Which Hana? Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

どうなるかと思った…

I was wondering what would happen...

物語本筋の入れ替わりの謎解きもあり、胸キュンもあり、人生のしんどさなどのリアルもあってすごくいいお話でした。最後の巻なんて本当にどうなっちゃうんだろう！？というドキドキで胸が痛かったです。久々に良い作品に出会えてよかったです。

It was a really nice story because there was also mystery solving that replaced the main story, and there was also a sense of reality such as the hardships of life. What's really going to happen with the last volume!? My heart hurt because of that excitement. I'm glad I came across a good work after a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

涙＆胸キュン

Tears & Heartbreak

一気読みしてしまった…。魂が入れ替わるとか…、こういう系で胸がキュンと締め付けられるなんて思わなかった。花さんとチカくんが幸せになれたらいいなぁ。

I read it all at once... Souls are being replaced... I never thought my heart would be tightened so tightly in this kind of system. It would be nice if Hana and Chika-kun were happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続編希望！！！

I hope for a sequel!!!

キレイにまとまった！まとまったけれども、続編を希望します。花さんが目覚めてからチカと結婚するまでをみたい。花さん目線からの話もチカ目線からの話も両方欲しい。ハルさんと花ちゃんの番外編も見たい。完結してしばらく経ったけど、やっぱり見たい。難しいですかね？めっちゃ読みたいんだけどなぁ…是非ともお願いいたします。

It came together nicely! It's settled, but I hope for a sequel. It looks like Hana wakes up until she gets married to Chika. I want both a story from Hana's point of view and a story from Chika's point of view. I also want to watch the extra edition of Haru and Hana. It's been a while since I finished, but I still want to watch it. Isn't it difficult? I really want to read it, but... please go ahead.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

期待を裏切らない

Does not disappoint

作家さん買いです！ファンタジーの中にキュンと感動と盛り沢山！読み終わったあと、しばらく放心状態でした〜また最初から読み返したます！

The artist is buying it! There is so much excitement and excitement in the fantasy! After I finished reading it, I felt at ease for a while ~ I reread it from the beginning again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった❗

That was great ❗

This review contains spoilers. 一番最初の所は、ヒロインが暗い性格で全く魅力を感じなかったけど、読み進めていくたびにどんどん引き込まれて、最後まで飽きることなく楽しく読めました。ハルさんは、素敵だったけど、私的には、高校生のチカ君の真っ直ぐに気持ちを伝えてくれる所が素敵だと思いました。購入して良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. At the very beginning, the heroine had a dark personality and wasn't appealing at all, but as I read on, I was drawn in more and more, and I enjoyed reading it until the end without getting bored. Haru-san was wonderful, but personally, I thought it was wonderful that Chika, a high school student, directly conveys her feelings. I'm glad I bought it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったー

That was great

This review contains spoilers. 俺が今までには見たことない感じで読むのが面白くて最後まで一気に読んでしまいました。最後は皆元に戻ってくれてよかったですお気に入りの本になりました

This review contains spoilers. It was interesting to read like I had never seen it before, and I read it all at once until the end. I'm glad everyone came back to normal at the end, it became my favorite book

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

読んで良かった

I'm glad I read

This review contains spoilers. すっごく良かった。ハッピーエンドになって良かった。一時期はどうなるのか全く検討がつかなくて、私も登場人物と一緒に模索して、とても面白かったです。みんな過去に辛い思いをして、それぞれの事情があって…とにかく面白かったです。

This review contains spoilers. It was sooo good. I'm glad it had a happy ending. I couldn't consider what would happen at one point, and I also searched for it together with the characters, which was very interesting. Everyone had a hard time in the past, and they had their own circumstances... it was just interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい！

It's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. ずっと気になっていた一冊。最終巻まで出たので大人買い(笑)。花ちゃんとはあまり仲が良くない晴親は入れ替わりを理解しているうえに花さんが好き。陽希は花ちゃんに振られるが諦めてはいない。そして花さんは陽希が気になる…。なんともややこしい関係だが、花ちゃんの魂はどこにいったのか？そして、花さんの身体は無事なのか？どきどきハラハラの展開が続くが、全く飽きがこないのはさすがとしか言いようがない！ラストまで気が抜けないが、あっという間に読めてしまう。オススメです。

This review contains spoilers. A book I've always been interested in. The last volume came out, so I bought it as an adult (laughs). Haruchika, who isn't on very good terms with Hana, understands the replacement and likes Hana. Yuki is swayed by Hana, but she hasn't given up. And Hana is worried about Yuki... It's such a complicated relationship, but where did Hana's soul go? And is Hana's body safe? The thrilling and harrowing development continues, but I can only say that I never get tired of it! I can't lose my mind until the end, but I can read it in no time. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

引き込まれた！

I'm drawn in!

