Twittering Birds Never Fly Manga Reviews (P.73)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

矢代の幸せとは？

What is Yashiro's happiness?

This review contains spoilers. 初めて読んだときはBLの分野を超えたヤクザの社会を舞台にした作品に感動した。ストーリー性が高く、印象的なセリフやシーンがあり、素晴らしい。何度か読むうちに矢代の痛々さがかわいそうで見ていられなくなり、5巻で断念した。矢代は変態ではない。好きな人を怒らせて興奮したり、好きな人が恋をしてどう抱くか盗撮したり、自分を傷付ける性的な快楽に依存したり、すべての行為が辛い。矢代の少年時代のシーンの描写は生々しくて心が痛む。1巻に入っていた影山と矢代の高校時代のお話である『漂えど沈まず、されど鳴きもせず』は神。寂しさを知り、恋しさを知った矢代が、その感情を初めて教えてくれた影山から大事な親友と言われなかったら、矢代の人生は変わっていただろうか。ひとりの親友と言われたら感情を押し殺し、恋しくない、と思うしかない。全編を通して漂う矢代の諦めた感が物悲しい。『俺の人生は誰かのせいであってはならない』は、矢代の芯の強さと寂しさと孤独を表す名言だと思う。5巻では、可愛く思う百目鬼に優しく抱かれ、感情を揺さぶられ、寂しさを壊され、満たされた初めての感覚を知り、愛する人を失う怖さを知る。しかし、それと共に少年時代の根深い感情が蘇り、無表情になった矢代が悲しかった。矢代にとって幸せとは何なのか？メリバでもいい。矢代自身が幸せだと思う最終話を見届けたい気持ちはある。影山と久我のラブラブシーンは好きだった。4.4

This review contains spoilers. When I first read it, I was moved by the work set in a yakuza society that transcends the BL field. The story is high, there are impressive lines and scenes, and it's wonderful. After reading it a few times, I felt sorry and couldn't watch Yashiro's pain, so I gave up on volume 5. Yashiro isn't a pervert. All acts are painful, such as making someone you like angry and excited, voyeurizing how someone you like is in love and holding them, and depending on sexual pleasures that hurt yourself. The depiction of scenes from Yashiro's boyhood is vivid and heart-wrenching. “Drifts and Doesn't Sink, But Doesn't Cry,” which is a story about Kageyama and Yashiro's high school days that was in volume 1, is a god. If Yashiro, who knows loneliness and knows about loneliness, wasn't called an important best friend by Kageyama, who first taught me that feeling, would Yashiro's life have changed? I have no choice but to think that being called my best friend would kill my emotions and I don't miss them. The feeling that Yashiro has given up that drifts throughout the entire story is sad. I think “My life shouldn't be anyone's fault” is a quote that expresses the strength, loneliness, and loneliness of Yashiro's core. In volume 5, you learn about the first feeling of being gently hugged by the cute Momome demon, shaken by your emotions, broken by loneliness, and being satisfied, and learn about the fear of losing someone you love. However, along with that, deep-seated feelings from his boyhood came back to life, and Yashiro, who had become expressionless, was sad. What does happiness mean to Yashiro? Meriba is fine too. I have a feeling that I want to watch the final episode where Yashiro himself feels happy. I loved the love scene between Kageyama and Kuga. 4.4

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

待ってました！

I've been waiting!

続きが気になっててようやく発売されたから即買いしちゃいました！矢代と同じ世界にいたい為にヤクザになった百目鬼、久しぶりに再会してからの百目鬼の表情がなんともいえない！はやく次の巻が見たい！！

I was curious about the continuation and finally went on sale, so I bought it right away! The expression of Momome Demon, who became a yakuza because he wanted to be in the same world as Yashiro, is indescribable after being reunited after a long absence! I want to see the next volume soon!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

試し読みで気になって購入。綺麗な作風とエロさ重視で買う事が多いのですが、この作品はとにかくストーリーが気になって読みたくて、、気づくと最新巻まで買ってました。面白いです。

It was a trial reading and I was curious and bought it. I often buy this work because of its clean style and emphasis on eroticism, but I was curious about the story and wanted to read it... and when I noticed it, I even bought the latest volume. It's interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

重め暗め

Heavy and dark

暴力苦手で読み進めるか迷いつつ、、6巻まで読みました。ヤクザものもマンガによってはそういう設定だけだったり派手な部分だけだったり中身がなかったり色々ですが、本当のヤクザの世界は分からないけど、BLってことを忘れそうになるくらい、ちゃんと物語があり人や心が描かれている作品だと思いました。顔や名前が覚えられなくて、これ誰？？と思いながら読んでるので何回か見直さないと難しそう笑痛そうな場面が多いし暗めの話で、ほいほい読めないけど、読みがいのあるマンガだと思います。絵はそんなには好きじゃないですが。

