MangaPlaza

Sorry! You need an account to do that! Sign up now to get the most out of your MangaPlaza experience!

Register For Free!

Already registered?

All

Romance

MP Originals

Action

BL

Adult Romance

Yuri

Fantasy

Drama

Horror

Harlequin

Light Novels

|

Find Titles

Search Menu

Search by Genre

Explore Premium

New
Best Sellers
SALE
Coupon
Now Free

Search by Popular Keywords

Others

Search by Author

Special Collections

Reviews for A WINTER PROPOSAL Manga

Overall :

4.5

15 Global Ratings

5 star

47%
4 star

53%
3 star

0%
2 star

0%
1 star

0%

1 - 15 of 15 Reviews

Sort by

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

Translate All Reviews to English

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

よりにもよって

More depending

何故、婚約者がいるのに、他に好きな人ができたのをサッサと言わないのか。雪のなか待たせたあげくに告げるなんて最悪。

Why don't you say that even though you have a fiancé, you've found someone else you like, Sassa? Telling after making them wait in the snow is the worst.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

似た者同志なのかな。

I wonder if they are similar people.

強い女性が登場するハーレクインが好きなのですが、この女性は弁護士でむっちゃ強くて、美しくて、素敵でした。ヒーローも一途な恋心で最後まで攻めまくるところが胸キュンでした。二人、お似合いだなぁって思いました。

I like Harlequin, where strong women appear, and this woman was a lawyer, very strong, beautiful, and wonderful. I was thrilled that the hero also attacked until the end with an unwavered love. I thought they were a good match.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

最高にステキ！

It's so wonderful!

ヒロインが素晴らしい！ストーリーも面白い。グイグイ引き込まれて、読んでいっちゃう感じでラストまで止まらなかった！ヒロインが祖母の言葉を思い出す場面がいじらしい。

The heroine is amazing! The story is also interesting. I was so drawn in that I couldn't stop until the end because I felt like I was reading it! The scene where the heroine remembers her grandmother's words is disturbing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

弁護士

lawyers

This review contains spoilers. ヒロインは仕事ができて強いのかと思いきや、そうではなかった。ヒーローの不器用な優しさが良いです。

This review contains spoilers. I thought the heroine was good at her job, but that wasn't the case. The hero's clumsy kindness is good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

作者買いです。ヒーローは弟に対しても社員に対してもヒロインに対しても傲慢で愛があって周りが見えなくなるくらい一途な人なんだと思った。自分本位な愛だと気付いて、相手の気持ちを尊重する事を覚えたヒーローは最高にイイ男になった！

I'm buying the author. I thought the hero was so arrogant and loving towards his younger brother, employees, and heroine that I couldn't see his surroundings. Realizing that it was self-centered love, the hero who learned to respect his partner's feelings became the best man!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインの

The heroine's

強く見えるけど弱い部分をしっかりと受け止めるヒーローが雨滴だと思った。ヒーローは最初はめっちゃ失礼なやつ！って思ったけれど、ちゃんと謝ったり、認めたり、、、それによってヒロインの心も溶かされて、、、、いい話でした。

I thought Raindrop was the hero who looked strong but took the weak parts firmly. Heroes are so rude at first! I thought, but they properly apologized and acknowledged... it melted the heroine's heart... it was a great story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

珍しいかも

Maybe unusual

This review contains spoilers. 篠田先生の作品で、ラブHがないなんて？！何て珍しいのでしょう(笑) ストーリーとしては、前半のヒーローはどうにもならない傲慢ヤローでしたが、後半はヒロインにグイグイ押しまくって、しかも実はいい奴でした。

This review contains spoilers. I can't believe there is no Love H in Shinoda sensei's work?! How unusual is that (laughs) As a story, the hero in the first half was an arrogant Yarrow who couldn't do anything, but in the second half, he really gave the heroine a bang, and he was actually a nice guy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

思い込みとトラウマと

Assumptions and Trauma

弟の冤罪を通して距離が近くなったヒーローと弁護士のヒロイン。女性蔑視な発言をしてしまうヒーローもある意味成長できてなかったのかと思います。ヒロインは恋人に裏切られてから頑なになっていて。自分のトラウマを口にできてようやく見える道もあったのかと思います。

The hero and heroine, who became close through her younger brother's misdemeanor, and the heroine are lawyers. I think heroes who make statements that disdain women haven't been able to grow in a sense. The heroine has been stubborn since she was betrayed by her lover. I think there was also a path where I was able to talk about my trauma and finally saw it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

