No Touching At All Manga Reviews (P.62)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

淡々とすすむ

Proceed softly

This review contains spoilers. いまいち嶋と外川それぞれがお互いを好きなのが分かりづらく、どのタイミングで？て感じなので、最後まで感情移入しづらかった。外川は飄々としてるし、嶋は過去を引きずって好きにならないようにしてたし、余計に分かりづらい。ただ、そこに折り合いつけて体だけの関係ではなく離れがたいもの同士なんだと思って読めば、そのあと切なく感じる。心理描写が精緻。じわじわくる

This review contains spoilers. It's hard to understand that Imaichi Island and Togawa both like each other, so at what timing? It felt like that, so it was hard for me to empathize until the end. Togawa is hesitant, and Shima dragged on his past so he wouldn't fall in love with it, so it's extra hard to understand. However, if you come to terms with that and read it thinking that it's not just about the body, but that they are things that are hard to separate from, then I feel sad after that. The psychological depiction is exquisite. Slowly coming

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何度か読みました

I read it a few times

ヨネダ先生の漫画はとても好きで、色々読みましたがこちらは今ひとつ私には刺さらなかった。とても評価が高いので期待しすぎたかもしれません。スピンオフの小野田さんの話のほうがリアリティがあって好きです。嶋くんのことが良く理解出来ないとこの漫画の良さがわからないのかなあと思ってしまいました。

I really like Yoneda-sensei's comics, and I read a lot of them, but this one didn't stick to me right now. The reviews are so high that I may have expected too much. I like the spin-off story of Mr. Onoda because it's more realistic. I was wondering if I couldn't understand Shima-kun well, I wouldn't understand the merits of this comic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

お幸せに

Be happy

日常を描いた、言っちゃえば平凡な設定ですが妙にリアルで楽しく読ませて頂きました。心理描写が丁寧で2人が惹かれあっているのを感じられたので物語としてとても充実していて満足感がありました。これからも2人で穏やかに暮らしていって下さい。

It's a plain setting, which depicts everyday life, but it was strangely realistic and enjoyable to read. The psychological depiction was careful and I was able to feel that the two were attracted to each other, so it was very fulfilling as a story, and there was a sense of satisfaction. Please continue to live peacefully with the two of you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けます

It makes me cry

二人の気持ちがやっと通じ合った時はほんとに良かったです。禁煙マークのたばこを見て涙があふれた場面は号泣しちゃいました。

It was really nice when their feelings finally came through. I cried when I saw a cigarette marked as non-smoking and burst into tears.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

攻めの包容力

The inclusiveness of aggression

This review contains spoilers. 二人がそれぞれ相手を思う気持ちは本当に尊いんだけど、やっぱりどうしても遠距離というのがね。何年我慢すればまた一緒にという話でもないしね。去る者日々に疎しって言葉、けっこう重い真実語っているのよね。だからハピエンでもないなと読後感がちょっと暗くなるので☆1コ減りました。

This review contains spoilers. The feeling that they each have for each other is really precious, but after all, it's always a long distance. Nor is it about putting up with it for a few years and then being together again. The phrase “those who leave everyday are ignorant” tells a pretty heavy truth, doesn't it? That's why the feeling after reading that it's not even Happien gets a little dark, so it's reduced by ☆ 1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた

wept

泣いた。目が腫れた。最高だった。お互いがお互いにそこまで好きになるほどのきっかけがどこにあったかは分からんくてそこはモヤモヤしたけど、内容は良かった。辛かった、、、嶋が勇気出して会いに行けて良かった。小野田さんええ人すぎて惚れてまう。この人が近くにおってくれるだけで全然ちがうやろうなっておもった。俺に過去を恨めってかって言うセリフには心がぎゅっとなった、、なんとも言い表せん感情になったなあ。外川課長は強いよ。そして嶋は繊細すぎ。わかるけどね。でも1回決断してそれでも付き合ったってことはこの先ずっとずっと幸せでおれるよ。

I cried. My eyes are swollen. That was awesome. I didn't know what led them to fall in love with each other so much, so I was confused, but the content was great. It was hard... I'm glad Shima gathered his courage and went to see him. Onoda is so human that I'm in love with him. I thought it would be completely different just because this person was close to me. The line that said they hated the past made my heart feel tight... it became an indescribable feeling. Chief Togawa is strong. And the island is too delicate. I understand, though. But the fact that we made a decision once and even then started dating means we'll be happy for a long time to come.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

｢それでも､優しい恋をする｣と一緒に是非

Be sure to join “Still, Have a Tender Love”

