1122: For a Happy Marriage Manga Reviews (P.17)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

レビュー低くなるのは仕方ない！

The reviews can't be helped to get lower!

This review contains spoilers. あんまり共感できない内容なので、星が比較的低いのはしょうがないですよね。ストーリーの胸糞とか抜きにしたら良い作品だと思います！扱っている題材が新しいし、主題的だと感じます。まぁ私は読んでてストレスがすごいので途中で離脱しましたが…

This review contains spoilers. I don't really sympathize with the content, so it can't be helped that the stars are relatively low. I think it would be a good work without taking the heartbreak from the story! The subject I'm dealing with is new, and I feel like it's thematic. Well, I was so stressed when I was reading it, so I left halfway through...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

両方よかった

Both were good

This review contains spoilers. 漫画もメディア化された作品も両方よかったです。夫婦の形も様々、考え方も様々、でも最後はやはり・・今でも両方繰り返して見てしまう作品です

This review contains spoilers. Both comics and mediated works were good. There are various shapes of married couples, and there are various ways of thinking, but at the end... it's still a work where I watch both over and over again

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

秩序

Order

多様性がうたわれる時代に、普通ではない夫婦の関係の話。でもこの作品は逆説的に、一定の規律、秩序の大切さを伝えていると思う。

A story about an unusual marital relationship in an age where diversity is celebrated. But paradoxically, I think this work conveys the importance of a certain level of discipline and order.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

微妙な関係

A delicate relationship

This review contains spoilers. リアルにありそうで無さそうで、微妙な夫婦の日常が描かれていて面白いです。とはいえ、身近には無さそうな話なので漫画で楽しめるのは良いかな。サバサバしている女性でもやはり心の奥底は揺れているのですね。

This review contains spoilers. It's interesting because it depicts the delicate everyday life of a married couple, which seems unlikely to be real. Nonetheless, it's a story that doesn't seem familiar, so I think it would be nice to enjoy it in comics. The depths of a woman's heart are still shaking, aren't they?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

誰も報われない…

Nobody gets rewarded...

うーん…理解はできるけど、共感はできないかな。いろんな事情はあれど、公認とはいえ不倫は不倫だし。おとやん、気が利いて優しいから一見いい男風に見えるけど、とんでもないクズな気がする。でも、マンガとしては面白いです。

Hmm... I can understand it, but I wonder if I can sympathize with it. There are various circumstances, but an affair is an affair even though it is officially recognized. Otoyan, he's attentive and kind, so at first glance he looks like a nice man, but I feel like he's ridiculous. But it's interesting as a manga.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

結婚とは

What is marriage

This review contains spoilers. もういっそ離婚してしまえばいいと思うのですが、なんでそんなに結婚という形に拘っているんですかね。確かに結婚による法的なメリットなどはありますが、気持ちが付いてこなくて、経済的な理由とかもないのなら、いっそ離婚した方が健全な心を保てる気がします。

This review contains spoilers. I think it would be better if they got divorced, but why are they so obsessed with the form of marriage? Certainly, there are legal benefits from marriage, etc., but if feelings don't come along and there are no financial reasons, I feel that it is better to keep a healthy mind if you get divorced.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

モヤモヤ

Moya Moya

面白いとは思いますが読後感はモヤモヤしました。何か夫は自分勝手だし。結局あまり読み直しもしていません。

I think it's interesting, but the feeling after reading it was fuzzy. Somehow my husband is selfish. After all, I haven't re-read it much.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

既婚者も未婚者もグッと入っていける

Both married people and unmarried people can get in

This review contains spoilers. 作者、渡辺ペコ先生の作品にハズレなし。登場人物全てのキャラクターの気持ちがよくわかる。ある日はいちこの気持ちで読み、ある日はおとやんの気持ちで読む。いちこの詩的な表現の性欲に強く共感。おとやんの目線がすごくいい。いちこを見る目は優しげだけど長くいる者に向けるなんでも知ってしまっているような…対して妻公認の浮気相手に対しては目を開き、知らない事への嬉しさが見てとれる。ストーリーだけでなくもちろん絵も繊細で良い。食べ物の塩気や甘みまで伝わってくるようだ。

