A CINDERELLA FOR THE GREEK Manga Reviews

Meily

Report

Feb 02, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 172

Very touching

I love the story like cinderella but it is more convincing. The girl is lovely and strong in character.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

これは良いラスト

This is a good last

This review contains spoilers. 思ったよりポーリーンとクロエがタチ悪すぎて引きました。散財するだけでなくエレンはシンデレラのようにコキ使われていたとは。でも王子様と引き合わせてくれたのが魔法使いではなく継母と意地悪な妹でした～たっていうのが面白いですね。マックスに冒頭のスピリチュアルな幻覚を見せたのはマックスの母親か、もしくはエレンの母親かな…？と思ってしまいました。ラスト、エレンがまたここに来ると確信したマックスが待っててくれるのが愛ゆえだなと思うし、売り払われた絵画や家宝も買い戻してもらえて家の権利ももらえて、「君だけが欲しい」と求められる。最高に幸せなシンデレラでした。一つ気になるのが、ポーリーンとクロエ、お金使い果たしたらきっと帰ってきますよね？笑。その前に新しいカモを見つけるのかな？とりあえず、マックスとエレンの結婚式を新聞記事で見て悔しがって欲しいww

This review contains spoilers. Pauline and Chloe had a worse position than I expected, so I pulled them out. Not only was she splurging on money, but Ellen was using her job like Cinderella. But it's interesting that it wasn't the wizard who brought the prince in, but his stepmother and her mean sister. Was it Max's mother or Ellen's mother who showed Max his initial spiritual hallucination...? It made me think. At the end, I think it's because of love that Max, who is convinced that Eren will come here again, waits for me, and they buy back paintings and heirlooms that have been sold off, get the rights to the house, and are asked “only you want it.” She was the happiest Cinderella. One thing that bothers me is that Pauline and Chloe will definitely come back when they run out of money, right? lol. Will they find new ducks before then? Anyway, I want you to be disappointed to see Max and Ellen's wedding in a newspaper article lol lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインの境遇

The Heroine's Circumstances

This review contains spoilers. ヒロイン父親に女性を見る目がなかったばかりにヒロインの人生が大きく狂ってしまいました。ヒーローには正しい判断のできる目があったようです。義母と義妹が没落するところも見たいと思うほど腹立たしかった。

This review contains spoilers. The heroine's life went crazy just because the heroine's father had no eye for women. The hero seemed to have an eye for making the right decisions. It was so infuriating that I wanted to watch my mother-in-law and sister-in-law fall.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

のしあがったヒーロー

The Hero Who Has Shrunk

This review contains spoilers. 作者買いです。大富豪は元々は貧困層からののしあがり。ヒロインは本来は富豪の家系だったのに、継母とその娘の散財で傾き、さらに父親をも亡くしてしまった。そんな２人が出会って、お互いの考えを変えてしまう。出会うべくして出会った２人。この先の幸せが目に浮かびます。

This review contains spoilers. I'm buying the author. The millionaires originally hailed themselves from the poor. The heroine was originally from a wealthy family, but she lost her father due to splurging money on her stepmother and her daughter. When these two meet, they change their minds. Two people who met because they were meant to meet. The happiness ahead comes to my eyes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

ヒーローが素敵過ぎる！ヒロインを様々な呪縛から解き放ち、愛される喜びを教えてくれました。継母子が何の咎めもなくスルーされたことにモヤモヤが残るけど…少しくらいは痛い目に合ってほしかった。

Heroes are too nice! She freed the heroine from various spells and taught me the joy of being loved. There's still some confusion about the fact that the stepmother and child were passed through without any blame... but I wanted it to be a bit painful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

感動

touching

感動的なお話でした。ああ、私をこんな風に助けてくれる人が現れてくれないかな？私は主人もいるし、娘にはもうすでに婚約者がいるし、仕方ないので、漫画で代理満足。

It was a moving story. Oh, I wonder if someone who can help me like this will show up? I have a husband, and my daughter already has a fiancé, and I can't help it, so I'm satisfied with acting in comics.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

美しいです

It's beautiful

まず、どのページを見ても秋元先生の絵は小さな背景まで美しいです。そして、あらすじだけでは王道シンデレラストーリーと見せかけて、2人の心の深いところまで踏み入ったストーリーもいいですね。

First of all, no matter which page you look at, Akimoto-sensei's paintings are beautiful, even with a small background. Also, it's nice to have a story that goes deep into the hearts of the two, by pretending to be a classic Cinderella story with just the synopsis.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ホートン邸は幸せがいっぱい☘

The Horton House is full of happiness ☘

This review contains spoilers. 未婚の母の元に生まれ義父から不当な扱いを受けて逃げ出しひとりで這い上がってきたヒーロー。親子で幸せに暮らしていたが母親は事故で急死し父親は子連れの女性と再婚、陰で義母と連れ子にイジメられていたヒロイン。二人はヒロインが住んでいるホートン邸の売却話で知り合います…… 紆余曲折あるもののひかれあっていた二人は幸せになります☘ 秋元先生の絵は悲しみから喜びに変わる様子がとても素敵に描かれていて綺麗です? 物語の内容もウルッと来ました(涙) しかしヒロインの義母と連れ子は性悪です? 「金になりそうな再婚話」に鼻が利きそうな二人です? 途中から旅行に出たという設定で姿を見なくなりスッキリしました?

