Twittering Birds Never Fly Manga Reviews (P.53)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤクザ物苦手だけど読んで損はしない

I'm not good at yakuza stuff, but there's no harm in reading

This review contains spoilers. エロを外せば、青年誌で連載していて何の違和感もない程、お話、展開力、画力、人物描写、全てが完璧な作品。BL界の歴史も概念も変えた作品な気がする。ヤクザ物は好きではないのですが、それでも読んでしまう引力がある。素晴らしい作品なだけに、綺麗に終わることを信じています。

This review contains spoilers. If you leave out eroticism, it is a work that is serialized in a youth magazine and has no sense of incongruity, and everything about the story, development power, drawing power, and character depiction is perfect. I feel like it's a work that changed the history and concepts of the BL world. I don't like yakuza stuff, but it still has an attraction that makes me read it. Just because it's a great work, I believe it will end beautifully.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤクザモノ苦手でした。

I didn't like yakuzamono.

が、そんな意識を変えさせてくれたのがこの作品でした。一気に5巻まで読みました。最終が気になりますが、幸せになってほしいです。

But it was this work that made me change my mind. I read up to 5 volumes at once. I'm worried about the end, but I want them to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

息つく間もない展開に引き込まれます

I'm drawn into a development where I can't take my breath

時折絵柄の構図にものすごくコーフンさせられます。この作品はスピード感があるのにだからといってストーリーの展開が雑なわけでなく、むしろ登場する数々の人物の過去や背景まで丁寧に描かれていて、呼吸するのを忘れてしまうくらい夢中になって何度も読みました。百目鬼さんをはじめ敵味方関係なく登場する人物のほとんどが矢代さんに魅了されていくのも当然のように納得させられる、ヨネダコウ先生の作品力は本当にすばらしい、最高です。

Occasionally, I am extremely impressed by the composition of the design. Even though this work has a sense of speed, that doesn't mean the story development is sloppy; rather, it carefully depicts the past and backgrounds of the various characters that appear, and I was so engrossed that I forgot to breathe, and I read it over and over again. It's no surprise that most of the characters who appear regardless of whether they are enemies or allies, including Momome Oni, are fascinated by Yashiro, and Yoneda Kou-sensei's artistic ability is really amazing and amazing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買いです。

I'm buying the author.

5巻まで一気読み。めちゃくちゃ良いです。ヨネダ先生の心理描写は何故こうも巧みなのだろう。矢代が切なくて堪らない。愛されずに育った歪んだ大人が誰かに心を開くのはこんなにも困難…だよね。…どうか百目鬼の想いがちゃんと矢代に伝わりますように、2人が幸せになれますように、と祈るしかできない（泣）

Read up to 5 volumes at once. It's insanely good. Why is Yoneda sensei's psychological depiction so clever. Yashiro is so sad that I can't stand it. It's so difficult for a distorted adult who grew up not to be loved to open up to someone... ... I can only pray that Momome Oni's feelings will be properly conveyed to Yashiro and that the two of them will be happy (crying)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

深い

deep

5巻いっきによみました‼読み応えがあって様々な人の思いが巡ってすごい引きつけられる?最初軽い感じで見てたけどだんだん内容が深くなって面白い‼今後2人がどんな風になっていくのか気になる?

I read volume 5 at once ‼ It's a good read, and it really attracts the thoughts of various people? I watched it lightly at first, but the content got deeper and more interesting ‼ Curious about what the two of them will look like in the future?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマった〜

I'm addicted to it~

初めて試し読みした時は全然ハマらなかった。でも、評価が高いのと、この先生の他の作品が好きで、なんとなく読み始めたらどっぷりハマってしまった〜高評価に間違いは無い！早く続きが読みたい！

When I first tried reading it, I wasn't at all addicted to it. However, the reviews were high, and I liked this teacher's other works, and when I somehow started reading them, I was completely addicted to it ~ there is no doubt that it was highly rated! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

