HIS FRAGRANCE AND MY SCENT Manga Reviews (P.6)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

書き直し 2023.8

Rewrite 2023.8

This review contains spoilers. はじめは匂いフェチのぶっ飛んでる話だったのがだんだんと変わってきて今の話めちゃ好きです！好きだとか嫌いだとか結婚とか不倫とか離婚とかもあったのにそんな普通(？w)な話題を超えて誰しもが持つ心の弱さとか格差とか社会的な問題とかも絡めてきて中身が濃い〜重い内容もあってもサラッと読めるしはじめの評価どこいった！(星3)てくらい好きになりました！おススメ。

This review contains spoilers. At first, it was a wild story about smell fetishes, but it gradually changed, and I really love this story! I liked it, didn't like it, got married, had an affair, or divorce, but that's normal (? Beyond the (w) topic, it also involved everyone's weakness of mind, disparities, and social issues, etc., and I was able to read it smoothly even with dark to heavy content, and where was the initial evaluation! I loved it so much (3 stars)! I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

始まりからは想像もできない

I can't even imagine it from the beginning

絵が苦手で(目が怖かった)なかなか読み出せなかったんですが何回も目にするので、とりあえず１話だけのつもりで読んでみました。面白くて、止まらなくなってしまいました。読み始めからは想像もつかなかった展開で先が気になり、どんどん読み進めてしまいました。こんな深いお話になるとは思いもしませんでした。相変わらず、ちょっと絵は苦手ですが、この作家さんの他の作品も読んでみたいと思いました。

I wasn't good at drawing (I was afraid of my eyes) and couldn't read it easily, but I watched it over and over again, so I read it with the intention of just one episode. It was so funny that I couldn't stop. From the beginning of reading, I was worried about the future due to developments that I had never imagined, and I continued reading more and more. I had no idea it would be such a deep story. As always, I'm a little bad at painting, but I wanted to read other works by this artist.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

結局は終わらない物語

A story that never ends

This review contains spoilers. バリバリ仕事できる女性と真逆な女性がたまたま外見が似てただけで、人生までも真逆のように運ばれて、読んでいくうちに憂鬱な気分になりました。なにしろ報われない、残酷な人生模様は妙にリアルさもあって、いつものファンタジーな気分で読む漫画とは違いました。元夫も寝取ったその愛人も別離後関わらなければ、そこまでの事なのに見過ごせない主人公の心情には少々理解不能で、私もどちらかと言えば、白川さんの思考に共感です。ラストは随分含みを持たせた終わり方だったなぁという感じです。これも「その後」は各読者で描いてください的なものですかね。その辺りも妙にリアルでした。

This review contains spoilers. A woman who is the exact opposite of a woman who can work well just happened to have a similar appearance, and my life was carried away as if it were the exact opposite, and I felt depressed as I read it. After all, the cruel pattern of life without being rewarded was strangely realistic, and it was different from the comics I usually read in a fantasy mood. It's a bit incomprehensible to me about the feelings of the protagonist, who cannot be overlooked even though it was up to that point, and if anything, I sympathize with Shirakawa-san's thoughts. I feel like the last one was a way of ending that had quite a bit of meaning. This is also something that each reader should draw “after”, isn't it? That area was strangely real too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

中毒性のあるストーリー

Addictive storyline

何気なく読み始めて、どのキャラも個性的すぎる中、白川くんエンドのラストを望みつつ...。読み進めてしまっている中毒性のあるストーリーだなぁと思います。ラストをどういう風に持っていくのか、気になりつつ読み続けるか迷っています。

I started reading it casually, and while every character was too unique, I was hoping for the end of Shirakawa-kun... I think it's an addictive story that I've been reading. I'm wondering how to bring the last one and keep reading while wondering.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

う〜ん…

hmm...

This review contains spoilers. 白川くんが可哀想で読むのが嫌になってきた。先輩にされてきた事は忘れたの？みどりの事を尊重して大切にしてくれる白川くんをもっと大切ににしなよ。

This review contains spoilers. I don't like reading it because I feel sorry for Shirakawa-kun. Have you forgotten what your senior did to you? Take more care of Shirakawa-kun, who respects and cherishes Midori.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

まさかそんな…

no way like that...

色々あっても前向きで四人とも成長していい方向に向かってたのに、まさかココでそんな不幸なことが起きるなんて。今ここで幸せを断ち切るような不幸は正直よみたくはなかった。現実ではもっとひどくて大変な事が起こってるのだけど…好みは色々あるけれど、前向きで笑えて元気をもらえるストーリーを望みます。

Despite everything, they were positive, and all four of them were moving in a direction where they could grow, but I can't believe such an unfortunate thing happened here. To be honest, I didn't want to miss the misfortune that would cut off my happiness here and now. There are even worse and more difficult things happening in real life... I have a lot of preferences, but I want a story that is positive, funny, and energizing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

星1であり星5である漫画

A comic with 1 star and 5 stars

元気な時にしか読めない漫画なんですけど～((( ；ﾟДﾟ)))こんな体力使う漫画珍しい(笑)最悪なエピソードが多いけど面白い。この作者の漫画はしんどい話多いよね。