I'm not good at violence, so I read up to 6 volumes while wondering whether to proceed. Depending on the manga, there are various Yakuza things, with only that kind of setting, only flashy parts, or no content, but I don't know the real world of Yakuza, but I thought it was a work with a proper story, and people and minds were drawn. I can't remember his face or name, who is this? I'm reading it while thinking, so if I don't review it a few times, there are a lot of scenes that seem difficult and laughable, and it's a dark story, and I can't read it very well, but I think it's a manga worth reading. I don't like pictures that much though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

引き込まれました

I was drawn in

内容が濃いです！三巻まで一気に読んでしまいました。続きがとても楽しみで仕方ないです！ヤクザの世界は、まったく分かりませんが、いろいろあって、理解不能なところも。無知過ぎる自分がイヤになりました。続き、楽しみです。

The content is intense! I read up to three volumes at once. I can't help but look forward to the continuation! I don't understand the world of the Yakuza at all, but there are so many things that I can't understand. I don't like myself for being too ignorant. I'm looking forward to continuing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 10, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

深いストーリー

A deep story

レビューが良くて前から気になってたけど、ヤクザものだったのでちょっと避けていた作品です。割引されてたので買ってみたら、続きが気になって既存７巻まで購入。全体的に暗いというか静かというか…、ダークというかシリアスというか、表現がちょっと難しい。ストーリーの展開はジワジワ進んでく感じかな。いきなり回想というか過去に飛んだ時は「あれ？」ってなってページを戻って「あ～過去の話か！」ってなりましたが(笑)何気に捻くれてる恋心が見え隠れするところが好きだったりします(笑)これは最終的にハッピーエンドになるのかなー。なって欲しいけど、なって欲しくないような…。（個人的にバッドエンドも好きなので）とりあえず７巻がめっちゃ気になる終わり方をしたので８巻の発売が待ち遠しい！！！

The reviews were good and I was interested in it for a while, but since it was Yakuza stuff, I avoided this work for a bit. It was discounted, so when I bought it, I was worried about the continuation, so I bought up to 7 existing volumes. Overall, dark or quiet... dark or serious, it's a bit difficult to express. The development of the story seems to be slowly progressing. Suddenly reminiscences, or rather, when they flew into the past, were “huh?” I went back to the page and said, “Oh, that's a story from the past!” It came down to that (laughs), but I like places where my twisted love is visible and hidden (laughs) I wonder if this will eventually have a happy ending. I want it to be, but it's like I don't want it to be... (I personally like Bad Ends too) Anyway, volume 7 ended in a really worrisome way, so I can't wait for volume 8 to be released!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

これを超える作品はないと思っていた。。

I didn't think there was any work that surpassed this one..

星５以上でした、6巻までは。7巻でアレ？ってなって、8巻で。。。わざと引き伸ばしてますよね？？そうとしか思えない。。残念過ぎる。。

It was 5 stars or higher, until volume 6. is that in volume 7? It became, in volume 8... You're stretching it on purpose, right?? I can only think so.. too disappointing..

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

どうにかならないの？

Is there anything that can be done?

This review contains spoilers. 辛くて、辛くて、どうにかならないの？て、思うくらいドーンとくる話だけど、好きな作品です。

This review contains spoilers. It's hard, it's painful, can't you do anything about it? It's a story that comes as far as I thought, but it's a work I like.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤクザなのに憎めないキャラたち

Characters you can't hate even though they're Yakuza

以前劇場版？をテレビで見て、続きが気になって購入。普段ヤクザ物読まないので、難しいところもちょこちょこありましたが、面白かったです。矢代さんや百目鬼さんもだけど、周りにいるキャラもヤクザなのに憎めない！

previous movie version? I watched it on TV and bought it because I was curious about the continuation. I don't usually read Yakuza stuff, so there were a few difficult points, but it was interesting. Yashiro and Momome Oni too, but I can't hate the characters around them even though they are yakuza!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

まだ２巻までですが、先がきになります

We're still up to volume 2, but we have a head start

矢代と百目鬼の関係が気になります。時々、痛い場面も、反吐がでそうな場面もありますが、この先どうなるのか。画力がある先生なので、絵はきれいてす。

I'm curious about the relationship between Yashiro and Momome Oni. Occasionally, there are painful scenes and scenes where people seem to have a backlash, but what will happen in the future? The teacher has good drawing skills, so the pictures are beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

高評価に納得のストーリー

A story that satisfies the high ratings

This review contains spoilers. 6巻いきなりは多いな～、ちょっとずつ集めようかなーと思ってましたが、無理でした。続きが気になり過ぎて結局全巻購入(笑)ヤクザという独特な（狭い）世界の中で、ストーリーがしっかり作られていて引き込まれました。第一部的な大きなストーリーが終わって別れた二人の関係が今後どうなるのか、続きがすごく気になります。来年まで待ちきれないっ

