポートはかしてはダメです。

This review contains spoilers. I think they endured both surrogacy and pregnancy well, but they weren't able to raise children, so split the twins. You can't change your passport.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

知るタイミングとか淡々と展開

Things like the timing of getting to know it unfold indifferently

見るからにまっとうな生き方をしてるなりをしてるも、それを最初は嘘だと思う。接触するうちに違うのかなと。自然にいくかと思えばいやいや騙されるな、と、戸惑い隠して疑い続けようとするも、結局確認。もうヒロインに魅力を感じている自分が(←ルチアーノ)。だって職業考えると嘘もない。そっちを確認しなさいよ、勤務履歴ですぐわかる。それでもこれはお話だから。赤ちゃんの親権はHQ定番中の定番。でもここはあれ？、最後にバレるヒロインが隠してることが、簡単に事が運んで拍子抜け。自分で「名士」を名乗る彼、しょうもなさ過ぎて笑える。惚れた方が負け、というなら、二人のシーンで少し甘さを足しておいて欲しかった。けれど、17か月待った、という下りは胸が痛かった。部下も家の使用人も皆憎めない。彼が本当は繊細で、優しい人、というのをヒロインが見抜くのもいいところだったと思う。クライマックスとはいえ告白シーンに少しドキンと来たかった。羽生先生の描かれる綺麗な絵が、ここに感情的な盛り上がりより、端正さを狙うのが、私的にはウーン、なのだ。ドラマ的に、なんだ、そうだったのか！、というのをより味わって見たかった。そこにお話の主眼がなかったと言っても、物語終盤のただただ筋が絵になったという感覚ではない、「読んでる」気分よりも、二人を「眺めて」、互いに、相手の想いを、または相手へのどれだけ想っているかを、より感じ取りたかった気分が残った。ただ、私が読んだ羽生先生の他のHQ作品よりも、時間をかけて読めた。双子ものは、ホントにHQには多いなぁとつくづく思う。蛇足：私の甥っ子は、その月齢で哺乳瓶を手で持って飲んだ。(私の娘には全然出来ない事だった)「マンマ」は言えるかどうかまでは記憶に無いけれど、多分喃語(つまり大人は特定の意味付けを取りにくいが、言いたいことを、赤ちゃんなりに発声出来る音声で、表現を試みてる)として、かなり言ってたような気がしてる。甥っ子はもちろん、それなら我が娘も。彼等なりの言語は早くから発してる。

They seem to be living a proper way of life, but at first I think that's a lie. I wonder if it will be different as we come into contact. Even though they were puzzled and tried to keep doubting, that if they thought it would go naturally, no, don't be deceived, they eventually confirmed it. I'm already fascinated by the heroine (← Luciano). Because when you think about your job, there's no lie. Please check that; you can tell right away from your work history. Still, this is a story. Baby custody is a staple of HQ classics. But this is it? The fact that the heroine who is revealed at the end is hiding something that easily unravels the tempo. He, who calls himself a “celebrity,” is so unhelpful that it's funny. If the one who falls in love loses, I wanted them to add a little sweetness to the scene between the two of them. However, it hurt my heart to go down after 17 months of waiting. I don't hate my subordinates or my house servants. I think it was a good place for the heroine to see through that he really is a sensitive and kind person. Even though it was the climax, I wanted to come to the confession scene with a bit of excitement. I personally aim for neatness rather than emotional excitement in the beautiful pictures drawn by Professor Hanyu. Dramatically, why was that so! I wanted to enjoy it even more. Even if I said that the main focus of the story wasn't there, it wasn't a feeling that the simple story at the end of the story had become a picture; rather than the feeling of “reading,” the feeling that I wanted to “look at” the two and feel more about each other, or how much they felt for the other person, remained. However, I was able to read it more time than Hanyu sensei's other HQ works I've read. I keep thinking that there are really a lot of twins in HQ. Jagatari: My nephew held a baby bottle in his hand and drank it at that age. I don't even remember being able to say “mamma” (something my daughter couldn't do at all), but I feel like they probably said quite a bit as a whisper (in other words, it's hard for adults to take a specific meaning, but they're trying to express what they want to say with a voice that can be voiced in a baby's way). Not to mention my nephew, then my daughter too. Their language started early.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買いです。

I'm buying the author.