入れ替わりのストーリーはよくあるけど、そんな単純な入れ替わりじゃなくて、すごく引き込まれました。ファタジーなのか？ミステリーなのか？途中、暗く重い内容もあるが笑いもあり、最後ちゃんと回収してくれるのはさすがです！←何様wあぁ、それにしても小田原先生の描く男子たちは毎回イケメンすぎやしませんか？笑ハルさんも素敵だけど、チカくんの言動と笑顔にやられっぱなしでした(*´艸｀*)

There are a lot of replacement stories, but it wasn't such a simple replacement, and I was really drawn in. is it fat? is it a mystery? Along the way, there was dark and heavy content, but there was also laughter, and it's amazing that they properly collected it at the end! ←Whoa lol, aren't the boys Odawara-sensei draws too handsome every time? lol Haru-san is wonderful too, but I was still carried away by Chika-kun's words, actions, and smiles (*'｀*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ラストが

The last

気になり過ぎて、最終巻だけ購入。上手く収まるところにおさまりましたね。どうなるかなって思ってました。こちらの作者さんの絵が綺麗で好きです。

I was so worried that I only bought the last volume. It fits nicely, doesn't it? I was wondering what would happen. I like this artist's beautiful pictures.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマる！

I'm addicted to it!

この作者さんの作品と絵が好きで、5までは一気に読んで、6.7は購入しました！入れ替わりもので、でも色んなキャラクターが魅力的で、楽しく読めましたし、ちょっとメッセージ性もあり、購入して正解でした！違う作品のキャラもこっそり出てきたのも良かったです！

I love this artist's work and pictures, read all at once until 5, and bought 6.7! It was a replacement, but the various characters were attractive, I enjoyed reading it, and it also had a bit of a message, so I was right when I bought it! It was nice that characters from different works also came out secretly!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ベタかも知れないが面白い！

It might be solid, but it's interesting!

ありがちな設定と言えばそうかも知れませんが、キャラクターが魅力的なので新鮮な気持ちで読めました。きゅんとして、うるっとして、未来に希望を持てる、素敵なお話。おすすめです！

Speaking of common settings, that may be the case, but since the characters are attractive, I was able to read it with a fresh feeling. It's a wonderful story where you can be quiet, quiet, and have hope for the future. I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

どうなっちゃうの？

What's going to happen?

この作者さんのお話、すごく好きです。この作品も一気に5巻まで読んでしまいました。今後どんな風に展開していくのか、ほんと気になりますが、ハッピーエンドならいいな…

I really love this author's story. I also read up to 5 volumes of this work at once. I'm really curious about how it will unfold in the future, but it would be nice if it had a happy ending...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

最高！

the best!

作者さん本当凄い！面白い！引き込まれる！！めちゃくちゃ面白くキュンキュンするし泣けるしで感情がとても忙しかった(笑)番外編としてすこし続きが見たい！

The author is really amazing! interesting! I'm drawn in!! It was insanely funny, it made me cringe, and I was so busy with my emotions (lol) I want to watch a little more as an extra edition!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょっと生きにくさを感じてる花と花が・・

Flowers and flowers that feel a little difficult to live...

This review contains spoilers. 仕事運、男運のなさで、日常に疲れていた来生花が、ある日、階段を踏み外し、目覚めたら、姿が高校生の山田花になっていた。自分が来生花でありながら、体が山田花になってしまった来生花が、生田荘で、心優しい陽希や風変わりな高校生晴親達と暮らす事に。事情を知った陽希と晴親と、何故入れ替わってしまったのか、早く山田花に体を元に戻してあげたいと思っていたら、先に山田花が元の体に戻り、今度は、来生花がどうなったのかを晴親は、必死に探す。来生花の元カレに会い、無理やり来生花の連絡先を聞き、会いに行ってみれば、事故後、昏睡状態のままの花を目の当たりにし、それでも、晴親だけには、幽体離脱状態の花が見え、話もできる。そうこうしているうちに、何の関わりもない2人のようだが、以前、傘を持たずに、死を考え、踏み切りで立っていた山田花に来生花が傘を貸した事で、山田花に死を思い止ませた過去があったことがわかる。最後までヤキモキし、焦ったいお話だったが、小田原みづえさんマジックで、締め括ってくれました。