1番好き

I like it the most

全ての漫画の中で1番好き。終わってほしくないけど進んで欲しいし話の続きも気になるけど、終わってほしくない！！(笑)ヨネダ先生の作品は全部大好きで、絵も大好きですがやっぱりストーリーが本当に良くて何度も読み返す作品ばかりです！囀る〜は出てくるキャラクター全員がとても魅力的で、メインの2人も本当に1番大好き！はやく幸せになって！

I like it the most of all comics. I don't want it to end, but I want it to move on, and I'm worried about the continuation of the story, but I don't want it to end!! (Laughter) I love all of Yoneda sensei's works, and I love the pictures, but after all, the story is really good and I read them over and over again! All of the characters that appear in ~ are so charming, and I really love the two main characters the most! Be happy quickly!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

想像以上の！！

More than I could have imagined!!

ヨネダ先生の作品は大好きなのですが、痛かったり怖かったりが苦手で放置してましたが、クーポンにつられて購入。結果ハマりました！！ずっとこの世界観から離れられません。もっと早くに読めばよかったです。

I love Yoneda sensei's work, but I didn't like it because it was painful or scary, so I left it alone, but I was stuck with a coupon and bought it. I'm addicted to the results!! I can't get away from this view of the world for a long time. I wish I had read it sooner.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

長編映画を観てるような

It's like watching a feature film

先にヨネダ先生の「どうしても…」「それでも…」を読みました。こちらはヤクザ物という毛色の違う作品なので読むのはどうしようと思っていたのですが試しに1巻読んでみたら見事にハマりました。続けてあれよあれよと5巻まで購入。ヨネダ先生らしい心理描写と魅せるコマ割りがストーリーをより深いものにしています。百目鬼の過去もそうですが、矢代の過去もまた壮絶で…過去が作り出してしまったであろう今の「矢代」を救えるのはきっと百目鬼だけ。まだまだ続くようなのでこれからどんな試練があるのか気が気じゃないですがどうか2人が幸せになれますように。とにかくBLという括りでは勿体無いたくさんの方に読んでもらいたい作品です。

I read Yoneda sensei's “No Matter What...” and “Still...” This is a work with a different coat called Yakuza Mono, so I was wondering how to read it, but when I tried reading volume 1, I was really addicted to it. Keep going and buy up to 5 volumes. The psychological depiction and fascinating frame division typical of Yoneda sensei make the story even deeper. As is the case with Momome's past, Yashiro's past is also fierce... I'm sure only Momome Oni can save the present “Yashiro,” which the past would have created. It seems like it's still going on, so I'm not worried about what kind of trials are ahead, but I hope the two of them can be happy. Anyway, it's a work I want many people to read without thinking about it in the BL category.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

映画みたい

It's like a movie

５巻まで買いました。最近はこの作品ばかり何度も読み返していますが読み終わった後、好きな映画を見たあとのような満足感があります。５巻の作者さんのあとがきに「これで一括りだけどまだまだ続く」とありました。まだまだ続きを読みたいです。この先が気になってihr HertZで続きを読みたくなる。エロメインでストーリーがテンプレみたいなBLは買って損したって思うけどこういうストーリーに入り込める作品を探し当てられて嬉しいです。展開が読めなくて本当に面白いです。ヨネダ先生の他の作品も小説以外は全て揃えてしまいました。

I bought up to 5 volumes. Recently, I've only been rereading this work over and over again, but after I've finished reading it, I feel as satisfied as after watching my favorite movie. In the afterword of the author of volume 5, there was “This is all in one go, but it's still going on.” I still want to read more. I'm worried about the future and want to read more on ihr HerTZ. I think I lost by buying a BL with an erotic main story that looks like a template, but I'm happy to be able to find a work that fits into this kind of story. I can't read the development and it's really interesting. I now have all of Yoneda sensei's other works other than novels.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

星5じゃ足りない！

5 stars isn't enough!

