My Best (♀) Butler Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった！

That was interesting!

男性みんなかっこよくて少女漫画によくあるどろどろ展開もなくさらっと一気に読めました。終わり方がまだ続きそうな終わり方で物足りなさがありましたがそれだけこの漫画が面白かったんだなと…番外編的な感じで続き出ないですかね

All the men were so cool that I was able to read it all at once without the mushy developments common in girls' comics. The way it ended seemed like it was still going on, and it was unsatisfactory, but I think that's how interesting this comic was... it felt like an extra edition and wouldn't it continue

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

☆

☆

絵が綺麗だし、テンポもよく面白い。人におすすめしたい作品です。

The pictures are beautiful, and the tempo is good and interesting. I would recommend this work to people.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

イケメンに囲まれるイケメン女子、イイですねぇ。真崎先生の作品はイヤな感じのキャラが出てこないので、最後まで楽しんで読めます。すごくほっこりします。

Handsome girls surrounded by good-looking guys are nice, aren't they? There are no disgusting characters in Masaki-sensei's works, so I enjoy reading them until the end. It makes me feel so relaxed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

愉快痛快?

Happy, exciting?

テンポが小気味良い。ノリツッコミと、とにかく面白い。個人的には茶くまぽんグッズが欲しい(笑)

The tempo is slightly good. Noritsukomi, it's just so funny. Personally, I want brown bear pon goods (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

俺の執事(♀)がイケている

My butler (♀) is cool

ワクワクするストーリーです。今の日本の貧困さが、わかりやすくストーリーに練り込まれています。すごく面白いです(≧～≦))

It's an exciting story. The current level of poverty in Japan is woven into the story in an easy-to-understand manner. It's really interesting (≥～≤))

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

絵がとても可愛くて、大好きな作品です。茶クマぽんも読んでいくうちに大好きになりました。

The picture is so cute and I love it. As I read Cha Kumapon, I fell in love with it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

はまった

I'm addicted

絵がきれいで可愛いので、見てていい感じ。話もサクサク進んで飽きないです。

The pictures are beautiful and cute, so it's nice to look at them. The story progressed quickly and I never got tired of it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

とても笑えて面白く、ストーリーもとても良いです！秦来さんがかっこいいです。。

It's so funny and the story is so good! Mr. Hatarai is cool..

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

かっけー

cool

でてくる人みんなカッコいい?るいちんは、女の子だけど一押しだわ?

are all the people that come out cool? Ruichin is a girl, but I recommend it, right?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃすき

I really like it

イケメン女子がすきな人におすすめしたい！とにかくカッコいいです！

I would recommend it to anyone who likes good-looking girls! Anyway, it's cool!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いやー面白かった

Well that was interesting

眼福でした。腐女子にも好感度満点な主人公(訳あって女の子を隠して執事見習い)がまずいい。で女性アレルギーの御曹司が浮世離れで我が儘なのに優しくて、幼さが残ってそりゃあお世話したくなるでしょ。と思ってたら出るわ出るわイケメンゾロゾロ。目移りするほど皆いい！ＢＬに浸かりきってても、たまにはこんなのもいいな。とってもハッピーになりました。

It was a blessing. The main character (who hides the girl for some reason and becomes a butler apprentice), who is likable even for rotten girls, is bad. So my scion, who is allergic to women, is kind even though he is selfish and selfish, and his childhood is left behind, and well, I think I want to take care of him. If you think about it, it will come out, handsome guy, rozoro. The more distracted they are, the better everyone is! Even if you're fully immersed in BL, it's nice to do this once in a while. It made me so happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

完結！

complete!