絵が好きです。美男美女で、二人が本当に素敵です。他の作品も読んでみたいです。

I like the picture. They are beautiful men and women, and they are really wonderful. I'd like to read other works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素朴でかわいい

Simple and cute

ヒロインは外見は美しく、内面は強く、素晴らしい女性。まだ24歳だけど、さすがニッキーを育てただけある！ヒーローはものすごく俺様だと思うけど、ヒロインが言うように回りの人に慕われていたり、色々気にしてるところがかわいらしくもあって、結果お似合いの二人でした。

The heroine is a wonderful woman who is beautiful on the outside and strong on the inside. I'm only 24 years old, but as expected, I've only raised Nikki! I think the hero is really me, but as the heroine says, they are loved by the people around them, and they are cute, and the things they care about are cute, and the results were perfect for them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買いです

I'm buying the author

作者さんの描く絵が好きです。王道ストーリーで、安心して読めます。ヒロインの短気ですぐイラつくところが他の作品と違ってよかったです。

I like the artist's paintings. It's a classic story, and you can read it without worry. I'm glad that the heroine has a short temper and gets irritated quickly, which is different from other works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

あっさり

Lightly

あっさりしていて、安心して読める。ハッピーエンドは最初からわかっているので、スッキリ読めてストレスフリーな作品。ただ、ボリュームの割には値段が高い。クーポンなしではお薦めしません。

It's easy, and I can read it without worry. I know the happy ending from the beginning, so it's a clear and stress-free work. However, the price is high for the volume. I wouldn't recommend it without a coupon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

もうちょっと

Just a little bit more

最後の方にお二人の仲良しなお話が続けばもっと良かったなぁ〜〜〜。子どももなんだかんだ可愛かったし、元々はみんな強面だけどいい人ばかりだし、ほっこりするお話でした。

It would have been even better if they continued to talk about how good they are towards the end ~~~. The kids were also kind of cute, and originally they were all strong but nice people, so it was a relaxing story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

小説も読みたくなりました。

It made me want to read novels too.

絵が気に入って購入しましたが、内容も良くて楽しく読めました。コミックでは少し省略されてるような気がして、小説の方も買いたくなりました。

I liked the picture and bought it, but the content was good and I enjoyed reading it. I felt like it was slightly omitted in comics, and I wanted to buy the novel one too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ハッピーエンド

happy ending

This review contains spoilers. トラブルメーカー。そんな妹に振り回されて借金を抱え、恋人も寝盗られたのに、健気に妹の尻ぬぐいをする真面目な教師の姉。トラブルメーカーの妹が代理母をして金を盗みドラッグに溺れ死んだ。その尻拭いを勝って出た姉と代理母を雇ったセレブイケメンとの恋、なかなか進展しない仲なのに意識し合ってる感じがいい。作者さんの絵が好きです。特にS系イケメンが！カッコ良すぎます。

This review contains spoilers. troublemaker. An older sister who is a serious teacher who cheerfully wipes her sister's butt even though she is swayed by her younger sister and is in debt, and her lover has also been robbed of her sleep. The troublemaker's sister acted as a surrogate mother, stole money, and drowned in drugs. It's nice to feel that they are aware of the love between the older sister who came out and the celebrity handsome guy who hired a surrogate mother, even though they haven't progressed easily. I like the author's paintings. S type handsome guys in particular! That's too cool.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 17, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

男性キャラが素敵でした！

The male characters were wonderful!

初めて購入する作者さんでしたが、絵も綺麗だし、男性キャラが素敵に描かれていてキュンとしました(^^)

It was the first time the author bought it, and the pictures were beautiful, and the male characters were drawn nicely, so I was amazed (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

羽生シオンの作品が大好きです。表紙を見て思わず購入しました。彼も素敵ですね。作品も良かったです。

I love Hanyu Shion's work. I saw the cover and bought it without thinking. He's wonderful too. The work was good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

思ったより

More than I thought

This review contains spoilers. ヒーローの大富豪の傲慢ぶりが典型的なパターンですが、この作品ではヒーローはすごくいいひとのようです。ストーリーもよくあるパターンではあるのですが、いいですね。一番いいのは「オレも自分が一番すきなタイプのように見える」と自覚してところがいいですね。

This review contains spoilers. The hero's arrogance of the millionaire is a typical pattern, but in this work, the hero seems to be a very nice person. The story is also a common pattern, which is nice. The best thing is being aware that “I look like the type I like the most.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

格好いい

It's cool

大好きな先生なので必然的に星4つですが男性目線からの女性を描写してある所がドキドキして楽しめました！もっとラブシーンのページを増やして下さい！

It's my favorite teacher, so it's inevitably 4 stars, but I was excited and enjoyed the fact that it depicts a woman from a male perspective! Please increase the number of love scene pages!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

好きです羽生シオン先生の作品

I like Hanyu Shion sensei's works

This review contains spoilers. 羽生シオン先生の作品は全部買っていますが、今回の作品も裏切らない作画でした。ただ双子のくだりと、代理出産の絡みがチョット弱い気がして今回は星4個になりました。

This review contains spoilers. I bought all of Hanyu Shion's works, and this one didn't betray me either. However, I felt that the entanglement between the twins Kuri and surrogacy was a bit weak, so I got 4 stars this time.

Helpful

Reviews for THE SICILIAN'S STOLEN SON Manga