真面目に生きて

Live seriously

ずっと恋人に裏切られた事が忘れられず、次に進めない。心変わり、不確かなもの、結局恋人も他人だものね。結婚してから浮気されるよりいいのかな。辛い経験があるから人は深く生きれるのかもしれない。

I can't forget that my lover has always betrayed me, and I can't move on. A change of heart, something uncertain, and after all, lovers are different people too. Maybe it's better than being cheated on after getting married. People may be able to live deeply because they have had painful experiences.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

主題てんこ盛り

The theme is full of excitement

This review contains spoilers. トラウマがあって男性拒否気味でもすぐグダグダになるタイプが多いHQで最後まで服を脱がなかったヒロインは中身もしっかりして好感度大です。ヒーローとヒロインが惹かれあっていく途中描写があまりなかったのが残念です、しょうがないとはいえ弟関連に頁取られ過ぎ？この頁数で頑な心を溶かす恋愛と犯罪の謎解き、青年の成長と内容があり過ぎたせいでしょうか？

This review contains spoilers. The heroine who didn't take off her clothes until the end in HQ, where there are many types of people who are traumatized and feel rejected by men, is very likable because of her solid content. It's a pity that there weren't many depictions of the hero and heroine being attracted to each other, and even though it can't be helped, were there too many pages taken up in relation to the younger brother? Maybe it's because this number of pages solved the mystery of romance and crime that melts stubborn hearts, and the growth and content of a young man was too much?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった。

That was great.

ヒーローの粘り勝ちですね。10代の頃クリスマスに辛い別れを経験したヒロインですが、最後クリスマスにハッピーエンドでよかった！

The hero's persistence wins, isn't it? The heroine experienced a painful break up on Christmas when she was a teenager, but I'm glad she had a happy ending on Christmas at the end!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

前半はヒーローの分かりにくい片思い状態&空回りっぽい展開で、ドキドキする要素も少なく、よく読むハーレクインとは少し様子が違いましたが、ラストはもちろんハッピーエンド。こんな感じのゆったりした展開も良い感じです。

The first half was a bit different from Harlequin, the hero's unintelligible state of unrequited love and emptiness, and there were few exciting elements, and the situation was slightly different from Harlequin, which I often read, but of course the last one had a happy ending. This kind of relaxed development is also a nice feeling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

辛い過去

painful past

This review contains spoilers. １０代の辛い別れが忘れられないヒロイン。仕事でいくら活躍しても、心の穴は埋められないけれど、気づかないふりしてバリバリ仕事して生きている。元婚約者に裏切られたクリスマスの年から、彼女の愛はストップしていたのですね。最後ヒーロー頑張ったけれど、終わり方があっさり。絵は好きです。

This review contains spoilers. A heroine who can't forget her painful break up as a teenager. No matter how active they are at work, they can't fill a hole in their heart, but they live by pretending not to notice it. Her love has stopped since Christmas year when she was betrayed by her former fiancé. The hero did his best at the end, but the way it ended was easy. I like pictures.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローの一目惚れ！

A hero's love at first sight!

This review contains spoilers. 作者買いです。値下げなってたのでラッキーでした。ヒロインは過去の事から、頑なに仕事一筋、実力で認めてもらえるように頑張ってるのに、また外見で判断されたと…ヒーローに反発しつつ惹かれて行くという王道でした。

This review contains spoilers. I'm buying the author. The price was reduced, so I was lucky. It was a royal road where the heroine stubbornly worked hard, worked hard to be recognized for her ability, and was judged by her appearance... it was a royal road where she was attracted to the hero while rebelling against her.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ぐいぐいと進む話

A story that progresses rapidly

結果的に言えばヒーローの一目惚れなんだと思います。見た目のいい女性として目をひき、中身を知って行ったのかと。一方のヒロインは過去の裏切りでついた傷から立ち直れず、自身の見た目に惹かれて寄って来る男性にうんざりしてる。この傷は深く誰かを信じることが怖くなる傷だからこそ、一歩進む勇気が出せて良かったね、と思います。でも才色兼備のヒロインが10代の失恋によって恋愛に臆病になるって一途さが好きだな。

As a result, I think it was the hero's love at first sight. She caught her eye as a good-looking woman, and I wonder if she knew what was inside. The heroine, on the other hand, can't recover from the wounds caused by past betrayals, and she's sick of men who come up to her because she is attracted to her own appearance. I'm glad I had the courage to go one step further because this scar is a wound that makes me afraid to deeply believe in someone. But I love that the talented heroine becomes timid in love due to her teenage heartbreak.

Helpful

Stay Connected!

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter
Add to
Home Screen
Our Premium
Membership
Instagram

Other Social Media：X | X(BL) | Facebook | Youtube | TikTok

Register For Free!