間違いなく伝説になるBL作品の一つ。ヤクザモノでハードな場面も多いですが、とにかく清濁合わせた主人公の矢代（受け）がたまらなく魅力的。重厚で男臭い物語に、矢代の魅力が華とエロスと抜け感と切なさを加え、作品をより深いものにしています。ヨネダコウ先生は漫画的表現がとても上手いですね。

Definitely one of the legendary BL works. There are also a lot of hard scenes with Yakuza Mono, but the main character, Yashiro (take), who cleans things up anyway, is irresistibly attractive. To the profound and masculine story, Yashiro's charm adds glamor, eros, a sense of emptiness, and sadness, making the work even deeper. Yoneda Kou sensei is very good at comic expressions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

星５つじゃ足りない

5 stars is not enough

作者買いです。やくざものはな～…と、食わず嫌いしていたんですがもっと早く読んでおけば良かった。ヨネダさんの描かれる作品は全て、BL漫画って括りに収まりきらないです。こちらの作品は、心を抉られるような真綿で絞められるようなそれでいて柔く撫でられるようなアンバランスさが癖になります。

I'm buying the author. I didn't like yakuza mono... without eating it, but I wish I had read it sooner. All of Yoneda's works don't fit into a BL comic. I have a habit of this work because of its unbalance, like being strangled with cotton and yet gently stroked.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

好きすぎた

I liked it too much

ヨネダコウ先生大好きです?何度読んでも飽きません。5巻でてますけど、付箋回収も進んでて関係も進んでてこれからどーなるのか！すごい楽しみです。ここまできたらバットエンドでは終わらないでほしい！でも幸せになんてなれるのかな。読者は楽しいです(笑)

Do you love Yoneda Kou-sensei? No matter how many times I read it, I never get tired of it. There are 5 volumes out, but sticky note collection is progressing and relationships are progressing, so what will happen from now on! I'm really looking forward to it. If you get this far, I don't want you to end up with a butt end! But I wonder how I can be happy. Readers are fun (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

頑張りすぎてない絵の雰囲気がいい！

The atmosphere of the picture without trying too hard is nice!

抜け感のある作画が、ヤクザ物テーマを和らげている感じがします。淡々としたストーリーかと思いきや伏線が…。エロもありますが、ドキドキするストーリーと主人公2人から目が離せません。まだまだ続いて欲しい作品！

I feel that the drawing, which has a sense of emptiness, softens the yakuza theme. I thought it was a bland story, but the foreshadowing... It's also erotic, but keep an eye out for the exciting story and the two main characters. I want this work to continue!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です。

It's the best.

はやく最終巻が見たい。でも、終わってもほしくない。何回もリピしてます。作者買いしてますが、いつもとても深いですよね。ＢＬだけど、ＢＬ好きじゃない人にも読んでほしい。迷ってる方は、必見です。

I want to see the final volume soon. But I don't want it to end. I've been replaying it many times. I buy the artist, and it's always very deep, isn't it? It's BL, but I want people who don't like BL to read it. If you're unsure, this is a must-see.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

どう見積もっても最高にしかならない

No matter how you estimate it, it's only going to be the best

This review contains spoilers. もう、この漫画最高です。BLだけど、めちゃくちゃきます！！(語彙力なくてすみません)どのキャラクターにも愛着湧きます。あ、でも私平田は好きになれません…。ヤクザ物だけど、死ぬのとかザラなんだろうけど、でも皆に死んでほしくない…。あーめっちゃ続きが早く読みたい！！てか完結してから読めばよかった。八代さんカッコいいなぁ～。皆から愛されてんなぁ～。百目鬼との○ックスも物凄いページ数使って、間合いの感じとか心情がよく伝わってきてかなり良かったです！！ヤクザ物苦手だけど、これは大丈夫でした！ヨネダ先生最高です！！

This review contains spoilers. This comic is already awesome. It's BL, but it's messed up!! (Sorry I don't have vocabulary) I love every character. Ah, but I don't like Hirata... It's a yakuza thing, but I wonder if they die or something, but I don't want everyone to die... Ahhh, I really want to read the continuation soon!! Heck, I should have read it after I finished it. Yashiro is so cool. they are loved by everyone. Momome Oni and ○X also used a tremendous number of pages, and the feeling of spacing and feelings were conveyed very well, which was pretty good!! I'm not good at yakuza stuff, but this was fine! Yoneda sensei is awesome!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