This review contains spoilers. A hero who was born to an unmarried mother, was treated unfairly by her father-in-law, ran away, and crawled up alone. The heroine lived happily as a parent and child, but her mother died suddenly in an accident, her father remarried a woman with children, and was bullied by her mother-in-law and stepchildren behind the scenes. The two get to know each other through the sale story of the Horton mansion where the heroine lives... although there are twists and turns, the two people who were drawn to each other will be happy ☘ Akimoto-sensei's paintings depict how they change from sadness to joy so nicely and are they beautiful? The content of the story also came as a surprise (tears) but are the heroine's mother-in-law and stepchildren rude? Are they two people who seem to have a good sense of “remarriage stories that seem to turn into money”? The setting was that they set out on a trip halfway so you didn't see them and felt refreshed?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

秋元さんの作品！

Akimoto's work!

秋元さんの作品が好きで、色々持っていたのですが、このシリーズはなかったので購入！

I liked Akimoto-san's works, and I had a lot of them, but this series wasn't there, so I bought it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローは魔法使いのおばあさん

The hero is the wizard's grandmother

This review contains spoilers. 素直に楽しめるお話でした。タイトル通りシンデレラみたいな境遇のヒロインですが、漫画の絵だと美人に見えるのに自分は醜いと言っているのがちょっと違和感でした。ドレス姿もきれいでしたが、あとがきにもあるように、私もジャージ姿がお気に入りです。悪役母娘は役割通り嫌な感じのキャラを演じ切ってくれました。あきらめの後に来るもの＝ラストシーンは結構感動的でした。

This review contains spoilers. It was a story I could honestly enjoy. As the title suggests, the heroine is in a Cinderella situation, but I was a little uncomfortable saying that she was ugly even though she looked beautiful in comic pictures. The dress was beautiful, but as you can see in the afterword, I also like wearing a jersey. The villain mother and daughter played characters that I didn't like according to their roles. What comes after giving up = the last scene was quite moving.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

遺産

patrimony

This review contains spoilers. 代々その家の女性に受け継がれてきた宝石類は、義理の母娘には権利が無いのでは？他の家財もそうだけれど、直系の者にしかどうこうはできないんじゃ。出ていったけれど、もっときちんと縁を断つべき。相手のそれまでの立ち回りから、最大限の用意周到さが必要かと。かれもほとんど信じていたし。

This review contains spoilers. Aren't mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law not entitled to jewelry that has been handed down to women in that family from generation to generation? As is the case with other household goods, only direct family members can do something about it. They left, but they should break off the relationship more properly. From the opponent's fight up to that point, I wonder if maximum preparation is necessary. He almost believed it too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

継母たちを苦しめる毒はやがて君をも侵す

The poison that torments stepmothers will eventually invade you too

ヒロインエレンは、大好きなホートン邸を売りに出す継母に対抗してきた。しかし、交渉相手として現れた眉目秀麗な男性ヒーローマックスに出会い、義妹と比較されるみすぼらしい自分を恥じ、より一層邸を売ることに反抗するのだった。しかし、女性の扱いには手馴れているように見える彼の手練手管にいとも簡単にエレンはおちた。マックス自身も最初はそれだけのつもりだったが、美しく変身した彼女に惹かれていた。ここまではＨＱあるあるの物語だけれど、ここからは私がトキメイタ部分。彼はエレンに邸を売ることを勧めた。それは、そもそも自分の物にしたかったからだったが、今は違う。継母たちへの恨み、復讐心は捨てろと彼女を説得しているのだ。酷い人達なのは重々承知。けれど、自分が幸せになればそんなことは些細な事と言えるようになるのだと、彼女たちを許すことが自分の幸せへの１歩だと言い聞かせたのだ。エレンはこの言葉に拒絶するが、想いを変える。そう、愛しているマックスの言葉を信じ、自分を変えるのだと決意したのだ。ここまでの流れが素晴らしく好きだ。このままハピエンに展開するのだが、最もやってはいけない事を織り交ぜてきた。それは、母の所持していた宝石を買い戻すという行為。ルビーのセット１つだけなら良しとしよう、けれど全て見つけるというのはいけない。彼女の決意を無にする行為に思える。それでも、理不尽に奪われた彼女の母の思い出を、その手に還すマックスの優しさに私もジンときた。が、思い出と拘りは違う。それらの宝石たちも、誰かに愛してもらえるのだからと、そういう真意の説得を彼はエレンにしてきたのだから。そして、許しを与えた彼女に必要なのはマックスだけなのだから。