This review contains spoilers. There is nothing wrong with the work of the author, Watanabe Peko. I can really understand the feelings of all the characters. One day I read it with the feeling of being at home, and the other day I read it as if it were yesterday. I strongly sympathize with Ichiko's poetic expression of sexual desire. Otoyan's point of view is really nice. Ichiko's eyes are kind, but she seems to know everything for those who have been around for a long time... In contrast, she opens her eyes to her wife's official cheating partner, and I can see the joy of not knowing. Not only the story, but of course the pictures are also delicate and nice. It seems that even the saltiness and sweetness of the food are transmitted.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

This review contains spoilers. すごーく考えながら読みました。いちこちゃんとおとやくんすごくいい夫婦なんだよね。うきうき公認不倫してたおとやんがいちこの風俗に拒否反応出してたとこは、そんな権利おまえにねーよと思ったけど。傍からみたらいびつな夫婦でも、当人同士がいろいろ考えているのを読むと感情移入しちゃう。複雑な夫婦関係をよくかけているなと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I read it while thinking a lot. Ichiko-chan and Toyakun are a really nice couple, aren't they? I thought you didn't have that kind of right when Otoyan, who was excited to have an official affair, rejected this custom. Even if you look at it from the side, even a messy couple empathizes when you read that the person in question is thinking about various things with each other. I think they often play on complicated marital relationships.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

夫婦のお話

A story about a married couple

This review contains spoilers. 家族、夫としては一緒にいたいから、公認で不倫は許す。って、最初は割り切って上手くやっていけるなんて考えてるけど、やっぱり感情としては無理がでてくるよねー。作品としては最初のつかみのインパクトはありますけどね。それぞれの立場からの考えや気持ちが丁寧に描かれている作品です。しかし、最後の剣山は…。痛すぎるねー…。

This review contains spoilers. I want to be together as a family and husband, so an affair is officially permitted. At first, I'm thinking that I can get along well by dividing, but after all, it's impossible as an emotion. As a work, the first grab has an impact, though. It is a work that carefully depicts thoughts and feelings from each standpoint. However, the last Kenzan... it hurts too much...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

試し読みからはまってしまいました。

I got addicted to trial readings.

This review contains spoilers. けっこう一気に読んでしまって、面白かったです。ただ、おとやんの事がずっと腹立たしくて仕方がなかったです。外で処理しろと言われても、恋人や不倫はあかんやろって感じです。どうせなら風俗のほうがマシです。子供もいないのに、夫婦でいる意味なくない？って感じ…。いち子ちゃんよりで読んでしまっていたので、ひたすら、おとやんに苛立ちが…。でもやさしい人だから最後の方は見直しました。青年まんがのジャンルになっているのもちょっとびっくりしました。

This review contains spoilers. I read it all at once, and it was interesting. However, the thing about Otoyan was so infuriating that I couldn't help it. Even if you're told to handle it outside, it feels like a lover or affair is wrong. Anyway, the manners are better. Isn't there no point in being a married couple even though they don't have children? it feels like... I had read it from Ichiko-chan, so I was just so frustrated... But since he's a kind person, I reviewed the last one. I was also a little surprised that it has become a youth manga genre.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

This review contains spoilers. ドロドロした内容ですが淡々と描かれて面白かったです！しかし女風の描写にリアリティがないのが気になりました。本番アリってそれ違法なのでは…？リスク背負ってる割に5時間5万とか格安だしｗまだ女風がそれほど知名度上る前に描かれたから取材とかちゃんとしなかったのかな？？あと若いイケメン男子が急に40おばさんを好きになる描写がご都合すぎるかな～そして一瞬で消えて何がしたかったのかな～？と…それ意外は結構面白くよめました！全体的には面白かったです！絵もあっさりめですがきれいで好みでしたオチも予想できた結末でしたが上手くまとまっててよかったと思います。

This review contains spoilers. The content was muddy, but it was so easy to draw and it was interesting! However, I was concerned that there was no reality in the woman-style depiction. Aren't live ants illegal...? It's cheap for 5 hours and 50,000 for taking risks lol I wonder if they didn't do the coverage or anything since the girl style was drawn before they were that famous?? Also, I wonder if the depiction of a young handsome boy suddenly falling in love with 40 is too convenient ~ and then disappeared in an instant what did they want to do ~? And... surprisingly, it was pretty interesting! Overall it was fun! The picture was also simple, but it was beautiful and I liked it. I was able to predict the punch line, but I'm glad it came together so well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキしながらイッキ読み

Read it clearly while being excited

私には新しい視点からのストーリーだったので、かなり新鮮でした。でも誰にでもある問題だと思うし、だからこそ気持ちを揺さぶられました。

It was a story from a new perspective for me, so it was pretty fresh. But I think it's a problem that everyone has, and that's why it shook my mind.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

結婚制度に対するアンチテーゼ？

An antithesis to the institution of marriage?