さじ加減が絶妙

The degree of moderation is exquisite

This review contains spoilers. 何と言いましょうか、BL要素がありますが、描いているのはただのBLではないというか……。人間模様をじっくりと描いていらっしゃる感じですね。ただ、それがどぎつくならないのがすごいなぁ～と思います。BL作品として求められる要素がどうかということを論じるよりも、違った次元で語るべき作品と思わせる印象です。ポップなBL作品を楽しみたい心境の時には他の物の方が良いかもしれませんが、「今日はじっくりと人間ドラマ的作品を読みたいな」という時には、読む価値があると思います。この作品はヤクザの抗争など、描かれている要素が恋愛だけではないので、恋愛の進みはゆっくりです。追記：5巻まで読みました。もう、表現力がすごいです！セリフ無しでの表現。ストーリーの組み立てだけでなく、それを絵で表現する技術の高さと言いましょうか、エロスの表現とか、感情の表現とか。娯楽性高い漫画というよりも、「表現の限界」に挑戦しているのだろうかと思うくらいの芸術性だと思ってしまいました。魅せる漫画だと思います。

This review contains spoilers. What should I say, there are BL elements, but what I'm drawing isn't just BL... It feels like you're drawing human patterns carefully. However, I think it's amazing that it doesn't stick. Rather than discussing the elements required for a BL work, I have the impression that it is a work that should be talked about on a different level. Something else might be better when you're in the mood to enjoy pop BL works, but I think it's worth reading when “I want to read human dramas carefully today.” Love is not the only element depicted in this work, such as the Yakuza conflict, so the romance progresses slowly. Update: I've read up to 5 volumes. The expressive power is already amazing! Expression without dialogue. Not only is it about framing a story, but let's call it a high level of skill to express it with pictures, like the expression of eros, or the expression of emotion. Rather than being a highly entertaining comic, I thought it was so artistic that I thought it was challenging the “limits of expression.” I think it's a fascinating comic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい作品です

It's a great work

This review contains spoilers. 5巻読みました。ついにやっと矢代と百目鬼の関係に進展が…ですが、なんてせつない…胸が苦しくなりました。まだまだ続くそうですが、最後は絶対に２人が幸せになるところが見たいです。あと、矢代に対して屈折した想いを抱える竜崎が男気溢れてかっこよかった。平田はね、男の嫉妬って恐ろしいですね。次巻が待ち遠しいです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read 5 volumes. At last, the relationship between Yashiro and Momome Oni progressed... but it was so annoying... it made my heart ache. It seems like it's still going on, but I definitely want to see the two of them happy at the end. Also, Ryūzaki, who has refracted feelings for Yashiro, was full of masculinity and was cool. Hirata, men's jealousy is horrible, isn't it? I can't wait for the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

読んで後悔。

I read it and regret it.

設定にいまいちピンとこなかったけど、読んで後悔。もっと早く読めばよかった･･･！こんなに読み応えがあるのに、笑えて泣けて面白い。ＢＬ枠で留まっているのがもったいない！続きが早く読みたい。

I didn't really get the hang of the settings, but I regret reading it. I wish I had read it sooner...! Even though it's such a great read, it's funny to laugh and cry. Staying in the BL slot is a waste! I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

なんとなく重そうな雰囲気で読むのを躊躇っていましたが、ついに読ませていただきました。高評価にあるように、ストーリー設定がしっかりしていて、読み応えのある作品でした。2人には幸せな結末をぜひ用意していただきたい！そして、面白さは素晴らしいのですが、重い、そしてヒリヒリとした切なさが常にある雰囲気。もー少し甘くて軽い場面も欲しいなぁと。。

I was hesitant to read it in a somewhat heavy atmosphere, but I finally read it. As you can see from the high ratings, the story setting was solid, and it was a work that was worth reading. I want the two of them to prepare a happy ending! Also, while the fun is amazing, the atmosphere is heavy and always tingling and sad. I also want a slightly sweet and light scene...

Helpful

Reviews for Twittering Birds Never Fly Manga