It's a comic you can only read when you're well ~ (((;°))) comics that use this kind of physical strength are rare (lol) There are a lot of worst episodes, but it's interesting. There are a lot of tough stories in comics by this author.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最新刊の顔ヤバ

Face dangerous in the latest issue

この作品は最新みるためにわざわざ分別版買ってるます。（後から読みにくい）最新刊表紙、先輩の顔がかなりヤバ…と思い、中身もきわどいとこついてくるね。広田ワールド。絵はクセあるので万人受けしないが、ストーリーが独特で面白い。先が読めんよね。主人公も変わってるし周りも変わりもんだから…だからハマると沼ります?

I went out of my way to buy separate editions of this work in order to see the latest one. (It's hard to read later) I think the cover of the latest issue, and the senpai's face is pretty dangerous... and the contents come along really fast. Hirota World. The pictures are peculiar, so not everyone likes them, but the story is unique and interesting. You can't read ahead, can you? the main character has changed and so has the surroundings... so if you get addicted to it, you'll get swampy?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い?

interesting?

This review contains spoilers. この話も、連載、長くなってきましたね?みどりと白川くんが両思いになれて、めでたし、めでたしと思ってたけど、それからも、何か色々と問題がありますね?ちょっと気になる事があるんですけど、みどりの前に、白川くん、彼女的な人がいましたね⁉白川くんは、そうでもないけど、彼女が白川くんの事好きだったと思うんです。あの関係は、どうなったんだろうか?気になります。今はみどりとラブラブで良いのですが?どうなんでしょう⁉

This review contains spoilers. this story has also been serialized for a long time, hasn't it? Midori and Shirakawa-kun got along, and I thought it was a blessing, but even after that, there are various issues, right? I'm a little worried, but before Midori, Shirakawa-kun had someone like her ⁉ Shirakawa-kun, that's not the case, but I think she liked Shirakawa-kun. What happened to that relationship? I'm curious. Is it OK to just love love with Midori now? What do you think ⁉

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

全員やばい

Everyone is crazy

登場人物全員ちょっとずれてる。でも面白い。まあでもなんだかんだ誰でもこんな気持ちは持っているのかも。

All of the characters are a little off. But it's interesting. Well, for some reason, everyone probably has this kind of feeling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

もうそろそろ

It's almost there

This review contains spoilers. ここに来てそれはいらんかったかなー。読む方もある程度予想したかもしれないけど、嫌だった。どう終着するんだろう。白川がかわいそうでならない。香がいた意味って何なんだろう。

This review contains spoilers. I wonder if I didn't need that since I came here. People who read it may have anticipated it to some extent, but I didn't like it. How will it end? I don't feel sorry for Shirakawa. What does incense mean.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

やっと！

at last!

This review contains spoilers. やっと白川と結ばれたところをとりあえず買いました(*^^*)笑可愛らしい女の子の話ではありません。みどりは自分に正直に生きる飾らない女の子で、真っ直ぐな揺れる気持ちが女子としてすごく共感できます。そして白川、めっちゃいーやつ！！！

This review contains spoilers. I finally bought a place where I was connected to Shirakawa (*^^*) lol I'm not talking about a cute girl. Midori is an unadorned girl who lives honestly with herself, and I can really sympathize with her straight, swaying feelings as a girl. And Shirakawa is such a great guy!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

香の話長いよ

The incense story is long

This review contains spoilers. 最新の39話を読んでの。ここのところ香の人物深掘りになり背景の描写も納得、派遣で（派遣で働くこと自体は悪くはないが）育ちも恵まれたわけでもなく、積み重なった諦めが黒木との出会いによって光を見出され、続けたセカンドとしての関係。確かに共感の余地はありました。が、最新話で暴漢に襲われみどりへ助けを求めるところで終わり、そこまでして香に同情エピソードをもってくるか。これではもう香を非難するどころの話ではなくなってきます。みどりの転職、白川との遠距離話も出てきている矢先、また問題山積。みどりと香が東京で一緒に暮らすエンド、的な展開が待っているのでは、と一抹の不安が。

This review contains spoilers. Read the latest 39 episodes. Up to this point, Incense's characters have dug deep, and the depiction of the background is convincing, and they haven't been raised or blessed by being dispatched (although working as a temporary worker itself), and their accumulated abandonment has found light through her encounter with Kuroki, and the relationship continues as a second one. There was certainly room for empathy. But it ends with being attacked by thugs and asking Midori for help in the latest episode, and will it go that far and bring an episode of sympathy for Incense? Now I'm not talking about criticizing Incense anymore. Just when Midori's job change and long-distance talk with Shirakawa came up, problems piled up again. There is a lot of anxiety that the end where Midori and Kaori live together in Tokyo is about to unfold.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

最初面白かった

It was interesting at first

This review contains spoilers. 作者様の医療漫画が好きでこちらも読み始めたら面白くてずっと読んでた。けど不倫してた先輩に幻滅してから話もいまいちになりもういいかなと。面白かったのに残念。

This review contains spoilers. I like the author's medical comics, and when I started reading this one, it was interesting and I've been reading it for a long time. However, after I became disillusioned with my senior who had an affair, I thought it would be okay if the conversation went wrong. It was funny, but it's a shame.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

やめたいのにやめれん…

I want to stop but I can't...