続きが気になってしまう作品だったので、完結して一気に買って読みました！絵がさっぱりしているので好みが分かれるかもしれませんが、真崎先生の作品は個人的にハズレなしです。ラブラブのシーンをもう少し描いて欲しかった気もするのでスピンオフとかあればいいなと思います。

It was a work that made me curious about the continuation, so I finished it and bought it all at once and read it! The picture is clean, so people may have different tastes, but I personally don't lose sight of Masaki-sensei's work. I also feel like I wanted some more lovey-dovey scenes to be drawn, so I think it would be nice if there was a spin-off or something.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 20, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったかっこいい男装女子執事

Funny cool male dressed female butler

女子高生が男装して、御曹司の執事になり、男子校生活を送る。ベタな設定なのですが、この作者さんの作風のせいか、さらりとして、淡々と過ぎていきます。普通の少女漫画であれば、ドキドキシーンなのに、良い意味でゆるく、ドロドロしていないので、読みやすいです。笑えるシーンもあるし、男子の登場人物達が綺麗で個性的なので、楽しめます。

A high school girl dresses up as a man, becomes the scion's butler, and lives a boys' school life. It's a solid setting, but it goes by without hesitation, probably because of this author's style. If it's a normal girls' comic, even though it's a heart-pounding scene, it's easy to read because it's loose and not muddy in a good sense. There are also funny scenes, and the male characters are beautiful and unique, so you can enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 18, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった！！クリエイティビティ恐るべし

That was interesting!! Creativity is scary

This review contains spoilers. 冷ややかに見える画風なのに矢鱈おかしくて、信じられないほど突飛な設定を引ける才能に、居直ったような虚構。そこがシュールで、引き込まれた。言葉がストーリーをジャンプをさせてかなり省きがあるのに、唐突感何故か無く、逆にサッパリとした魅力あり。白っぽいと見えても手抜きの白さではなく、作者世界の主張をしかと感じ取らせてあり、グレー使いが巧み。細やかさゆえの白さ、というべきだろう。女装とか、男子だらけに女子紛れ込む、というのはあるし、主人公はモテモテというのも安定の少女漫画路線。なのに、そんな展開のどの作品とも被らない。ラインが太くないがふらついておらず、その迷いのなさが、ストーリーの特殊な環境に作品世界の中のリアルを持ち込む。崩しすぎるくらい崩したギャグ的表現に、もう少し人間関係の綾が負けてないと良かった。しかし、これでいいと思えてしまう。そのくらい、作品の放つ個性に、ねじ伏せられた。女性アレルギーという発想、私には大和和紀先生の「はいからさんが通る」に出てくる青江冬星編集長以来だった。女子を感じさせない女主人公「類」が男子男子校に入り込む設定は「花盛りの君たちへ」が大胆設定で寮生活までさせていることを思い起こすと、本作は類がふらふら焦点定まらぬ軽い迷走するほど(祷真、遥祈、秦来)というのが、寧ろ違和感ない。一途にひとりだけを想い続けるのも素敵だけれど、目移りしたり他の人の良さに気づいて意識してしまうのも、人間だから有りかと。フラフラするのを悪いこと、と決めつけてしまうと実社会でも遊びがなくなるしで、花男でつくしが司と類でふらついたのが話に厚みを生んだように、本作もまた、どっちなのか自分でもわからないと主人公に自問させる場面まで描写したのは、色々巻き込まれ感が膨らんで良かったと思う。

This review contains spoilers. It's a fictional style that looks cool, yet it's crazy, and it's a fictional place where you can draw unbelievably outlandish settings. That was surreal, and I was drawn in. The words jump through the story and there are quite a few omissions, yet for some reason there is no sense of abruptness; on the contrary, it has a refreshing appeal. Even if it looks whitish, it's not about cutting corners on whiteness, and it only makes me feel that the author's world claims, and the use of gray is clever. It should probably be called white because of its fineness. There are things like crossdressing and girls sneaking in with boys, and the fact that the main character is popular is also a stable girls' manga line. And yet, it doesn't match any work with such a development. The line isn't thick, but it's not wobbly, and that lack of hesitation brings the reality of the world of the work into the special environment of the story. It would have been nice if Aya in Human Relations hadn't lost a little more to the gag expression that broke down too much. However, it makes me think this is fine. To that extent, I was screwed by the individuality that the work gave off. The idea of female allergies started for me after Editor-in-Chief Aoe Fuyusei, who appeared in Yamato Kazunori sensei's “Haikara-san Goes Through.” The setting where the heroine “Rui,” who doesn't make you feel like a girl, enters a boys' school is when you think of “To Kimitachi in Blossoming” making you live in a dormitory in a bold setting, and the fact that in this work, the fact that Ryu wanders lightly without being focused (Zoshin, Haruki, Qin Rai) is rather incongruous. It's wonderful to keep thinking about only one person at a time, but I wonder if it's because we're humans that we get distracted or notice the goodness of others. If you decide that fluttering is a bad thing, there will be no fun even in the real world, and just as the fact that Tsukushi wandered around with Tsukasa in Flower Man gave depth to the story, I think it was good that this work also depicts scenes where the main character asks himself if he doesn't even know which one it is, and I think it was good that the feeling of getting caught up in various ways grew.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いい！

That's good!