こちらの作品は、Theヨネダコウ先生って感じです。暗く、重くて、切ないストーリー展開。そういうのが苦手な方は、全然響かないと思いますし惹かれないですね。でも、そういうのが平気な方は是非お試しください! 確かに内容は特化してる訳ではないのですが、ヨネダ先生のファンということで星4つ♦やさくれた、だらしない男に、何故惹かれていってしまうのかがキーです。ダメ男というか、影がある男性って色気があるんですよね〜✨スピンオフ｢それでも〜｣は、さらにイイです!私は、そちらの方が好きです⤴

This work feels like Mr. Yoneda Kou. A dark, heavy, and sad storyline. If you don't like that kind of thing, I don't think it will resonate at all, and you won't be attracted to it. But if you don't mind that kind of thing, please give it a try! Certainly, the content isn't specific, but the key is why people are attracted to Yoneda sensei's fans, 4 stars ♦ kind, and sloppy men. Bad guys, or rather, men with shadows have sex appeal, don't they? ✨ The spin-off “Still...” is even better! I like that one ⤴

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

心情がリアリティあり過ぎて切ない

My feelings are so realistic that it's sad

囀る…が好きでこちらも購入。いい話ですよ。でも途中せつなすぎて読むと重い気持ちになってしまうのでなかなか読み返せない作品。囀る…の方が重い話のはずなのに非現実的過ぎて自分とは無縁と割り切って読んでるんですかね。この作品は日常に溶け込んでてリアルだから片想いが辛いのかな。

I like Chiru... so I bought this one too. That's a great story. However, it's a work that is too hectic and makes you feel heavy when you read it, so it's hard to read it again. It's supposed to be a heavier story, but it's so unrealistic that you're probably reading it as having nothing to do with yourself. This work blends into everyday life and is realistic, so I wonder if unrequited love is painful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

うーん…。

hmm...

レビュー高いけど、良いお話しだけど、私にはあまり響きませんでした…。スピンも同時購入したのでそちらも読んでみます

The reviews are high, but it's a good story, but it didn't really resonate with me... I also bought Spin at the same time, so I'll read that one too

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

幸せだからいいんですが、人間模様というか恋愛関係なくドラマな作品で。でもほんとうにあるような話でこの2人にはそれぞれの傷をお互い癒して行って欲しい。

It's fine because they're happy, but it's a drama about human patterns, or rather romance. But I really want these two people to heal each other's wounds in a story that seems to be true.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

触れたくない…のは？

What... don't you want to touch?

エッ軽！…外川さんの最初の印象です。飄々としていて掴み所のない人。対して嶋くん、内に秘めて本音を見せません。でも顔に出ちゃうんですね～( ´-｀)そんな嶋くんに気付くのは外川さんだから？だったのかな…2人とも辛い過去がありましたね…自然に涙がこぼれました。タイトルは、嶋くんかな…。自分のも相手のも変えられない過去と、自分には訪れないであろう未来、には「触れたくない」だったのかなぁ……嶋くん、今度はきっと信じても大丈夫だよ！幸せになろう(^^)

Eh, light! ... This is my first impression of Mr. Togawa. A person who is stubborn and has no place to grasp. On the other hand, Shima-kun keeps his true intentions hidden within and doesn't show his true intentions. But it shows up on my face ~ ('-`) Is Tokawa-san the one who notices Shima-kun like that? I wonder if that was the case... they both had a difficult past... tears naturally spilled out. I wonder if the title is Shima-kun... I wonder if I “didn't want to touch” the past where I couldn't change either myself or my partner's, and the future that wouldn't come to me... Shima-kun, I'm sure it's okay to believe this time around! Let's be happy (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

実写で

In live action

実写で見たことあったから避けていましたが、個人的には漫画の方がかなりすき！漫画の方がリアリティ感じた

I've seen it in live-action, so I avoided it, but personally, I like comics quite a bit! I felt that comics were more realistic

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになってほしい

I want you to be happy

「囀る鳥は羽ばたかない」からの作家買い。自身も辛い過去があるのに、優しく包容力のある外川さんにメロメロです。幸せになってほしい。

Buy an artist from “Chirping Birds Don't Flap Their Wings.” Even though she herself has a difficult past, I am overwhelmed by Togawa-san, who is kind and tolerant. I want them to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけど、幸せって

Sad but happy

This review contains spoilers. 作者さんの他の作品は気になりつつもこちらを購入。ラブラブでもエチエチでもないけど、現実ではこんなふうにBL感が展開されるのかなぁと感じられる作品。だから、ストーリー重視の方にはオススメです。でも、ちゃんとハピエンだし、二人のその後を読んでみたくなるので安心して読めます。