This review contains spoilers. 面白かったけど、自分は単純な人間なのでこういう繊細な感情の表出を伴うヒューマンドラマはやっぱり難しい。二組の夫婦の紆余曲折物語で結局雨降って地固まる感じなんだけど・・・登場人物達、モノローグが多くて屁理屈多いなあ、と。特に夫の言動がヒロインに対しても浮気相手に対しても嘘臭くて本当にこんな男おる？って感じ。ヒロインも友人達との絡みの方が夫婦でいる時よりリアリティーがあって面白かった。最終的にヒロイン夫婦は離婚したけどもやっぱり一緒に生きることを選びます。結婚って、夫婦ってなんなん？てことなのかなあ。けど現実にはもっともっといろんな形の夫婦がいるからねえ。だから特に感慨もなく、そうなんだ～で終わってしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. It was interesting, but since I'm a simple person, human dramas involving such delicate expressions of emotion are difficult after all. It's a story of twists and turns between two couples, and it feels like the ground solidifies after all, but... the characters have a lot of monologues and a lot of nonsense. In particular, is there really such a man whose husband's words and actions smell like lies to both the heroine and his cheating partner? It feels like that. The heroine was also more realistic and interesting when she got involved with her friends than when they were a married couple. In the end, the heroine couple got divorced, but they still choose to live together. Marriage is what is a married couple? I wonder if that's it. But in reality, there are even more different types of married couples. So I wasn't particularly impressed, and that was it, it ended.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

夫婦ってなんでしょうね、考えさせられる

I wonder what a married couple is, it makes me think

This review contains spoilers. 夫からのお誘いを断り、夫は心がポッキリ折れてその穴を埋めるように夫に好きな人が出来、不倫です。妻は自分のせいでもあると認めてしまったところから物語は始まります。夫側、妻側のどちらの気持ちもわかり、心情描写がリアルに描かれてます。ですが自分は初めからずっとモヤモヤしてました。嫌だよね本当は嫌だよ。不倫相手との逢瀬にホクホクしてる顔見せられてさ、傷つかない人はいない。心技体を取り戻すために関わった女性風俗との出会い。それを気持ち悪いと出て行った夫。よくまぁ自分の事は棚に上げたなとずっとモヤモヤですが、非常に先が気になります。そしてこの夫婦の答えを一緒に考え見守る、考えさせられるテーマでした。

This review contains spoilers. I declined an invitation from my husband, and my husband broke his heart so that he could fill that hole with someone he liked, and it's an affair. The story begins where my wife admits that it is also her fault. I understand the feelings on both the husband's side and the wife's side, and the emotional depiction is realistically depicted. However, I was confused the whole time from the beginning. I don't like it, I really don't like it. There is no one who doesn't get hurt when they're shown a happy face when they meet their affair partner. An encounter with female customs involved in order to regain one's mind, skill, and body. My husband said he didn't feel comfortable with it and left. Well, I'm always confused when I put myself on the shelf, but I'm really worried about the future. And it was a thought-provoking theme where they thought and watched over the couple's answers together.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

夫婦を続ける難しさがリアル

The difficulty of continuing to be a married couple is real

This review contains spoilers. 同じじゃないけど、なんか「わかる！」と共感する。夫婦って続けていくことこそが難しくて、自分の考えも相手への気持ちも変化するし、自分でもわからない状態にもなる。恋より難解。そして正解なんてなくて。漫画のようなハッピーエンドはなかなかないもんです。曖昧な終わりもリアルさたっぷり。どうなるかなんて死ぬまでわからない。そんな夫婦の複雑さがよく出ていました。楽しくは読めない。おもたいし、痛いし、解決しないし。だけど、夫婦に行き詰まったら一度は読んでもいいかも。そう思った作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. It's not the same, but something like “I understand!” I sympathize with you. It is difficult for a married couple to keep on going, their own thoughts and feelings for their partner change, and they become in a state where they don't even understand. More difficult than love. And there's no right answer. There aren't many happy endings like in comics. The ambiguous ending is also full of realism. You don't know what's going to happen until you die. The intricacies of such a married couple were often revealed. It's not fun to read. It hurts, it hurts, and it doesn't work out. However, if you get stuck as a married couple, you might want to read it at least once. It was a work I thought so.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

結局のところ、、

At the end of the day...