絵もきれいでかわいいし、内容もおもしろくて、ほんとに良かったです！

The pictures were beautiful and cute, and the content was interesting, which was really nice!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い設定?

An interesting setting?

高レビューと試し読みが楽しかったので購入。結論、大満足です。ストーリーは、男装女子高生と女性アレルギーの金持ち坊ちゃんのお話。アレルギーと言っても女性嫌いレベルではなく、本当に身体に蕁麻疹、高熱等の症状が出てしまうやつ?健全な男子高校生には、本気で行き辛いと切なくなる場面も‥脳まで騙せるレベルの男装女子に出逢い少しずつ克服？していくお話で◎。登場人物も個性的なキャラで心情も丁寧に描かれており◎。迷ってるなら読んでみて！

I bought it because of the high reviews and the trial reading was fun. I am very satisfied with the conclusion. The story is about a male high school girl and a rich boy who is allergic to women. Even if you say it's an allergy, it's not at a level that dislikes women, and is it really something that causes symptoms such as hives and high fever in the body? For healthy high school boys, there are situations where it's really hard to get to... they meet girls dressed as men who can fool their brains and overcome them little by little? It's a story I'm going to do ◎. The characters are also unique characters, and their feelings are carefully drawn ◎. If you're unsure, read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

キャラクターがそれぞれ個性があって面白いです。笑いながら読ませてもらいました。

Each character has its own personality, which is interesting. I read it while laughing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

☆4.5

☆ 4.5

イケメン男装女子で、しかも大金持ちのお坊っちゃまの執事というてんこ盛りな設定で、非日常な世界感を楽しませてもらいました?類の周りの少年達がみんなイケメンばかりで目の保養です。闇のある執事の秦来は結構好きなキャラでしたね。ラストがあっさりというか駆け足気味で、もう少ししっかり楽しみたかったかなー。

I was able to enjoy an extraordinary sense of the world in a setting full of excitement where the handsome male dressed girl is also a very rich monk butler? The boys around them are all good-looking guys, so it's a feast for the eyes. Hatarai, the dark butler, was a character I liked quite a bit. The last one was so easy, or rather a rush, so I wonder if I wanted to enjoy it a little more thoroughly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

もっと読みたかった

I wanted to read more

最後まで読みました。スッキリした絵柄で見やすくて内容も面白かったです。こんなに最後まで誰とゴールインするか読めない漫画は初めてでした。

I read it all the way to the end. The clean design was easy to read, and the content was interesting. It was my first comic where I couldn't read who I finished with until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

みんないい奴

Everyone is a good guy

This review contains spoilers. ちょこちょこ嫌な奴は出てきますけど、基本的に主人公に深く関わる人はみんな良い人ばかりです。だから、モヤモヤしないしスッキリ完結するから、後味も悪くないです。ただ、なんとなーく現実離れし過ぎてる気はするかなぁ？主人公良い子だから、周りから好かれるのはわかるけど、周りの大人達まで絵に描いたような良い人揃いでね、その辺が少しだけ気になりました。私の心が汚れてるから、そう思っちゃうのかも知れないけど笑

This review contains spoilers. There are a few disgusting people coming out here and there, but basically all the people who are deeply involved with the main character are all good people. So, it doesn't get messy, and it finishes refreshingly, so the aftertaste isn't bad either. However, I wonder if it somehow feels like it's too far from reality? The main character is a nice kid, so I know he is liked by people around him, but even the adults around him are such nice people as if they were drawn in a picture, and I was just a little concerned about that. my heart is dirty, so maybe I think so lol

Helpful

Reviews for My Best (♀) Butler Manga