This review contains spoilers. Kisuihana, who was tired from everyday life due to lack of work luck or luck with men, stepped down the stairs one day, and when she woke up, she looked like Yamada Hana, a high school student. Kisuihana, whose body has become a Yamada flower herself, ends up living with kind-hearted Yoki and eccentric high school student Haruchika at Ikuta-so. I wonder why they were replaced by Haruchika and Haruchika, who learned about the circumstances, and if Yamada Hana wanted to restore her body as soon as possible, Yamada Hana returned to her original body first, and now Haruchika desperately searches for what happened to Kisei Hana. I met Kisuihana's ex-boyfriend, and when I forcibly asked Kisuihana's contact information, and when I went to meet him, I saw Hana in a coma after the accident, and even so, only Haruchika could see the flower in an astral state, and even so, only Haruchika could see the flower in an astral state and talk. In the meantime, it seems like they are two people who are not involved in anything, but it can be seen that there was a past where Yamada Hana stopped dying because she thought about death and had previously lent an umbrella to Yamada Hana, who was standing at the railroad crossing without carrying an umbrella. The story was exciting and impatient until the end, but Mizue Odawara concluded it with magic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

人生立て直し、人生ゲーム。

Rebuilding your life, the game of life.

まず、小田原先生のファンタジー索引は一度読みだすとその世界に引き込まれて、魅了されるので、一気読みが自分の中では気に入っています。そして、この作品も一気読みしました。この作品のヒーロー二人は苦しい過去や現在を背負っていて、その合間に二人の魂が入れ替わるのだけれど、生きたいという切実な当たり前な欲望と笑ったり楽しいという気持ちを味わることや自分の気持ちに寄り添ってくれる人たちに出会って、年長者の花さんのほうが、ハナちゃんと自分のために頑張って元に戻る方法を探ります。花さんをサポートしてくれるのがイケメンな二人のいとこたち。あぁ、眼福。（と思ったのは花さんも同じ、笑）とにかくどきどきハラハラして、時には彼女たちの過去や現在を振り返って、悲しいなぁ、切ないなぁ、でも頑張ってって思っちゃいました。小さなヒントがパズルピースを埋めていくかのように、話は進んでいきます。っていうか、双六かな。時には前に進め、時には、元に戻れ、又はそこで、立ち止まって。人生ゲームって言ってもいいかもしれないですね。最後の終わり方、しっくりきてよかったです。

First, once I start reading Odawara-sensei's fantasy index, I'm drawn into that world, and I'm fascinated, so I like reading it all at once. Also, I read this work all at once. The two heroes of this work are burdened with a painful past and present, and their souls are replaced in between, but they meet people who enjoy the earnest, natural desire to live and the feeling of laughing and having fun, and are close to their own feelings, and the elder Hana works hard for Hana and herself to search for ways to return to normal. Hana's two handsome cousins support her. Ahhh, eye candy. (I thought Hana was the same, lol) Anyway, I was thrilled and harassed, and sometimes I looked back on their past and present, and I thought they were sad, sad, but they did their best. The story progresses as if small hints fill in the puzzle pieces. I mean, maybe Double Six. Sometimes move forward, sometimes go back, or stop there. Maybe it's fair to say Game of Life. I'm glad the way it ended at the end was perfect.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いストーリーだった。

It was an interesting story.

ストーリーが面白かったです。花さんがとても良い人で、変わっていく世界が良かった。ハルさん、ちかくん、どちらもかっこよくて、みーんながハッピーで良かった！

The story was interesting. Hana was a very nice person, and it was nice to see the changing world. Both Haru-san and Chika-kun were so cool, and I'm glad everyone was happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

展開が読めない

I can't read the development

展開が読めなくて面白い！！入れ替わりものだから良くある感じかと思いきやそうではないため展開が読めなくて面白いのでお勧めです(*^^*)

I can't read the development so it's interesting!! Since it's a replacement, I thought it was a good feeling, but since that's not the case, I can't read the development and it's interesting, so I recommend it (*^^*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

言葉にできなあ

I can't put it into words

もぉねぇ〜この人の作品は全部面白すぎ。本当に困っちゃう。続き気になっちゃって完結したやつじゃないと読めないかも…とっても一気見したい！！そしてねぇ〜もぉねぇ〜イケメンすぎ！！

Wow, all of this person's works are too interesting. I'm really in trouble. I'm curious about the continuation, so I might not be able to read it unless it's completed... I really want to watch it all at once!! And hey, hey hey, he's too handsome!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

入れ替わりモノ、、、でも！

Replacement stuff... but!

魂の入れ替わりモノは余り好みませんが、この作品は一味違う！状況探究、恋愛模様、全ての展開が面白く、一気に読んでしまいました！

I don't really like Soul Replacements, but this work is a bit different! The investigation of the situation, the romance pattern, all the developments were interesting, and I read them all at once!

Helpful

Reviews for Which Hana? Manga