The heroine Ellen has fought against her stepmother, who puts her favorite Horton house up for sale. However, he met Max, a good-looking male hero who appeared as a negotiation partner, and was ashamed of his shabby self compared to his sister-in-law, and rebelled against selling the house even more. However, Eren fell very easily into his skilled hands, who seemed to be used to dealing with women. Max himself initially thought that was all, but he was attracted to her, who had transformed beautifully. Up to this point, it's a story with HQ, but from here on, I'm the Tokimeita part. He recommended that Ellen sell the house. That was because I wanted to make it my own in the first place, but now it's different. I'm persuading her to let go of her resentment and sense of revenge against her stepmothers. I know very well that they are terrible people. However, I told them that forgiving them is one step towards my own happiness, that if I become happy, I will be able to say that such things are trivial. Eren rejects these words, but she changes her mind. Yes, I believed the words of Max, whom I love, and made up my mind to change myself. I love how things have gone so far. It continues to unfold into Happien, but it has interlaced the least things that should be done. It is the act of buying back jewels that my mother owned. One set of rubies would be fine, but don't find them all. It seems like an act of losing her mind. Even so, I was struck by Max's kindness in returning her mother's memories, which had been taken unreasonably, into her hands. However, memories and obsession are different. That's because he convinced Eren of his true intentions, because those jewels would also be loved by someone. And because Max is all she needs, who has given her forgiveness.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

心根の優しい女神

A kind-hearted goddess

ひどい継母娘の仕打ちを受けながらも頑張って家を守っていたヒロインの前に現れたヒーロー。心情描写が細かくてヒロインの家族と家を大事にする気持ちがよく伝わってきて良かったです。そしてラスト、抱きしめて告白するところがとても好きでした。

A hero who appeared in front of the heroine who was doing her best to protect her home while being treated by a terrible stepmother and daughter. I'm glad that the emotional depiction was detailed and that the heroine's feelings of taking care of her family and home were well conveyed. And at the end, I really liked the fact that they hugged and confessed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

義理の

In-law's

マミーこと義理の母と義理妹に制裁を！！ここを放置なのが優しい世界だなぁ。あと、常々思うのはＨＱってどうして”キミの事が好きだ、付き合ってくれ”が一足飛びで”結婚してくれ”になるんでしょうね。お国柄なの？気持ちを自覚したら即結婚の流れがおいおい早いなと思うばかりですが、それもまたＨＱですし、醍醐味ですかね。

Sanction my mother-in-law called Mommy and my sister-in-law!! It's a kind world to leave this place unattended. Also, what I always think is why does “I like you, go out with me” on HQ jump one step further and become “get married.” Is it a national pattern? I just think that once you become aware of your feelings, the marriage process will be really fast, but that is also HQ, so it's probably the real thrill.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

うむ

Hmm

This review contains spoilers. ヒーローもヒロインも素敵なシンデレラストーリーでした！が個人的には継母と妹にギャフンと言ってもらいたかったw

This review contains spoilers. It was a wonderful Cinderella story with both the hero and heroine! I personally wanted my stepmom and sister to say gaffn lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

王道のシンデレラストーリー

The classic Cinderella story

ヒロインがヒーローと出会って幸せになれてよかった！ただ継母子が逃げ得のままなのが…そこが－☆１

I'm glad the heroine met the hero and was happy! However, the stepmother and child are still able to escape... that is- ☆ 1

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

まさにシンデレラ

Exactly Cinderella

虐げられて自信もなくしてるけど強い女性ってのが伝わる絵で、ヒーローがそこにどんどんメロメロ(笑)になってくとこが好き。ただひとつ、あの意地悪継母と娘がぎゃふんというとこが欲しかったなぁ。

It's a picture that conveys a strong woman who has been oppressed and has no confidence, and I like the fact that the hero gets more and more melodious (laughs) there. I just wanted one thing: a place where that mean stepmother and her daughter are crazy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

秋元先生買い

Buy Akimoto sensei

作画が綺麗なこともあり、秋元先生の作品が大好きで、最近よく読んでます。義理の妹に傷つけられたヒロインの本質を見抜いたヒーローはえらい！本当にシンデレラストーリーでした。

There are times when the drawings are beautiful, and I love Akimoto-sensei's works, and I've been reading them a lot lately. The hero who saw through the essence of the heroine who was hurt by her sister-in-law is amazing! It really was a Cinderella story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

現代版シンデレラ

Modern Cinderella

秋元先生のホワっとする作風が、虐げられたヒロインの心と環境をうまく表現しています。ヒロインの少しづつ頑なな心をとかしてゆくヒーロー。未来に進んでいこうとするヒロイン。終盤この言葉がとても印象的でした。私には私がいる。生まれ変わった私がじゅうぶんよ。それが今この手にできるすべてなんだから

Akimoto-sensei's cool style successfully expresses the oppressed heroine's mind and environment. A hero who takes care of the heroine's stubborn heart little by little. A heroine trying to advance into the future. These last words were very impressive. I have me. It's enough for me to be reborn. because that's all I can do in my hands right now

Helpful

Reviews for A CINDERELLA FOR THE GREEK Manga