This review contains spoilers. 最初のほうは完璧！みどりが変態感出ててよい。でも段々と黒木先輩とみどりの性格が当初よりブレてきててどちらもどんな性格だったのかようわからん。白川だけがまともにキャラ設定どおり走ってるかな。もう黒木先輩と浮気相手のあのメンヘラ感がしんどいしやめたいがみどりと白川が気になってやめれん。あー誰か止めてください！

This review contains spoilers. The first one is perfect! It's good that Midori has a perverted feeling. But gradually, the personalities of Kuroki senpai and Midori have blurred since the beginning, and I don't know what kind of personalities they both had. I wonder if only Shirakawa is running properly according to the character settings. That menhera feeling of cheating on Kuroki senpai and her partner is tough and I want to stop, but I'm worried about Midori and Shirakawa, so I can't stop. Ahhh, someone please stop it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

感情

sentiments

読んでみようかな…と思い読んでみたら色んな感情がわいてくる絵はまあまあ良い感じ？とにかく面白いこの子強いなあ続きが気になります

I think I'll read it... and when I read it, the picture that evokes a lot of emotions feels pretty good? Anyway, it's funny, this kid is strong, I'm worried about the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

エッチ

sex

エロいけど、面白い、匂いで興奮って、わかる所もあり、引き込まれる感じです、次が楽しみです

It's erotic, but it's interesting, and there are places where I can understand it, I feel drawn in, I'm looking forward to the next one

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

先輩ただのクズ男にされちゃった。

Senpai was made to be just a scum guy.

This review contains spoilers. 最初は面白かったんだ、ヒロインが先輩と両思いになっていく展開は。ただ途中なぜ先輩を、ダメ男にしてしまったのかな？ずっと先輩てヒロインの事好きで、最後まで好きで。ヒロインが勝手に振り回しただけだよね。ヒロインを好きにならなかったら、覚醒しなかったよね。そのまま真面目でよかったんだよね。転職して別れたあとも好きだったよね、二人とも。それが、結婚する前から浮気してたの衝撃だったわ。ヒロイン似てるからて、中身見ろ‼️5年もやってたんだ。最低、クズ。‼️それも、相手ろくな女じゃないよね。人間的にダメだろ、この女性。こんな関係おかしくて呆れる。先輩病気？あんなにイケメンだったのに。こんなクズ男になって。でも優しいのに。ヒロインがダメにしたよね。なんだかんだ嫌になって。結局、先輩の存在てなんだったの？最初からいらなくない？ヒロインと男の人がじれったいだけに、付き合わされただけ。このヒロインもなんかおかしいから。面白いけど、ヒロインの魅力がわからないストーリーだった。唯一相手の男の人が一番まともだっただけ。イライラ、モヤモヤで終わる作品だなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. It was interesting at first; the development where the heroine falls in love with her senior. However, why did they turn Senpai into a bad guy along the way? Senpai always loved the heroine, and I loved her until the end. The heroine just swayed around without permission, didn't she? If you didn't fall in love with the heroine, you wouldn't have woken up. I'm glad they were serious as they were. They both liked each other even after they changed jobs and broke up. It shocked me that they had an affair even before they got married. They look like the heroine, so look at what's inside ‼️ I've been doing it for 5 years. At worst, crap. ‼️ That's not a bad girl either, is she? this woman is no good in human terms, isn't she? I'm amazed at how strange this relationship is. senpai sick? even though he was such a handsome guy. Become such a scum guy. But it's kind. The heroine ruined it, didn't she? Somehow I didn't like it. After all, what was the existence of Senpai? Don't you need it from the beginning? The heroine and the man just fell in love with each other, so they just fell out with each other. That's because this heroine is also kind of strange. It was an interesting story, but I didn't understand the heroine's appeal. The only man I was dealing with was just the most decent. It's a work that ends in frustration and confusion.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

個性的

distinctively

キャラが個性的なので、ストーリーにぐいぐい引き込まれます。次巻が待ち遠しいです。

The characters are unique, so I'm really drawn into the story. I can't wait for the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと読んでます

I've been reading this whole time

This review contains spoilers. 主人公はなかなかの性格でその彼女に振り回される夫となった先輩と同期の彼。本人は自分が酷い事をしている自覚はあるので見ていてちょっと清々しいです。好き嫌い分かれそうな作品です。

This review contains spoilers. The main character has quite a personality and he is in the same age as his senior, who became her husband. The person himself is aware that he is doing something terrible, so it's a bit refreshing to watch. It's a work that seems to divide likes and dislikes.

Helpful

Reviews for HIS FRAGRANCE AND MY SCENT Manga