This review contains spoilers. There are a lot of volumes 6 all of a sudden, so I was wondering if I would collect them little by little, but that was impossible. I was so worried about the continuation that I ended up buying the entire volume (laughs) in the unique (small) world called Yakuza, and I was drawn in because the story was well-made. I'm really curious about the continuation of the relationship between the two people who broke up after the first part of the big story is over. I can't wait until next year

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

ヨネダ先生の作品はシナリオがとてもいいですよね。でもヤクザものちょっと苦手だから、「どうしても触れたくない」みたいな、普通の会社員話次は期待したいなあ。そっちのが感情移入しやすいかも。

Yoneda sensei's work has a very good scenario, isn't it? But I'm a little bad at yakuza stuff, so I'd like to look forward to the next normal office worker story, like “I really don't want to touch it.” That one might be easier to empathize with.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

BLのお話でも、ヤクザの話なので重たい感じがしますが、読んでみると本当に切ない。不器用な主人公が、どうにか幸せになってほしくて続きが気になります。

Even though it's a BL story, it feels heavy because it's a Yakuza story, but when I read it, it's really sad. I want the clumsy protagonist to somehow become happy, so I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

痛すぎて。。

it hurts too much..

レビューで高評価もすごくよくわかるのですが、私には設定上仕方のないことだとはいえ、登場人物が心も身体も傷つけられて、痛すぎて、かわいそうすぎて、読むのが辛く苦しかったです。。。完結してから読めばよかったのかな。でも、ふたりとも、もしくはひとりが死んで終わりとかなったら、救われない。。。死ぬのが幸せ、とかいうエンドだったら、まじ泣きます。こういうレビュー書いてるから、ハマってるんでしょうね。でも、ほんとに痛すぎたので、星4つで。

I can understand the high ratings very well in the reviews, but even though it was unavoidable for me due to the settings, the characters were hurt both mentally and physically, and it was so painful, so pathetic, and it was hard and painful to read... I wonder if I should have read it after I finished it. But if both of them or one person die and it comes to an end, they won't be saved... If it ended up being happy to die, I would really cry. I'm writing this kind of review, so I guess I'm addicted to it. But it really hurt so much that I gave it 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

まだハードル高そうです

It seems like the hurdles are still high

レビューでたくさんの方が大絶賛しておられるので気になってました。全巻立読みしてから購入しましたが、内容が濃すぎるのか読み進むのが辛くなりました。多分時期じゃなかったんだと思います。引き込まれそうな自覚はあり、きっと時間を忘れるほど夢中になって、続きを乞うようになると思うので、それまでしばしお預けです。

I was curious because many people gave it rave reviews. I bought it after reading the entire volume, but it became difficult to read on because the content was too intense. I think it probably wasn't the right time. I'm aware that I'm about to be drawn in, and I'm sure I'll get so carried away that I forget the time, and I'll start begging for more, so I'll leave it for a while until then.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

これは…

this is...

かなりハマります。読み始めはそんなでも無かったけど、何か中毒性が有ると言うか何と言うか…。妙に色気が有って、読み進めるのに凄くドキドキしましたwとにかくエロい！！女性じゃないトコがまた唆られる作品だと思います。

I'm pretty addicted to it. It wasn't like that when I first started reading it, but what do you say that it's addictive... I had strangely sex appeal, and I was really excited to read on lol anyway, it's erotic!! I think it's a work that also suggests places that aren't women.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

深い、、、

deep...

作者買いでしたが、やっぱりヨネダ先生の作品はストーリーがとにかく深い。心理描写も絶妙で、まるでドラマを見ているような、映像で再生されているような、そんな臨場感があります。続きがきになる。

I bought the artist, but after all, Yoneda sensei's work has a very deep story. The psychological depiction is also exquisite, and there is such a sense of realism, as if watching a drama or being played back on video. It will be continued.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良いです。

It's good.

完結するまで購入を控えていましたが、映画を見て続きが気になり購入しました。これからの展開が楽しみです。

I was refraining from purchasing until it was completed, but after watching the movie, I was worried about the continuation, so I bought it. I'm looking forward to future developments.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になってしまった

I'm worried about the continuation

こういうドM系は苦手なのでずっと避けてきたけど、レビュー見て読み始めたら続きが気になって購入してしまいました〜

I'm not good at this kind of M series, so I've been avoiding it for a long time, but when I saw the reviews and started reading them, I was worried about the continuation and ended up buying it~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤクザものめちゃくちゃ良い！

Yakuza are insanely good too!

映画を先に観たので続きが気になって全巻購入しました！BL作品とまとめていいのか難しいのですが、人間味あふれる登場人物たちが大好きになりました。色気がすごい！続きが早く読みたいです…

I watched the movie first, so I was worried about the continuation, so I bought the whole volume! It's difficult to put it together with a BL film, but I fell in love with the characters full of humanity. The sex appeal is amazing! I want to read more soon...

Helpful

Reviews for Twittering Birds Never Fly Manga