This review contains spoilers. I was curious about the author's other works, but I bought this one. It's not love love or etiquette, but it's a work where I can feel that the BL feeling will unfold like this in reality. So I recommend it to those who focus on the story. But it's really happy, and it makes me want to read after the two of them, so I can read it without worry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

ハッピーエンドで良かったです！外川さんも嶋くんも辛い過去があり…お互いに出会えて良かったね！！って思いました。ずっとずっと仲良く一緒にいられるといいね。同僚の小野田さんもいい人で好きでした。

I'm glad it had a happy ending! Togawa-san and Shima-kun both have painful pasts... I'm glad they met each other!! That's what I thought. It would be nice if we could stay together all the time. My colleague, Mr. Onoda, was also a nice person and I liked him.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

This review contains spoilers. ゲイの嶋とノンケの外川。嶋は前の会社で付き合ってたノンケがいて、周りにバレたら隠すために酷い態度とられて会社を辞めた。転職先の上司を意識するようになり、でもノンケで、なのになぜか身体の関係を持つようになる。外川さん、ノンケじゃないの！？で、お互い本気になって、このまま付き合いたい外川さんだけど、嶋はノンケと付き合う勇気や外川さんの過去と家族や子供に憧れる気持ちを知ってるから前に進めずお別れ。でもずっと外川さんが忘れられず電話をして会いに行き、自分の気持ちを伝えてハッピーエンド。外川さん、嶋くんのこと超好きだよね。ラブラブな二人のその後が見たい。

This review contains spoilers. Gay Island and Nonke's Tokawa River. Shima had a relationship with at her previous company, and she left the company because she was treated harshly in order to hide it if people around her found out. I became aware of the boss I was changing jobs to, but for some reason I began to have a physical relationship even though it was nonsense. Isn't Togawa-san nonke!? So, we both got serious, and Togawa-san wanted to stay with each other as is, but since Shima knows the courage to go out with Nonke and Togawa-san's past and the feeling of longing for family and children, they don't move forward and say goodbye. But I couldn't forget to call Togawa-san all the time and went to meet him, conveyed my feelings, and had a happy ending. I really like Togawa-san and Shima-kun. I want to see what happened after these two lovey-dovey couples.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

大人の恋愛

adult romance

大人の恋愛って現実味があってしっぽりしていて何度も読み返しちゃいますね☺幸せが続いてほしいなぁ〜続編あったら嬉しいな〜何年後かのふたりみたい

Adult romance is realistic and I read it over and over again ☺ I want happiness to continue ~ I would be happy if there was a sequel ~ it's like the two of them years from now

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい大人の話

A gentle adult story

This review contains spoilers. 過去をトラウマにしてる人だから浅い人間関係で自分を守ろうとする。辛い過去に前向きに進んできた人は寂しい人が気にかかる。これは寂しくて優しい大人の話です。

This review contains spoilers. Since they are traumatized by their past, they try to protect themselves through shallow relationships. People who have progressed positively in a difficult past are concerned about lonely people. This is a story about a lonely and kind adult.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切な過ぎるやないかい

that's too sad isn't it

それでも優しい恋をするの表紙買いからこちらを買いました。お互いの気持ちのすれ違いや、過去の生い立ち、トラウマなどこっちの方が切ない成分多めですね。

Nevertheless, I bought this one from the cover of A Tender Love. There are a lot of sad ingredients here, such as mutual feelings, past upbringing, trauma, etc.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まぁまぁかな

I wonder if that's OK

ヨネダさんの作品は囀ずる…を読んで暫くしてそれでも…を読んで、、だーいぶ経ってからこれを読みました。買った翌日に割引になってて悲しかったけど笑良かったです。ただ、嶋くんの良さは正直あんまり私には分からなかったです。ヨネダさんの絵は好きでもないけどじわじわと好きになりますね。目線が好きです。それでも…に出てくる小野田さんとこっちに出ている小野田さんのイメージがなんか違います。こっち先に読んでたら、それでも…は読まなかったかも？？

It's been a while since I read Yoneda's work: Zuru..., and then I read this after a long time. I was sad that it was discounted the day after I bought it, but lol it was good. However, to be honest, I didn't really understand how good Shima-kun is. I don't even like Yoneda's paintings, but I'm slowly falling in love with them. I like the way you look. Still, the image of Mr. Onoda who appears in... and Mr. Onoda who appears here is somewhat different. If I read this earlier, maybe I still haven't read...?

Helpful

Reviews for No Touching At All Manga