This review contains spoilers. 全巻購入組です。賛否両論あるようですね笑私はこの話のテーマは「夫婦にセッ●スは必要か」だと思って読んでました。でも、結局のところ、その焦点は「夫婦に子どもは必要か」にすり替わり、終いには戸籍も不要だと、プラトニックな関係は可能だという結論だったのだなと理解しました。皆さまのモヤモヤは、この【すり替え】が原因ではないでしょうか。で、結局、ふたやんは一子さんとセック●出来たのでしょうか？？個人的には美月さんの旦那、大好きです。ぶれないイケメン、かっこいい！

This review contains spoilers. This is an all-volume purchase group. There seem to be pros and cons lol I was reading this because I thought the theme of this story was “Do married couples need sex?” But at the end of the day, the focus changed to “do couples need children?” and at the end of the day, I understood that a platonic relationship was possible if a family register was unnecessary. I think this [replacement] is the cause of everyone's confusion. So, after all, was Futayan able to have sex ● with Ichiko?? Personally, I love Mizuki's husband. An unshakable handsome guy, so cool!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

夫婦について考えた

I thought about the couple

とても奥深いお話でした。妻側の感情も夫側の感情も描かれていたのが良かったです。女性誌ではなく、青年マンガなのに後から気づいて驚き、とても関心しました。青年誌でも、こういう夫婦間の奥深いお話もあるのですね。とてもいいと思いました。ドラマ化されているCMを観て、気になって読みました。夫婦関係は、いろいろありますし、それぞれ幸せの基準も違うので、お互いいろいろ話あっていて、お互いの事を気遣っているけど、自分のしたい事もしている。モヤモヤもかなりありましたが、いい夫婦関係とは思いました。とても興味深いお話で面白かったです。

It was a very profound story. It was nice that both the wife's side's feelings and the husband's side's feelings were depicted. I was surprised to notice later that it was a youth manga, not a women's magazine, and I was very interested. Even in youth magazines, there are deep stories about married couples like this. I thought it was very nice. I watched commercials that had been made into dramas, and I was curious to read them. There are various marital relationships, and each has different standards of happiness, so they talk about various things with each other, care about each other, but they also do what they want to do. There was quite a bit of confusion, but I thought it was a good marital relationship. It was a very interesting story and it was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

4巻最高

Volume 4 is the best

This review contains spoilers. 剣山を突き立てたシーンをみて、溜飲が下がりました。女性は月経、初体験、妊娠、出産などで出血し、痛い思いをするのに、男性は気持ちいいだけ。不貞行為をしたらこれくらいの痛み、出血を感じさせてもよい。性犯罪を犯したら、100回くらい剣山の刑とかそういう法律ができないかな

This review contains spoilers. I saw the scene where Mount Tsurugi was thrust up, and my drink went down. Women bleed during menstruation, first experience, pregnancy, childbirth, etc., and feel pain, but men just feel good. If you commit an act of infidelity, you may feel this much pain or bleeding. If you commit a sexual crime, I wonder if Kenzan's sentence or something like that can't be done about 100 times

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

羨ましいなぁ

I envy you

This review contains spoilers. いちこちゃんの友達とのやり取りが、ひたすら羨ましい。ここまで、話せる友達が自分にはいないのかもなぁ。性欲の話とか性生活の話は、軽くするけど、お互いジリジリと様子みながら話してる感じ。あと、おとやんが、公認不倫を自分の頭の中で一生懸命に正当化してるとこは、おとやん、賢い人だから、気づいて欲しかったかな。自分は、必死で正当化して快楽だけじゃなく、愛情まで持って不倫してること。いちこちゃんと決めたって言ってもさ。でも、総じていい夫婦だなぁ。羨ましいなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. I'm just envious of Ichiko-chan's dealings with her friends. Maybe I don't have any friends I can talk to up to this point. I'll keep talking about sexual desire and sex life lightly, but it feels like they're talking in a daze with each other. Also, the place where Otoyan works so hard to justify an official affair in her own head is Otoyan, she's a smart person, so I guess I wanted her to notice. I am having an affair with not only pleasure but also love by desperately justifying it. You could even say that I made the decision with Ichiko. But overall, they're a nice couple. I'm envious.

Helpful

Reviews for 1122: For a Happy Marriage Manga