Flower Shadow's Memory Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2011 (PST) | Translate to English

せつな～い。。。

that's annoying...

若き貴族。使用人。禁じられた関係。純愛。この単語にピンッと来た方はパックで購入されて良いかと思います！二人の切ない気持ち互いを思いやる気持ちが、丁寧に書かれていて、とっても感情移入出来ます！エロは、ほとんどありません^_^;物語重視の方には、大満足いただけると思います！！！最後の最後まで、じれったいですが、読み終えた時に胸があったかくなるような作品だと思います！

A young aristocrat. The servant. Forbidden relationships. pure love. If you get caught up with this word, I think it's okay to buy it in packs! Their sad feelings and feelings of caring for each other are carefully written, and I can really empathize with them! There is almost no eroticism ^_^; I think those who focus on stories will be very satisfied!!! I'm confused until the very end, but I think it's a work that warms my heart when I finish reading it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

身分差

Status difference

This review contains spoilers. 庭師と貴族の身分差の物語で、すれ違うさまと最後の甘々のギャップか良かった

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about the difference in status between a gardener and an aristocrat, and I'm glad it was the gap between how they passed each other and sweet at the end

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

絵はイマイチだけど。

The picture isn't good though.

ちょっと違った世界観がある作品。絵がイマイチだけど、この作品とはすごくあってる。

This work has a slightly different view of the world. The picture isn't good, but it really matches this one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

読みホにて。

Read it in Ho.

心の葛藤と思いの伝え方の描写が素敵です。物語もゆっくり展開してくので読んでて一緒の気持ちになれました。絵も好きです。

The depiction of emotional conflicts and ways of communicating thoughts is wonderful. The story unfolds slowly, so I was able to read it and feel like we were together. I like pictures too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

心が痛い

My heart hurts

幼馴染として育った2人、身分が違う故に、徐々に心が伝わらなくなってしまい、執事ロランの想いは、主のアーサーに届かず、アーサーはロランの真意が掴めず、イライラしてロランに当たってしまう。それを耐えるロランが痛々しい。お互い、相手を想うのに、すれ違い、なかなか結ばれず、このまま終わってしまうかとハラハラしましたが、最後の最後、アーサーの歩み寄りにホッとしました。惜しむらくは、2人のハッピーな姿が少ししか描かれていないことです。もっと幸せな姿がを見たかった…

Since the two people who grew up as childhood friends are in different statuses, their hearts are gradually not conveyed, the feelings of the butler Laurent do not reach the Lord Arthur, Arthur is unable to grasp Roland's true intentions, and he is frustrated and hits Laurent. It's painful for Roland to endure it. Even though we thought of each other, we passed each other, couldn't get along easily, and I was worried that it would end like this, but at the very end, I was relieved to have Arthur walk close to me. Regrettably, only a few happy figures of the two were depicted. I wanted to see a happier figure...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

童話みたいなぼんやり感

A fuzzy feeling like a fairy tale

お話はありきたりですが、優しい感じで良かった。絵がぼんやりし過ぎてて、ところどころ何があったのかよくわかんなかったけど、そこはもう印象でって感じ。ところで最後にカレルが出てこないのか寂しいわ。

The stories are common, but I'm glad they were kind. The picture was so vague that I didn't really understand what happened here and there, but I feel like that already made an impression on me. By the way, it's sad that Karel didn't come out at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 18, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

BL版HQ？

BL version HQ?

This review contains spoilers. ハーレクインでありがちな話ですが、私は好きです。作画も丁寧に書かれており、主人公の想い人の性格に難があるものの最後は身分を捨ててでも愛する人の傍で生きたいと願い主人公を探し出した事で帳消しになりました。後日談もほのぼのとして良かったですが、やはり本編の最終で駆け足だったのが残念でした。

This review contains spoilers. It's a common Harlequin story, but I love it. The drawing is also carefully written, and although there is a problem with the personality of the protagonist's lover, it was written off at the end because they searched for the protagonist in the hope that they would live next to their loved ones even if they abandoned their status. It was nice that the discussion at a later date was also heartwarming, but it was a pity that it was a rush at the end of the main story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

すこし残念

It's a bit disappointing

すごくていねいに描かれた素敵なストーリーと展開だったのに…最後バタバタと急に終わってしまったような気がしてすこし残念でした。

It was a wonderful story and development that was drawn so carefully... it was a bit disappointing because I felt like it ended so suddenly at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 19, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

主と使用人の恋

The love between the Lord and his servant

This review contains spoilers. ロレンがどこまでも真面目で一途でした。横暴なアーサーが自分の全てを投げ打ってロレンと共に生きる事を選んだのは最高のハッピーエンドでした。ちょっとキャラの書き分けがイマイチで何人か同じ顔に見えました。

This review contains spoilers. Loren was always serious and unwavering. It was the happiest ending when the tyrannical Arthur threw everything out of his own and chose to live with Lauren. The spelling of the characters wasn't good, and they all looked the same.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです。

That was great.

身分違いの恋…お互い好きなのに、すれ違う二人が切ないです。なかなか、くっつかない二人にジレますが、最後はハッピーエンドで良かったです。

Love with different statuses... Even though they like each other, it's sad for two people passing by. It's easy for the two of them to stick together, but I'm glad they had a happy ending at the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい

beautiful

はかなげで華奢な雰囲気、せつない流れだけれど一途なラブ＆ハッピーエンドだし楽しめました。

I was able to enjoy the casual and delicate atmosphere, and although it was a hectic flow, it had a steady love and happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

詩的な雰囲気

A poetic atmosphere

独特の詩的な雰囲気のある作品で、絵もきれいです。両想いでも、主人と執事の身分的な壁ってやっぱり大きいのかしら？簡単にくっつかないお話は好みの路線なのですが、執事のロランが頑なに主のアーサーを受け入れないのがじれったいです。ロランが見た目も役割もちょっと女っぽいのが残念。読み始めは独特な空気感がいいなぁと思いながら読んでたのですが、だんだんロランが女に見えてきたのが残念でした。ちょっと甘めの★4です。総196ページ。

The work has a unique poetic atmosphere, and the pictures are beautiful. I wonder if the status barrier between husband and butler is still huge, even if they have both feelings? Stories that don't stick easily are my favorite routes, but I'm upset that Roland, the butler, stubbornly doesn't accept the Lord Arthur. Too bad Roland's appearance and role are a bit feminine. At the beginning, I was reading it while thinking that the unique atmosphere would be nice, but it was a pity that Roland gradually became visible to me as a woman. It's a little sweet ★ 4. 196 pages in total.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです。

That was great.

絵は、好みはあるでしょうが綺麗で好きでした。レンタルで見ました。購入しようか迷いましたがやめました。ハッピーエンドですが、全体的に辛い切ない恋愛で、ラブ感がほとんどないのであまり読み返すことはないかな。

I may like the picture, but I liked it because it was beautiful. I watched it in a rental. I wasn't sure if I should buy it, but I stopped. It's a happy ending, but overall it's a painful and sad romance, and there's almost no sense of love, so I don't think I'll read it over often.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

身分違う恋模様

Love pattern with a different status

身分違い故の気持ちのずれに悩む2人は。。。。。お互いに歩み寄るがどうしても超えられない壁でもハッピーエンドに終わって良かったよ！

Two people who suffer from a misunderstanding due to a difference in status... I'm glad it ended in a happy ending even though they walked up to each other but couldn't overcome it by any means!

Helpful

Reviews for Flower Shadow's Memory Manga